User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > For the curious- Current # of CPU teams in AA leagues
Page:
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by avgbrad

look at your conf - maybe 5 teams that deserve to be in AA. and by AA i mean lvl50+ and i'm not saying they are great teams at that. the rest look more like lvl 46/42


don't base it on your situation in a weak league. THE LEAGUES ARE ALMOST ALL PATHETICALLY WEAK

the argument would be if your team got thrown into condensed AA leagues that you would get it handed to you. tbh imo


Hmmmm...so if there are no longer any uncapped minor leagues, then where are all the level 50+ players that *should* be in AA? They must already be in AA or in the higher leagues. Am I right?

If that is the case, and there are still 381 CPU teams, then level 50 is surely too high of a "minimum" level for AA. Thus, your argument is false and based on the past when there was a glut of season 1 and season 2 players still around. Please tell me the flaw in my logic.

In fact, you kind of make my point. Since there are not enough players to fill AA and the higher level players gravitate to the higher leagues, then the logical solution is to move 42/46 into AA and remove an unnecessary step hindering team progress to the Pros.

For the record, the statement I was referring is this one - "... promoting cap 42 and cap 46 teams to AA will make the scores go from 255-0 to 120-35, it doesn't actually do anything for league parity..."

Edited by Plankton on Jan 23, 2010 21:05:14
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
In the end, I think people need to realize that the way things were for 10 - 11 seasons is not the way they will be long term. We all made players in Season 1 and Season 2, so almost every league was basically the same level. Thus the better builds moved up while the worse builds (and younger players) moved down.

That is no longer the case. The upper leagues are going to always be in transition, even if the transition is moving players from a farm team into an established Pro team.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chappy2235
The real answer is to get rid of cap 46 and cap 42 and just fill in the regions.


actually the answer is to remove AA, condense those teams to a cap 52 tier if needed and give dots the option to play against other dots the same level / age through day 320 or so.

SSD is correct, moving those 46 and 42 teams up wouldn't do anything to improve the AA leagues. The problem with the AA leagues is that there aren't enough high level dots to fill them - if there were, we wouldn't think moving level 42 and 46 dots would help the situation.

Increase the player pool. Either contract teams or reduce max roster sizes. Since there appears to be demand for team ownership according to the waiting lists I think smaller rosters would do wonders for this game.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
actually the answer is to remove AA, condense those teams to a cap 52 tier if needed and give dots the option to play against other dots the same level / age through day 320 or so.


I would be fine with that. Would give a team like mine another season to probably get a trophy and not be any further away from the Pros. However, that removes alot of potential homes for the higher level players, since you would now only have 16 AAA leagues and 9 Pro leagues for players above level 52 to play in. Unless you add the Uncapped minors back, which just like making another AA tier.

In the end, there are only two choices. Allow there to be a tier where uncapped players that are not AAA/Pro worthy can play or force their retirement. If you are going to allow there to be a tier for those players, why not allow them to compete against lower leveled players that are built better so that there can be even competition? That is what AA is right now, and if you want to fill them up, then the next lowest caps are where the teams will have to come from.


Edited by Plankton on Jan 23, 2010 21:32:28
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Combine EE and WE... problem solved...
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Well actually combining them would shrink but not solve the problem.

Here is a more broken down count on CPU teams i did a few minutes ago (at bottom). Currently 383 CPU marked teams in the majors, is just 1 team short of 12 leagues worth of teams. There are 7 leagues in a region. The number of CPU's in AA's is down by 4 since my initial post so at least a few are being eliminated but not significantly. So just a single merger would not accomplish the goal of CPU elimination unless somehow we can get the CPU count down to 224.

Merging either 4 into 2 would likely be the best merge method and push out the remaining gutted/under leveled teams down into the capped minors where they would fit as there are still CPU teams in the minors (though bort is slowly cleaning those out as he is handing teams out). The then free floating CPU's could be used where needed to satisfy cap 14 needs (up to the point where there are actually enough players for teams)

As for putting a bottom cap on leagues, the problem with that is that is old thinking. A team that is looking to the new way of things does not just have all high level players. They have their vets and they have guys they are grooming for the future who are still good players and can contribute to the team. I understand the intent of suggesting a min cap but it would not be a good idea for teams to stay continuously viable. If something like that were implemented it would have to take into account the other players on the team. Having a level 1 player on a team with 45 level 60 players would not likely impact the viability of the team. Or having 10 level 35 guys playing ST's on a team full of 55's might not be as effective but a team could still be viable. I think the intent needs to be implemented differently.

