Originally posted by Cryptotich
It's not a copout it is a reason. By calling it a copout you seem to be assuming that there is an imaginary state where vision checks are never failed for any reason. And in this state, your player will do as exactly as you have told him to do, and always make the correct choice when presented with a quandary. I am pretty sure that because of the random number generator, that state will never exist, and your player will make mistakes.
No it's a copout because "more vision" is all that is said, there is never a benchmark, delta or reference given. It's a blanket statement and the end of the discussion.
Originally posted by
If all the players did exactly what they were supposed to do in college or pro football, there would be a lot less scoring. Ever hear the term "Broken Coverage", "Missed Assignment", or "out of position"? They usually come after a big play either on offense or defense. In GLB our rough equivalent of a players "football sense" is Vision.
I agree to some extent, however in this case there are only 3 options. Cover, Blitz, or Zone, if your assignment is cover player X or Blitz then those should be the only two actions a player takes regardless of a vision check. Dropping into zone or picking up another man is not the loldot's responsibility. In one of the replays the LB doesn't follow his man or blitz, instead picks up the TE that is streaking down the field. So does that mean he failed a vision check and did his own thing? He passed the Coverage Vision check and realized his man was blocking then failed his blitz vision check? Did he fail the vision check at the snap and completely missed the whole play?
I've said it before, you go onto the field with your responsibilities and you don't worry about anything else. If your told to cover the FB or Blitz and there isn't a FB on the field then your blitzing. As a player you do not get to make the choice to disregard the coach and cover the TE instead. So if the TE is left wide open it's up to the QB to make his vision check and get the pass off to the open man to create your Broken Coverage", "Missed Assignment", or "out of position".
Originally posted by
The exact numbers you need to reach to pass a given vision test are unknown, as are the factors that go into the making the roll. So when someone comes i here and his player does something unusual, the first thing we ask ourselfs is what was he supposed to be doing, then we compare it to what he did. Most of the time its's a pretty clear case that a better vision check roll looked like it would have helped. would have helped.
Hence the major gripe from the player base and the wearing thin of the vision excuse by the Admins. If I scout a team and they've got a crappy tight end, I'll blitz more and suck up the plays that the TE makes. If my LB isn't following the logic given to him in the AI then it's a bug.
It's not a copout it is a reason. By calling it a copout you seem to be assuming that there is an imaginary state where vision checks are never failed for any reason. And in this state, your player will do as exactly as you have told him to do, and always make the correct choice when presented with a quandary. I am pretty sure that because of the random number generator, that state will never exist, and your player will make mistakes.
No it's a copout because "more vision" is all that is said, there is never a benchmark, delta or reference given. It's a blanket statement and the end of the discussion.
Originally posted by
If all the players did exactly what they were supposed to do in college or pro football, there would be a lot less scoring. Ever hear the term "Broken Coverage", "Missed Assignment", or "out of position"? They usually come after a big play either on offense or defense. In GLB our rough equivalent of a players "football sense" is Vision.
I agree to some extent, however in this case there are only 3 options. Cover, Blitz, or Zone, if your assignment is cover player X or Blitz then those should be the only two actions a player takes regardless of a vision check. Dropping into zone or picking up another man is not the loldot's responsibility. In one of the replays the LB doesn't follow his man or blitz, instead picks up the TE that is streaking down the field. So does that mean he failed a vision check and did his own thing? He passed the Coverage Vision check and realized his man was blocking then failed his blitz vision check? Did he fail the vision check at the snap and completely missed the whole play?
I've said it before, you go onto the field with your responsibilities and you don't worry about anything else. If your told to cover the FB or Blitz and there isn't a FB on the field then your blitzing. As a player you do not get to make the choice to disregard the coach and cover the TE instead. So if the TE is left wide open it's up to the QB to make his vision check and get the pass off to the open man to create your Broken Coverage", "Missed Assignment", or "out of position".
Originally posted by
The exact numbers you need to reach to pass a given vision test are unknown, as are the factors that go into the making the roll. So when someone comes i here and his player does something unusual, the first thing we ask ourselfs is what was he supposed to be doing, then we compare it to what he did. Most of the time its's a pretty clear case that a better vision check roll looked like it would have helped. would have helped.
Hence the major gripe from the player base and the wearing thin of the vision excuse by the Admins. If I scout a team and they've got a crappy tight end, I'll blitz more and suck up the plays that the TE makes. If my LB isn't following the logic given to him in the AI then it's a bug.
Edited by Signalsgt on Jul 1, 2009 08:08:00






























