Originally posted by ryanshaw
Originally posted by backstop
Still haven't heard anything from the top. I hope this isn't just getting blown off.
Quite.
There have actually been two bugs reported here:
1. AI calling plays not in playbook/not in output that covers that eventuality.
2. OAI randomiser not being random (eg streaks of plays being called that have very little chance of happening if sim was really choosing at random based on percentages in AI, even when auto adjust is off).
I wonder if the issue is that the two things are connected? I have always thought that (2) might be deliberate and that the sim adjusts playcalls, maybe that is what is causing (1)?
Given the number of times (2) has been raised and the lack of anyone from GLB addressing it, I am beginning to wonder...#2 is random. A play with 5% chance can be called 5 times in a row...it will happen about every 3,000,000 chances.
There are roughly 2,700,000 plays called in just the 8 regions each season, so one would expect a 5% play to be called 5 consecutive times about once each season for someone in the AA or higher levels.
#1- As painful as it is, I have never managed to actually nail down what I thought was a bug of this nature. I have always found the problem eventually...though sometimes the problem is quite obscure.
Don't examine your AI with the assumption that there is a bug or flaw, but rather with the assumption that you have made an error. Take it as a challenge to find it.
Could be a bug. But I would lay 100-1 odds that it is an error (or a known "feature" at least

)