User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add 10 season decline to the NEVER going to happen list
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mgbl3
I really think more about this topic needs to be listed in the FAQ. People start playing this game and invest plenty of time and money into it without realizing that at somepoint their characters will decline.

Then again I dont exactly know the details on what happens. Do you actually get worse? Or does the rate of you getting better level off?

I don't really see why players getting worse is necessary. Why can't there just be a level cap where progression stops?


Seasons 1-9: players get better, on a declining scale based on level
Season 10: plateau
Seasons 11+: decline
At any time, retire your player...get 100% of creation cost back + 70% of boosts/custom equipment...create a new player.

That is about what we know for now, the details past that are fuzzy as we aren't anywhere near that point and other things need more attention (i.e. tactics, things for players to do, etc.)

Plus, there have been MANY discussions about other options rather than just a retire/create a new guy scenario, as mentioned above.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by mgbl3

I really think more about this topic needs to be listed in the FAQ. People start playing this game and invest plenty of time and money into it without realizing that at somepoint their characters will decline.

Then again I dont exactly know the details on what happens. Do you actually get worse? Or does the rate of you getting better level off?

I don't really see why players getting worse is necessary. Why can't there just be a level cap where progression stops?


Seasons 1-9: players get better, on a declining scale based on level
Season 10: plateau
Seasons 11+: decline
At any time, retire your player...get 100% of creation cost back + 70% of boosts/custom equipment...create a new player.

That is about what we know for now, the details past that are fuzzy as we aren't anywhere near that point and other things need more attention (i.e. tactics, things for players to do, etc.)

Plus, there have been MANY discussions about other options rather than just a retire/create a new guy scenario, as mentioned above.


Bort has indicated that he'd at least seriously consider both the coaching option and having a kid with a few extra stats option.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
100% is a ridiculous thing to expect.

I do think that if you play a player into the decline phase, and retire him outright (without using any of the other options, from coaching to Seniors' Leagues to siring a "son" with a few extra points) you should be rewarded with 80% or so-- in other words, more than standard.

They can make up the lost revenue from that by giving less back if one of the other options are used.

Those who play in Seniors' Leagues would get 70% if/when they actually retired, but playing in them (for server usage) would cost a non-refundable fee per season.

Coaches may get just 60% back when retiring, and siring a son with extra stats only 50% or so-- as that's an in-game advantage and should be paid for.


I'm talking 100%, without leagues for the retired players. Just like right now. But I think a full refund should be given even for the custom equipment. If not, I think that it should remain the same as it is now. 100% for retired players, 70% for custom equipment.

Let's say you accidentally click to confirm a player, when you meant to click to re-roll their stats...then you lose 30% FP because you accidentally clicked the wrong spot. Or say someone else gets ahold of your computer, like a child or something, and creates a player. Should you be penalized in these situations?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by Ken1

100% is a ridiculous thing to expect.

I do think that if you play a player into the decline phase, and retire him outright (without using any of the other options, from coaching to Seniors' Leagues to siring a "son" with a few extra points) you should be rewarded with 80% or so-- in other words, more than standard.

They can make up the lost revenue from that by giving less back if one of the other options are used.

Those who play in Seniors' Leagues would get 70% if/when they actually retired, but playing in them (for server usage) would cost a non-refundable fee per season.

Coaches may get just 60% back when retiring, and siring a son with extra stats only 50% or so-- as that's an in-game advantage and should be paid for.


I'm talking 100%, without leagues for the retired players. Just like right now. But I think a full refund should be given even for the custom equipment. If not, I think that it should remain the same as it is now. 100% for retired players, 70% for custom equipment.

Let's say you accidentally click to confirm a player, when you meant to click to re-roll their stats...then you lose 30% FP because you accidentally clicked the wrong spot. Or say someone else gets ahold of your computer, like a child or something, and creates a player. Should you be penalized in these situations?


Actually, you don't. The actual creation of the player is 100% refundable. Before the reroll button existed, people used to retire players to reroll. It's one of the reasons it was added.

It's only boosts and custom equipment that are 70%.

