User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tagging players is ready
Page:
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carpy
I am an OC on a Pro team that has a great running QB (who is also a decent passer).

To be honest, I think this is a great addition (but also agree that there is no reason why we don't get QB2 slots now).

This means that "scrambling" built QBs are very useful and players built as pure rushers should be useless.

If the defense sells out to stop the QB run, then the QB should be able to beat the defense with his arm.


ding ding ding
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Frycicle
This is why I own a casual team. Lol


Yeah, as much as I hate to say it, casual teams are looking more and more enticing.

I was against them to begin with, but coordinating just seems more and more like a waste of time...from being jaded, from getting even more time-consuming, and from being a game of rock paper scissors (which is a good balancing mechanic, but a terrible gameplay mechanic).
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Frycicle

This is why I own a casual team. Lol


Yeah, as much as I hate to say it, casual teams are looking more and more enticing.

I was against them to begin with, but coordinating just seems more and more like a waste of time...from being jaded, from getting even more time-consuming, and from being a game of rock paper scissors (which is a good balancing mechanic, but a terrible gameplay mechanic).


Ya they are super time consuming. I love that they are realistic but I certainly am not gonna put in the time. D:
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Frycicle
Originally posted by Deathblade

Would have to manually add the custom plays.

Plus adjustments.


This is why I own a casual team. Lol


serously im thinking about this now
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by KalkmanC

not allow custom depth chart spots for offense? no more te1/te2 or rb1/rb2?


Works for me.

Have always thought that was a terrible change, not only because of the mismatches it makes, but because of how retarded it makes building those positions.

Any TE that resembles a TE is absolutely terrible in GLB.


+100

If "tagging" is instead the solution, we'll see record numbers of teams gut, unable to find DC's who will do a full time job for free.
Edited by Ken1 on Sep 21, 2009 22:10:03
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
+100

If "tagging" is instead the solution, we'll see record numbers of teams gut, unable to find DC's who will do a full time job for free.


Bort is going to start having to hand out flex to coordinators on non-casual teams.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82
Your point is well-taken, but the fact is that such athletes DO exist in football, and the only reason they don't succeed and reach the highest levels is that defensive coordinators can minimize their one-dimensional skills by doing precisely what tagging players allows DCs to do.

So basically you could take the cheap and easy route and prevent specialized builds at all, or you could take the realistic route and allow them, but give DCs the tools to make them ineffective. I applaud Bort for taking the realistic way.


But no, I'll reply to this with what I think should be the case.

Custom Slots should have some sort of penalty incurred, whether that be energy, a hit to attributes, or not 100% "uptime". Or hell, give a vision boost to the defense.

Keep the custom slots. But make it so that if a team forces TE2 to be in the game, he isn't nearly as effective as if he was just the normal TE.
Edited by Deathblade on Sep 21, 2009 22:16:54
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82

Your point is well-taken, but the fact is that such athletes DO exist in football, and the only reason they don't succeed and reach the highest levels is that defensive coordinators can minimize their one-dimensional skills by doing precisely what tagging players allows DCs to do.

So basically you could take the cheap and easy route and prevent specialized builds at all, or you could take the realistic route and allow them, but give DCs the tools to make them ineffective. I applaud Bort for taking the realistic way.


But no, I'll reply to this with what I think should be the case.

Custom Slots should have some sort of penalty incurred, whether that be energy, a hit to attributes, or not 100% "uptime". Or hell, give a vision boost to the defense.

Keep the custom slots. But make it so that if a team forces TE2 to be in the game, he isn't nearly as effective as if he was just the normal TE.


Solution makes sense but I have always thought that OOP is fairly unrealistic. ESPECIALLY if it is a position he was built and trained to play.

But I see you are looking at this from the perspective of how to make it easier to play and don't care as much if it's realistic, so I guess we won't agree at any rate.
Edited by tjplainclothesmod82 on Sep 21, 2009 22:27:23
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drakeborn
Leave RB1/2 in. Remove TE1/TE2 and FB1/FB2.


Hell no, dont get rid of FB1/FB2, how in the hell am I going to get my bigger stronger FB in on up the gut runs and my faster FB in on outside pitches?
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
100
 
Carpy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
But no, I'll reply to this with what I think should be the case.

Custom Slots should have some sort of penalty incurred, whether that be energy, a hit to attributes, or not 100% "uptime". Or hell, give a vision boost to the defense.

Keep the custom slots. But make it so that if a team forces TE2 to be in the game, he isn't nearly as effective as if he was just the normal TE.


I 100% disagree.

Just liked balanced QBs, this makes Balanced TEs very effective.

If my speed TE is in the game and you come out in a dime package because you want a CB to cover him, then if he is built as an excellent blocker as well, I'm running straight at you and pancaking the CB every time. If he is built as another WR then you know that when he is in the game, the chance of seeing a rushing play is remote, and you can tag a CB to cover him instead of having a mis-match.

Defensive co-ordinators are seeing tagging as a way to stop one-dimensional builds (which it is). As an OC, I see tagging as a way for my offense to dictate the defensive personnel that will be on the field at any time, which is a huge benefit.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carpy
Originally posted by Deathblade

But no, I'll reply to this with what I think should be the case.

Custom Slots should have some sort of penalty incurred, whether that be energy, a hit to attributes, or not 100% "uptime". Or hell, give a vision boost to the defense.

Keep the custom slots. But make it so that if a team forces TE2 to be in the game, he isn't nearly as effective as if he was just the normal TE.


I 100% disagree.

Just liked balanced QBs, this makes Balanced TEs very effective.

If my speed TE is in the game and you come out in a dime package because you want a CB to cover him, then if he is built as an excellent blocker as well, I'm running straight at you and pancaking the CB every time. If he is built as another WR then you know that when he is in the game, the chance of seeing a rushing play is remote, and you can tag a CB to cover him instead of having a mis-match.

Defensive co-ordinators are seeing tagging as a way to stop one-dimensional builds (which it is). As an OC, I see tagging as a way for my offense to dictate the defensive personnel that will be on the field at any time, which is a huge benefit.


I think DB recognizes that it will work now, but he just laments all the time it would take to set up a proper DAI with tagging. He'd rather Bort remove some of the realism in favor of a simpler AI.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=3734

Looks pretty organized to me.


Actually 1 thread for each new thing would sure be nice.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Frycicle

Bye bye rushing QBs


Hardly.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjplainclothesmod82
Solution makes sense but I have always thought that OOP is fairly unrealistic. ESPECIALLY if it is a position he was built and trained to play.

But I see you are looking at this from the perspective of how to make it easier to play and don't care as much if it's realistic, so I guess we won't agree at any rate.


Of course, this is a video.

Video games are supposed to be fun, not a job. The incentive of a job is getting paid.

The people "in real life" get paid for putting in 8 hours a day. People in GLB do not. This is like trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. This is a game. If you want the extreme intricacies of football gameplanning, you are better off trying to get hired for a coaching job.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.