User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
1. The instances were they are moving sideways and sometimes actually moving towards the WR as he moves forwards are due to fakes leading the CB to believe the WR is heading in that direction. Being instructed to be 0 yards away (no idea if the aggressive setting has any effect) means they will attempt to move to be that distance away. Poor turning circles and all that jazz can have various side effects. That's WAI. Whether it's particularly attractive is another matter. Whether alleged Pro CB's should be making the same errors as PeeWee is a completely different issue. Unfortunately the game doesn't represent the difference between A and Z when it comes to mistakes. All are equally inept.

2 - The second set of replays with the CB seeminly losing the WR who races past him is another kettle of fish. They might be being faked backwards - but I'm not convinced. I think instead they're failing a different vision check and either:
A - not reading the route at all.
or
B - reading the play as a run.
or
C - fooled by some other element into stepping up.

These would still all be WAI. Ungainly and unsightly, but actually working.

At an outside chance it might be:
D - the defender is set to "auto-dither". i.e. the moment the ball is snapped they "move". This is generally/automatically forwards unless otherwise instructed. When they fail all their checks the dither moves the CB forwards.

or

E - when a defender loses "M2M" due to failed vision check he may default to some form of zone causing him to "step" towards the nearest defender.

If anyone can identify what it is I'd be glad to hear it, for now though all I can do is try to gather the info needed to actually investigate it properly.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Here's some more examples from that other bugs thread, all going up

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720612&pbp_id=9497217
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720612&pbp_id=9494988
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=720612&pbp_id=9497106

Like I said, it seems to be like 99% of the time going up.
 
Tigerbait0307
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde

At an outside chance it might be:
D - the defender is set to "auto-dither". i.e. the moment the ball is snapped they "move". This is generally/automatically forwards unless otherwise instructed. When they fail all their checks the dither moves the CB forwards.



What is auto-dither??
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
In some games (such as Madden) players cannot actually stand still when playing defence. They "dither" (definition: act nervously; be undecided; be uncertain) regardless of if they actually have a job to do or not.

I.e. you'll see an LB shuffle left or right even though nobody has hit his area of influence. It's a way of imitating real life where players are constantly in motion.

The alternative is that players, without instruction, simply freeze. Which is possible, but I would hope not the case.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Well ideally the CB would bite in the direction the fake was actually GOING in. No way did the WR head fake to his rear...or juke to his rear. I'm not even sure what that would look like.


Assumption 1. What direction did he fake in?


The point is, there is no direction of a WR fake that should cause the CB to move forward at the snap.

Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Koncorde
Sorry to point it out, but my CB reads screens and has successfully PD's WR screen plays.

Post examples. I have never seen a CB come forward at the snap in reaction to a WR screen. They do come up, but it's movement at the snap that is causing this problem.


+1

Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

If that's the case, then that is definitely something that should be looked at as well. Really? A head fake to the backfield as they're running forward? And the CB falls for it?


Didn't feel like searching for much, but he's a prime example of a step-back juke http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oBXPx_tn0Tc


First of all, that is completely different than what is discussed here. Your video is a juke by an already-moving ballcarrier in the middle of the play. We're talking about WRs on the line right at the snap of the ball, starting from a motionless state.

Second of all, that video is not even a step-back juke. The guy actually jukes sideways, the only reason he moves "back" is because his initial direction was diagonal on the field axis to begin with. He starts out going 45 degrees forward-right and the 90-degree juke moves him 45 degrees backward-right.
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 13:50:16
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 13:42:27
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
A huge part of the problem IMO is that CBs are lined up too far off the line.
Even with the DPC you can't make them actually line up at the LOS.
They are always a full step back of the defensive linemen, which is absolutely not how you wnat to line up if you are trying to play tight coverage.

Suggestion: Players that are set to Coverage Distance less than x ought to line up closer to the line (unless they are set to Cover Man w/o Move). With x being perhaps a smaller number against WRs off the line than against WRs on the line.
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 17:18:47
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 14:20:16
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
The point is, there is no direction of a WR fake that should cause the CB to move forward at the snap.


If a WR on the weak side runs directly from the snap 90 degrees to his left towards the sideline, where is the correct position for him to take up?
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by TrevJo

The point is, there is no direction of a WR fake that should cause the CB to move forward at the snap.


If a WR on the weak side runs directly from the snap 90 degrees to his left towards the sideline, where is the correct position for him to take up?


Directly to his right (WR's left).
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Directly to his right (WR's left).


Parallel? What advantage is that?

If they are 3 yards away at the snap, and you're set to 0 yard coverage...how close do you get?
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by TrevJo

Directly to his right (WR's left).


Parallel? What advantage is that?

If they are 3 yards away at the snap, and you're set to 0 yard coverage...how close do you get?


The advantage is you don't let the WR get behind you and take yourself out of the play just in case it's a wheel route or something like that.

