User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Major changes need a separate, temporary forum...
Page:
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ahrens858
a forum that is subject to not allowing people into it that do nothing but troll.


Like I said, the forum would still be controlled, probably even stricter than General Discussion. Trolling wouldn't/shouldn't be tolerated, serious discussion on the new changes only imo.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Neeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed this...
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Why not create a mod specially for finding worthwhile points in a discussion thread from say the Goal Line Blitz, like the worthwhile points in the The Archetype discussion thread. They quote them, and keep track of them in the new forum. It could just be place in the Announcement forum under it's own thread. So many people want to be a mod, well, there you go. Make this the entry level mod position. If Bort post something in the The Archetype that should be known by the community, but people don't want to go through 45 pages to find it. This mod will have already had it, and posted it in the announcement section.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
well, we have the Q and A mods and when I've merged a thread into another I've pmed him the link to where the merge starts. Honestly, the better thing is to get the temp forum going and have area mods for that forum.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
well, we have the Q and A mods and when I've merged a thread into another I've pmed him the link to where the merge starts. Honestly, the better thing is to get the temp forum going and have area mods for that forum.


Well, if this mod can't even manage to keep up with that, then what qualifications does this person have to actually be a mod. It's basically a new guy position. If you can't hack it there, then your services aren't needed.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justin.clemons88
Originally posted by JcWildcat

well, we have the Q and A mods and when I've merged a thread into another I've pmed him the link to where the merge starts. Honestly, the better thing is to get the temp forum going and have area mods for that forum.


Well, if this mod can't even manage to keep up with that, then what qualifications does this person have to actually be a mod. It's basically a new guy position. If you can't hack it there, then your services aren't needed.


My solution was a compromise with yours tbh.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
My solution was a compromise with yours tbh.


The only problem with that is. Let's say Bort post on page 34 of 90 pages. He's the 4 person to post. Is the average player going to see this post? Probably not. Especially if the average player of the game doesn't get to involved in the forums. I don't quite understand the point of the Temp. Forum. Why not just have a permanent forum, for major changes. Then you still have the forum, find mods to take out the vital parts post them in a sub-topic. Not sure if GLB forum's will allow this. Maybe have this post directly under the discussion thread. This way the average player can just click there to find out the information they need, without reading through 90 pages to find out where Bort said Super Vision doesn't work on KR/PR guys.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
You've seen what the Q and A guys did right?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3762512

That's from just one of the archetype discussion threads.

But yes that could be done (something close to that anyway) for a temp forum/or forum for major changes. Either in the OP of each thread, or via summary threads.

One thing at a time though, because the separate forum for major changes would work wonders for all involved (admin, mods, userbase).
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
You've seen what the Q and A guys did right?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3762512

That's from just one of the archetype discussion threads.

But yes that could be done (something close to that anyway) for a temp forum/or forum for major changes. Either in the OP of each thread, or via summary threads.

One thing at a time though, because the separate forum for major changes would work wonders for all involved (admin, mods, userbase).


That is perfect. That would be perfect.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Isn't that basically what people are wanting with the temp. forum.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justin.clemons88
Isn't that basically what people are wanting with the temp. forum.


No, the temp forum would allow for more than one thread for discussion rather than stockpiling it all into one to keep it all together.

Temp forum would allow for organization for the admins (all the ideas together), userbase has the option to post in just more than one thread (unlike now since it all NEEDS to be kept to one thread).

Everyone wins, admins/userbase/mods.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
No, the temp forum would allow for more than one thread for discussion rather than stockpiling it all into one to keep it all together.

Temp forum would allow for organization for the admins (all the ideas together), userbase has the option to post in just more than one thread (unlike now since it all NEEDS to be kept to one thread).

Everyone wins, admins/userbase/mods.


So there will be like 5 or 50 threads about the same subject? Seams to defeat the purpose of what you guys are doing now to keep the like items in the same thread. I mean I don't see a point to have 5 different threads on the new player system coming out. Not unless it was broke down like this.

Thread A - For New System
Thread B- Against New System
Thread C- Suggestions for New System
Thread D- Post by Admins in Above Threads

Not

Thread A - I hate this it sucks.
Thread B- This is awesome.
Thread C- I can't believe all this crap.
Thread D- I Quit
Thread E- I love the new system
Thread F- Bort why did you do this?
Thread G- I fail.
etc. etc. etc.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
It would be the constructive threads allowed only. It would still be a modded forum, strictly modded at that but would allow for organization, probably even more so than now with our system of everything being lumped into one thread.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
It would be the constructive threads allowed only. It would still be a modded forum, strictly modded at that but would allow for organization, probably even more so than now with our system of everything being lumped into one thread.


I don't know. Just don't see how you can give people the ability to post numerous threads on the same subject, and say it will be organized. I think unless you as Mods setup the organization, and strictly enforce the posting in the certain threads. It will just be a mess like we have now. When I say strictly enforced, I mean erasing post, not having them be able to continue to detract from the certain thread, automatic bans for even the first offense. No warnings, no chances.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by justin.clemons88
Originally posted by JcWildcat

It would be the constructive threads allowed only. It would still be a modded forum, strictly modded at that but would allow for organization, probably even more so than now with our system of everything being lumped into one thread.


I don't know. Just don't see how you can give people the ability to post numerous threads on the same subject, and say it will be organized. I think unless you as Mods setup the organization, and strictly enforce the posting in the certain threads. It will just be a mess like we have now. When I say strictly enforced, I mean erasing post, not having them be able to continue to detract from the certain thread, automatic bans for even the first offense. No warnings, no chances.


Bort was working out compromise stuff throughout this thread also, we would want this to go as smooth as possible for all involved. You're bringing up good points, and hopefully Bort and co will see them.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.