+1 i like this idea
Forum > Suggestions > Team Captain Feature:
tuba_samurai
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
You want Bort to spend his already limited time coding that crap? Do you realize how many of your "remedied fairly easily" items would require his time? Such as voting (we don't have the ability to create polls) and eligibility, to include "top ten player" calculations (based on...what?) as well as "with the team the longest" and "best numbers" (based on...what?). You're really suggesting that Bort spend his limited coding time on this clunker of an idea? Why not simply focus on the sim?
You want Bort to spend his already limited time coding that crap? Do you realize how many of your "remedied fairly easily" items would require his time? Such as voting (we don't have the ability to create polls) and eligibility, to include "top ten player" calculations (based on...what?) as well as "with the team the longest" and "best numbers" (based on...what?). You're really suggesting that Bort spend his limited coding time on this clunker of an idea? Why not simply focus on the sim?
ijg
offline
offline
funny thing is I was just coming here to post something similar but decided to check if anyone else had the idea, so I'll say +1 but agree it needs to be modified.
I actually think this could be worked into the coaching position. One (or more) of the coaches gets to assign the captains. That at least takes it out of the owner's hand a little (I know, the owner can control all the coaches, but he doesn't have to).
I actually think confidence is the best attribute for a captain since that's morale related, but I can see vision too. Something like +1% confidence for each coaching point assigned. Probably should be some benefit for other players on that side of the ball depending on how "good" the captain is.
Other option is to make it have a temp boost potential. So, coach has 15 captain points to assign for the season. He can either give out 1/game or say 5/game for 3 games. I know people don't like temp boosts, but at least this would be a rationale to have one...i.e. the captain fired you up for the big game, rather than just I had some tokens sitting around (if necessary, Bort could use this as an excuse to eliminate temp boosts from tokens) and this would give every team the ability to temp boost instead of just the ones who save tokens.
I also think captain should be assigned for the season (so it can't hop around game to game to find an exploit) and only players above say the median level of the team should be eligible (so that a Pro team can't use it as a way to give a boost to their lvl 50s who are already being mentored). Other thing to avoid exploit is it can't stack with mentor...so if you have 2 LBs with 25 (max) in mentor, you can't make another LB a captain, it would have to be a different position.
I honestly don't think this is one that would be too hard to do and to make exploit free and it's a good thing to add to the coaching options.
inb4 Roadgrader says he doesn't like it again.
I actually think this could be worked into the coaching position. One (or more) of the coaches gets to assign the captains. That at least takes it out of the owner's hand a little (I know, the owner can control all the coaches, but he doesn't have to).
I actually think confidence is the best attribute for a captain since that's morale related, but I can see vision too. Something like +1% confidence for each coaching point assigned. Probably should be some benefit for other players on that side of the ball depending on how "good" the captain is.
Other option is to make it have a temp boost potential. So, coach has 15 captain points to assign for the season. He can either give out 1/game or say 5/game for 3 games. I know people don't like temp boosts, but at least this would be a rationale to have one...i.e. the captain fired you up for the big game, rather than just I had some tokens sitting around (if necessary, Bort could use this as an excuse to eliminate temp boosts from tokens) and this would give every team the ability to temp boost instead of just the ones who save tokens.
I also think captain should be assigned for the season (so it can't hop around game to game to find an exploit) and only players above say the median level of the team should be eligible (so that a Pro team can't use it as a way to give a boost to their lvl 50s who are already being mentored). Other thing to avoid exploit is it can't stack with mentor...so if you have 2 LBs with 25 (max) in mentor, you can't make another LB a captain, it would have to be a different position.
I honestly don't think this is one that would be too hard to do and to make exploit free and it's a good thing to add to the coaching options.
inb4 Roadgrader says he doesn't like it again.
driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Flash83
Some sentiment against it, and quite a bit support for it. Seems like it'll need some rethinking if it's ever accepted. The few who are against it are definitely against it though. A few agents really want to push it and have been wanting it for a while. Most of the negative comments about it can be remedied fairly easily, in my opinion. As far as everyone voting for themselves, there should probably only be certain players eligible for the award, such as the top ten players who have been with the team the longest and have put up the best numbers, with everyone voting among those ten players.
I like the age factor required to be a team captain, though I wouldn't mind previous stats with the team to have some affect as well.
You want Bort to spend his already limited time coding that crap? Do you realize how many of your "remedied fairly easily" items would require his time? Such as voting (we don't have the ability to create polls) and eligibility, to include "top ten player" calculations (based on...what?) as well as "with the team the longest" and "best numbers" (based on...what?). You're really suggesting that Bort spend his limited coding time on this clunker of an idea? Why not simply focus on the sim?
Hell, we can't even get a proper MVP formula put in yet.
Features like this might be great once Bort gets to that "happy" place in the sim.
Originally posted by Flash83
Some sentiment against it, and quite a bit support for it. Seems like it'll need some rethinking if it's ever accepted. The few who are against it are definitely against it though. A few agents really want to push it and have been wanting it for a while. Most of the negative comments about it can be remedied fairly easily, in my opinion. As far as everyone voting for themselves, there should probably only be certain players eligible for the award, such as the top ten players who have been with the team the longest and have put up the best numbers, with everyone voting among those ten players.
