User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Yes, we are aware the I slam play is frequntly cheesy and many teams are running it over and over. No, we are not updating things in-season.
Page:
 
l40niners1
offline
Link
 
How bout an amendment to the week 12 rule such as:

If after week 12 no new additions to the game such as it is now except exploits to the game can be fixed at anytime as long as advanced notice is given.

ex. Slam is a known exploit so it will be fixed after week 12 after Bort makes an announcement letting everyone know he is going to do so
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
[Off-Topic]
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 17:49:44
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Bort,

Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.

Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s
 
Link
 
Instead of taking out I slam now, how about giving defense big bonus after seeing same play many times. This would only penalize teams running same play over and over again, which is not you want to see it happened anyway.
 
Papa Zito
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I can answer questions here and there, but I have mods, testers, and support staff who can help answer your questions as well. Send them a PM or post in the test blog section - they are happy to talk with you about your questions. .


No. No, this does not work. Your mods, testers, and support staff have the same access to the actual code that we do, so they can't answer our questions. We want to know how X works, or if X works at all, or if X affects Y, or if other variables are important, and they just don't know. At best, they have to run simulation after simulation to make educated guesses and then pass those along as fact. Hence the desire to "hear from the horse's mouth"... you're the only one who can actually answer questions without conjecture.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by jdbolick


Nice to get some confirmation, but I am concerned from reading the Season 9 announcement that the running game as a whole will get nuked instead of just addressing one overpowered and overused play. From what I've seen and read, running is next to impossible on the test server.


Mostly, it's been one tester concerned about one particular player having trouble, and less so recently. He recently beefed up the blocking for that player's team and he gained 1-2 YPC more. Blocking is quite important to a good running game.




Bort:

Seriously speaking ...

The slam is overpowered, no doubt about that. But if anything, the rest of the rushing game is under-powered. It is pretty damn hard to run against a decent defense without the slam (whoch is a big part of the reason it gets spammed).

I am very fearful that your global changes will eliminate the running game entiorely.

Are you taking a global approach to a specific problem?


The thing that's overpowered about the slam is the speed at which you can get to the line and then fall forward for 5 yards. Many of the other plays take longer to set up and get moving, which makes them less effective, though you can still get yards with them.

What's considered a "good" running game? Lots of people are used to 5, 6, 7 YPC being average on here, which is WAY too high - auto first down every 2 plays. Most runs against a good D should go for 2-5, not 4-7. Big runs in the NFL come from missed tackles or blown defensive play calls. If the box is stacked, we shouldn't be forcing teams to get 4 YPC just because it's a number to shoot for - that should shut down the run and make for some wide open receivers. The goal should be to force the defense to play more honest, through variety of plays and the passing game working well.
 
Little Dragon
offline
Link
 
I started to create a poll but forgot it was against forum rules. I will tell you the results surprised me though the ones that did vote.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Bort,

Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.

Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s




This would be a pretty good long term solution that would seem to catch a lot more problems...
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by l40niners1


If a play is so messed up why not just take it out of the sim until fixed? Its the same for everyone..

All it would really take to tone it down with the current code is adding a little delay at the start of the play, actually.
Once again, we go back to that week 12 thing.


while not altering the sim midway through the season is the best rule of thumb, i'm guessing most people would've preferred to make an exception in this case.

there needs to be a mechanism in place to handle situations when the line is crossed from "cheese" to "sim-breaking"... and i'm not sure the forums are the best vehicle for that.

perhaps next time, a poll? an "owners tribune"? we need something.


An owners only poll or something?


Please. Owners are overwhelmed in every poll about -team ownership(league restructuring for example)- by people that don't own teams.
 
saltman241
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by jdbolick



Nice to get some confirmation, but I am concerned from reading the Season 9 announcement that the running game as a whole will get nuked instead of just addressing one overpowered and overused play. From what I've seen and read, running is next to impossible on the test server.


Mostly, it's been one tester concerned about one particular player having trouble, and less so recently. He recently beefed up the blocking for that player's team and he gained 1-2 YPC more. Blocking is quite important to a good running game.




Bort:

Seriously speaking ...

The slam is overpowered, no doubt about that. But if anything, the rest of the rushing game is under-powered. It is pretty damn hard to run against a decent defense without the slam (whoch is a big part of the reason it gets spammed).

I am very fearful that your global changes will eliminate the running game entiorely.

Are you taking a global approach to a specific problem?


The thing that's overpowered about the slam is the speed at which you can get to the line and then fall forward for 5 yards. Many of the other plays take longer to set up and get moving, which makes them less effective, though you can still get yards with them.

What's considered a "good" running game? Lots of people are used to 5, 6, 7 YPC being average on here, which is WAY too high - auto first down every 2 plays. Most runs against a good D should go for 2-5, not 4-7. Big runs in the NFL come from missed tackles or blown defensive play calls. If the box is stacked, we shouldn't be forcing teams to get 4 YPC just because it's a number to shoot for - that should shut down the run and make for some wide open receivers. The goal should be to force the defense to play more honest, through variety of plays and the passing game working well.


Passing game LOLOLOLOLOLOLO!
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.

Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s


a common suggestion and a great one.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Bort,

Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.

Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s


I have tested it and it doesn't do a whole lot unless you buff a lot of defenses' abilities. You could have 1000 vision, but if you can't make it past a blocker, you're still screwed.
 
joemiken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Bort,

Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.

Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s


I support this 100% and I'm sure a lot of other coordinators will as well. This would prevent a team from running the same running/passing play over and over or just spamming the same blitz over and over. You can still have a heavy-run team, but they won't be able to key in on one play and cheese it to death. This would force a lot of OC/DCs to actually gameplan (i.e. do their job) and would greatly benefit the game.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Bort
An owners only poll or something?

Please. Owners are overwhelmed in every poll about -team ownership(league restructuring for example)- by people that don't own teams.


exactly.

and this also means that teams comprised of just a few agents get equal voice.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gart888

Bort,

Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.

Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s


I have tested it and it doesn't do a whole lot unless you buff a lot of defenses' abilities. You could have 1000 vision, but if you can't make it past a blocker, you're still screwed.


Then buff a lot of defenses' abilities.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.