User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > If X-Factor Theory is Legit, How Will You React?
Page:
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Domer

It seems there are merits to the X-Factor exists argument. But we have very little data to back it up. A few these two players have nearly the same build yet etc... arguments doesn't hold water. For one, it's a very small sample. And secondly, nearly the same build isn't the same build.

It's possible that the player's with so called X-factor simply have hit the sweet spot with their builds. They have perfect ratios between certain attrubutes, SA and VET's that make there player perform at optium levels. It's much more likely IMO, this is the case, than there being some random x-factor built into players. But who knows.

Domer


So you think these x-factor players stay in that perfect ratio their entire career? It is more than two players, I've dealt with tens of thousands of player builds.


Who knows, maybe.

It wouldn't surprise me at all to learn there was an X-factor, the theory has merit IMO, I just haven't seen enough myself to say it exists without question. There are IMO other explainations that have equal merit.

Domer
 
Kegergator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BengalDuck
I just want to applaud Pierre for showing the build. We all hear so much about Dooley (and others) but only Pierra has given a glimpse...


 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
It wouldn't surprise me at all to learn there was an X-factor, the theory has merit IMO, I just haven't seen enough myself to say it exists without question. There are IMO other explainations that have equal merit.

"Equal" merit? No. Not remotely true. Not in the same universe as the truth. There are other bullshit explanations that people make because, for some reason, they just can't bring themselves to accept the possibility of an X-factor in GLB. The reality is that DB's script and PierreThomas' builds have proven beyond the shadow of any doubt that the X-factor is real. There is no debate anymore, and everyone who insists otherwise should go help O.J. look for the "real killer."
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Wolf
Originally posted by Domer

It seems there are merits to the X-Factor exists argument. But we have very little data to back it up. A few these two players have nearly the same build yet etc... arguments doesn't hold water. For one, it's a very small sample. And secondly, nearly the same build isn't the same build.

It's possible that the player's with so called X-factor simply have hit the sweet spot with their builds. They have perfect ratios between certain attrubutes, SA and VET's that make there player perform at optium levels. It's much more likely IMO, this is the case, than there being some random x-factor built into players. But who knows.

Domer


I do because I built 2 OTs with identical size and rolls. Built them for 2 years exactly the same. They split playing time as best as I could get it set up and they alternated starts/backups. OT B out performed OT A 95% of the games.


That's ONE case and is in part my point. While it seems your test shows the existence of an x-factor, it could just be a statistical anomally. There could be many things contributing to that one player doing better. Perhaps, despite your best efforts, the first player always went up against worse players in his matchups? IF not always, perhaps just most of the time.

OF maybe there isn't an X-factor, maybe the RNG is either not random enough or too random?

Once case doesn't prove a point.

Domer
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Domer

It wouldn't surprise me at all to learn there was an X-factor, the theory has merit IMO, I just haven't seen enough myself to say it exists without question. There are IMO other explainations that have equal merit.

"Equal" merit? No. Not remotely true. Not in the same universe as the truth. There are other bullshit explanations that people make because, for some reason, they just can't bring themselves to accept the possibility of an X-factor in GLB. The reality is that DB's script and PierreThomas' builds have proven beyond the shadow of any doubt that the X-factor is real. There is no debate anymore, and everyone who insists otherwise should go help O.J. look for the "real killer."


a build with 2 more speed is slower and that's proof beyond a shadow of a doubt?
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
One thing to consider here. I don't think speed or for that matter any interaction has been calculated the same way from one season to the next. The X-factor assumes a static variable attached to the player. I doubt even height and weight have been treated the same in every season. I think some of you may be giving Bort a little too much credit as a mad scientist here.

The builds he uses on his development server probably vary from the test server builds. One glance at the test server reveals massive differences from the live server. It really seems more rational that the code isn't always accounting properly for this variance.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
I'll admit I've been extremely skeptical about x-factor in the past, but Slow Aschit's absurd Speed compared to players with higher attributes is pretty damning evidence, even if it isn't rock solid "proof"
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
I'll admit I've been extremely skeptical about x-factor in the past, but Slow Aschit's absurd Speed compared to players with higher attributes is pretty damning evidence, even if it isn't rock solid "proof"


I agree it is proof that things aren't working in an intuitive way.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
That's ONE case and is in part my point. While it seems your test shows the existence of an x-factor, it could just be a statistical anomally. There could be many things contributing to that one player doing better. Perhaps, despite your best efforts, the first player always went up against worse players in his matchups? IF not always, perhaps just most of the time.