But wanting 100% back for all your boosts...no damn way. I'd be playing for free after I retired my players. Not in the site's best interest (would be cool for me, I'll admit).
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 15:56:51
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
yeah wisler, Ken is on the money...you get 100% of player creation cost back..you only lose 30% on boosts & buying custom equipment, all of which are optional (yet really necessary) to be competitive...look at those costs as your payment to play the game, and you get 70% back later on.
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
yeah wisler, Ken is on the money...you get 100% of player creation cost back..you only lose 30% on boosts & buying custom equipment, all of which are optional (yet really necessary) to be competitive...look at those costs as your payment to play the game, and you get 70% back later on.


That's exactly what I had stated.

But I had mentioned that if Bort does not want to give 100% back on everything, he should keep it how it currently is, not drop it to 70% for everything.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by SCACE

yeah wisler, Ken is on the money...you get 100% of player creation cost back..you only lose 30% on boosts & buying custom equipment, all of which are optional (yet really necessary) to be competitive...look at those costs as your payment to play the game, and you get 70% back later on.


That's exactly what I had stated.

But I had mentioned that if Bort does not want to give 100% back on everything, he should keep it how it currently is, not drop it to 70% for everything.


How it currently is, is 70% for everything (except initial creation).
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by cwisler

Originally posted by SCACE


yeah wisler, Ken is on the money...you get 100% of player creation cost back..you only lose 30% on boosts & buying custom equipment, all of which are optional (yet really necessary) to be competitive...look at those costs as your payment to play the game, and you get 70% back later on.


That's exactly what I had stated.

But I had mentioned that if Bort does not want to give 100% back on everything, he should keep it how it currently is, not drop it to 70% for everything.


How it currently is, is 70% for everything (except initial creation).


Yes, I know. Was I not clear enough in my initial post? Sorry if I wasn't.

My ideal thought:
100% Refund for Player creation
100% Refund for Custom equipment
100% Refund for Boosts

Current:
100% Refund for Player creation
70% Refund for Custom equipment
70% Refund for Boosts

What I had thought had been proposed:
70% Refund for Player creation
70% Refund for Custom equipment
70% Refund for Boosts
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
no, noone has ever proposed getting back less (i.e. dropping creation from 100% to 70%) as far as I've seen.
 
manic
offline
Link
 
What about adding an option when retiring a player after his skills start to decline to get the 70% refund for custom equipment, or keep the custom equipment to use on a future player. If an SA tree had been added to the equipment leave the 300 flex invested in the equipment but set it where the tree needs to be selected again when the the player hits level 8..
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 18:23:33
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by manic
What about adding an option when retiring a player after his skills start to decline to get the 70% refund for custom equipment, or keep the custom equipment to use on a future player. If an SA tree had been added to the equipment leave the 300 flex invested in the equipment but set it where the tree needs to be selected again when the the player hits level 8..


It is at most $2.70 hit per player to retire custom equipment, much less if you bought your XP in bulk, down to almost $1.00 for those that bought the biggest package. A $1.00 - $2.70 cost over 450+ days (10 seasons, but you might play more) seems reasonable, no?

This probably deserves posting again...(I round, but you'll get the just of it)

Glamour Position, 12 seasons (assuming 12 seasons of boosting + full custom):

Gross Cost: 12,000 Flex Points
Returned Upon Retirement: 8,400 Flex Points
Net Cost: 3,600 Flex Points
Days of enjoyment (approx.): 540 (or almost 1 1/2 actual years)
Gross Cost per day: 22 flex points
Net Cost per day: 7 flex points
Real Money Max Gross Cost: $120
Real Money Max Net Cost: $36
Real Money Max Gross Cost per day: $0.22
Real Money Max Net Cost per day: $0.07
Real Money Min Gross Cost: $48
Real Money Min Net Cost: $14.40
Real Money Min Gross Cost per day: $0.09
Real Money Min Net Cost per day: $0.03

Normal Position, 12 seasons (assuming 12 seasons of boosting + full custom):

Gross Cost: 8,300 Flex Points
Returned Upon Retirement: 5,810 Flex Points
Net Cost: 2,490 Flex Points
Days of enjoyment (approx.): 540 (or almost 1 1/2 actual years)
Gross Cost per day: 15 flex points
Net Cost per day: 5 flex points
Real Money Max Gross Cost: $83
Real Money Max Net Cost: $24.90
Real Money Max Gross Cost per day: $0.15
Real Money Max Net Cost per day: $0.05
Real Money Min Gross Cost: $33.20
Real Money Min Net Cost: $10.00
Real Money Min Gross Cost per day: $0.06
Real Money Min Net Cost per day: $0.02

