User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
aerophil
offline
Link
 
Will there be any more reshuffles of the teams in the AAA Leagues to balance things out? I've noticed that some teams have been moving via support requests.
 
Mavooo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Didn't read the whole thread but I did read the OP in full.

This is the polar opposite of the "there needs to be league parity within the leagues" complaint, and that is why everything is complicated. On the one hand, people wanted coherent rivalries and competitive balance within the tiers, and on the other hand people want the best teams in AAA to promote to pro. Should AAA be dominated by the best teams across the board or should each AAA have it's own competitive balance? If you go to some non-standard promotion technique then you invalidate the regular season and playoffs of the AAA leagues - who cares if you won AAA if it has no bearing on anything? People will only try in the tournament or whatever and the playoffs become meaningless lolplayoffs. Why even have them then?

There aren't easy answers to this and at the end of the day compromises are going to end up being made and some group or another WILL be unhappy with the outcome.

Personally, I think making an Elite AAA and adding some preferred promotion to that league into pro after all the conference champs of AAA are promoted might be one of the better solutions. I'd have to review the league promotion rules but I suspect that if there is a way to tank games to try to "fast track" your team to the Pros by ending up in a weaker AAA in that system, it's probably a fine line to walk to avoid spending extra seasons in the minors just getting to the weaker AAA in the first place.


That seems like a great idea.
Edited by Mavooo on Jul 16, 2010 12:22:14
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
I'm beginning to think from an agents perspective the best way to play this game is just be a mercenary and go from team to team , cap to cap , season to season to actually get something for your money.
Edited by F8n4tune on Jul 16, 2010 15:32:43
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Wondering if this thread needs to be revisited? With the ability of folks to buy Pro teams directly, it would appear that there will only be 32 AAA teams promoted. However, there are 11 AAA leagues, and thus 22 AAA conference champions. How will those other 10 teams be picked?

The "elite" league mentioned in the OP is currently 4 - 16 in ranked scrimmages against teams from AAA #3, including multiple losses by one of the teams listed as a top 3 AAA team (and this was before they got gutted as a result of a crap agent). Catch said in the Q & A that ranked scrimmages will not factor in, so how will they differentiate? Will it be because some folks have pimped their league as the best? Will it be based on Effective Level, even though in just about every league you can find plenty of examples of top teams having lower EL or teams with higher EL not doing well at all?

In the end, I think we need to understand the criteria for success (beyond just winning it all, which is really the only safe plan at this point). If my team's relative youth and relative low SP value (as compared to other teams in AAA, not as compared to their age) will limit their ability to go pro for a couple of season (even though we beat a Pro team by alot in a ranked scrimmage), I would like to know so that I can get up early Tuesday morning to try to buy a Pro team directly.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
In the past, I think playoff wins have been the primary factor in determining promotion in the pyramid. I think that makes alot of sense to continue using it. That would mean that the fist 22 non-champion promotions would come from the conference championship runner ups. In the spirit of earning your promotion, that seems fair to me.

However, you still have the issue of determining which those 22 runner ups deserve promotion, assuming you do not have 12 or more voluntary demotions from the pros. Additionally, if there are more than 12 voluntary demotions, you would need to pick the most deserving teams from the 44 second round losers, which would be even more difficult to differentiate.

Here are my takes on the other options:

* Regular Season wins - This is fair in some ways, simply because it is rewarding success on the field, not success in building players. In the end, this game is about winning games, not building for the highest SP. Granted, you wont win without the great builds, but if the SPs are misplaced or the coordinators are not as good, they should not be rewarded simply because of their build's SP value. I understand the concern that some teams have easier schedules as well though.

* Total SP value of team - This rewards teams that have 55 players over teams that have 48 players, simply because they signed more players. Having more players does not make you a better team necessarily.

* Average SP value of team - I can easily show many examples of teams that have lower average SP value being the best teams in a league, and I can just as easily show many examples of teams that have higher average SP value being average teams in a league. Of course, there are teams that have high average SP value and are the best, just like there are teams that have low average SP value and are not good. The point is that average SP value of a team is not a very good indicator of success. More often then not, it is an indicator of the age of the players, and since all good AAA teams are level 60+, that should not be a major factor here.

* Average Level of team - Even less useful than SP value, but wanted to include it since it is a possible way of gauging a team's "value".

