Originally posted by WearyWarrior
Originally posted by Animalmother
Bort it seems nobody has had much luck with Sure Tackler and one would assume a 75% re-roll chance should result in far less missed tkls. Do the offensive sa's that may have broke the tackle trigger on both rolls? For example if power thru/spin etc triggers your going to miss the tkl anyway so a second roll wouldn't apply?
Just asking because I saw a Lb with 50+ str/60 tkl/10 sure tkl and he missed 16 tkls in one game...that leads me to believe the va isn't working correctly?
I had it maxed too, nothing so drastic but i added sure tackler and had my most missed tackles of my career (my ss)
And most of those were against powerbacks? I am guessing. And most of those power backs likely had used their VA's to up their attributes only.
Thats the problem.
An attribute boosted has far more effect than any other thing you can boost.
You get a decent chance to get a second tackle. 75%, but, tackling vs Powerbacks, per Bort, if you followed the powerback thread, requires a really high tackling stat. So, you may have had a lot of second chances, but they still didn't help significantly. You would have been better off using those 15 VA poins to get 15% added to your tackling skill.
Since these are multiplicative effects, you're only increasing the percentage chance by a percentage chance.
Look at 'forced fumbles' for example
Your SS had 101 tackles/missed tackles. Of hose he forced a fumble three times. Thats abou 2.9% chance per tackle of a forced fumble.
Lets be generous and double ta and say you have had really bad luck last season.
So, you have a 6% chance of causing a forced fumble. If you MAX Power Tackling this 6% becomes 6*1.30 = or 7.8%, you MAY have increased your ouput for the season by a single fumble.
You would have benefitted more from increasing the base tackling stat. Or, some other stat that is used more often on every play. In your case as a SS, Maybe Vision or Speed. But if you have enough points, why not do one or the other of those AND tackling.
Upping the tackling stae helps you across the entire board. It increases everything where tackling is used.
That's my argument for why the attribute based VA's are just too powerful and need removing or a serious diminishment so the other VA's are at some level of parity.
The reason I am opposed to 'buffing' the other VA's is to buff them reasonably, we're going to get very unrealistic results from our games. Which will also result in los of complaints from player base (ball carriers whining about all the fumbles, etc)