Please to be limiting the number of players allowed to be tagged. And only 1 can actively be tagged per play. Tag the right player = bonus for the defense. Tag the wrong player = bonus for the offense.
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Anarcho
offline
offline
Everything from the Monsterkill script should be available.
I don't understand the mentality of those who say they don't want too much info available.
The info is already available. Why make it so that only a select few have access to it though?
I thought one of the goals of this game was to try to eliminate some of the "work" that has to be put into the game in order to succeed.
Give as much info as possible in these things and bring some of the fun and ease back to scouting.
I don't understand the mentality of those who say they don't want too much info available.
The info is already available. Why make it so that only a select few have access to it though?
I thought one of the goals of this game was to try to eliminate some of the "work" that has to be put into the game in order to succeed.
Give as much info as possible in these things and bring some of the fun and ease back to scouting.
driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Anarcho
Everything from the Monsterkill script should be available.
I don't understand the mentality of those who say they don't want too much info available.
The info is already available. Why make it so that only a select few have access to it though?
I thought one of the goals of this game was to try to eliminate some of the "work" that has to be put into the game in order to succeed.
Give as much info as possible in these things and bring some of the fun and ease back to scouting.
The info should be made available but it shouldn't be made ready with no work required to get it.
To make something that will readily tell you who blitzes, from where, how many times they ran "X" play etcetc shouldn't be made ready with no work required. Scouting be required still to do this but the tools to make it easier should be made game ready, IE the monsterkill and PBR scripts with some tweaks to them.
Everything from the Monsterkill script should be available.
I don't understand the mentality of those who say they don't want too much info available.
The info is already available. Why make it so that only a select few have access to it though?
I thought one of the goals of this game was to try to eliminate some of the "work" that has to be put into the game in order to succeed.
Give as much info as possible in these things and bring some of the fun and ease back to scouting.
The info should be made available but it shouldn't be made ready with no work required to get it.
To make something that will readily tell you who blitzes, from where, how many times they ran "X" play etcetc shouldn't be made ready with no work required. Scouting be required still to do this but the tools to make it easier should be made game ready, IE the monsterkill and PBR scripts with some tweaks to them.
Anarcho
offline
offline
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
The info should be made available but it shouldn't be made ready with no work required to get it.
To make something that will readily tell you who blitzes, from where, how many times they ran "X" play etcetc shouldn't be made ready with no work required. Scouting be required still to do this but the tools to make it easier should be made game ready, IE the monsterkill and PBR scripts with some tweaks to them.
Sure, I don't think we should have it handed to us, but it should be made easier.
Right now scouting is like making a puzzle. The only problem is that we are working in the dark.
Make the pieces easily seen and accessible so that we can easily put the thing together if we spend a few minutes looking at it.
I think splitting the replay up into formations like Monsterkill does is amazing and really helps with scouting.
I'd also like the ability to add my own filters like Monsterkill does.
I just think it's a shame that there are some people who would really prefer that this game continues to progress into a part time job without helping to trim a little off the workload.
The info should be made available but it shouldn't be made ready with no work required to get it.
To make something that will readily tell you who blitzes, from where, how many times they ran "X" play etcetc shouldn't be made ready with no work required. Scouting be required still to do this but the tools to make it easier should be made game ready, IE the monsterkill and PBR scripts with some tweaks to them.
Sure, I don't think we should have it handed to us, but it should be made easier.
Right now scouting is like making a puzzle. The only problem is that we are working in the dark.
Make the pieces easily seen and accessible so that we can easily put the thing together if we spend a few minutes looking at it.
I think splitting the replay up into formations like Monsterkill does is amazing and really helps with scouting.
I'd also like the ability to add my own filters like Monsterkill does.
I just think it's a shame that there are some people who would really prefer that this game continues to progress into a part time job without helping to trim a little off the workload.
butler312
offline
offline
This may be taking things a little too far, but the amount of information could be something that a coach could bring once that feature gets implemented. I don't exactly know how those are going to work but there are tons of ways that could be worked in.
