Can't wait to see something implemented for this, it's really THE #1 issue in the sim today .
Forum > Suggestions > Repetitive plays: More it's run, more likely the defensive is to stop it.
Didn't see this, but you could add some further realism and "complexity" to it by having the Vision/Stat increase be modified by the rank of the "Generals" on the field. Thus, a team with a NT that has D-Line General of 3 would get a smaller increase than a team with D-Line General of 10. This simulates the fact that in real football, those guys are the ones calling out the defensive audibles and should be the ones to recognize a play first.
Or, you could keep the stat increase the same, but let the General SAs modify the number of times a play must be run before it is "recognized" and the stat increases kick in.
Or, you could keep the stat increase the same, but let the General SAs modify the number of times a play must be run before it is "recognized" and the stat increases kick in.
Randy03Texags
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I am testing out this idea right now, though I don't know how well it'll really work as far as stopping an overpowered play. A recognition boost still won't help you break blocks or make tackles. It will just get you to the block or missed tackle quicker.
See my post on Page 5, wait .. I know that I cant trust you to look, I have made a lot of good suggestions that never got looked at before. Even the suggestions that you said were good and you would get to Peter, you completely didnt get to and it has made stats and trophies worthless for the 4-5 seasons since we agreed that it would be in the best interest of GLB to not have stats against the bottom 4-6 teams counted for trophies or league leaders.
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Originally posted by jktooley
Not going to read through all of this.... But the idea I had....
run 10 times - +5% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again
run 20 Times - +10% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again
run 30 Times - +20% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again....
Yep thats close to what I think as well .. you need a +% all attributes as a scaling factor
It could be a +1% per time the play is run, that would be reasonable, you could run it 10 times and not notice a difference, but by 30 times, you would likely really notice, would it be too late by then? Thats a good question.
If you really wanted to force people to open up their playbooks .. a +2% per incident would work I figure that would amount to
5 times = 10%
10 times = 20%
20 times = 40% (I figure that would cut this crap out real quick)
30 times = 60% bonus
40 times = 80% bonus (doubt it would get this far then, only out of fear if anything)
I am testing out this idea right now, though I don't know how well it'll really work as far as stopping an overpowered play. A recognition boost still won't help you break blocks or make tackles. It will just get you to the block or missed tackle quicker.

See my post on Page 5, wait .. I know that I cant trust you to look, I have made a lot of good suggestions that never got looked at before. Even the suggestions that you said were good and you would get to Peter, you completely didnt get to and it has made stats and trophies worthless for the 4-5 seasons since we agreed that it would be in the best interest of GLB to not have stats against the bottom 4-6 teams counted for trophies or league leaders.
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Originally posted by jktooley
Not going to read through all of this.... But the idea I had....
run 10 times - +5% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again
run 20 Times - +10% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again
run 30 Times - +20% attribute boost across the board for defense when facing that play again....
Yep thats close to what I think as well .. you need a +% all attributes as a scaling factor
It could be a +1% per time the play is run, that would be reasonable, you could run it 10 times and not notice a difference, but by 30 times, you would likely really notice, would it be too late by then? Thats a good question.
If you really wanted to force people to open up their playbooks .. a +2% per incident would work I figure that would amount to
5 times = 10%
10 times = 20%
20 times = 40% (I figure that would cut this crap out real quick)
30 times = 60% bonus
40 times = 80% bonus (doubt it would get this far then, only out of fear if anything)
Last edited Mar 25, 2009 15:16:10
ralphy2236
offline
offline
How about you can pick one or two plays before the game that your team will focus on when the formation of that play shows up. When that formation shows up, you're players cheat towards where that play goes. If the team fools you and runs a different play you're screwed. Bam, prob solved.
P.S. I quit reading around page 3/4. Just putting that out there.
P.S. I quit reading around page 3/4. Just putting that out there.
