User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tackling: The most useless attribute?
Page:
 
KCChiefsMan
offline
Link
 
SSB have nothing to complain about, you already have an unfair advantage over your opponent.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Still LOL'g over the fact that this is an argument about "TACKLING ... the attribute" itself being useless, and we have a tester here that's tried to turn it into a convo about connecting attributes, SA's, VA's, positions, youtube... Every single response missing the main point of the thread...



Final question of the night, and I'm turning in... Meatdawg, if I can build a player without ever investing a single SP into tackling, and not training the attribute for the first 4-5 seasons of that players career, and never getting the attribute above 40-45, should he be able to accomplish that action with relative consistency? Even when compared to players who invested in it early ,and accounting for the fact that it's an action specific attribute? If so, that attribute actually is worthless... Think about it.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Still LOL'g over the fact that this is an argument about "TACKLING ... the attribute" itself being useless, and we have a tester here that's tried to turn it into a convo about connecting attributes, SA's, VA's, positions, youtube... Every single response missing the main point of the thread...



Final question of the night, and I'm turning in... Meatdawg, if I can build a player without ever investing a single SP into tackling, and not training the attribute for the first 4-5 seasons of that players career, and never getting the attribute above 40-45, should he be able to accomplish that action with relative consistency? Even when compared to players who invested in it early ,and accounting for the fact that it's an action specific attribute? If so, that attribute actually is worthless... Think about it.


Comparing tackling on cb's to tackling on DT's is apples to oranges. I'm sorry if you cant grasp the other factors that go into it.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

I didn't link a player with less than 50 vision, but here are 2 players with 70+ vision and 68+ tackling that missed a combined 9 tackles in 1 game

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1000296


Open all 3 builds, and we can dissect why they missed the tackles.


I was only referring to the2 FSs, and I already told you the vision/tackling of each player (if you think I'm lying I will PM the team owner to give you GM rights..) There's always going to be something that you can say is " too low" in attributes, but that doesn't take away from my point that tackling/vision are not taken into account for enough when DBs try to tackle a power back.
Edited by jaxinthebox on May 5, 2010 22:26:54
Edited by jaxinthebox on May 5, 2010 22:26:18
 
Billy Corman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Comparing tackling on cb's to tackling on DT's is apples to oranges. I'm sorry if you cant grasp the other factors that go into it.


And that's why this game is broken.

QB's have to have their Strength nerf'd when being tackled. DT's need far more Tackling than a CB to bring down the same HB. Seriously, that's terrible.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Comparing tackling on cb's to tackling on DT's is apples to oranges. I'm sorry if you cant grasp the other factors that go into it.


How? Explain how tackling is different between the two positions so that I can grasp it... Let me make the baseline for comparison so fucking basic that even you couldn't mess it up...


CB - 50 in tackling, 8 in every attribute across the board, no VA's, no SA's...

DT - 50 in tackling, 8 in every attribute across the board, no VA's, no SA's...

So you're saying the two will tackle differently? You're saying that the DT will be the worse tackler of the two because of position?


Are you missing my point completely that I'm not arguing about position? I could give a fuck less about it in the discussion. Straight up, I'm saying that the attribute itself really has nothing to do with the action. Which is retarded if you're going to name a full attribute for the action, and make it a major/minor attribute for certain archetypes...



 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
tackling on DTs is pretty worthless but shitty builders don't want to admit they've wasted tons and tons of SP

so yeah you aren't going to get people admitting it here for another 7-8 seasons when they have better built (60 or less tackling) DTs of their own.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Originally posted by Meatdawg

Comparing tackling on cb's to tackling on DT's is apples to oranges. I'm sorry if you cant grasp the other factors that go into it.


How? Explain how tackling is different between the two positions so that I can grasp it... Let me make the baseline for comparison so fucking basic that even you couldn't mess it up...


CB - 50 in tackling, 8 in every attribute across the board, no VA's, no SA's...

DT - 50 in tackling, 8 in every attribute across the board, no VA's, no SA's...

So you're saying the two will tackle differently? You're saying that the DT will be the worse tackler of the two because of position?

Are you missing my point completely that I'm not arguing about position? I could give a fuck less about it in the discussion. Straight up, I'm saying that the attribute itself really has nothing to do with the action. Which is retarded if you're going to name a full attribute for the action, and make it a major/minor attribute for certain archetypes...


^ Still gets it
 
RyanCane26
offline
Link
 
I have no opinion on the matter really but this thread is making me lol @ me three capping tackling first on my archetype lb
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg


Comparing tackling on cb's to tackling on DT's is apples to oranges. I'm sorry if you cant grasp the other factors that go into it.


So a CB should never be as good of a tackler as a DT? You're stoned if you believe this..

Need my Atwater link again?
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley

CB - 50 in tackling, 8 in every attribute across the board, no VA's, no SA's...

DT - 50 in tackling, 8 in every attribute across the board, no VA's, no SA's...

So you're saying the two will tackle differently? You're saying that the DT will be the worse tackler of the two because of position?


You're making it too easy.

Factor in the HB and where he is in position to when the DT tries to tackle him and the CB tries to tackle him.

I wonder if cretin VA's of the HB would trigger for one and not the other..... Hmmm

Originally posted by jktooley
Final question of the night, and I'm turning in... Meatdawg, if I can build a player without ever investing a single SP into tackling, and not training the attribute for the first 4-5 seasons of that players career, and never getting the attribute above 40-45, should he be able to accomplish that action with relative consistency? Even when compared to players who invested in it early ,and accounting for the fact that it's an action specific attribute? If so, that attribute actually is worthless... Think about it.


Don't let me keep you up Jk

 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
So a CB should never be as good of a tackler as a DT? You're stoned if you believe this..

Need my Atwater link again?


still waiting on those 3 open builds...
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by jaxinthebox

So a CB should never be as good of a tackler as a DT? You're stoned if you believe this..

Need my Atwater link again?


still waiting on those 3 open builds...


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1077645

That's the only 1 I can do
 
Billy Corman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
You're making it too easy.


You don't think this game code takes into account the position's attribute's to tackle? You think the mechanics behind the roll are exactly the same for a CB and a DT? No way I do.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Don't let me keep you up Jk



except I've seen DT's miss more than enough tackles in situations where SYM isn't firing...


and in your retarded dream scenario mentioned above... Do you really expect your all 8's with 50 tackling DT to get backfield pressure in a league that has allowed you to face HB's with SYM?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.