Anarcho
offline
offline
Originally posted by butler312
This may be taking things a little too far, but the amount of information could be something that a coach could bring once that feature gets implemented. I don't exactly know how those are going to work but there are tons of ways that could be worked in.
Perhaps certain types of coaches can reveal additional pieces of information?
This may be taking things a little too far, but the amount of information could be something that a coach could bring once that feature gets implemented. I don't exactly know how those are going to work but there are tons of ways that could be worked in.
Perhaps certain types of coaches can reveal additional pieces of information?
butler312
offline
offline
Originally posted by Anarcho
Perhaps certain types of coaches can reveal additional pieces of information?
Yeah, something like that. I haven't read up on the ideas for coaches, but if there are going to be attributes for them one could definitely be scouting and would increase the amount of info available.
Perhaps certain types of coaches can reveal additional pieces of information?
Yeah, something like that. I haven't read up on the ideas for coaches, but if there are going to be attributes for them one could definitely be scouting and would increase the amount of info available.
driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Anarcho
Everything from the Monsterkill script should be available.
I don't understand the mentality of those who say they don't want too much info available.
The info is already available. Why make it so that only a select few have access to it though?
I thought one of the goals of this game was to try to eliminate some of the "work" that has to be put into the game in order to succeed.
Give as much info as possible in these things and bring some of the fun and ease back to scouting.

Kind of like what I posted on it earlier.

Originally posted by
Exactly my thoughts on it.
Pretty much, Pbr scout mixed with something along the lines of the monster scout script/and addon but with some enhanced features/functionality to it.
IE: being able to select pass/player and for it to pull up the plays that player was passed to in that game. That way you can browse through those select plays to see which ones were screens or routes, short or long. etcetc
Everything from the Monsterkill script should be available.
I don't understand the mentality of those who say they don't want too much info available.
The info is already available. Why make it so that only a select few have access to it though?
I thought one of the goals of this game was to try to eliminate some of the "work" that has to be put into the game in order to succeed.
Give as much info as possible in these things and bring some of the fun and ease back to scouting.

Kind of like what I posted on it earlier.

Originally posted by
Exactly my thoughts on it.
Pretty much, Pbr scout mixed with something along the lines of the monster scout script/and addon but with some enhanced features/functionality to it.
IE: being able to select pass/player and for it to pull up the plays that player was passed to in that game. That way you can browse through those select plays to see which ones were screens or routes, short or long. etcetc
1) My earlier concept of a "Scout" would be a player who had become a coach and instead of training points gathered "Scouting Hours". These would be spent on various scouting options. For instance you could spend 2 scouting points to get an approximation of a specific players attribute or skill (modified as they are by any VAs SAs equipment or boosts at that moment), by choosing Higher Than X (dragged down selection of a player on your team - maybe only have this if the two have played each other in the past), Higher or Lower. The end result of the first would be Target Players Stat is Higher/Lower/AbouttheSame as Comparison Players stat without any range given (could be 3 higher or 30). The second would be "Target Players Stat is Higher than a Number" or the third "Lower than a Number" with that number being closer to the actual stat depending upon the success of the roll (ie normal success 10 to 15 points off of the actual stat - as in the players speed is 90 and a normal success would say the Speed is over 75 or over 80 or so and a good success would be over 85 to 89, good success within 5 etc). The level of success would vary based upon the scouts vision, pre-retirement level, generals SA and VA levels (and which type compared to the target player), position of scout compared to target player (lineman good at scouting D and O linemen etc) and so forth. Plus the player could use options similar to training to improve the chances of success (ie 5 SPs to scout two things with increased chance of success). Also scouting choices could be to detect what VAs the target has, or the approximate level of a VA or SA, or to check for equipment boosts on a target piece of equipment (ie plus % to Fake etc). The means to scout these things could be here, as well as the means to share the results.
2) Formation and Play Tendencies. Allow players to enter data from this and have it compiled together with notes on which downs they scouted. So that one player could scout the first quarter, and another the second etc. Also make room for down situations (Redzone, Shortyardage etc).