Last edited Mar 25, 2009 15:53:49
Octowned
offline
offline
This suggestion needs a lot more meat to really give much that could be implemented without obvious exploits.... Here is a complex suggestion I have been thinking of for a while:
The defense "keeps track" of plays run out of certain formations. They "guess" with a certain extremity that the DC selects, much like the auto-adjust setting. If they guess right, they get a bonus. If they guess wrong, they don't get a bonus. Their aggressiveness on guessing is based on that DC setting, which would basically tell them when to guess, how to guess, etc., in a way we don't see (much like we don't know how auto adjust ACTUALLY works).
A few quick ideas on this:
After X strong I plays, the defense knows there have been "Y run right, X-Y pass."
The defense rolls "run" or "pass" based on aggressive checks.
1) Have there been enough plays for us to even guess yet?
-Aggressive approach: start guessing after just 2-3 plays
-Conservative approach: wait until later in the game, maybe after as much as 10-12 plays ran out of the formation
-Moderate approach: Somewhere in the middle...
2) Has there been enough discrepancy to BOTHER guessing?
-Aggressive approach: always make a guess
-Conservative approach: only guess if there is a higher ratio of one play to the others.. for example, only to start guessing if the run/pass ratio out of the formation is 70% or higher
-Moderate approach: That 70% could be lower.. down toward 60%
3) There is a roll to determine what the defense thinks is going to happen
-Aggressive approach: guess whatever has happened the most. If it is 7 run, 5 pass, they are guessing run 100% of the time.
-Conservative approach: weight the guess based exactly on what has happened... My example in part 2) was 70% to even guess. Say it was 75% run so far out of this formation. 75% of the time, the roll comes up "guess run", 25% "guess pass"
-Moderate approach: For example, a 60% run 40% pass ratio they might guess run somewhere weighted even higher, like 70% or more.
4) There is a roll to determine what bonuses are given to the defense
-- If they guess right, they get a bonus
-- If they guess wrong, they get a NEGATIVE "bonus"
-- The bonus given is based again on the aggressiveness of their guessing
-Aggressive approach: Because they sold out run, they are very confidence. If they are right, they get a substantial bonus to certain stats (can be discussed later). But if they are wrong, they also get a substantial decrease in stats
-Conservative approach: Because they were more "unsure" of how to guess, if they are right they receive a small bonus. Wrong, small decrease in stats.
-Moderate approach: you get the idea
5) There is a check BY PLAYER to determine if they even get the rolled bonus.
This is done player by player, based on vision and confidence of the defense, to decide if they even get the bonus from part 4).
Additional things that must be taken into account:
A) Trends
- We need to look at what has happened RECENTLY. Instead of saying "20 strong I plays, 15 run and 5 pass, we'll guess run 75%," it needs to be based on recent plays and trends. Rather than %s, it could be a "score." More of the same thing in a row changes things much faster in that direction. A sudden change drops their guess considerably, etc.
Run run run pass run run pass pass pass pass may give a score of...
+1 run, +3 run, +6 run, +3 run, +4 run + 6 run + 3 run + 1 run 0 +4 pass.
If you care to follow how I did it, math doesn't matter right now
B) Position, etc.
- If all the data is from 1st and 2nd down, it shouldn't really give us much info about 3rd down. The aggressiveness could take this into account, by only relying on very similar data for conservatives, or just saying "f-it, who cares what the field position is, they're running"
SUMMARY:
- Team keeps track of what type of plays are run out of various formations
- DCs have an "aggressive" behavior they can set, much like auto-adjust
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team starts to guess what is going to happen based on in-game trends
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team receives various bonuses or negatives depending on the accuracy of their guess
- Players get this bonus only if they pass a vision and confidence check on the snap
- It must take into account trends
- It must take into account field position, score, etc, all based on "aggressive" setting
EXTENSIONS:
Instead of being formation based, this could be actual play based as well. If a certain play has been run every 1st and 10, the defense knows this, etc. It would take a more complex structure, because a team running a certain play 25% of the time isn't even close to being worth actually guessing they WILL run it (<50%), however is very unreasonable as even running 4 plays is far too little for a balanced offense
This can be player-based as well. The defense can choose players to "spot" ahead of time, up to 3. If it is a powerback, they play one way. An elusiveback, another way. They can adjust in-game to who they see on the other side of the line. This could also extend to spotting a TE. If they see the same TE every running play, and a different TE every passing play... well, come on, even if they are splitting run/pass evenly, they are still being obvious with player choice. This could also be looking at the QB for rollouts.