Africa
AA1-14
AA2-11
AA3-17
AA4-23
Total: 65
Rest of Africa- 0

USA
AA1-0
AA2-1
AA3-0
AA4-2
Total: 3
Rest of USA-1 (AAA#2)

Canada
AA1-13
AA2- 12
AA3-13
AA4-6
Total: 44
Rest of Canada- 0

EE
AA1-15
AA2- 9
AA3- 21
AA4- 27
Total: 72
Rest of EE-0

WE
AA1-15
AA2- 8
AA3- 11
AA4- 10
Total: 44
Rest of WE-0

Oceania
AA1-6
AA2-4
AA3-10
AA4- 17
Total: 37
Rest of Oceania-2 (1 in each AAA)

SA
AA1- 7
AA2- 9
AA3- 6
AA4- 23
Total: 45
Rest of SA-1 (AAA#1)

SEA
AA1-15
AA2- 15
AA3- 15
AA4- 22
Total: 67
Rest of SEA- 2 CPU(pro)

Total AA: 377
Total Majors: 383
 
Real LT
offline
Link
 
GLB is starting to resemble a black hole. Everything is collapsing in on itself.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Condense the leagues, and then offer the same number of promotions, but spread them evenly among the condensed leagues. What's hard about this?
 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Condense the leagues, and then offer the same number of promotions, but spread them evenly among the condensed leagues. What's hard about this?


this is not a solution. He did that last season and we have the same problem again. Promote more teams.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kenshinzen
Originally posted by Gart888

Condense the leagues, and then offer the same number of promotions, but spread them evenly among the condensed leagues. What's hard about this?


this is not a solution. He did that last season and we have the same problem again. Promote more teams.


We only have the same problem again because he hasn't done it again.

In other words:

1) There's a problem in season X.
2) A temporary solution is provided
3) Same problem is around in season X+1
4) We don't go with the same solution as season X.
5) The problem persists.
5) IT MUST BE THE FAULT OF SOLUTION IN STEP 2!

Edited by Gart888 on Jan 24, 2010 12:06:24
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl

SEA
AA1-15
AA2- 15
AA3- 15
AA4- 22
Total: 67
Rest of SEA- 2 CPU(pro)

Total AA: 377
Total Majors: 383


The real problem is, even though thats a huge number, it isnt accurate. Its way off. Because you are only counting teams OWNED by CPU.

I'm in SEA AAA1 and we have 7 teams with less than 20 players on them. 1 of those 7 could make a push to fill the roster by season start.

Which means these 6 teams, might as well be CPU,
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=1259 (1 player)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=447 (21 players, could fill by season start)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=5054 (0 players)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=3350 (28 players, all CPU)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=4918 (14 players, not likely to fill roster by season start)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=3139 (0 players)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=987 (2 players)




yet..we were counted as having 0 CPU teams. If our 1 league has 6 (possibly 8 teams that will have at least half a roster of CPUs), then theres going to be at least double the amount of teams that should be counted as CPU teams. I would say its a safe bet that there are at least 800 teams in all the majors that are CPU/Human owned with at least half a roster of CPU players. Probably closer to 1,000 teams.

The problem is far worse than it looks, and it looks horrible.

 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Yep i made it clear (i hope) in my OP that i was only counting teams listed as CPU in the league lists. It takes enough time to count that up, trying to look through every 1024 teams in AA to see if they are equivalent to cpu is a bit beyond the time I want to put into it and also more subjective. Any of those teams could potentially pull together a roster before day 1. A CPU owned team will not and must be sold to someone first or eliminated.

There are still a lot of players in the market still but many of them are doing the same old "sit on a contract for 2 weeks waiting for all my options" stuff. I understand why they do but doesn't help get recruiting done. But thats a whole other issue not really dealing with this topic.

 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Yep i made it clear (i hope) in my OP that i was only counting teams listed as CPU in the league lists.


I meant to just reiterate that with emphasis to show how much worse it really is as opposed to what shows on the outside of the only 383 CPU teams. Didnt mean to sound like ya didnt spend the time to fully research the issue because it would take a full season to even count that manually. Was just trying to add to info to show how bad the CPU situation really is.
 
chappy2235
offline
Link
 
Do your part to fix GLB. Move up to AA!
 
Kenshinzen
offline
Link
 
Move all cap 46 teams to AA and solve the problem. Seems easy.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.