User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Having coach abilities that cost money and improve the development of players seems like a very, very bad idea - it's going to create farm teams whose only purpose is to fund the coaching abilities for a few seasons and then fold. There's already enough reasons for teams to exist that don't care about winning, and adding another one is a horrible idea.

Even if they just can spend $$ to affect the outcome of games, you're in trouble - teams already have done some odd things in order to get enough money just to cover equipment for all their players; this will just increase the need to do that. It's too easy to get money to players at the expense of teams (and agents have no concern over a secondary team folding if that was its purpose).

What I'm suggesting is that instead of having coaches spend money (which is really just having the team spend money, let's not fool ourselves into thinking this is a character decision), the coaches should just have useful skills, which are better controlled on a per-team level - presumably the number of coaching slots will be limited, thus each team will have a governor on how much coach gains they can get, keeping the playing field level at the top, and not requiring the sacrifice of other teams for cash.


I thought there was going to be a limit to how many coaches a team can have and the teams in higher tiers could have more coaches.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
coaches will coach for minimum

(paid by paypal)
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by christianhall

I think physically having a player's piece of advanced EQ upgraded permanently by a coach wouldn't work, as the upgrades should only remain for as long as the player is playing under the coach.


I'd worry about super stacked equipment in that case. Too many bonuses due to coaches, etc. There'd need to be a total limit of upgrades, since we wouldn't really want equipment to be able to be upgraded beyond a player's normal number of upgrades via coaches.


True. Maybe just allow one additional coaching upgrade for any specific piece of advanced equipment?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It's not random if it's somebody on your team doing it, though. I guess it's out of your control technically, but coaches will do more to help your player train and play better than anything. I think most people just don't want to see their player play worse for no reason. If they get out-gameplanned, for instance, it's out of their control, but still fair.


There's TWO parts to your post, and they exhibit both the least objectionable and most objectionable aspect of implementing "coaches".

LEAST OBJECTIONABLE: "If they get out-gameplanned...". The customer base will (grudgingly) put up with that--it has ZERO impact on the LONG-TERM BUILD of individual builds. It will affect the game stats of those players, but we've all learned to grade builds on the BUILD ITSELF, not the game stats.

MOST OBJECTIONABLE: "...coaches will do more to help your player train better". Bort, that's a deal-breaker--it'll have the effect of POISONING builds if agents are unfortunate enough to sign with any but the best of the best of "coaches". Afterall, sub-optimal "training" will inevitably lead to sub-optimal builds. Builds are the only reason that non-team-owner agents log-on daily--the moment that significant numbers of those agents believe that they're trapped with sub-optimal training is the moment they give up on the game.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
Having coach abilities that cost money and improve the development of players seems like a very, very bad idea - it's going to create farm teams whose only purpose is to fund the coaching abilities for a few seasons and then fold. There's already enough reasons for teams to exist that don't care about winning, and adding another one is a horrible idea.

Even if they just can spend $$ to affect the outcome of games, you're in trouble - teams already have done some odd things in order to get enough money just to cover equipment for all their players; this will just increase the need to do that. It's too easy to get money to players at the expense of teams (and agents have no concern over a secondary team folding if that was its purpose).

What I'm suggesting is that instead of having coaches spend money (which is really just having the team spend money, let's not fool ourselves into thinking this is a character decision), the coaches should just have useful skills, which are better controlled on a per-team level - presumably the number of coaching slots will be limited, thus each team will have a governor on how much coach gains they can get, keeping the playing field level at the top, and not requiring the sacrifice of other teams for cash.


So, perhaps some of these ideas are good, but should just be skills for the coach to buy with his skill points, and then he can do them X number of times per day/week/etc.

Or perhaps every ability described here should require skills to be built up along side the cash requirements.

There is definitely a per-team limit on coaches. There's only so many slots.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
MOST OBJECTIONABLE: "...coaches will do more to help your player train better". Bort, that's a deal-breaker--it'll have the effect of POISONING builds if agents are unfortunate enough to sign with any but the best of the best of "coaches". Afterall, sub-optimal "training" will inevitably lead to sub-optimal builds. Builds are the only reason that non-team-owner agents log-on daily--the moment that significant numbers of those agents believe that they're trapped with sub-optimal training is the moment they give up on the game.