The defense "keeps track" of plays run out of certain formations. They "guess" with a certain extremity that the DC selects, much like the auto-adjust setting. If they guess right, they get a bonus. If they guess wrong, they don't get a bonus. Their aggressiveness on guessing is based on that DC setting, which would basically tell them when to guess, how to guess, etc., in a way we don't see (much like we don't know how auto adjust ACTUALLY works).
A few quick ideas on this:
After X strong I plays, the defense knows there have been "Y run right, X-Y pass."
The defense rolls "run" or "pass" based on aggressive checks.
1) Have there been enough plays for us to even guess yet?
-Aggressive approach: start guessing after just 2-3 plays
-Conservative approach: wait until later in the game, maybe after as much as 10-12 plays ran out of the formation
-Moderate approach: Somewhere in the middle...
2) Has there been enough discrepancy to BOTHER guessing?
-Aggressive approach: always make a guess
-Conservative approach: only guess if there is a higher ratio of one play to the others.. for example, only to start guessing if the run/pass ratio out of the formation is 70% or higher
-Moderate approach: That 70% could be lower.. down toward 60%
3) There is a roll to determine what the defense thinks is going to happen
-Aggressive approach: guess whatever has happened the most. If it is 7 run, 5 pass, they are guessing run 100% of the time.
-Conservative approach: weight the guess based exactly on what has happened... My example in part 2) was 70% to even guess. Say it was 75% run so far out of this formation. 75% of the time, the roll comes up "guess run", 25% "guess pass"
-Moderate approach: For example, a 60% run 40% pass ratio they might guess run somewhere weighted even higher, like 70% or more.
4) There is a roll to determine what bonuses are given to the defense
-- If they guess right, they get a bonus
-- If they guess wrong, they get a NEGATIVE "bonus"
-- The bonus given is based again on the aggressiveness of their guessing
-Aggressive approach: Because they sold out run, they are very confidence. If they are right, they get a substantial bonus to certain stats (can be discussed later). But if they are wrong, they also get a substantial decrease in stats
-Conservative approach: Because they were more "unsure" of how to guess, if they are right they receive a small bonus. Wrong, small decrease in stats.
-Moderate approach: you get the idea
5) There is a check BY PLAYER to determine if they even get the rolled bonus.
This is done player by player, based on vision and confidence of the defense, to decide if they even get the bonus from part 4).
Additional things that must be taken into account:
A) Trends
- We need to look at what has happened RECENTLY. Instead of saying "20 strong I plays, 15 run and 5 pass, we'll guess run 75%," it needs to be based on recent plays and trends. Rather than %s, it could be a "score." More of the same thing in a row changes things much faster in that direction. A sudden change drops their guess considerably, etc.
Run run run pass run run pass pass pass pass may give a score of...
+1 run, +3 run, +6 run, +3 run, +4 run + 6 run + 3 run + 1 run 0 +4 pass.
If you care to follow how I did it, math doesn't matter right now
B) Position, etc.
- If all the data is from 1st and 2nd down, it shouldn't really give us much info about 3rd down. The aggressiveness could take this into account, by only relying on very similar data for conservatives, or just saying "f-it, who cares what the field position is, they're running"
SUMMARY:
- Team keeps track of what type of plays are run out of various formations
- DCs have an "aggressive" behavior they can set, much like auto-adjust
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team starts to guess what is going to happen based on in-game trends
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team receives various bonuses or negatives depending on the accuracy of their guess
- Players get this bonus only if they pass a vision and confidence check on the snap
- It must take into account trends
- It must take into account field position, score, etc, all based on "aggressive" setting
EXTENSIONS:
Instead of being formation based, this could be actual play based as well. If a certain play has been run every 1st and 10, the defense knows this, etc. It would take a more complex structure, because a team running a certain play 25% of the time isn't even close to being worth actually guessing they WILL run it (<50%), however is very unreasonable as even running 4 plays is far too little for a balanced offense
This can be player-based as well. The defense can choose players to "spot" ahead of time, up to 3. If it is a powerback, they play one way. An elusiveback, another way. They can adjust in-game to who they see on the other side of the line. This could also extend to spotting a TE. If they see the same TE every running play, and a different TE every passing play... well, come on, even if they are splitting run/pass evenly, they are still being obvious with player choice. This could also be looking at the QB for rollouts.