* Average player age - Once again, age means much less than build quality and gameplanning skills.

* Average/Total conference/league SP value - Bort mentioned Strength of Schedule in the Q & A but without using ranked scrimmages, the only way I can fathom to build a league's strength is by taking the SP value of the teams in it to create an overall league strength. As mentioned above, this is flawed tho, since SP value is not a very good indicator of a team's strength. Thus, it is also not a very good indicator of a league's strength. It certainly would demonstrate which leagues have the least reams full of CPU or crap human, but does that really make the teams at the top better?

-----

In my opinion, the best option is to reward the results on the field by making playoff wins the primary factor and regular season wins the secondary factor. Doing so promotes folks trying during the regular season and seems to be more to the spirit of the game (winning vs. player building).

When you need to break ties, the league SP value is probably as fair of a way as is left to determine the Str of Schedule of the wins, unless you are willing to include ranked scrimmages (once again, rewarding wins vs. builds).

------

I do wonder if there would be a way to have the runner ups all play their final scrimmage against someone from a different league instead of the other runner up from their own league. Likewise, you could have the second round losers all play teams from other leagues to further help establish the leagues' relative strength and those teams that deserve to be promoted if more than 44 teams are promoted in a season. That could be another way to establish the relative strength of the leagues and allow teams to earn their way in. It would be more fair, since the schedules would be random and not teams picking their opponents, and it would not exclude an owner that did not want to pay for scrimmages.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Problem always is that team performance is based off the previous season, while the team can be totally different going into the new season.

Also the transition from AAA -> Pro is a big jump.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
Problem always is that team performance is based off the previous season, while the team can be totally different going into the new season.

Also the transition from AAA -> Pro is a big jump.


Is the goal of promotion to predict the next season's performance or to reward the previous season's performance? I always thought promotion was a reward for good performance.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Pretty dumb for them to try to give everyone an equal shot...... means we'll have 850 effective level teams winning their weak AAA tiers, and (for instance) in our conference this season we have 6 or 7 legit contenders. 2 will move on, and the other 5 will be here next season to beat the living shit oput of the rest of the league. Add in 2 or so legit contenders moving up from AA ball, and we are left with a rinse:repeat scenario in seasons to come.

Make a effective level minimum and a roster size minimum for Pro level maybe? IDK if this is a good fix, but what they have done here clearly has a ton of negative fallout.....
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Pretty dumb for them to try to give everyone an equal shot...... means we'll have 850 effective level teams winning their weak AAA tiers, and (for instance) in our conference this season we have 6 or 7 legit contenders. 2 will move on, and the other 5 will be here next season to beat the living shit oput of the rest of the league. Add in 2 or so legit contenders moving up from AA ball, and we are left with a rinse:repeat scenario in seasons to come.

Make a effective level minimum and a roster size minimum for Pro level maybe? IDK if this is a good fix, but what they have done here clearly has a ton of negative fallout.....


Are there really 850 EL teams winning their AAA conference? I went thru each league and no team leading their conference was below 900 EL.

It's funny because in your league, the top teams are ranked 17th and 18th in EL (that is the lower half of 32) and the team with the second highest EL is 4-9. Thus, an arbitrary SP limit could exclude both the leaders from your league.
Edited by Plankton on Aug 23, 2010 18:14:20
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Are there really 850 EL teams winning their AAA conference? I went thru each league and no team leading their conference was below 900 EL.

It's funny because in your league, the top teams are ranked 17th and 18th in EL (that is the lower half of 32) and the team with the second highest EL is 4-9. Thus, an arbitrary SP limit could exclude both the leaders from your league.


Yea and I am on the top team.....


i really think there needs to be a way to decide this........

We need Catch and/or Bort to tell us what they have thought out.....

Anybody know when the next Q&A is.....
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beachsand DTD
Yea and I am on the top team.....


i really think there needs to be a way to decide this........

We need Catch and/or Bort to tell us what they have thought out.....

Anybody know when the next Q&A is.....


Since we just had one, my guess is that there will not be another before the promotions are done.

I think this is like most issues in GLB. No one pays attention to it until it impacts them, and then it is usually too late to do anything. I can not fathom Bort undoing his promotions once they are done, so this one is definitely going to be like that.

