last night I went thru every offensive play the last game and our guard pulls alot but then just stops and does nothing. Alot of plays a blocking player could have turned a short gain into a long one.
sunder B
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dave Fahrer
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by nithos
Yeah, something is messed up with the pulling logic. The Guards are afraid to cross the line of scrimmage.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2899123
I worked so hard on getting his speed and agility up so you could make it to the outside with the HB, just to have him stop before he can even be effective.
What is his vision?
that is what i want to know. Vision comes into play alot with pulling. to see where the threat is coming from and then go to it.
That is backwards logic. When a guard pulls, he should lead the way until someone is in front of him. If no one is in front of him, he should continue downfield.
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by nithos
Yeah, something is messed up with the pulling logic. The Guards are afraid to cross the line of scrimmage.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2899123
I worked so hard on getting his speed and agility up so you could make it to the outside with the HB, just to have him stop before he can even be effective.
What is his vision?
that is what i want to know. Vision comes into play alot with pulling. to see where the threat is coming from and then go to it.
That is backwards logic. When a guard pulls, he should lead the way until someone is in front of him. If no one is in front of him, he should continue downfield.
Dave Fahrer
offline
offline
but if you are coming round the OT then you need to the look and pick a direction. as playing a guard i had to look for where is the threat coming from. the better you know what your looking for the quicker you get at it.
Kettle
offline
offline
This is the one play that drives me crazy and I see it several times in his games. Watch the LG, his speed is 27.8, Agil 27.9 but vision is 23.3. He will never get to lead the dive play so why have him pull?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5059388
...or what stats need to change so he can lead the play? LOL, don't tell me 44 speed.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5059388
...or what stats need to change so he can lead the play? LOL, don't tell me 44 speed.
taylonr
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dave Fahrer
but if you are coming round the OT then you need to the look and pick a direction. as playing a guard i had to look for where is the threat coming from. the better you know what your looking for the quicker you get at it.
What part of bad vision tells the guard to drop back 4 steps before pulling?
but if you are coming round the OT then you need to the look and pick a direction. as playing a guard i had to look for where is the threat coming from. the better you know what your looking for the quicker you get at it.
What part of bad vision tells the guard to drop back 4 steps before pulling?
nithos
offline
offline
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by nithos
Yeah, something is messed up with the pulling logic. The Guards are afraid to cross the line of scrimmage.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2899123
I worked so hard on getting his speed and agility up so you could make it to the outside with the HB, just to have him stop before he can even be effective.
What is his vision?
Not sure about the guards in that play since the backups were in, my guards both have a vision of 28-30 and rarely cross the line of scrimmage on the pull.
Originally posted by nithos
Yeah, something is messed up with the pulling logic. The Guards are afraid to cross the line of scrimmage.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2899123
I worked so hard on getting his speed and agility up so you could make it to the outside with the HB, just to have him stop before he can even be effective.
What is his vision?
Not sure about the guards in that play since the backups were in, my guards both have a vision of 28-30 and rarely cross the line of scrimmage on the pull.
Last edited Jun 2, 2008 19:40:18
lukin83
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by jrg42
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3002295
OK. I put one of my WR's with 40 speed and 27 agility and 24 vision in at RG. Still cannot even get close to the outside and make the block. He is not tired as he only played 13 plays the entire game.
I think just tweaking the AI for down field block pickup is not enough, unless it is intended for G's to have massive amounts of points in 'fast type' skills. If this is the case and in your simulations a higher level player (with the right build) can make it out there 70% of the time, that is great. I agree it should not be easy, but I would have guessed that a level 11 WR could at least get out to the right spot in time to do something.
Need some better AI when they run down the line to avoid their own players from getting in their way.
That's not a very good test. The WR gets a huge penalty to his stats for playing at G.
Here is a test with an OT with 40.74 speed and 27.8 agility lined up at RG...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5198393
Originally posted by jrg42
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3002295
OK. I put one of my WR's with 40 speed and 27 agility and 24 vision in at RG. Still cannot even get close to the outside and make the block. He is not tired as he only played 13 plays the entire game.
I think just tweaking the AI for down field block pickup is not enough, unless it is intended for G's to have massive amounts of points in 'fast type' skills. If this is the case and in your simulations a higher level player (with the right build) can make it out there 70% of the time, that is great. I agree it should not be easy, but I would have guessed that a level 11 WR could at least get out to the right spot in time to do something.
Need some better AI when they run down the line to avoid their own players from getting in their way.
That's not a very good test. The WR gets a huge penalty to his stats for playing at G.
