User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Gameplan doesnt run in playoff game WTF?
Page:
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=693220&pbp_id=18396295
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=693220&pbp_id=18397313
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=693220&pbp_id=18400321
http://i27.tinypic.com/dey1zs.jpg

I'd be less worried except for my passing QB was on the depth chart before the game (in the QB slot as usual) and there are no 5WR runs in my playbook.
 
backstop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Headbutt
What the fuck is going on with all the AI fuck ups in the playoffs and why the fuck isn't Bort doing something about it RIGHT NOW?


+ fucking 1

This is bullshit. Tons of time and $$ and the fucking AI goes haywire in the conference championship. Wrong guys running the ball, no punts at all, going for it deeeep in our own territory. Auto adjust off too. WTF!
Edited by backstop on Jul 27, 2009 15:59:36
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
bump
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
I always worried about the transfer AI's script from team to team. Probably the conspiracy lover in me, but it wouldn't surprise me if there is a way to circumvent the player id's and send a bogus AI to a team, or to actually fool the server into believing you should have access to someone else AI and just screw up a few things. hate to throw that out there, but it mhas crossed my mind.

Probably crazy talk, since most of the problems are people due to adding additional stuff to the AI for the playoffs and screwing up some settings.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I always worried about the transfer AI's script from team to team. Probably the conspiracy lover in me, but it wouldn't surprise me if there is a way to circumvent the player id's and send a bogus AI to a team, or to actually fool the server into believing you should have access to someone else AI and just screw up a few things. hate to throw that out there, but it mhas crossed my mind.

Probably crazy talk, since most of the problems are people due to adding additional stuff to the AI for the playoffs and screwing up some settings.


Even if it were possible to "Send" the AI, you would not be able to "Update" it because you are not an OC on the team. And as we have all learned the hard way.. if you don't hit "Update" then it isn't saved, or used.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I always worried about the transfer AI's script from team to team. Probably the conspiracy lover in me, but it wouldn't surprise me if there is a way to circumvent the player id's and send a bogus AI to a team, or to actually fool the server into believing you should have access to someone else AI and just screw up a few things. hate to throw that out there, but it mhas crossed my mind.

Probably crazy talk, since most of the problems are people due to adding additional stuff to the AI for the playoffs and screwing up some settings.


Of course it is possible these are just computers and sure have some securities flaws. However to do it without a trace (like having the messed up OAI remaining after the game) will take some skill. If someone is doing it you should see that something wrong just by having the problem rising in a specific league. Hopefully we are through with the Dongs
 
backstop
offline
Link
 
Still haven't heard anything from the top. I hope this isn't just getting blown off.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by backstop
Still haven't heard anything from the top. I hope this isn't just getting blown off.


Quite.

There have actually been two bugs reported here:

1. AI calling plays not in playbook/not in output that covers that eventuality.
2. OAI randomiser not being random (eg streaks of plays being called that have very little chance of happening if sim was really choosing at random based on percentages in AI, even when auto adjust is off).

I wonder if the issue is that the two things are connected? I have always thought that (2) might be deliberate and that the sim adjusts playcalls, maybe that is what is causing (1)?

Given the number of times (2) has been raised and the lack of anyone from GLB addressing it, I am beginning to wonder...
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
Originally posted by backstop

Still haven't heard anything from the top. I hope this isn't just getting blown off.


Quite.

There have actually been two bugs reported here:

1. AI calling plays not in playbook/not in output that covers that eventuality.
2. OAI randomiser not being random (eg streaks of plays being called that have very little chance of happening if sim was really choosing at random based on percentages in AI, even when auto adjust is off).

I wonder if the issue is that the two things are connected? I have always thought that (2) might be deliberate and that the sim adjusts playcalls, maybe that is what is causing (1)?

Given the number of times (2) has been raised and the lack of anyone from GLB addressing it, I am beginning to wonder...



#2 is random. A play with 5% chance can be called 5 times in a row...it will happen about every 3,000,000 chances.

There are roughly 2,700,000 plays called in just the 8 regions each season, so one would expect a 5% play to be called 5 consecutive times about once each season for someone in the AA or higher levels.