Non-Glamour Position, 12 seasons (assuming 12 seasons of boosting + full custom):

Gross Cost: 4,600 Flex Points
Returned Upon Retirement: 3,220 Flex Points
Net Cost: 1,380 Flex Points
Days of enjoyment (approx.): 540 (or almost 1 1/2 actual years)
Gross Cost per day: 9 flex points
Net Cost per day: 3 flex points
Real Money Max Gross Cost: $46
Real Money Max Net Cost: $13.80
Real Money Max Gross Cost per day: $0.09
Real Money Max Net Cost per day: $0.03
Real Money Min Gross Cost: $18.40
Real Money Min Net Cost: $5.50
Real Money Min Gross Cost per day: $0.03
Real Money Min Net Cost per day: $0.01
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LoperK
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by tpaterniti


You can criticize it but Bort has told me plainly that it is never going to happen. But by all means discuss to your hearts content.


What I have said many times is that players are going to decline in some way at some point. They are not going to live forever and keep getting better until every stat is at 100, because that would be really dumb and would make the HOF pointless. I'm still up for suggestions on things they can do after they start to "get old" (coaches, "legacy", etc)

You can add 100% FP refund on retirements to the "never going to happen" list, though.


Ya 100% FP refund is a retarded idea. I just think this idea needs to be revamped to make it so everybody is happy. That way Bort makes a profit, (which he obviously should) noobies get to get better and be on top, and vets are happy and not left discarded on the side.


The vets will never be "left discarded on the side" that's a dumb way to think about it. Their oldest players may get discarded, but that doesn't give them any disadvantage that every other player in the game won't face as well. The fact is that if you create a player every season, you will never get "discarded on the side." Only if you want to create one player and have him go forever...which would completely screw the realistic nature of this game.
 
Deadpool
offline
Link
 
First off, I don't like the 70% refund policy, but i understand that it is a must to keep the game alive, so hey i will learn to live with it.
Secondly if retired players can become coaches ( which i think is a better idea then a leauge foe 10+ season players ) how about a coach option at the character creation stage. At low levels they can be video assistants e.c.t. and move on to QB/LB coaches, Co-ordinators then Head Coaches.
Each stage might give bonuses to different stats i.e. video assistants gain vision faster.
A Coach could have a career span of say 30 seasons before retiring.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deadpool
First off, I don't like the 70% refund policy, but i understand that it is a must to keep the game alive, so hey i will learn to live with it.
Secondly if retired players can become coaches ( which i think is a better idea then a leauge foe 10+ season players ) how about a coach option at the character creation stage. At low levels they can be video assistants e.c.t. and move on to QB/LB coaches, Co-ordinators then Head Coaches.
Each stage might give bonuses to different stats i.e. video assistants gain vision faster.
A Coach could have a career span of say 30 seasons before retiring.


If becoming a coach is a perk for retired players, it loses its value if at the creation stage someone can select it.
 
JuggaloXtreme
offline
Link
 
He meant discuss it in this thread!

Originally posted by Animalmother
Originally posted by LoperK

Originally posted by imwatchingespn


Originally posted by LoperK



tpaterniti, why are we not allowed to make discussions on this?


because you're wrong


Wrong about what? They are ideas, 99% of them are not mine. I am not wrong about anything you moron.



tap said discuss it all you want...hold him to it.

go make a post that says ...GOOD idea 10 season Decline...

Keep it positive and only for progress TOWARDS FIXING DECLINE for everyone.

Decline in some form is a Fact now.... not a option were going to change.
Bort ended the debate with his post here.

If you like any posts from it...link the pages in your opening thread and they live forever. Or copy paste quotes...

Maybe its best you just try to collect ideas and opinions for moving foward.
I dont see them backing off of decline untill the market is so screwed from other football mmorpgs they just have to.

IDK just an idea...its been hours and its super easy to unlock a thread...I dont think they want some of it read with tons of new peeps joining either




The fight is in getting a good program to work along with decline for long term players.

.

We all had good ideas and im sure they talked it over so rehashing it at this point may be mute.... now that i think about it?


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.