User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #3 > USA AA #3 Pro Bowl Thread
Page:
 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by packabacka19
Originally posted by ravensfan

Originally posted by kr0n


Originally posted by packabacka19



I know we're not supposed to nominate our own guys, but I just want to make sure no one leaves out our starting left outside linebacker Eirik Elvheim just because we're not a top team. He has 130 tackles, 1 sack, and 8 FF. Leads the league in tackles and FFs.

Thanks


Tackles isn't a good stat to evaluate LB's. I like the 8 FF tho but one could say that the defense is always on the field and thats why he get's those numbers.


exactly what stat do you believe is more important for a linebacker than tackles???


I agree, what else do you think is more important? And I disagree, 130 tackles and 8 FFs is impressive no matter how much the defense is on the field.



just saying

a good defense doesn't have much tackles overall so it's kind of unfair to the LB's on the good teams that don't get much snaps on defense
 
packabacka19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kr0n
Originally posted by packabacka19

Originally posted by ravensfan


Originally posted by kr0n



Originally posted by packabacka19




I know we're not supposed to nominate our own guys, but I just want to make sure no one leaves out our starting left outside linebacker Eirik Elvheim just because we're not a top team. He has 130 tackles, 1 sack, and 8 FF. Leads the league in tackles and FFs.

Thanks


Tackles isn't a good stat to evaluate LB's. I like the 8 FF tho but one could say that the defense is always on the field and thats why he get's those numbers.


exactly what stat do you believe is more important for a linebacker than tackles???


I agree, what else do you think is more important? And I disagree, 130 tackles and 8 FFs is impressive no matter how much the defense is on the field.



just saying

a good defense doesn't have much tackles overall so it's kind of unfair to the LB's on the good teams that don't get much snaps on defense


Fair enough. IMO it evens out anyway since the good teams will likely get more pro bowl recognition.

Also, just cuz a defense is on the field a lot doesn't mean the team is bad. Just means the offense is inconsistent.
 
SmoothOne
offline
Link
 
penguins have the fewest tackles as a team and are undefeated. coincidence? i think not.
 
Merik
offline
Link
 
Our guy with most tackles that has played on the team all season has 46 tackles, and our defence isn't that bad....
 
foobar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by packabacka19
Originally posted by kr0n

Originally posted by packabacka19


Originally posted by ravensfan



Originally posted by kr0n




Originally posted by packabacka19





I know we're not supposed to nominate our own guys, but I just want to make sure no one leaves out our starting left outside linebacker Eirik Elvheim just because we're not a top team. He has 130 tackles, 1 sack, and 8 FF. Leads the league in tackles and FFs.

Thanks


Tackles isn't a good stat to evaluate LB's. I like the 8 FF tho but one could say that the defense is always on the field and thats why he get's those numbers.


exactly what stat do you believe is more important for a linebacker than tackles???


I agree, what else do you think is more important? And I disagree, 130 tackles and 8 FFs is impressive no matter how much the defense is on the field.



just saying

a good defense doesn't have much tackles overall so it's kind of unfair to the LB's on the good teams that don't get much snaps on defense


Fair enough. IMO it evens out anyway since the good teams will likely get more pro bowl recognition.

Also, just cuz a defense is on the field a lot doesn't mean the team is bad. Just means the offense is inconsistent.


Personally, I feel that TFLs, Sacks, Hurries, INTs and FFs are the measure of a LB. Any schmuck on a crappy team can have lots of tackles. It is when your tackles are for losses that it matters.
Last edited May 21, 2008 20:54:13
 
Merik
offline
Link
 
I think PD is also a good measure
 
foobar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Merik
I think PD is also a good measure


Agreed

But the point I am trying to make is that tackles by itself is a very poor measure of a LB. I would rather see a ratio of tackles to missed tackles.
Last edited May 21, 2008 22:00:17
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Pburg
Originally posted by andersonba1210

Originally posted by allenpoe


lol thanks. I wasn't fishing for props though (but i wont turn them down, lol), I was just commenting on dude saying CBs with high tackle numbers is a bad thing. so many things play a factor, that you have to really watch the games and see if the CB is doing his job


A CB with high tackles could simply mean he is a running focused corner, along with being a ball hawk.


I like the way you think...


Thank you, thank you...
 
LTizgreat56
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by allenpoe
lol thanks. I wasn't fishing for props though (but i wont turn them down, lol), I was just commenting on dude saying CBs with high tackle numbers is a bad thing. so many things play a factor, that you have to really watch the games and see if the CB is doing his job



oh i got ya and yeah i still agree with you, a CB that can play both areas of the game is a true Shutdown corner
 
packabacka19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foobar
Originally posted by Merik

I think PD is also a good measure


Agreed

But the point I am trying to make is that tackles by itself is a very poor measure of a LB. I would rather see a ratio of tackles to missed tackles.


His ratio is 65/1 for tackles to missed tackles. How does that compare?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=61065&playoffs=0

He's got 130 tackles, 2 missed tackles, 1 sack, 4 TFL, 3 PD, a sack, and 3 FRs.
 
quicksilver
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foobar

Personally, I feel that TFLs, Sacks, Hurries, INTs and FFs are the measure of a LB. Any schmuck on a crappy team can have lots of tackles. It is when your tackles are for losses that it matters.


Every stat is important for a LB... Focusing on these stats is the same as focusing on the Tackles stat... If the D is on the field more than other teams, the stats you think are the measure will be inflated as well.

What you have to do for a LB is take all the stats, and devide them by the number of plays. I think with that method, you eliminate the "He plays more" argument.. And you will still find that Elvheim is a solid star LB.
 
foobar
offline
Link
 
Normally I don't go into these chest-thumping threads. But by way of comparison, probably our best LB is Hey Odie and here is how he compares:

Tk = 52
MsTk = 0
Hry = 2
Sack = 2
TFL = 8
PD = 16
Int = 0
FFum = 1
FumRec = 1
 
quicksilver
offline
Link
 
Those are good numbers too. You guys must blitz a more than most?
 
packabacka19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foobar
Normally I don't go into these chest-thumping threads. But by way of comparison, probably our best LB is Hey Odie and here is how he compares:

Tk = 52
MsTk = 0
Hry = 2
Sack = 2
TFL = 8
PD = 16
Int = 0
FFum = 1
FumRec = 1


Good numbers. Lots of PDs. Does he play LOLB?
 
LTizgreat56
offline
Link
 
shakes spear is having a great year himself look at these #'s


Defense
Season G Tk MsTk Hry Sack SackYd TFL PD Int IntYd IntTD DefTD FFum FumRec Sfty
1 8 27 3 1 0 0 1 3 0 0 0 0 0 1 0
2 13 97 7 2 1 5.5 8 3 0 0 0 0 4 1 0
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.