2) Formation and Play Tendencies. Allow players to enter data from this and have it compiled together with notes on which downs they scouted. So that one player could scout the first quarter, and another the second etc. Also make room for down situations (Redzone, Shortyardage etc).
Kana
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I
One problem is defense, if we want to scout that at all: DPC makes it pretty hard to do, especially if a play gets deleted after it's used. Best I could do is probably % of 4-3/3-4/nickel/dime, etc, but with DPC plays even that is hard. Defense would likely need to still be mostly a manual scouting process, outside of stats like ints/pds/sacks.
Yeah but the DPC still uses basic formations to start with (3-4, 4-3, nickel, dime, quarter, yet no GL). So the output could still be done in that at least for the defense. As for the Offensive side of things I would love to see specific play tendencies listed say top 5 plays or something along those lines.
I
One problem is defense, if we want to scout that at all: DPC makes it pretty hard to do, especially if a play gets deleted after it's used. Best I could do is probably % of 4-3/3-4/nickel/dime, etc, but with DPC plays even that is hard. Defense would likely need to still be mostly a manual scouting process, outside of stats like ints/pds/sacks.
Yeah but the DPC still uses basic formations to start with (3-4, 4-3, nickel, dime, quarter, yet no GL). So the output could still be done in that at least for the defense. As for the Offensive side of things I would love to see specific play tendencies listed say top 5 plays or something along those lines.
driftinggrifter
offline
offline
Originally posted by yello1
1) My earlier concept of a "Scout" would be a player who had become a coach and instead of training points gathered "Scouting Hours". These would be spent on various scouting options. For instance you could spend 2 scouting points to get an approximation of a specific players attribute or skill (modified as they are by any VAs SAs equipment or boosts at that moment), by choosing Higher Than X (dragged down selection of a player on your team - maybe only have this if the two have played each other in the past), Higher or Lower. The end result of the first would be Target Players Stat is Higher/Lower/AbouttheSame as Comparison Players stat without any range given (could be 3 higher or 30). The second would be "Target Players Stat is Higher than a Number" or the third "Lower than a Number" with that number being closer to the actual stat depending upon the success of the roll (ie normal success 10 to 15 points off of the actual stat - as in the players speed is 90 and a normal success would say the Speed is over 75 or over 80 or so and a good success would be over 85 to 89, good success within 5 etc). The level of success would vary based upon the scouts vision, pre-retirement level, generals SA and VA levels (and which type compared to the target player), position of scout compared to target player (lineman good at scouting D and O linemen etc) and so forth. Plus the player could use options similar to training to improve the chances of success (ie 5 SPs to scout two things with increased chance of success). Also scouting choices could be to detect what VAs the target has, or the approximate level of a VA or SA, or to check for equipment boosts on a target piece of equipment (ie plus % to Fake etc). The means to scout these things could be here, as well as the means to share the results.
2) Formation and Play Tendencies. Allow players to enter data from this and have it compiled together with notes on which downs they scouted. So that one player could scout the first quarter, and another the second etc. Also make room for down situations (Redzone, Shortyardage etc).
Wanting way to much information spoon fed to you. There should be no way you should be able to see or know the exact or approx. amount of VA's/SA's if the build is closed. Same with any other of their attributes.
1) My earlier concept of a "Scout" would be a player who had become a coach and instead of training points gathered "Scouting Hours". These would be spent on various scouting options. For instance you could spend 2 scouting points to get an approximation of a specific players attribute or skill (modified as they are by any VAs SAs equipment or boosts at that moment), by choosing Higher Than X (dragged down selection of a player on your team - maybe only have this if the two have played each other in the past), Higher or Lower. The end result of the first would be Target Players Stat is Higher/Lower/AbouttheSame as Comparison Players stat without any range given (could be 3 higher or 30). The second would be "Target Players Stat is Higher than a Number" or the third "Lower than a Number" with that number being closer to the actual stat depending upon the success of the roll (ie normal success 10 to 15 points off of the actual stat - as in the players speed is 90 and a normal success would say the Speed is over 75 or over 80 or so and a good success would be over 85 to 89, good success within 5 etc). The level of success would vary based upon the scouts vision, pre-retirement level, generals SA and VA levels (and which type compared to the target player), position of scout compared to target player (lineman good at scouting D and O linemen etc) and so forth. Plus the player could use options similar to training to improve the chances of success (ie 5 SPs to scout two things with increased chance of success). Also scouting choices could be to detect what VAs the target has, or the approximate level of a VA or SA, or to check for equipment boosts on a target piece of equipment (ie plus % to Fake etc). The means to scout these things could be here, as well as the means to share the results.