#1- As painful as it is, I have never managed to actually nail down what I thought was a bug of this nature. I have always found the problem eventually...though sometimes the problem is quite obscure.


Don't examine your AI with the assumption that there is a bug or flaw, but rather with the assumption that you have made an error. Take it as a challenge to find it.

Could be a bug. But I would lay 100-1 odds that it is an error (or a known "feature" at least )
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by islander1


Did one of you have the tactics/AI page open after 1pm?



Don't know.

But as for the FG thing:

http://img407.imageshack.us/img407/5112/picture5w.png

LOL. In the very same picture you have us kicking a FG, and the AI tester saying Punt. I love it.


I had problem with the OAI/DAI tester from the replay page. It sometime runs the wrong test.


Hit the "link" button before you test.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by ryanshaw

Originally posted by backstop


Still haven't heard anything from the top. I hope this isn't just getting blown off.


Quite.

There have actually been two bugs reported here:

1. AI calling plays not in playbook/not in output that covers that eventuality.
2. OAI randomiser not being random (eg streaks of plays being called that have very little chance of happening if sim was really choosing at random based on percentages in AI, even when auto adjust is off).

I wonder if the issue is that the two things are connected? I have always thought that (2) might be deliberate and that the sim adjusts playcalls, maybe that is what is causing (1)?

Given the number of times (2) has been raised and the lack of anyone from GLB addressing it, I am beginning to wonder...



#2 is random. A play with 5% chance can be called 5 times in a row...it will happen about every 3,000,000 chances.

There are roughly 2,700,000 plays called in just the 8 regions each season, so one would expect a 5% play to be called 5 consecutive times about once each season for someone in the AA or higher levels.



#1- As painful as it is, I have never managed to actually nail down what I thought was a bug of this nature. I have always found the problem eventually...though sometimes the problem is quite obscure.


Don't examine your AI with the assumption that there is a bug or flaw, but rather with the assumption that you have made an error. Take it as a challenge to find it.

Could be a bug. But I would lay 100-1 odds that it is an error (or a known "feature" at least )


I can guarantee you it was a bug for us.

Ran tester with the EXACT situation down to the second, it gave us an output. Checked output, exact plays were selected using select play feature. Completely different plays were used with the wrong personnel too. Like putting our scat back in I-form rushes up the middle we didn't even have in the output in the first place. Passing to our blocking TE we haven't passed to once the whole regular season.

And we didn't even change the AI from one game to the next; just the outputs.

Oh yeah...and the 3 60+ yd FGs when we never attempted one past 57 yards all season, and when our max was set to 57 yds.

I can't blame you for being skeptical. I know it would too if it didn't happen to me. I just can't find any reason at all it didn't run our gameplan. So far I am still at a loss.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology


#2 is random. A play with 5% chance can be called 5 times in a row...it will happen about every 3,000,000 chances.

There are roughly 2,700,000 plays called in just the 8 regions each season, so one would expect a 5% play to be called 5 consecutive times about once each season for someone in the AA or higher levels.


With respect, you do not know that it is random, you are simply choosing to assume it is random. I know the odds as well but this has been reported consistently and my own experience is that it happens too much to be random - I usually see very low percentage outcomes 2-3 times a season for my own team. For clarity, we are not talking about just the same play being called a few times in a row, but the chance that the actual outcome could occur at random based on the AI inputs (eg 30% chance of x being called, actually does not get called on x number of instances - what is the chance this could happen if choice was random).

All I (and others) have asked is that it be checked and someone report back, which never happens. Two simple questions:

1. Is there something wrong with the randomiser (I have seen a comment saying that Bort has acknowledged there might be, but cannot find that original post). If so, can it be fixed?
2. Is there ANYTHING in the sim that interferes with the play selection being totally based on the AI when auto adjust if off. Any momentum effects? Anything at all?



 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by ryanshaw


Originally posted by backstop



Still haven't heard anything from the top. I hope this isn't just getting blown off.


Quite.