Here is a test with an OT with 40.74 speed and 27.8 agility lined up at RG...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5198393
TrevJo
offline
offline
Here is an OG with 34.5 speed, 26.7 agility, and 27.1 vision:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5269333
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271393
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271771
I'll just list the things that don't make sense about this play and how it is executed:
-RT and TE blocking down makes no sense.
-The guard's initial movement is directly backwards. Even with his first two steps the guard should be moving more toward the sideline than backwards.
-Given the HB's initial direction (45 degree angle upfield and outside), it makes no sense to have a pulling guard on the play. The only way a guard could reasonably be expected to get in front of a HB on a pitch play is if the HB did some kind of counter or delay, or if the HB's movement was to go directly outside for the first few steps and then cut almost straight upfield.
It's time to stop blaming player builds and call the destructor on this play.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5269333
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271393
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271771
I'll just list the things that don't make sense about this play and how it is executed:
-RT and TE blocking down makes no sense.
-The guard's initial movement is directly backwards. Even with his first two steps the guard should be moving more toward the sideline than backwards.
-Given the HB's initial direction (45 degree angle upfield and outside), it makes no sense to have a pulling guard on the play. The only way a guard could reasonably be expected to get in front of a HB on a pitch play is if the HB did some kind of counter or delay, or if the HB's movement was to go directly outside for the first few steps and then cut almost straight upfield.
It's time to stop blaming player builds and call the destructor on this play.
Last edited Jun 3, 2008 20:44:12
taylonr
offline
offline
Some of the responsibility falls on the HB too. He shouldn't take the handoff and hit his breakaway speed. From watching the replays (and not just yours) it looks like there is do difference between the speed after the HB gets the ball and when he gets in the open field.
That being said, I'm not opposed to blaming this on the player builds. HOWEVER, if it is solely a player build issue, then THAT is the bug. A guard should not have superb agility, speed and vision to take his first step towards the sideline as opposed to straight back on pulls.
That being said, I'm not opposed to blaming this on the player builds. HOWEVER, if it is solely a player build issue, then THAT is the bug. A guard should not have superb agility, speed and vision to take his first step towards the sideline as opposed to straight back on pulls.
titanicwin
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
Here is an OG with 34.5 speed, 26.7 agility, and 27.1 vision:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5269333
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271393
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271771
I'll just list the things that don't make sense about this play and how it is executed:
-RT and TE blocking down makes no sense.
-The guard's initial movement is directly backwards. Even with his first two steps the guard should be moving more toward the sideline than backwards.
-Given the HB's initial direction (45 degree angle upfield and outside), it makes no sense to have a pulling guard on the play. The only way a guard could reasonably be expected to get in front of a HB on a pitch play is if the HB did some kind of counter or delay, or if the HB's movement was to go directly outside for the first few steps and then cut almost straight upfield.
It's time to stop blaming player builds and call the destructor on this play.
Thanks for posting that. I had been pouring AGI and speed into one of my OGs to see if that would eventually fix the problem (as vision is already at 27). I had not found any difference so far, though my player is only at 20 speed and 21 agility. You just saved me from a lot of unwisely spend skill points. Thanks.
I really do wish this play would be fixed. Its so frustrating to see a HB that could pick up a 10+ yard gain instead of a 2 yard loss if the OG would just do their job.
Here is an OG with 34.5 speed, 26.7 agility, and 27.1 vision:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5269333
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271393
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=5271771
I'll just list the things that don't make sense about this play and how it is executed:
-RT and TE blocking down makes no sense.
-The guard's initial movement is directly backwards. Even with his first two steps the guard should be moving more toward the sideline than backwards.
-Given the HB's initial direction (45 degree angle upfield and outside), it makes no sense to have a pulling guard on the play. The only way a guard could reasonably be expected to get in front of a HB on a pitch play is if the HB did some kind of counter or delay, or if the HB's movement was to go directly outside for the first few steps and then cut almost straight upfield.
It's time to stop blaming player builds and call the destructor on this play.
Thanks for posting that. I had been pouring AGI and speed into one of my OGs to see if that would eventually fix the problem (as vision is already at 27). I had not found any difference so far, though my player is only at 20 speed and 21 agility. You just saved me from a lot of unwisely spend skill points. Thanks.
I really do wish this play would be fixed. Its so frustrating to see a HB that could pick up a 10+ yard gain instead of a 2 yard loss if the OG would just do their job.
chief31
offline
offline
I agree with most of the assessments to this problem. As A K.C. Chiefs fan, I have watched a whole lot of pulling o-linemen, performed by the likes of Willie Roaf and Will Shields. Pulling linemen for sweeps was a mainstay of the Vermiel offense for several years in K.C. And it was performed as well as it can be here.