I think you've overestimating the training skills I'm talking about. These aren't skills that give +50% increase to strength, etc. I'm doing more along the lines of skills that unlock additional secondary abilities and intense combos. Stuff like that.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Here's a really random idea and it might be going a little too mmo for GLB, but what about the ability to hire a team seamstress as part of a coach's staff?

Who'd be able to "recycle" (basically disenchant) , and then recombine Advanced Equipment at a steep Shopping Token cost.

So for example a Superior Blue Headband might have +1 Agiliy +1Shutdown Coverage. For 8 shopping tokens a player could hire the seamstress to recycle that item, which then returns a partial headband that's stats are either +1 agility or +1 Shutdown Coverage, the odds of either would be 50/50. For this example they got lucky and have a partial headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage.

Then if the player recycled another head slot item, with say +1 strength +5% deflect ball chance. Again at a cost of 8 shopping tokens and then they again got lucky on the coin flip and ended up with a partial headband with+5% deflect chance, they'd be able to hire the seamstress to combine the two items at a cost of yet another 8 shopping tokens to create a headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage and +5% Pass Deflection Chance.

Of course standard AE rules would apply an SA couldn't be combined with an SA etc.

Actually after rereading that 8 shopping tokens might be a little steep per stage, 4 might be better.

Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 21:28:31
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
If there was a total limit to the effect coaches have on any given game, regardless of how many coaches are on a team, that would be cool. Basically if a GM or Owner could have a tactics page with a slider that gave a percent to each coach.

Coach A 20%
Coach B 20%
Coach C 20%
Coach D 40%
Total 100% worth no more than a total 10% game bonus. (10% is just a figure off the top of my head.)

Say coach A improves offensive SA by a percent, Coach B improves Defensive skills by a percent, coach C improves kicking by a percent, and coach D improves stamina. The percents applied by a GM or Owner would control how much of a coaches skills were actually used in a game. This way they could not stack too high.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Here's a really random idea and it might be going a little too mmo for GLB, but what about the ability to hire a team seamstress as part of the staff?

Who'd be able to "recycle" (basically disenchant) , and then recombine Advanced Equipment at a steep Shopping Token cost.

So for example a Superior Blue Headband might have +1 Agiliy +1Shutdown Coverage. For 8 shopping tokens a player could hire the seamstress to recycle that item, which then returns a partial headband that's stats are either +1 agility or +1 Shutdown Coverage, the odds of either would be 50/50. For this example they got lucky and have a partial headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage.

Then if the player recycled another head slot item, with say +1 strength +5% deflect ball chance. Again at a cost of 8 shopping tokens and then they again got lucky on the coin flip and ended up with a partial headband with+5% deflect chance, they'd be able to hire the seamstress to combine the two items at a cost of yet another 8 shopping tokens to create a headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage and +5% Pass Deflection Chance.

Of course standard AE rules would apply an SA couldn't be combined with an SA etc.

Actually after rereading that 8 shopping tokens might be a little steep per stage, 4 might be better.



Would that be a coach option, or just an addition to the normal AEQ options?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
If there was a total limit to the effect coaches have on any given game, regardless of how many coaches are on a team, that would be cool. Basically if a GM or Owner could have a tactics page with a slider that gave a percent to each coach.

Coach A 20%
Coach B 20%
Coach C 20%
Coach D 40%
Total 100% worth no more than a total 10% game bonus. (10% is just a figure off the top of my head.)

Say coach A improves offensive SA by a percent, Coach B improves Defensive skills by a percent, coach C improves kicking by a percent, and coach D improves stamina. The percents applied by a GM or Owner would control how much of a coaches skills were actually used in a game. This way they could not stack too high.


Hm, that'd be a good way for the owner to maintain some control over the coaches' influence as well (rogue coach!)
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Here's a really random idea and it might be going a little too mmo for GLB, but what about the ability to hire a team seamstress as part of the staff?

Who'd be able to "recycle" (basically disenchant) , and then recombine Advanced Equipment at a steep Shopping Token cost.

So for example a Superior Blue Headband might have +1 Agiliy +1Shutdown Coverage. For 8 shopping tokens a player could hire the seamstress to recycle that item, which then returns a partial headband that's stats are either +1 agility or +1 Shutdown Coverage, the odds of either would be 50/50. For this example they got lucky and have a partial headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage.