Randy03Texags
offline
offline
Originally posted by ralphy2236
How about you can pick one or two plays before the game that your team will focus on when the formation of that play shows up. When that formation shows up, you're players cheat towards where that play goes. If the team fools you and runs a different play you're screwed. Bam, prob solved.
Tecmo Bowl
I chose the right one! QB Sack .. Ray Childress/Howie Long .. whatever
How about you can pick one or two plays before the game that your team will focus on when the formation of that play shows up. When that formation shows up, you're players cheat towards where that play goes. If the team fools you and runs a different play you're screwed. Bam, prob solved.
Tecmo Bowl

I chose the right one! QB Sack .. Ray Childress/Howie Long .. whatever
Black Box
offline
offline
Originally posted by jamz
Can't wait to see something implemented for this, it's really THE #1 issue in the sim today .
Pretty much.
Can't wait to see something implemented for this, it's really THE #1 issue in the sim today .
Pretty much.
Firenze
offline
offline
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Firenze
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Firenze
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Firenze
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Well, I was thinking more professionally
You get the point though.
Originally posted by Firenze
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Well, I was thinking more professionally
You get the point though.GoVolsKickSomeAss
offline
offline
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Firenze
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Well, I was thinking more professionally
You get the point though.
I would think it would increase morale if youre able to run the same play 6 times in a row and pick up 6 first downs.
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Firenze
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Well, I was thinking more professionally
You get the point though.I would think it would increase morale if youre able to run the same play 6 times in a row and pick up 6 first downs.
GoVolsKickSomeAss
offline
offline
Originally posted by Octowned
This suggestion needs a lot more meat to really give much that could be implemented without obvious exploits.... Here is a complex suggestion I have been thinking of for a while:
The defense "keeps track" of plays run out of certain formations. They "guess" with a certain extremity that the DC selects, much like the auto-adjust setting. If they guess right, they get a bonus. If they guess wrong, they don't get a bonus. Their aggressiveness on guessing is based on that DC setting, which would basically tell them when to guess, how to guess, etc., in a way we don't see (much like we don't know how auto adjust ACTUALLY works).
A few quick ideas on this:
After X strong I plays, the defense knows there have been "Y run right, X-Y pass."
The defense rolls "run" or "pass" based on aggressive checks.
1) Have there been enough plays for us to even guess yet?
-Aggressive approach: start guessing after just 2-3 plays
-Conservative approach: wait until later in the game, maybe after as much as 10-12 plays ran out of the formation
-Moderate approach: Somewhere in the middle...
2) Has there been enough discrepancy to BOTHER guessing?
-Aggressive approach: always make a guess
-Conservative approach: only guess if there is a higher ratio of one play to the others.. for example, only to start guessing if the run/pass ratio out of the formation is 70% or higher
-Moderate approach: That 70% could be lower.. down toward 60%
3) There is a roll to determine what the defense thinks is going to happen
-Aggressive approach: guess whatever has happened the most. If it is 7 run, 5 pass, they are guessing run 100% of the time.
-Conservative approach: weight the guess based exactly on what has happened... My example in part 2) was 70% to even guess. Say it was 75% run so far out of this formation. 75% of the time, the roll comes up "guess run", 25% "guess pass"
-Moderate approach: For example, a 60% run 40% pass ratio they might guess run somewhere weighted even higher, like 70% or more.