The 'drop-back' move that is the pulling OGs first several steps is easily the most notable problem here. Since the OT and TE that start the play between the pullin OG and his immediate destination of 'outside', make their first step forward, there is nothing to stop our pulling OG from making his first step toward the sideline.
And then there is that wierd 'go backward' move that often happens when the OG finally gets outside. The letter 'W', 'T' and 'F' come to mind here.
Along with the HBs innability to use good VISION and allow the block to get set-up. I am not certain rather the VISION attribute has an effect here. or not.
And the pulling OGs innablity to recognize his blocking assignment when lead-blocking. Again, this could be something that falls under the VISION catergory.
But I would like to add that I don't think that the AGILITY attribute is functioning properly. Even with 40-50 AGILITY, the slightest angled cut still causes a severe decrease in speed. no matter how slight a cut a player makes, unless one of the 'special abilites' kicks-in, the cut never seems to happen smoothly. (Key word, SMOOTHLY.)
AGILITY should be as impactful as either STRENGTH, or SPEED. A high enough AGILITY should make the player almost 'bounce around' like a pinball. (Barry Sanders)
While I can certainly live with the AGILTY situation, as it is across the boards, I believe that it has an impact on pulling OG problem.
Without making any adjustment to the effects of AGILITY, I would agree that this problem could be eliminated through the 'special abilities' tree. Perhaps even adding a third tree for o-linemen, strictly revolving around pulling skills.
A third 'tree' could consist of FIRST STEP; SUPER VISION; QUICK CUT; OPEN FIELD and LEAD-BLOCK. With OPEN FIELD giving a boost to blocking to a specific side of a defender in the open, and LEAD-BLOCK giving a boost to his own abilities, and perhaps giving a boost to the HBs vision.
Not that I expect a third 'tree' to actually be installed here, I'm just throwing out an idea for any/everyone to bash.
The 'drop-back' move that is the pulling OGs first several steps is easily the most notable problem here. Since the OT and TE that start the play between the pullin OG and his immediate destination of 'outside', make their first step forward, there is nothing to stop our pulling OG from making his first step toward the sideline.
And then there is that wierd 'go backward' move that often happens when the OG finally gets outside. The letter 'W', 'T' and 'F' come to mind here.
Along with the HBs innability to use good VISION and allow the block to get set-up. I am not certain rather the VISION attribute has an effect here. or not.
And the pulling OGs innablity to recognize his blocking assignment when lead-blocking. Again, this could be something that falls under the VISION catergory.
But I would like to add that I don't think that the AGILITY attribute is functioning properly. Even with 40-50 AGILITY, the slightest angled cut still causes a severe decrease in speed. no matter how slight a cut a player makes, unless one of the 'special abilites' kicks-in, the cut never seems to happen smoothly. (Key word, SMOOTHLY.)
AGILITY should be as impactful as either STRENGTH, or SPEED. A high enough AGILITY should make the player almost 'bounce around' like a pinball. (Barry Sanders)
While I can certainly live with the AGILTY situation, as it is across the boards, I believe that it has an impact on pulling OG problem.
Without making any adjustment to the effects of AGILITY, I would agree that this problem could be eliminated through the 'special abilities' tree. Perhaps even adding a third tree for o-linemen, strictly revolving around pulling skills.
A third 'tree' could consist of FIRST STEP; SUPER VISION; QUICK CUT; OPEN FIELD and LEAD-BLOCK. With OPEN FIELD giving a boost to blocking to a specific side of a defender in the open, and LEAD-BLOCK giving a boost to his own abilities, and perhaps giving a boost to the HBs vision.
Not that I expect a third 'tree' to actually be installed here, I'm just throwing out an idea for any/everyone to bash.

Last edited Jun 8, 2008 04:23:33
drkbgrk
offline
offline
it's a problem of path scripting not attributes. Vision, agility, speed, blocking, strength, etc can all do their thang as soon as their assignment is fixed. Hey and fix TE paths too, while you're in there.
coach
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I'm making some updates to the pitch plays to force the G's to "lead block" upfield like FB's do, though if they have terrible agility and speed they will have trouble turning, stopping, and getting going.
Did this happen?
I'm making some updates to the pitch plays to force the G's to "lead block" upfield like FB's do, though if they have terrible agility and speed they will have trouble turning, stopping, and getting going.
Did this happen?
coach
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
The new play definitions are in place, so we'll see what happens in the next couple days worth of games.
Ahhh... guess it was adjusted. But no one has seen any change?
The new play definitions are in place, so we'll see what happens in the next couple days worth of games.
Ahhh... guess it was adjusted. But no one has seen any change?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