Then if the player recycled another head slot item, with say +1 strength +5% deflect ball chance. Again at a cost of 8 shopping tokens and then they again got lucky on the coin flip and ended up with a partial headband with+5% deflect chance, they'd be able to hire the seamstress to combine the two items at a cost of yet another 8 shopping tokens to create a headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage and +5% Pass Deflection Chance.

Of course standard AE rules would apply an SA couldn't be combined with an SA etc.

Actually after rereading that 8 shopping tokens might be a little steep per stage, 4 might be better.



Waiting for the people who will say "this is supposed to be a football sim, not a fantasy MMORPG".

But I like the idea, and think it would be pretty cool. Though not sure if it could be prevented from being abused. Also, the additional skill level of the 'Seamstress' could increase the odds of getting the half of the advanced EQ that you would like
 
Iron Maiden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Saris

Here's a really random idea and it might be going a little too mmo for GLB, but what about the ability to hire a team seamstress as part of the staff?

Who'd be able to "recycle" (basically disenchant) , and then recombine Advanced Equipment at a steep Shopping Token cost.

So for example a Superior Blue Headband might have +1 Agiliy +1Shutdown Coverage. For 8 shopping tokens a player could hire the seamstress to recycle that item, which then returns a partial headband that's stats are either +1 agility or +1 Shutdown Coverage, the odds of either would be 50/50. For this example they got lucky and have a partial headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage.

Then if the player recycled another head slot item, with say +1 strength +5% deflect ball chance. Again at a cost of 8 shopping tokens and then they again got lucky on the coin flip and ended up with a partial headband with+5% deflect chance, they'd be able to hire the seamstress to combine the two items at a cost of yet another 8 shopping tokens to create a headband with +1 Shutdown Coverage and +5% Pass Deflection Chance.

Of course standard AE rules would apply an SA couldn't be combined with an SA etc.

Actually after rereading that 8 shopping tokens might be a little steep per stage, 4 might be better.



Would that be a coach option, or just an addition to the normal AEQ options?


AEQ suggestion IMO
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think you've overestimating the training skills I'm talking about. These aren't skills that give +50% increase to strength, etc. I'm doing more along the lines of skills that unlock additional secondary abilities and intense combos. Stuff like that.


But it still affects the long-term ability of the build, doesn't it?

You've got to remember, agents are already min/maxing to squeeze every single point out of attributes they deem vital. The moment that significant numbers of agents believe that their prized player (or players) has had his build compromised by signing with the wrong "coach" is the moment they give up on that player. That translates into (from short term to long term) lost page hits, lost boosts, retired players, retired agents, and ultimately more and more teams that go CPU.

Again, if you feel you must implement the idea of "coaches", please allow us agents to RETAIN the control over the LONG-TERM portion of our players builds.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Would that be a coach option, or just an addition to the normal AEQ options?


Both if the seamstress was only available as a member of a coach's staff. I kind of liked the idea of being able to let each coach hire staff members who could provide different options or bonuses to the team.




 
Iron Maiden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

MOST OBJECTIONABLE: "...coaches will do more to help your player train better". Bort, that's a deal-breaker--it'll have the effect of POISONING builds if agents are unfortunate enough to sign with any but the best of the best of "coaches". Afterall, sub-optimal "training" will inevitably lead to sub-optimal builds. Builds are the only reason that non-team-owner agents log-on daily--the moment that significant numbers of those agents believe that they're trapped with sub-optimal training is the moment they give up on the game.


I think you've overestimating the training skills I'm talking about. These aren't skills that give +50% increase to strength, etc. I'm doing more along the lines of skills that unlock additional secondary abilities and intense combos. Stuff like that.


but if you unlock additional secondary abilities and intense combos, it's still a deal-breaker. Like said, "Builds are the only reason that non-team-owner agents log-on daily". So if I get worse training combos and can't optimize my build because of that, people are are going to whine again.

Say for a CB, right now the intense training chain is speed/agility > agility/vison > vision/jumping> jumping/ ???, but if I can unlock a strength/jumping combo, there will not be a break in my training chain.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.