User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
xxedge72x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
how about different XP earned by league level?

BBB = normal

A = +2%

AA = +4%

AAA = +6%

At least this way, leagues won't be forced into 32 identical teams, and owners that gut their teams and fill them with their own level 1 guys won't see supernatural growth.

This should be enough to encourage guys that are good enough to start at higher levels to go there.


If something IS going to be put into place then I like this idea, since at the very least there is incentive to move UP and not down. I would even reduce the bonus to something like this:

BBB - Normal
A - 1%
AA - 2%
AAA - 3%
Pro - 4%

And that could slide up if BB and B are later added. A bonus that is too small to make a significant impact but enough to encourage going up.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by datongw


I'm not trying to flame anyone here. I understand your situation, but what I am saying is that just because you are in a tough position, you should not punish everyone else in your league for it. Your team might have to tough it out another year, and if you improve and avoid relegation, then great, you are improving. If you still have a hard time competing, then you will be relegated next season. The system already in place is working, maybe just not as fast as some people would like.

If you put yourself in the position of the other 15 teams in your league, why should they be punished in their player development when they play against your team?


Cool enough...but the way I'm reading this proposal, Bort wouldn't make the XP differential be based on that particular game matchup, but rather each player's level compared to the league average...so if the league average is 13.4207 (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=324473) and we have half our line-up at or around level 10, then we'd get a significant bonus. The only players that would be penalized are the lv 17&18 guys on one or two teams that frankly signed at the wrong league level. The entire team wouldn't be punished, just the few players that are playing high school football at 23 years old...


I believe those players are in the minority, and honestly if they enjoy beating up on noobies then I really doubt this rule change will make them think twice. It's a team sport, 1 or 2 players won't make that much impact on the outcome of the game. If it's a team that is way above the league average, then the odds are that they won't be in that league for long anyways. I just think these changes are 1) extremely difficult to implement fairly, and 2) address a small problem. I think there are other things the GLB team can work on to make this game even better than waste their time on this issue.

Personally I'd prefer to play people that's higher level. It will make victory that much sweeter
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Also, maybe boost the minimum salary & signing bonus offers for the low level teams when they sign above the averages?

I hate using real-world analogies, but:
I don't think any top-tier NFL players will be playing Arena Football any time soon, but if the Arena leagues offered 2-3x as much money as the NFL was they'd change their tune pretty quickly, aye?
 
Drakau
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxedge72x


If something IS going to be put into place then I like this idea, since at the very least there is incentive to move UP and not down. I would even reduce the bonus to something like this:

BBB - Normal
A - 1%
AA - 2%
AAA - 3%
Pro - 4%

And that could slide up if BB and B are later added. A bonus that is too small to make a significant impact but enough to encourage going up.


isn't this just another thing bort wants to avoid though? the rich getting richer

 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxedge72x
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

how about different XP earned by league level?

BBB = normal

A = +2%

AA = +4%

AAA = +6%

At least this way, leagues won't be forced into 32 identical teams, and owners that gut their teams and fill them with their own level 1 guys won't see supernatural growth.

This should be enough to encourage guys that are good enough to start at higher levels to go there.


If something IS going to be put into place then I like this idea, since at the very least there is incentive to move UP and not down. I would even reduce the bonus to something like this:

BBB - Normal
A - 1%
AA - 2%
AAA - 3%
Pro - 4%

And that could slide up if BB and B are later added. A bonus that is too small to make a significant impact but enough to encourage going up.


But this will actually make the rich richer. Higher level will gain more XP, harder for lower levels to catch up.

Edit: LOL, someone beats me to it.
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 18:17:46
 
Zupe
offline
Link
 
I can see one way this could sort of be exploited, though I don't know how likely it is. If your goal is to get your player to the highest possible level in their 10 years, you'd be best off getting a Pro or AAA team, then either filling the entire roster with all level ones, or better yet, starting one level 1 on an otherwise high level team. For at least the first two seasons, even though you'd get relegated if the entire team was low level, you'd earn the full xp bonus every game, and thus would reach a higher level than anyone playing in an appropriate level league that started at the same time.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Honestly, I'm not so sure a bonus could be made significant enough to encourage the powergamers to leave. At level 16, you're only earning like 225 XP a game anyways. 10% would be 22.5 experience, or around 300 a season. And this would go down as the player got higher and higher leveled.

I just don't know if anything would be significant enough to act as an encouragement or deterrent Though, at least for now, the percentage bonus sounds like the best idea.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
All of these ideas are outrageously exploitable.

At least with XP gain differences by league, players should actually have incentive to sign with higher leagues. That's the problem he wants to solve.

When I first joined the game, I automatically assumed there was greater XP gain in the higher leagues. Why wouldn't there be? Right now there is no reason to want to gain a league.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

When I first joined the game, I automatically assumed there was greater XP gain in the higher leagues. Why wouldn't there be? Right now there is no reason to want to gain a league.


Better competition = more fun. Being in an A league with a team that could compete at a couple of levels higher while 50% of your division has teams that get sold back or are low level makes for a less fun experience. Here's to hoping the promotion and relegation system does solve this kind of situation within a few seasons.
 
xxedge72x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by xxedge72x

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


how about different XP earned by league level?

BBB = normal

A = +2%

AA = +4%

AAA = +6%

At least this way, leagues won't be forced into 32 identical teams, and owners that gut their teams and fill them with their own level 1 guys won't see supernatural growth.

This should be enough to encourage guys that are good enough to start at higher levels to go there.