4) There is a roll to determine what bonuses are given to the defense
-- If they guess right, they get a bonus
-- If they guess wrong, they get a NEGATIVE "bonus"
-- The bonus given is based again on the aggressiveness of their guessing
-Aggressive approach: Because they sold out run, they are very confidence. If they are right, they get a substantial bonus to certain stats (can be discussed later). But if they are wrong, they also get a substantial decrease in stats
-Conservative approach: Because they were more "unsure" of how to guess, if they are right they receive a small bonus. Wrong, small decrease in stats.
-Moderate approach: you get the idea
5) There is a check BY PLAYER to determine if they even get the rolled bonus.
This is done player by player, based on vision and confidence of the defense, to decide if they even get the bonus from part 4).
Additional things that must be taken into account:
A) Trends
- We need to look at what has happened RECENTLY. Instead of saying "20 strong I plays, 15 run and 5 pass, we'll guess run 75%," it needs to be based on recent plays and trends. Rather than %s, it could be a "score." More of the same thing in a row changes things much faster in that direction. A sudden change drops their guess considerably, etc.
Run run run pass run run pass pass pass pass may give a score of...
+1 run, +3 run, +6 run, +3 run, +4 run + 6 run + 3 run + 1 run 0 +4 pass.
If you care to follow how I did it, math doesn't matter right now
B) Position, etc.
- If all the data is from 1st and 2nd down, it shouldn't really give us much info about 3rd down. The aggressiveness could take this into account, by only relying on very similar data for conservatives, or just saying "f-it, who cares what the field position is, they're running"
SUMMARY:
- Team keeps track of what type of plays are run out of various formations
- DCs have an "aggressive" behavior they can set, much like auto-adjust
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team starts to guess what is going to happen based on in-game trends
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team receives various bonuses or negatives depending on the accuracy of their guess
- Players get this bonus only if they pass a vision and confidence check on the snap
- It must take into account trends
- It must take into account field position, score, etc, all based on "aggressive" setting
EXTENSIONS:
Instead of being formation based, this could be actual play based as well. If a certain play has been run every 1st and 10, the defense knows this, etc. It would take a more complex structure, because a team running a certain play 25% of the time isn't even close to being worth actually guessing they WILL run it (<50%), however is very unreasonable as even running 4 plays is far too little for a balanced offense
This can be player-based as well. The defense can choose players to "spot" ahead of time, up to 3. If it is a powerback, they play one way. An elusiveback, another way. They can adjust in-game to who they see on the other side of the line. This could also extend to spotting a TE. If they see the same TE every running play, and a different TE every passing play... well, come on, even if they are splitting run/pass evenly, they are still being obvious with player choice. This could also be looking at the QB for rollouts.
but can't this all be taken into account with proper scouting and subsequent adjustments to your AI?
This suggestion needs a lot more meat to really give much that could be implemented without obvious exploits.... Here is a complex suggestion I have been thinking of for a while:
The defense "keeps track" of plays run out of certain formations. They "guess" with a certain extremity that the DC selects, much like the auto-adjust setting. If they guess right, they get a bonus. If they guess wrong, they don't get a bonus. Their aggressiveness on guessing is based on that DC setting, which would basically tell them when to guess, how to guess, etc., in a way we don't see (much like we don't know how auto adjust ACTUALLY works).
A few quick ideas on this:
After X strong I plays, the defense knows there have been "Y run right, X-Y pass."
The defense rolls "run" or "pass" based on aggressive checks.
1) Have there been enough plays for us to even guess yet?
-Aggressive approach: start guessing after just 2-3 plays
-Conservative approach: wait until later in the game, maybe after as much as 10-12 plays ran out of the formation
-Moderate approach: Somewhere in the middle...
2) Has there been enough discrepancy to BOTHER guessing?
-Aggressive approach: always make a guess
-Conservative approach: only guess if there is a higher ratio of one play to the others.. for example, only to start guessing if the run/pass ratio out of the formation is 70% or higher
-Moderate approach: That 70% could be lower.. down toward 60%
3) There is a roll to determine what the defense thinks is going to happen
-Aggressive approach: guess whatever has happened the most. If it is 7 run, 5 pass, they are guessing run 100% of the time.