2) Formation and Play Tendencies. Allow players to enter data from this and have it compiled together with notes on which downs they scouted. So that one player could scout the first quarter, and another the second etc. Also make room for down situations (Redzone, Shortyardage etc).
Wanting way to much information spoon fed to you. There should be no way you should be able to see or know the exact or approx. amount of VA's/SA's if the build is closed. Same with any other of their attributes.
butler312
offline
offline
Agreed. I was kind of thinking that each coach should be able to scout 1 team every day (or maybe every in game week;so every other day). Each time you scout a team you get a little more info on them, but that info should ONLY be info that you could actually find out yourself if you took the time to all out scout. The amount of info you get should also be based on your coach's scouting level.
This way you can scout each team right before you play them and get a decent amount of scouting info from their recent games. Or you could even scout the same team for several weeks and get some extremely detailed info them. But again, only what you could have gotten by watching the actual replays yourself. No attribute info, unless the build is open.
This way you can scout each team right before you play them and get a decent amount of scouting info from their recent games. Or you could even scout the same team for several weeks and get some extremely detailed info them. But again, only what you could have gotten by watching the actual replays yourself. No attribute info, unless the build is open.
Anarcho
offline
offline
Originally posted by butler312
Agreed. I was kind of thinking that each coach should be able to scout 1 team every day (or maybe every in game week;so every other day). Each time you scout a team you get a little more info on them, but that info should ONLY be info that you could actually find out yourself if you took the time to all out scout. The amount of info you get should also be based on your coach's scouting level.
This way you can scout each team right before you play them and get a decent amount of scouting info from their recent games. Or you could even scout the same team for several weeks and get some extremely detailed info them. But again, only what you could have gotten by watching the actual replays yourself. No attribute info, unless the build is open.
Speaking of open builds, the scouting section should also highlight any players with open builds.
Agreed. I was kind of thinking that each coach should be able to scout 1 team every day (or maybe every in game week;so every other day). Each time you scout a team you get a little more info on them, but that info should ONLY be info that you could actually find out yourself if you took the time to all out scout. The amount of info you get should also be based on your coach's scouting level.
This way you can scout each team right before you play them and get a decent amount of scouting info from their recent games. Or you could even scout the same team for several weeks and get some extremely detailed info them. But again, only what you could have gotten by watching the actual replays yourself. No attribute info, unless the build is open.
Speaking of open builds, the scouting section should also highlight any players with open builds.
mpapara
offline
offline
For the defensive scouting
all you have to do is list the base formation 3-4 or 4-3
then breakdown the D-line, LB's. and Secondary with how many players drop to zone, play man, or blitz
give a ratio of tackles for a loss to amount of tackles
then a ratio of missed tackles to tackles
give a ratio of deflections vs catches to pass attempts
breakdown the amount of FF's and INT's
for tendencies
you could breakdown how many runs were HB/FB/QB
then inside/outside handoff or pitches
you could breakdown how many pass completions/pass attempts went to the HB/FB/TE/WR
all you have to do is list the base formation 3-4 or 4-3
then breakdown the D-line, LB's. and Secondary with how many players drop to zone, play man, or blitz
give a ratio of tackles for a loss to amount of tackles
then a ratio of missed tackles to tackles
give a ratio of deflections vs catches to pass attempts
breakdown the amount of FF's and INT's
for tendencies
you could breakdown how many runs were HB/FB/QB
then inside/outside handoff or pitches
you could breakdown how many pass completions/pass attempts went to the HB/FB/TE/WR
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