I like the age factor required to be a team captain, though I wouldn't mind previous stats with the team to have some affect as well.
You want Bort to spend his already limited time coding that crap? Do you realize how many of your "remedied fairly easily" items would require his time? Such as voting (we don't have the ability to create polls) and eligibility, to include "top ten player" calculations (based on...what?) as well as "with the team the longest" and "best numbers" (based on...what?). You're really suggesting that Bort spend his limited coding time on this clunker of an idea? Why not simply focus on the sim?
Hell, we can't even get a proper MVP formula put in yet.
Features like this might be great once Bort gets to that "happy" place in the sim.
-AB-
offline
offline
Originally posted by miguelitoisbeast
Signed in big letters. Lets keep this thread alive.
It would be cool where when you watch replays you could watch the coin toss. It would look like the three captains walking towards the middle and a coin flipped(similiar to the ball moving closer to the screen in a kickoff animation)
home team calls heads or something like that
But i like the idea
Signed in big letters. Lets keep this thread alive.
It would be cool where when you watch replays you could watch the coin toss. It would look like the three captains walking towards the middle and a coin flipped(similiar to the ball moving closer to the screen in a kickoff animation)
home team calls heads or something like that
But i like the idea
Flash83
offline
offline
With all the cash Bort makes, why don't we have a larger workforce behind the scenes on this game?
Larry Roadgrader, I used to work in software consulting, so I know how much time it takes to put together something like this - and it can be done, but only with hard work and ambition?
Let's get to that "happy place" in the sim, so I can stop hearing everyone gripe and moan about that needing to be done first before anything else is touched. I'm actually happy enough with the sim and would rather see "cosmetic" changes to the game already. Everyone says the sim is broken and this and that needs to be fixed. What's so bad about it that you just can't live with anymore? To me, everything seems somewhat minor in relation to the sim.
Larry Roadgrader, I used to work in software consulting, so I know how much time it takes to put together something like this - and it can be done, but only with hard work and ambition?
Let's get to that "happy place" in the sim, so I can stop hearing everyone gripe and moan about that needing to be done first before anything else is touched. I'm actually happy enough with the sim and would rather see "cosmetic" changes to the game already. Everyone says the sim is broken and this and that needs to be fixed. What's so bad about it that you just can't live with anymore? To me, everything seems somewhat minor in relation to the sim.
Edited by Flash83 on Nov 5, 2009 23:25:34
Edited by Flash83 on Nov 5, 2009 23:18:47
pottsman
offline
offline
Originally posted by pottsman
Giving players a bonus for being captains wouldn't go to the "best player" or the "best leader". It would go to the person who most needs extra vision or stamina. Well run teams would give it to a specific player regardless of "on field contributions".
Captains exist. They have the General SAs, Motivator and Mentor VAs. Anything else unneeded and will not be used properly.
Giving players a bonus for being captains wouldn't go to the "best player" or the "best leader". It would go to the person who most needs extra vision or stamina. Well run teams would give it to a specific player regardless of "on field contributions".
Captains exist. They have the General SAs, Motivator and Mentor VAs. Anything else unneeded and will not be used properly.
driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Flash83
To me, everything seems somewhat minor in relation to the sim.
Well said, the sim is the most important aspect of the game and should take priority over the cosmetics that you want.
To me, everything seems somewhat minor in relation to the sim.
Well said, the sim is the most important aspect of the game and should take priority over the cosmetics that you want.
Outlaw Dogs
offline
offline
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by pottsman
Giving players a bonus for being captains wouldn't go to the "best player" or the "best leader". It would go to the person who most needs extra vision or stamina. Well run teams would give it to a specific player regardless of "on field contributions".
Captains exist. They have the General SAs, Motivator and Mentor VAs. Anything else unneeded and will not be used properly.
Got to go with this really, This is already in place with Line General, Field General, D-Line General, and Defense General. Adding more is just overkill imo. As for everyone in here that say that they wouldn't abuse the system, there are 3 times the amount of owners that would use it wrong, and agents that would demand it, probably not making it worth the headache.
But if it was ever to be implemented it would either just have to be a quick change to the Top Threats, if no bonuses, or if a bonus was added, just make it an extra Equipment slot like the endorsements currently are.
Originally posted by pottsman
Giving players a bonus for being captains wouldn't go to the "best player" or the "best leader". It would go to the person who most needs extra vision or stamina. Well run teams would give it to a specific player regardless of "on field contributions".
Captains exist. They have the General SAs, Motivator and Mentor VAs. Anything else unneeded and will not be used properly.
Got to go with this really, This is already in place with Line General, Field General, D-Line General, and Defense General. Adding more is just overkill imo. As for everyone in here that say that they wouldn't abuse the system, there are 3 times the amount of owners that would use it wrong, and agents that would demand it, probably not making it worth the headache.
But if it was ever to be implemented it would either just have to be a quick change to the Top Threats, if no bonuses, or if a bonus was added, just make it an extra Equipment slot like the endorsements currently are.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