OF maybe there isn't an X-factor, maybe the RNG is either not random enough or too random?

Once case doesn't prove a point.

Domer


To me it does. If the results would of been closer I would be taking the other side of this argument but one OT vastly, just not a little, vastly outplayed the other game in game out.
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
One thing to consider here. I don't think speed or for that matter any interaction has been calculated the same way from one season to the next. The X-factor assumes a static variable attached to the player. I doubt even height and weight have been treated the same in every season. I think some of you may be giving Bort a little too much credit as a mad scientist here.

The builds he uses on his development server probably vary from the test server builds. One glance at the test server reveals massive differences from the live server. It really seems more rational that the code isn't always accounting properly for this variance.


Well Duh,

There are still many documented cases of AI not being followed that they can't find the reason for. I'm calling no shit on the code has errors part.

Not just that, whose to say all the server are running the same code? Remember that equipment bug where some of the server weren't using all the bonuses from AE to their SA's? Whose to say all the servers are running the same code?
 
RobertRJS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
One thing to consider here. I don't think speed or for that matter any interaction has been calculated the same way from one season to the next. The X-factor assumes a static variable attached to the player. I doubt even height and weight have been treated the same in every season. I think some of you may be giving Bort a little too much credit as a mad scientist here.

The builds he uses on his development server probably vary from the test server builds. One glance at the test server reveals massive differences from the live server. It really seems more rational that the code isn't always accounting properly for this variance.


we already know height/weight were altered in the formulas, fwiw.

code error code error code error!
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
One thing to consider here. I don't think speed or for that matter any interaction has been calculated the same way from one season to the next. The X-factor assumes a static variable attached to the player. I doubt even height and weight have been treated the same in every season. I think some of you may be giving Bort a little too much credit as a mad scientist here.

The builds he uses on his development server probably vary from the test server builds. One glance at the test server reveals massive differences from the live server. It really seems more rational that the code isn't always accounting properly for this variance.


So there is a bug in the code? I don't buy it, basically same builds, pierre's player (experimental jumping) who was exact same but 2 more base speed never got close to slow's speed in any game, on any replay. Unless slow hit the perfect combo, and has been continually maintaining that insane combo for 4 seasons straight you are wrong. What you are missing is this wr has been amazing for the last 3-4 seasons, and now is just incredible. Have you watched this dot move?

Here is just a few plays with slow in double coverage, schooling people like you won't believe These are just for anyone who hasn't seen this Dot God

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720887&pbp_id=8236756

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=781764&pbp_id=4668473
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720888&pbp_id=9083422
Edited by David Stern on Aug 31, 2009 22:40:29
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Domer

It wouldn't surprise me at all to learn there was an X-factor, the theory has merit IMO, I just haven't seen enough myself to say it exists without question. There are IMO other explainations that have equal merit.

"Equal" merit? No. Not remotely true. Not in the same universe as the truth. There are other bullshit explanations that people make because, for some reason, they just can't bring themselves to accept the possibility of an X-factor in GLB. The reality is that DB's script and PierreThomas' builds have proven beyond the shadow of any doubt that the X-factor is real. There is no debate anymore, and everyone who insists otherwise should go help O.J. look for the "real killer."


The idea of an x-factor isn't far fetched IMO. It's possible and it wouldn't surprise me at all if it exists. However, there hasn't been a single comprehensive study considering all the factors done on this. At least not one I've seen. Perhaps I have missed it. I don't read every thread on GLB, but from what I've seen discussed on the issue, there isn't anything to proves the existence of the X-factor beyond a shadow of a doubt. There isn't anything that disproves it either.

There are good theories and bad theories. There are plausible explainations for and against the x-factor. But undeniable proof? I haven't seen it.

Domer

 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Well Duh,

There are still many documented cases of AI not being followed that they can't find the reason for. I'm calling no shit on the code has errors part.

Not just that, whose to say all the server are running the same code? Remember that equipment bug where some of the server weren't using all the bonuses from AE to their SA's? Whose to say all the servers are running the same code?


I'm just saying this X-factor would have to be a priority to survive across all of the code changes.
 
TheWorstGuy
offline
Link
 
The Great Redneck Hope
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.