There have actually been two bugs reported here:

1. AI calling plays not in playbook/not in output that covers that eventuality.
2. OAI randomiser not being random (eg streaks of plays being called that have very little chance of happening if sim was really choosing at random based on percentages in AI, even when auto adjust is off).

I wonder if the issue is that the two things are connected? I have always thought that (2) might be deliberate and that the sim adjusts playcalls, maybe that is what is causing (1)?

Given the number of times (2) has been raised and the lack of anyone from GLB addressing it, I am beginning to wonder...



#2 is random. A play with 5% chance can be called 5 times in a row...it will happen about every 3,000,000 chances.

There are roughly 2,700,000 plays called in just the 8 regions each season, so one would expect a 5% play to be called 5 consecutive times about once each season for someone in the AA or higher levels.



#1- As painful as it is, I have never managed to actually nail down what I thought was a bug of this nature. I have always found the problem eventually...though sometimes the problem is quite obscure.


Don't examine your AI with the assumption that there is a bug or flaw, but rather with the assumption that you have made an error. Take it as a challenge to find it.

Could be a bug. But I would lay 100-1 odds that it is an error (or a known "feature" at least )


I can guarantee you it was a bug for us.

Ran tester with the EXACT situation down to the second, it gave us an output. Checked output, exact plays were selected using select play feature. Completely different plays were used with the wrong personnel too. Like putting our scat back in I-form rushes up the middle we didn't even have in the output in the first place. Passing to our blocking TE we haven't passed to once the whole regular season.

And we didn't even change the AI from one game to the next; just the outputs.

Oh yeah...and the 3 60+ yd FGs when we never attempted one past 57 yards all season, and when our max was set to 57 yds.

I can't blame you for being skeptical. I know it would too if it didn't happen to me. I just can't find any reason at all it didn't run our gameplan. So far I am still at a loss.


Sounds very much like you ran a "basic" AI setting for the game?

If your AI was corrupted (by trying to update right at rollover for instance) or was unavailable as someone was tryi g to update it just as the sim was trying to lock it for game time...I could maybe see that happening.

Was there anything recognizable, or were there just selected issues?
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology


Sounds very much like you ran a "basic" AI setting for the game?

If your AI was corrupted (by trying to update right at rollover for instance) or was unavailable as someone was tryi g to update it just as the sim was trying to lock it for game time...I could maybe see that happening.

Was there anything recognizable, or were there just selected issues?


bhall updated it in the afternoon the day before the game.

Anything recognizable? The whole thing looked like crap. I'm pretty sure it was just random. I only looked at a handfull of plays and tested them, and 100% of them were completely wrong. 3 first down plays I posted earlier in this topic , I also tested some 2nd down plays which were also wrong. I just didn't post them because I don't want to give away our whole freakin AI lol.

So all in all I tested about 10 plays, all 10 plays supposedly came out as the right output, but the plays that were called in the game were not the outputs we had. 100% of the ones I tested came out wrong in the actual game. That was enough for me.

Not to mention I watch all our games and know how our offense looks being the assistant OC. Just watching it you could tell it wasn't anything like what we usually run.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Jul 30, 2009 19:26:30
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Taut said exactly what I was thinking. It appears to be basic AI.

Means one of these things (assuming your AI tester states confirms that it's not an input error on your end)

1) Someone didn't check the Enable AI button
2) AutoAdjust was at 100 and you ran one play that worked and the AI just decided to do what it wanted to do that was similiar to that play
3) Your playbook/inputs/outputs were jacked up


I'd look at #3 real hard, I'm not familiar with the script you are using here

http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7942/picture1chy.png

but why does the sweep strong indicate pass? te quick hit indicate run pitch?

If I had to guess, I'd say this isn't a case of the sim just doing what it wants to do. I'd say either your input/outputs are screwed up (What you call them vs. what's actually in there) or your Playbook is messed up...wrong playbook...not enabled...whatever.

When you something gets selected...like 10% HB sweep strong and if you input/output/playbook match doesn't make any sense...the AI just picks something to run. I'll bet that's what happened here for sure.
Edited by BP on Jul 30, 2009 19:26:36
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.