User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #1 > Oceania AAA - Season 2 - MVP Candidates
Page:
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Not knocking John McNeeley's worth...but a #2 CB is usually covering a #1 WR who is usually the favourite target of the QB...

Good picks though for MVP overall...

 
nhazelett
offline
Link
 
Examples of McNeeleys success... 59 passes defended. 2 Ints for touchdowns. 8 Ints.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=14784&mode=pbp
This game for example, he had 9 tackles. 2 for a loss. 8 were on run plays. This isn't how EVERY game is, but he is a consistent run stopper, hence, all of the tackles. I'm not saying no one can throw on him, but look to exhibit A:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=14823

This game, McNeeley was playing special teams, trying to return kicks. Since he was doing that, he wasn't on Defense as much, and this is the result. McNeeley did have a horrible game though in that one. 2 missed tackles is no good. But I'm just using this as an example.
Last edited May 22, 2008 19:27:51
 
nhazelett
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3960806 MVP
Last edited May 22, 2008 19:23:04
 
Leionidas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nhazelett
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3960806 MVP

You aint lyin...
 
BMoreAbsurd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nhazelett
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3960806 MVP


Congratulations. You picked off a backup QB 6 levels below you rocking the 48 QB rating.

Good lawd. McNeeley may be good. But he's not so good that you can ignore the fact that (A) he isn't even the #1 CB on his own team, (B) he averages almost 60 snaps a game on a defense that gives up almost 350 yards a game, and (C) this is all on a team that isn't sniffing the playoffs.
Last edited May 22, 2008 20:44:56
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BMoreAbsurd
Originally posted by nhazelett

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3960806 MVP


Congratulations. You picked off a backup QB 6 levels below you rocking the 48 QB rating.

Good lawd. McNeeley may be good. But he's not so good that you can ignore the fact that (A) he isn't even the #1 CB on his own team, (B) he averages almost 60 snaps a game on a defense that gives up almost 350 yards a game, and (C) this is all on a team that isn't sniffing the playoffs.


Also, that was a really dumb pass to try.
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BMoreAbsurd
Originally posted by nhazelett

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3960806 MVP


Congratulations. You picked off a backup QB 6 levels below you rocking the 48 QB rating.

Good lawd. McNeeley may be good. But he's not so good that you can ignore the fact that (A) he isn't even the #1 CB on his own team, (B) he averages almost 60 snaps a game on a defense that gives up almost 350 yards a game, and (C) this is all on a team that isn't sniffing the playoffs.


Way to come off sounding like a total idiot, read back a few posts and maybe you wont be so ignorant. BTW we arent having a good season, but that doesnt make him less of an MVP candidate. For gods sake he is leading the league now in ton of catagories.

Mcneeley
Tackles: 127 1st
Passes Defended: 49 1st
INT Ret Yards: 188 1st
INT Ret TD: 2 1st T
INT: 8 4th T

please do tell me why exactly that doesnt make him a #1 contender for defense MVP

Ohh yah and...
A] He is in my #2 spot, and in case you dont know thats still a starter jackass.
B] we give up 207.2 passing yards per game. If you look at things a little more than at face value, thats because we havent had good depth till recently.
C] Yah MVPs only come from playoff teams, us low lifes on unsuccessful teams dont count. Way to sound like a douche. Also have someone explain the concept of Most Valuable Player to you sometime, it might be enlightening.
Last edited May 22, 2008 22:46:11
 
Avondell
offline
Link
 
Here's the way I feel: If you have to campaign and sell your guy and try to convince everyone he's the best...then he probably isnt.

The real MVPs stand out on their own. Its one thing to say, "Hey, please include my guy in the voting." Its another to spend a couple of pages explaining in detail why your guy is the best.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Avondell
Here's the way I feel: If you have to campaign and sell your guy and try to convince everyone he's the best...then he probably isnt.

The real MVPs stand out on their own. Its one thing to say, "Hey, please include my guy in the voting." Its another to spend a couple of pages explaining in detail why your guy is the best.


You hit the nail on the head.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
HaplosDog for MVP
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
HaplosDog for MVP


Woo!
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Avondell
Here's the way I feel: If you have to campaign and sell your guy and try to convince everyone he's the best...then he probably isnt.

The real MVPs stand out on their own. Its one thing to say, "Hey, please include my guy in the voting." Its another to spend a couple of pages explaining in detail why your guy is the best.


Thats kind of twisting it a bit. Granted I can see your point of view a little bit.

Truth is Im not "selling" anything, just sticking up for him. Maybe Im taking too many things the wrong way, but too often people are trying to discredit mcneeley on here. Besides I never asked for people to include him in the voting, he was allready on the original list. I also notice that the most adament nay sayers about his stats have CBs they think should be MVP. And, often The most they can say about those CBs is "they are on a good team".

Im sorry we have realy flooded this forum, but I posted on the Bulls defense page to come and publicly support Mcneeley. Im begining to fear that its having the reverse effect, people are geting iritated. Ill try to tone it down once again, but I cant help responding to certain people.
 
nhazelett
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Avondell
Here's the way I feel: If you have to campaign and sell your guy and try to convince everyone he's the best...then he probably isnt.

The real MVPs stand out on their own. Its one thing to say, "Hey, please include my guy in the voting." Its another to spend a couple of pages explaining in detail why your guy is the best.


