User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League? Poll the Audience.
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie


and get an empty win. A gold trophy in SLAP is not gold unless you take down the benitos


No. You get your chance to move into World. Then you get to play your dot heroes along with other top level teams. If you are unable to make it to World League you would not be able to beat them anyway.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

Some people are stating they are against this but not giving any reason why...I would love to hear some reasons why someone would be against this....


Originally posted by Ravenwood

Recap of the arguments against:

1. A world league erodes the identities and communities of the regions
2. A world league belittles the current pro leagues, which will basically become the equivalent of AAAs
3. A world league takes away the need for a tournament of champions - a tournament which adds a ton of flavour and an element of variety to the game
4. A world league, added at this point, after 10 seasons, gives the impression that GLB is all about keeping a certain few teams, players and agents at the very top of the pyramid, and be damned to everyone else.


As for #4, its already kind of like that, (when you have 2 top teams combine, yeah, its definitly like that). I'm not saying i have problem with that, its all about who you know,thats a fact of life. im just saying that impression has been there for a while now.

Pretend your in the pro leauges and not a part of the "elite group" who all seem to be involved with the same best teams from several of the leauges.

I know what me and the teams i am and have been involved with are up against and i'm fine with it, I'm a philly guy so i love to play rocky, but to someone who has to learn the hard way what it takes to overcome a top GLB team, after working long and hard for the chance (not to mention $), it might not be such a cool thing to realize.
Edited by odg62 on Jul 8, 2009 22:37:41
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by Second Goalie

Originally posted by dpride59


Originally posted by Ravenwood



Originally posted by dpride59




Because 95% of glb won't be able to participate. This should be a decision based on Bort, and the 50 or so candidates for the WPL.

So you're suggesting the entire game experience should be based on the interests of a select few?


How would your game experience be worse by seeing the 32 best run teams getting a chance to slug it out? You still get to compete with teams at your level, and if you are at that level of the best you get to go slug it out with the best.

I don't understand how the best of GLB in one league will make your gaming experience, or any ones gaming experience worse, other than jealousy.


Exactly. The only "change" would be top Pro teams would be playing all top pro teams. If anything it improves the gaming experience of every other team in GLB since the championship teams would not be around to dominate the league again the next season making room for another team to step up.


and get an empty win. A gold trophy in SLAP is not gold unless you take down the benitos


Honestly, the Benitos deserve better. They shouldn't have to stay in the Pros where it is clear that there are no teams that can compete with them (except of course the Monkeys who would also leave). Havoc and his team deserve the chance (like all the teams in the World League) to put their skills, builds, and AI to the test game in and game out against meaningful competition.

I understand the issues with building rivalries, I understand the issues with keeping leagues together, and I understand the issues with setting goals to take down the top teams.

Unfortunately, it isn't good business to have elite teams stay in the Pros and collect 5-10 gold trophies, especially with the new league structuring making it difficult to move up to the Pros to begin with.

How many teams get burnt out in the Pros because it simply isn't possible to compete with some of the top Juggernauts?

Sure, I'm probably biased, but the truth is, our team isn't likely to compete for a title without the Benitos either way. It just isn't fair to them or to the other teams in SLAP to keep them around when it is clear that they are ready to be promoted to something greater.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
I just can't imagine how so many people are so bunched up in the panties about the idea of a World League screwing up "rivalries" - it's not a fucking rivalry if they kick the shit out of you every time you play them...
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
I'm not really for or against the WPL. If it's done I think it should be made similar to the NFL with divisions and possibly tweak the schedule to be more like the NFL for the WPL. I also think it should be playoffs or back down.
 
The Big House
offline
Link
 
Vote! I'm in!
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
I'm not really for or against the WPL. If it's done I think it should be made similar to the NFL with divisions and possibly tweak the schedule to be more like the NFL for the WPL. I also think it should be playoffs or back down.


Eh. Sub-.500 should suffice.

If you're good enough to win more than you lose there, you've earned the right to another shot at it.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho

Honestly, the Benitos deserve better. They shouldn't have to stay in the Pros where it is clear that there are no teams that can compete with them (except of course the Monkeys who would also leave). Havoc and his team deserve the chance (like all the teams in the World League) to put their skills, builds, and AI to the test game in and game out against meaningful competition.

I understand the issues with building rivalries, I understand the issues with keeping leagues together, and I understand the issues with setting goals to take down the top teams.

Unfortunately, it isn't good business to have elite teams stay in the Pros and collect 5-10 gold trophies, especially with the new league structuring making it difficult to move up to the Pros to begin with.

How many teams get burnt out in the Pros because it simply isn't possible to compete with some of the top Juggernauts?

Sure, I'm probably biased, but the truth is, our team isn't likely to compete for a title without the Benitos either way. It just isn't fair to them or to the other teams in SLAP to keep them around when it is clear that they are ready to be promoted to something greater.


first of all i'd like to hear havoc weigh in on the issue.

secondly the benitos have been challenged from time to time (and nearly beaten by several teams over the seasons).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=477313 7 point win
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=292238 7 point win
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=376720 1 yard short of a loss

I can see your point though about the consistent challenge though, lol


 
Jayadamo
Vol4Life
offline
Link
 
The idea is great.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by Anarcho


Honestly, the Benitos deserve better. They shouldn't have to stay in the Pros where it is clear that there are no teams that can compete with them (except of course the Monkeys who would also leave). Havoc and his team deserve the chance (like all the teams in the World League) to put their skills, builds, and AI to the test game in and game out against meaningful competition.