If something IS going to be put into place then I like this idea, since at the very least there is incentive to move UP and not down. I would even reduce the bonus to something like this:

BBB - Normal
A - 1%
AA - 2%
AAA - 3%
Pro - 4%

And that could slide up if BB and B are later added. A bonus that is too small to make a significant impact but enough to encourage going up.


But this will actually make the rich richer. Higher level will gain more XP, harder for lower levels to catch up.

Edit: LOL, someone beats me to it.


The whole reason for the original idea was to try to encourage parity, not to help out younger players. The reason that there isn't parity is because higher level players are moving into leagues where they are head and shoulders above everyone else. If they had incentive to be in better leagues, such as the Pro leagues, where they should be, they would be less likely to move down.

A level 20 player still will gain XP at a slower rate than a level 10, or anyone lower level than them for that matter. A level 20 with a 4% xp boost from playing in a pro league is still gaining less XP than a level 12 with a 2% bonus playing in an AA league. The extra 2% however will be very attractive for the level 20 to stay in the Pro league rather than drop down to AA just to be guaranteed a starting job and more playing time.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose

Better competition = more fun. Being in an A league with a team that could compete at a couple of levels higher while 50% of your division has teams that get sold back or are low level makes for a less fun experience. Here's to hoping the promotion and relegation system does solve this kind of situation within a few seasons.


The BBB, A and AA leagues were created at the same time... There's nothing significant in competition by moving up or down in these leagues.

You are right, hopefully in several seasons it will work out.
 
xxedge72x
offline
Link
 
I don't know if anyone posted this as an idea... but instead of an XP bonus how about a salary cap (as opposed to another post which proposed a level cap).

Teams need to pay for higher level players... if there are scaling salary caps depending on the league type, then they will be forced to keep down the number of high profile players they bring in. In this system, Pro leagues wouldn't be affected by a salary cap, but everything below them (AAA, AA, A, BBB, etc.) would have salary based caps. The AAA would get a much higher salary cap than AA, and AA more than A, etc.

Combine salary caps with relegation and eventually a widened level gap, then teams should be able to manage their salary caps and get them upgraded once they do well enough in a league to get relegated upwards.

The only potential problem is for a team that spends close to cap and then gets relegated downwards... all I can say is that team probably is not spending its money wisely to spend that much and do that poorly, and will have to seriously reevaluate its roster and contracts in order to rebuild.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by thunderdoozer


When I first joined the game, I automatically assumed there was greater XP gain in the higher leagues. Why wouldn't there be? Right now there is no reason to want to gain a league.


Better competition = more fun. Being in an A league with a team that could compete at a couple of levels higher while 50% of your division has teams that get sold back or are low level makes for a less fun experience. Here's to hoping the promotion and relegation system does solve this kind of situation within a few seasons.


I'm confident that promotion/relegation will ensure that teams naturally migrate to their own competitive level and could reasonably expect to always be within one league level of "where they belong" based on talent, depth, and ability to gameplan and manage energy, chemistry and morale.

Unfortunately there is no solution to the problem of clueless people insisting that their teams belong in higher-level leagues in the face of objective evidence to the contrary (losing in the playoffs). I've seen several laughable cases on the league forums of people who insist that since they have higher level players or bigger scouting bars, that their teams are in fact "better" than the teams they lose to. Some people will always complain that promotion opportunities should be expanded despite having just proven they can't win at their current level.
 
bolo_76
offline
Link
 
There are a lot of good ideas here...all better than level caps...that causes way too many other issues.

I really think that everything will sort itself out eventually...the game is still new and the game needs time to find its level. If you have players that have that much of a level difference and you don't move up you are just a poorly run team. The name of the game is win and move up...if I had a chance to add a few higher level players (and could afford to) I would because that gives me a chance to get to the next level...where I would be with competition my own level, and then there is not problem...maybe you would get whooped for a season or so, but eventually the big dogs move on and likewise so does your team. If the relegation process is working properly a system like this shouldn't be needed...at least in my opinion...if something has to be in place I like this extra little bonus the best.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxedge72x
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by xxedge72x


Originally posted by thunderdoozer



how about different XP earned by league level?

BBB = normal

A = +2%

AA = +4%

AAA = +6%

At least this way, leagues won't be forced into 32 identical teams, and owners that gut their teams and fill them with their own level 1 guys won't see supernatural growth.

This should be enough to encourage guys that are good enough to start at higher levels to go there.


If something IS going to be put into place then I like this idea, since at the very least there is incentive to move UP and not down. I would even reduce the bonus to something like this:

BBB - Normal
A - 1%
AA - 2%
AAA - 3%
Pro - 4%

And that could slide up if BB and B are later added. A bonus that is too small to make a significant impact but enough to encourage going up.


But this will actually make the rich richer. Higher level will gain more XP, harder for lower levels to catch up.

Edit: LOL, someone beats me to it.


The whole reason for the original idea was to try to encourage parity, not to help out younger players. The reason that there isn't parity is because higher level players are moving into leagues where they are head and shoulders above everyone else. If they had incentive to be in better leagues, such as the Pro leagues, where they should be, they would be less likely to move down.

A level 20 player still will gain XP at a slower rate than a level 10, or anyone lower level than them for that matter. A level 20 with a 4% xp boost from playing in a pro league is still gaining less XP than a level 12 with a 2% bonus playing in an AA league. The extra 2% however will be very attractive for the level 20 to stay in the Pro league rather than drop down to AA just to be guaranteed a starting job and more playing time.





Intriguing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.