I am going to lock/close this thread in the next hour or so but wanted to first post the following:
We have no plans of changing the current morale system. I think many people are blaming morale for losses instead of looking at other issues. I've personally reviewed/studied morale losses in approximately 20 games since this season has started and from all appearances it is working as we designed it. There might be instances where a particular play or two is off - if you see something causing an abnormal morale loss or gain and want me to look into it, by all means pm me the play and I will.
Since 5Star posted this and I knew that there was no way any of his players lost 20 morale in one play:
Originally posted by 5STAR
I know against HHWC we were up 24-7 in the 3rd quarter
they scored a TD...we drove down and got stuffed on 4th n 1 at the 1 and our entire defense lost 20 morale
Which lead to 24 more 2nd half pointsI went and did an evaluation of the morale for Osaka's defense from that point until the end of the game. Understand there are varying factors that can lead to a morale increase or decrease but I think it's clear from looking at this data that it was not morale that caused Osaka to lose this game:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416679&pbp_id=4619856Before play starts (only included the 9 players that played in every defensive series):
Warning 100
Roper 100
Furley 100
George 100
PSP 100
Gamble 100
Kilowatt 100
Toole 100
Gorilla 100
After giving up the TD and being stuffed on 4th and goal:
Players morale at start of 1st play they appear in:
Warning 89 (loss of 11)
Roper 88 (loss of 12)
Furley 88 (loss of 12)
George 87 (loss of 13)
PSP 88 (loss of 12)
Gamble 85 (loss of 12)
Kilowatt 86 (loss of 14)
Toole 86 (loss of 14)
Gorilla 86 (loss of 14)
After getting a 3 and out and offense kicks a FG
Players morale at start of 1st play they appear in:
Warning 93 (gain of 4)
Roper 91 (gain of 3)
Furley 93 (gain of 5)
George 91 (gain of 4)
PSP 92 (gain of 4)
Gamble 92 (gain of 7)
Kilowatt 90 (gain of 4)
Toole 89 (gain of 3)
Gorilla 91 (gain of 5)
After giving up a TD and offense punting
Players morale at start of 1st play they appear in:
Warning 92 (loss of 1)
Roper 87 (loss of 4)
Furley 89 (loss of 4)
George 85 (loss of 6)
PSP 86 (loss of 6)
Gamble 87 (loss of 5)
Kilowatt 87 (loss of 5)
Toole 84 (loss of 5)
Gorilla 83 (loss of 8)
After forcing a punt, offense punts as well
Players morale at start of 1st play they appear in:
Warning 94 (gain of 2)
Roper 88 (gain of 1)
Furley 91 (gain of 2)
George 88 (gain of 3)
PSP 88 (gain of 2)
Gamble 89 (gain of 2)
Kilowatt 90 (gain of 3)
Toole 87 (gain of 3)
Gorilla 86 (gain of 3)
After forcing a punt, offense throws INT deep in their own territory
Players morale at start of 1st play they appear in (only these players appeared in the 1 play that led to a TD or the PAT):
Warning 97 (gain of 3)
Furley 97 (gain of 3)
George 90 (gain of 2)
PSP 94 (gain of 6)
Gamble 92 (gain of 3)
Kilowatt 95 (gain of 5)
Team gives up TD, offense punts
Players morale at start of 1st play they appear in:
Warning 91 (loss of 6)
Furley 90 (loss of 7)
George 82 (loss of 8)
PSP 86 (loss of 8)
Gamble 85 (loss of 7)
Kilowatt 88 (loss of 7)
Defense gives up TD, offense goes back down and scores TD
Warning 90 (loss of 1)
Furley 92 (gain of 2)
George 82 (even)
PSP 86 (even)
Gamble 84 (loss of 1)
Kilowatt 85 (loss of 3)
Defense forces punt, offense punts
Warning 96 (gain of 6)
Furley 92 (even)
George 85 (gain of 3)
PSP 86 (even)
Gamble 85 (gain of 1)
Kilowatt 85 (even)
Defense gives up FG, offense turns over on downs, last play of game, only 3 players from above appeared
Warning 92 (loss of 4)
Furley 89 (loss of 3)
George 81 (loss of 4)