I understand the issues with building rivalries, I understand the issues with keeping leagues together, and I understand the issues with setting goals to take down the top teams.

Unfortunately, it isn't good business to have elite teams stay in the Pros and collect 5-10 gold trophies, especially with the new league structuring making it difficult to move up to the Pros to begin with.

How many teams get burnt out in the Pros because it simply isn't possible to compete with some of the top Juggernauts?

Sure, I'm probably biased, but the truth is, our team isn't likely to compete for a title without the Benitos either way. It just isn't fair to them or to the other teams in SLAP to keep them around when it is clear that they are ready to be promoted to something greater.


first of all i'd like to hear havoc weigh in on the issue.

secondly the benitos have been challenged from time to time (and nearly beaten by several teams over the seasons).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=477313 7 point win
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=292238 7 point win
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=376720 1 yard short of a loss

I can see your point though about the consistent challenge though, lol




Havoc has always seemed like a hard-working stand up kind of guy who enjoys a challenge. I certainly can't speak for him, but I'm sure the only enjoyment he gets is not having to game plan during the regular season. It seems like the only game he has to prep for is the Monkeys every season. That can't be fun for him.

And even if it is, it's not fun for everyone else. Teams like MPHD, the Fire, the Wop Wops, etc. all deserve a shot at a title and it won't happen as long as the Benitos are in SLAP. I'm sure it's like that in other leagues too. If we are trying to get parity in the leagues, it has to go both ways. You have to get rid of the CPU teams AND the clearly superior teams. Otherwise you end up with a 1 game season (Benitos vs Monkeys).

EDIT: Also, your post just makes my point. Who wants to pay 400 flex per season to play for a CHANCE at having a 7 point loss at best?
Edited by Anarcho on Jul 8, 2009 22:59:14
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
I just can't imagine how so many people are so bunched up in the panties about the idea of a World League screwing up "rivalries" - it's not a fucking rivalry if they kick the shit out of you every time you play them...


lol

You mean WSI and santiago didn't have a rivalry with all the teams they stomped for 80 games in a row or whatever the streak was they were once on?

So basically it's another case of a team worried they can't make the big leagues mad because their "status" will be diminished. If people want the status and title of being a top team, just make wpl. Otherwise, keep working at it. Lots of solid AAA teams never make the pros. Look at Laredo Lesbians.

KKAR proved that you can have losing seasons and rebound. They went like 8-8 and then 6-10, in season 7 and 8 before having a big year in usa aaa2 and then getting to the pros and doing really well in usapl their first season at 5-4.

I think people forget that not all teams will be able to to be the best. They all have a chance at it if they're good enough, but chances are they're not as good as they think they are.
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 8, 2009 22:59:39
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho

How many teams get burnt out in the Pros because it simply isn't possible to compete with some of the top Juggernauts?


This is a problem. I'm not saying i have a solution and im not saying that the people who work hard to get to the top dont deserve it, but this is a problem.

I know realisim is frowend upon, but in the NFL a leuage of 32 teams (today) there have been 18 champs in 29 years since the super bowl. The top team has 6 chips in 29 years. In GLB with multiple 32 team leauges, it seems it always the same teams by far. At the pace this game is going there are teams that could have 15-20 chips by season 29.

A big reason the NFL is the most popular is the parity, the "any given sunday factor".

that is sorely lacking in GLB.

 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
Originally posted by HurricaneBear

I'm not really for or against the WPL. If it's done I think it should be made similar to the NFL with divisions and possibly tweak the schedule to be more like the NFL for the WPL. I also think it should be playoffs or back down.


Eh. Sub-.500 should suffice.

If you're good enough to win more than you lose there, you've earned the right to another shot at it.


I disagree. IF its supposed to be the best of the best, being .500ish isn't good enough. Playoffs or go home and let someone else from your original league take a crack. If it's going to be the big boy league, make it worth it. Will also make the Pro leagues still mean something as the WPL will not be something you can count on staying in.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
Originally posted by Anarcho


How many teams get burnt out in the Pros because it simply isn't possible to compete with some of the top Juggernauts?


This is a problem. I'm not saying i have a solution and im not saying that the people who work hard to get to the top dont deserve it, but this is a problem.

I know realisim is frowend upon, but in the NFL a leuage of 32 teams (today) there have been 18 champs in 29 years since the super bowl. The top team has 6 chips in 29 years. In GLB with multiple 32 team leauges, it seems it always the same teams by far. At the pace this game is going there are teams that could have 15-20 chips by season 29.

A big reason the NFL is the most popular is the parity, the "any given sunday factor".

that is sorely lacking in GLB.



http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1675992

3 and half seasons ago.

6 of those teams are still ranked in the top 25 (that's including Halifax-Drygerian). 9 of those teams no longer exist. Most of the rest are decent, but hardly at the top of the game. On top of that, you'll be amazed by the parity that will come to GLB once the plateau/decline goes into effect. Basically, at the top, you'll have about 6 seasons worth of players as opposed to the 3 seasons worth currently.
 
Buxx
offline
Link
 
How bout for the first year :

1) Stay in your league ... World League is an extra free scrimmage league
2) The commission chooses the teams ... disputes settled by scrimmages
3) 17 teams play each other once ... top 8 make playoffs



 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.