The problem I have with this whole thing is first and foremost, a priority of a CB is to stay in front of the WR. Giving up a 2 or 3 yd reception (biting on a fake and stepping forward I guess), should NOT happen as much as it does.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Aug 31, 2009 17:01:39
Edited by Sik Wit It on Aug 31, 2009 17:01:15
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
If they are 3 yards away at the snap, and you're set to 0 yard coverage...
Originally posted by TrevJo
A huge part of the problem IMO is that CBs are lined up too far off the line.
Even with the DPC you can't make them actually line up at the LOS.
They are always a full step back of the defensive linemen, which is absolutely not how you wnat to line up if you are trying to play tight coverage.

Suggestion: Players that are set to Coverage Distance less than x ought to line up closer to the line (unless they are set to Cover Man w/o Move). With x being perhaps a smaller number against WRs off the line than against WRs on the line.
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 17:19:03
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Basically what we have now is this:

-Oh he faked left or right for a short out or in, I better jump the route to get a good jump on the tackle so I give up 1 or 2 yds instead of 2 or 3. Oh shit he ran right by me, I guessed wrong and completely took myself out of the play, and it'll probably result in a 20+ yd gain or a TD.

And they get fooled over and over like that. How about the CBs get some logic and give up those short 2 or 3 yd receptions instead of giving up the big play?

Also, this still happens like 99% going up like I pointed out. Which leads me to believe it's not an intended result of the sim.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by Koncorde

Originally posted by TrevJo


Directly to his right (WR's left).


Parallel? What advantage is that?

If they are 3 yards away at the snap, and you're set to 0 yard coverage...how close do you get?


The advantage is you don't let the WR get behind you and take yourself out of the play just in case it's a wheel route or something like that.

The problem I have with this whole thing is first and foremost, a priority of a CB is to stay in front of the WR. Giving up a 2 or 3 yd reception (biting on a fake and stepping forward I guess), should NOT happen as much as it does.


I agree with Sik's answer.

Let me pose your own question to you, Koncorde:
If a WR on the weak side runs directly from the snap 90 degrees to his left towards the sideline, where is the correct position for him to take up?
Edited by TrevJo on Aug 31, 2009 17:30:57
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Let me pose your own question to you, Koncorde:
If a WR on the weak side runs directly from the snap 90 degrees to his left towards the sideline, where is the correct position for him to take up?


It would depend on the instructions I was given by the coach. In short - there is no "right" answer other than to not be beaten. If I was instructed to be 0 yards away from the WR I would move to 0 yards. If I am 3 yards away then then I will move closer.

Unfortunately GLB's m2m coverage cannot perform the minute logical shortcuts a real player would make, such as drifting away in order to avoid being wrong footed.

Originally posted by TrevJo

They are always a full step back of the defensive linemen, which is absolutely not how you wnat to line up if you are trying to play tight coverage.

Suggestion: Players that are set to Coverage Distance less than x ought to line up closer to the line (unless they are set to Cover Man w/o Move). With x being perhaps a smaller number against slot WRs than against WRs on the line.


Sorry if I missed that suggestion, but yes that might help.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Basically what we have now is this:

-Oh he faked left or right for a short out or in, I better jump the route to get a good jump on the tackle so I give up 1 or 2 yds instead of 2 or 3. Oh shit he ran right by me, I guessed wrong and completely took myself out of the play, and it'll probably result in a 20+ yd gain or a TD.

And they get fooled over and over like that. How about the CBs get some logic and give up those short 2 or 3 yd receptions instead of giving up the big play?

Also, this still happens like 99% going up like I pointed out. Which leads me to believe it's not an intended result of the sim.


Welcome to the mechanics of GLB. Critical fail is a critical fail, and worse still a demoralised CB will fall for it all the more the second time.

I would doubt there's any difference in up vs down. It probably requires a lot more looking into.

Another thing that actually popped into my head earlier is the potential for a "jumped snap" by a CB. I have no idea if it's possible, but a high vision CB may actually read the play and do that exceedingly dramatic jump forwards (rather than the drifting to the side one). So effectively a "critical success".
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by TrevJo

Let me pose your own question to you, Koncorde:
If a WR on the weak side runs directly from the snap 90 degrees to his left towards the sideline, where is the correct position for him to take up?


It would depend on the instructions I was given by the coach. In short - there is no "right" answer other than to not be beaten. If I was instructed to be 0 yards away from the WR I would move to 0 yards. If I am 3 yards away then then I will move closer.

Unfortunately GLB's m2m coverage cannot perform the minute logical shortcuts a real player would make, such as drifting away in order to avoid being wrong footed.


There is no coach in the world that is going to instruct his CB to move toward the WR at the start of the play for non-press coverage.

I don't think it's appropriate to tell us that GLB cannot do it. There are a lot of things in a sim like this that don't happen naturally, they require special attention. This is one of those things.

Please repeat this to yourself until you believe it, or can give a football-related reason as to why it is not true: Originally posted by TrevJo
there is no direction of a WR fake that should cause the CB to move forward at the snap.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.