User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Someone give me cliffs on the weight fix
Page:
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Krunchy

What I love is how PierreThomas continually gets vilified on these sorts of issues, when in fact he's doing GLB a great service. Maybe a thank you would be in order, or at very least maybe Bort could call off his pack of attack Mods?


Thanks Krunchy and everyone else that has had my back on this.



I woke up this morning and felt like I betrayed my team and the players on it. If this gets fixed mid season then it will change the landscape of every single team in the game. The first 7 weeks of the season will be meaningless and the whole season is screwed.

I basically just got my teams best players borted because I wanted an explanation why this was happening. The worst part is Bort still hasn't stated whether there is an x-factor and has danced around the issue. He was asked directly by Jed in the quotes on the first page but he danced around it yet again. All this stuff sounds too fishy for me. Until Bort directly addresses the x-factor or hidden attributes what else should I believe?

I know it sounds picky on my part screaming for seasons about something then when Bort finally acknowledges there is a problem he blames it on Taco Bell then proceeds to completely avoid the subject all together for a month then getting upset when he starts to fix this problem. I figured it was working as intended since he didn't properly address the issue. I've since retired a lot of players, recruited a team around these x-factor type players and now all that shit is going to waste because Bort ignored the problem when it was first presented to him.

This isn't the first time I have found a "bug" or something that didn't work right. The last time Bort said it was not a bug and working as intended and it wasn't until I gutted my team in USA Pro over it did Bort go back and look at the issue and realize that it was in fact a bug. It isn't like I've cried wolf in the past, when I see an issue from here out I'm going to be forced to keep it to myself. I don't have the fight to try and convince people on this site anymore only to go ignored for a couple seasons then be punished by my findings. It just isn't worth it. Hell, I may be done with the game all together, I haven't really decided that yet either. I guess we'll see how this works out first but right now it sure looks like I am getting the raw end of the deal.






Keep your chin up PT. We'll see how much this really affects things. Your efforts are appreciated!
 
MikeJ
offline
Link
 
I'd like to add my own personal thanks to PT onto the pile, and add that it's absolutely ridiculous that (as far as I know) Bort or even a mod has yet to do the same or publicly apologize for ignoring this for so long.
 
SAINT615
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MikeJ
I'd like to add my own personal thanks to PT onto the pile, and add that it's absolutely ridiculous that (as far as I know) Bort or even a mod has yet to do the same or publicly apologize for ignoring this for so long.


DL24 came pretty close to an apology.

Oh, wait, I have my definitions mixed up again.
 
MikeJ
offline
Link
 
Yeah, you're confusing 'apology' with 'half-witted, spectacularly ignorant attempt at a personal attack.'
 
Real LT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jiddy78
Originally posted by Krunchy

What I love is how PierreThomas continually gets vilified on these sorts of issues, when in fact he's doing GLB a great service. Maybe a thank you would be in order, or at very least maybe Bort could call off his pack of attack Mods?




+1
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
PierreThomas is awesome. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a fool.
 
coachviking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
PierreThomas is awesome. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a fool.


 
zamtik
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe Buck
Keep your chin up PT. We'll see how much this really affects things. Your efforts are appreciated!


 
Link
 
PT, thanks for opening up your builds again and finally getting Bort to start working on at least some of the X-factor variables.

If this is indeed part of some dots X-factor, I think for every superstar who got lucky enough to benefit from this there are probably just as many players out there saddled with an albatross around their neck because of it. The randomness of the weight problem and how it interacts with builds could make a mediocre build great, a great build mediorce, and anything in between. I doubt this issue affects just a few dots out of a million, we only notice it on the superstars because they are at the extreme end of the bell curve.

Marky Mark dedicates this one to you:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYAAbbuEpnw
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Isn't there a balance equation?

I wonder how incorrect weight readings would effect balance, and what that would, in turn, effect in the sim.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
I'm still not happy that there's something in the game (in this case, weight), that is non-adjustable and contributes to player performance. It makes no sense that we can't adjust player weight!

/rant
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
PierreThomas is awesome. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a fool.


Yep, PT is a quality guy.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
PT's work in the face of adversity here has been wonderful for the game. As a support developer myself, I can absolutely see how Bort gets into these situations, though.

Let's face it, there's a thousand crappy threads about how "my dot sucks and it's not my fault" for every good thread - it's very easy to get lost in the noise. So the first time around it's very easy to dismiss as "Yeah yeah there's a million different pieces that go into it and you're just guessing on your eyeballing of the replays and it's all subjective and whatever, I'm pretty sure that part of the code is solid." Then the whole thing crops up again with even more solid evidence and eventually you just say "Okay, fine, I'll grab a debug log on one of his next games just to make sure nothing's weird there and I can put this all to bed in my mind."

Then you open the debug up and get that big "Oh SHIT" look on your face. I've done it a few times myself - "Hey, customer, I know you think this piece of code is broken, but it's run a thousand times a second on a million boxes all over the world and you're the only one to hit this issue? Yeah right." *gather debug* "Oh..it's broken. Lemme go fix that."

As far as the X-factor comments, my gut feel from what Bort's said (and obviously we have nothing more than gut feel) is that he probably has some sort of "momentum" factor or "personal mood" factor that goes beyond your personal morale level, and randomly you get hit by negative and positive events (maybe it represents you starting a distracting public relationship, or perhaps you just got really motivated by that sick kid you visited and promised you'd get a sack for him).
If that does exist, I think it would be more interesting if it were visible to the player - get a little note with a random event and just say if your "mood" or whatever it's called went up or down that night. Even if we don't have an overall mood indicator. Then also publicize all the various ways to impact "mood" that we do have control over, and see what happens.

Who knows, maybe people would spend more nights on the town.

 
Link
 
PT for Bort
 
MrHockey
chopped
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
PT for Bort


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.