-Conservative approach: weight the guess based exactly on what has happened... My example in part 2) was 70% to even guess. Say it was 75% run so far out of this formation. 75% of the time, the roll comes up "guess run", 25% "guess pass"
-Moderate approach: For example, a 60% run 40% pass ratio they might guess run somewhere weighted even higher, like 70% or more.
4) There is a roll to determine what bonuses are given to the defense
-- If they guess right, they get a bonus
-- If they guess wrong, they get a NEGATIVE "bonus"
-- The bonus given is based again on the aggressiveness of their guessing
-Aggressive approach: Because they sold out run, they are very confidence. If they are right, they get a substantial bonus to certain stats (can be discussed later). But if they are wrong, they also get a substantial decrease in stats
-Conservative approach: Because they were more "unsure" of how to guess, if they are right they receive a small bonus. Wrong, small decrease in stats.
-Moderate approach: you get the idea
5) There is a check BY PLAYER to determine if they even get the rolled bonus.
This is done player by player, based on vision and confidence of the defense, to decide if they even get the bonus from part 4).
Additional things that must be taken into account:
A) Trends
- We need to look at what has happened RECENTLY. Instead of saying "20 strong I plays, 15 run and 5 pass, we'll guess run 75%," it needs to be based on recent plays and trends. Rather than %s, it could be a "score." More of the same thing in a row changes things much faster in that direction. A sudden change drops their guess considerably, etc.
Run run run pass run run pass pass pass pass may give a score of...
+1 run, +3 run, +6 run, +3 run, +4 run + 6 run + 3 run + 1 run 0 +4 pass.
If you care to follow how I did it, math doesn't matter right now
B) Position, etc.
- If all the data is from 1st and 2nd down, it shouldn't really give us much info about 3rd down. The aggressiveness could take this into account, by only relying on very similar data for conservatives, or just saying "f-it, who cares what the field position is, they're running"
SUMMARY:
- Team keeps track of what type of plays are run out of various formations
- DCs have an "aggressive" behavior they can set, much like auto-adjust
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team starts to guess what is going to happen based on in-game trends
- Based on this "aggressive" setting, the team receives various bonuses or negatives depending on the accuracy of their guess
- Players get this bonus only if they pass a vision and confidence check on the snap
- It must take into account trends
- It must take into account field position, score, etc, all based on "aggressive" setting
EXTENSIONS:
Instead of being formation based, this could be actual play based as well. If a certain play has been run every 1st and 10, the defense knows this, etc. It would take a more complex structure, because a team running a certain play 25% of the time isn't even close to being worth actually guessing they WILL run it (<50%), however is very unreasonable as even running 4 plays is far too little for a balanced offense
This can be player-based as well. The defense can choose players to "spot" ahead of time, up to 3. If it is a powerback, they play one way. An elusiveback, another way. They can adjust in-game to who they see on the other side of the line. This could also extend to spotting a TE. If they see the same TE every running play, and a different TE every passing play... well, come on, even if they are splitting run/pass evenly, they are still being obvious with player choice. This could also be looking at the QB for rollouts.
but can't this all be taken into account with proper scouting and subsequent adjustments to your AI?
Firenze
offline
offline
Originally posted by GoVolsKickSomeAss
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Firenze
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Well, I was thinking more professionally
You get the point though.
I would think it would increase morale if youre able to run the same play 6 times in a row and pick up 6 first downs.
We're trying to dissuade people from doing it, not encourage them
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Firenze
Haven't read the thread, but I have an idea related to it.
How about a morale loss after running too many consecutive plays? In real life (I know I shouldn't compare), players would get bored stiff of running the same plays. It's bound to decrease the happiness of the player.
Actually, in highschool anyway, we would be laughing in the huddle after running the same play with success 5-6 times straight.
Well, I was thinking more professionally
You get the point though.I would think it would increase morale if youre able to run the same play 6 times in a row and pick up 6 first downs.
We're trying to dissuade people from doing it, not encourage them
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