He was already on the original list of MVP candidates, so read the original post before posting anything. The nay sayers were complaining about the amount of tackles. So I came and defended that point, then people argued it, and I argued my point. That's pretty much how it's been, the entire thread, but you guys haven't read everything. Also, I play the #2 spot, still starting, and am the exact same level as the #1 guy. It's not like I'm a backup QB who is never on the field. And about the playoffs, who cares? The Bulls are gonna pick it up next year, when they solidify their team. It has nothing to do with MVP. Look, I'll let you guys debate it, because in part, you are right, I shouldn't have to argue why my guy should be MVP, and as a matter of fact, there is a DE who I think actually should be MVP over me. I just wanted to make my point that people say "This is what is happening" when it isn't. Everyone make your own decision, Rutger is right. If you ask a question, I'll answer it. If you have a comment, I won't respond, it's your opinion. Lastly, I'd like to conclude with BMoreAbsurd, yes, you are a douche bag.
 
BMoreAbsurd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001
HaplosDog for MVP


Now that's a bandwagon I can get behind.
 
BMoreAbsurd
offline
Link
 
My, my, my. Such venom, vitriol, and name calling for makeing observations. Looks like some fellas here got some sand in their shorts. Jackass? Douche? Douchebag? I'm overwhelmed by the maturity to be found on the Bulls squad. Really. Not neccessary. You want to disagree? Cool. But lets try not to act like 12 year olds who missed naptime, huh?


Originally posted by Rudger
Originally posted by BMoreAbsurd

Originally posted by nhazelett


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3960806MVP


Congratulations. You picked off a backup QB 6 levels below you rocking the 48 QB rating.

Good lawd. McNeeley may be good. But he's not so good that you can ignore the fact that (A) he isn't even the #1 CB on his own team, (B) he averages almost 60 snaps a game on a defense that gives up almost 350 yards a game, and (C) this is all on a team that isn't sniffing the playoffs.


Way to come off sounding like a total idiot, read back a few posts and maybe you wont be so ignorant. BTW we arent having a good season, but that doesnt make him less of an MVP candidate. For gods sake he is leading the league now in ton of catagories.

Mcneeley
Tackles: 127 1st
Passes Defended: 49 1st
INT Ret Yards: 188 1st
INT Ret TD: 2 1st T
INT: 8 4th T

please do tell me why exactly that doesnt make him a #1 contender for defense MVP

Ohh yah and...
A] He is in my #2 spot, and in case you dont know thats still a starter jackass.
B] we give up 207.2 passing yards per game. If you look at things a little more than at face value, thats because we havent had good depth till recently.
C] Yah MVPs only come from playoff teams, us low lifes on unsuccessful teams dont count. Way to sound like a douche. Also have someone explain the concept of Most Valuable Player to you sometime, it might be enlightening.


A. Yes, it is the starter. I never said it wasn't. It's also a position that normally covers the teams SECOND best WR. This has been covered. Not his fault, but not something that should be ignored, either.
B. How soon is "recently"? Yesterday? You've given up 320+ yards of offense in four of your last five games. And that 207 yards per game would be quite a bit higher if some teams even bothered to do anything but run the ball, or didn't play with the lead so often.
C. Quit playing the victim. Who was the last MVP that DIDN'T come off of a playoff team? Taking a good player off a playoff team (or a team in the hunt for the playoffs) could cost them a few wins and knock them out of the chase. Taking a good player of a bad team costs them...what? Perhaps they go from being bad to being relegated, I suppose, but that's about it. Tell me who was more valuable. Next year I can see the Bulls turning it around and McNeeley maybe being difference between a good and average squad. He's got a solid build. Perhaps a bit more in strength than a CB really needs, but a good build (by the by, you really should keep your profiles closed so your opponent can't see it and scout off of it) that should allow him to have continued success. I wouldn't be surprised if he was in this discussion next seaon.

Key word being "next".


Originally posted by nhazelett
Originally posted by Avondell

Here's the way I feel: If you have to campaign and sell your guy and try to convince everyone he's the best...then he probably isnt.

The real MVPs stand out on their own. Its one thing to say, "Hey, please include my guy in the voting." Its another to spend a couple of pages explaining in detail why your guy is the best.


He was already on the original list of MVP candidates, so read the original post before posting anything. The nay sayers were complaining about the amount of tackles. So I came and defended that point, then people argued it, and I argued my point. That's pretty much how it's been, the entire thread, but you guys haven't read everything. Also, I play the #2 spot, still starting, and am the exact same level as the #1 guy. It's not like I'm a backup QB who is never on the field. And about the playoffs, who cares? The Bulls are gonna pick it up next year, when they solidify their team. It has nothing to do with MVP. Look, I'll let you guys debate it, because in part, you are right, I shouldn't have to argue why my guy should be MVP, and as a matter of fact, there is a DE who I think actually should be MVP over me. I just wanted to make my point that people say "This is what is happening" when it isn't. Everyone make your own decision, Rutger is right. If you ask a question, I'll answer it. If you have a comment, I won't respond, it's your opinion. Lastly, I'd like to conclude with BMoreAbsurd, yes, you are a douche bag.


Who you kiddin', man? You don't think your guy should be MVP...yet halfway up the page you posted a link to one of his plays with the caption "MVP". At least be honest, huh?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.