I guess I have too much free time, but I like to think ahead and plan out how something will be handled. If they decide now and inform us (especially if it is a system where we can control the outcome via winning games), then folks really can not complain if they are not promoted, or at least if the system is bad, folks can start discussing the issues with it now.

I don't know why I would expect GLB to be proactive though. They never have been before, so why start now?
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
there are several issues with tournaments.

1) Would lead to longer post-season and more dormant time for teams that are eliminated. Dormant time is not a good thing in an online game.

2) We typically need between 30-80 spots filled in the Pro leagues. This high number pretty much renders the tournament results meaningless.

3) You're still going to have people complaining that such and such team that qualified for the tournament out of X league isn't as good as such and such team that did not qualify for the tournament out of Y league.

We are discussing some ideas right now but in the end we're probably going to go with something that is simple and straight forward. Conference winners and best available teams using standard tie breaking procedures. Yes, it might be initially unfair to some teams but as Bort has said over time the leagues will even out.

That being said, if you have an idea that makes sense, we'll evaluate it and discuss it. Obviously, we need to have something set in stone soon, so we're not going to be mulling this over for the next two weeks. So if you have an idea - now's the time to get it out here.


Don't necessarily care whether there is a tourney or not, but if there is then each league should have the same kind of set up for advancement.

And the part in bold above is very important, if you are going to do this (which is basically adding to the post season) then we really need to have teams be able to cut/recruit/sign players anytime after they have been eliminated because anything that lengthens the time teams are basically frozen in time until the playoffs are over like we have now is a real bad thing for the game.

It really is pretty simple to say that if you are in the playoffs then you can't sign new players, there isn't a good reason at this point to have everyone frozen after week 12.
 
sehorn31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Definitely agreed.

Plus, I'd imagine some mediocre/weaker AAA teams will be stacking their rosters with level 70+ with the extended plateau in effect. AAA could end up an absolute mess.


It has 10,lol.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Are there really 850 EL teams winning their AAA conference? I went thru each league and no team leading their conference was below 900 EL.

It's funny because in your league, the top teams are ranked 17th and 18th in EL (that is the lower half of 32) and the team with the second highest EL is 4-9. Thus, an arbitrary SP limit could exclude both the leaders from your league.


I don't think an arbitrary SP amount is even close to the answer. The problem IMO is that in the effort to make lower level teams and conferences more competitive, they have made AAA a disaster. People bitched that the mid-level tiers were not competitive enough, so they tried to put all good teams together, mediocre teams together, and poor teams together. The result though is very good teams going without trophies or being "stuck" in their respective tiers (bottleneck in AAA), and less deserving teams winning their leagues only to get completely throttled in Pro ball.
 
jmarter
offline
Link
 
Believe it or not, I think the solution to this would be adding 1 more upper tier and doing away with A. Hang with me, but check out these numbers:

WL (1 league, 32 teams) - no change here
Promotion: none
Demotion: 16 (non-playoff qualifiers)

Pro (8 leagues, 256 teams) - only is to up the demotions from 4 to 6 per league
Promotion: 16 (championship finalist in each league)
Demotion: 64 (bottom 8 from each league)

Semi-Pro (4 leagues, 128 teams) - new league (+4 leagues), training grounds for the PROs, complete turnover every season
Promotion: 64 (playoff teams)
Demotion: 64 (non-playoff teams)

AAA (8 leagues, 256 teams) - change to all 1st round playoff winners promote, -3 fewer leagues than currently
Promotion: 64 (all 1st round playoff winners)
Demotion: 48 (bottom 6 from each league)

AA (12 leagues, 384 teams) - change to conference finalists promote, +6 more leagues than currently
Promotion: 48 (all 2nd round playoff winners)
Demotion: 48 (bottom 4 from each league)

A (TBA) - need 48 teams per season to promote, # of leagues & promotion requirements dependent on # of teams eligible to move out of the minors

This can be accomplished quickly. Adds just one league to the current structure and would be stable long term.
Edited by jmarter on Aug 30, 2010 12:21:33
Edited by jmarter on Aug 30, 2010 12:18:58
Edited by jmarter on Aug 30, 2010 12:14:23
Edited by jmarter on Aug 30, 2010 12:13:26
Edited by jmarter on Aug 30, 2010 12:12:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.