User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Not enough fumbling?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sully
Congratulations on completely missing the point of the thread and contributing nothing to the discussion.


Thread Title: not enough fumbling?
Thread Body: Talk of not getting an inflated amount of fumbles

Congratulations on being able to go through life in complete oblivion. Must make things very peaceful for you.
 
Sec
offline
Link
 
I know this is a sim, and it's all about numbers versus other numbers and how they should work against each other, but just because Antonio Pierce lays a monster hit on say Desean Jackson, doesn't mean he's going to fumble. I think the number of times that a WR holds on to the ball after getting hammered (or drops it incomplete) is much higher than the number of times they fumble, even though they are getting hit by guys that would embarrass them in the weight room.

How many times have you seen a helmet hit directly on the arm that is carrying the ball? It doesn't happen that often. In those situations, I think you've got a much higher fumble percentage (but still not higher than 50), but how do you SIM that? Also, LBs in real life don't set before hand whether they are going to try to force fumbles for the game or just tackle the guy. It is a play by play decision (or at least it was for me). If the guy is already wrapped up, or doesn't see you coming, you make the decision then to try to strip the ball. If it's just you, him, and daylight, then you try to wrap him up as best you can.

The biggest issue with fumbles and other GLB unique football plays is that you can't insert better football logic into the SIM itself. Quarterbacks decide PER PLAY when they will gun it or loft it. Linemen decide PER PLAY if they are going to focus on pass blocking or run blocking. Linebackers decide PER PLAY if they are going to try to force a fumble or just try to make the tackle (and most times that's not even a decision, the fumble just happens because of the hit).

I think that in GLB QB fumbles should happen more often than they do, and if they do that might make the average closer to the NFL numbers (if that's what we are shooting for). I see more QBs dropping the rock after a big hit than any other position in real football.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by
The basic consensus of GLB is nerf everything that does not pertain to the players I own and beef everything that does pertain to them.
 
Hells Horses
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Second Goalie
Originally posted by sully

Congratulations on completely missing the point of the thread and contributing nothing to the discussion.


Thread Title: not enough fumbling?
Thread Body: Talk of not getting an inflated amount of fumbles

Congratulations on being able to go through life in complete oblivion. Must make things very peaceful for you.


Inflated implies "more than is realistic". Not enough is not necessarily saying "more than is realistic". Reading comprehension ftw!

Anyway, my LB. Last season his tackling, as of the last game of the season, was 45. He played Wrap Up every game, lacked the +12% FF chance from Power Tackler VA.

This season his tackling is 54, and he has the +12% from Power Tackler and has played every game with tackling set to Power Tackling.

So far he's caused at least 1 FF in every season he's played. Last season he had 2. In order to even match that I need to cause 2 fumbles in the next 10 games - but with my jump in tackling and my VA, plus tackling style change, wouldn't it make sense that I beat that number this year? Even if I only increased my fumbles by 1 and ended with 3 this season, I'd like to see some kind of increase.

Otherwise what's the point of being able to choose a tackling style or using a VA? As a side note, last season I also missed 19 tackles. This season, through six games, not one single missed tackle despite going with power instead of wrap up.
 
SoCold
offline
Link
 
not enough fumbling? tell it to this head hunter.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=493832&playoffs=0

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SoCold
not enough fumbling? tell it to this head hunter.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=493832&playoffs=0



http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=295556 <-- 6 here, yawn

still, even though the comp level besides that isnt too hot, that's a great build. Nicely done.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
So are these people saying it's "unrealistic" for a specially built defensive player to average 1 FF per game the same people who think it's OK for running backs to average 200 yards per game because it's "fun"? Unrealistic stats are only fun for offensive players?

 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I wouldn't mind seeing a few more fumbles overall, tbh, especially since a lot of people have gimpy carrying ability. I don't think right now is the best time to toy with it though, because honestly I think if more defenders had higher tackling skill (and I don't mean ~50), we'd see more fumbles anyway. That would be the point to getting tackling skill near 100, imo.


My thread got a Bort post!

My life is complete
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Second Goalie
Originally posted by sully

Congratulations on completely missing the point of the thread and contributing nothing to the discussion.


Thread Title: not enough fumbling?
Thread Body: Talk of not getting an inflated amount of fumbles

Congratulations on being able to go through life in complete oblivion. Must make things very peaceful for you.


Wrong again!

Originally posted by Hells Horses
Inflated implies "more than is realistic". Not enough is not necessarily saying "more than is realistic". Reading comprehension ftw!


This guy knows what he's talking about.

Anyway, since it wasn't apparently clear the first time (Even though it was to most of us) I noticed that the number of fumbles seemed low. The point of this thread was to discuss whether the number actually is low, what may be causing said number, and if it is low, what needs to be done to get it to a more realistic level.

Had you brought your reading brain to GLB, you may have been able to figure that out.
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
At first when I read the title I was going to say no way, but bringing up those numbers, and looking throughout the games in my own league, I must say, I wouldn't mind another 50% or 100% fumble increase. Most NFL games have a fumble, muffed punt, or something other than INTs going on. More often than not I see games where FF do not occur for either side. +1 for increase of FF.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Hells Horses
So far he's caused at least 1 FF in every season he's played. Last season he had 2. In order to even match that I need to cause 2 fumbles in the next 10 games - but with my jump in tackling and my VA, plus tackling style change, wouldn't it make sense that I beat that number this year? Even if I only increased my fumbles by 1 and ended with 3 this season, I'd like to see some kind of increase.

Otherwise what's the point of being able to choose a tackling style or using a VA? As a side note, last season I also missed 19 tackles. This season, through six games, not one single missed tackle despite going with power instead of wrap up.


You average 1 FF a season and are complaining you haven't gotten more than that in your first 6 games?

Originally posted by Hells Horses
Reading comprehension ftw!


You do realize that as you level up everyone else does as well right? You expect your FF stats to increase against opponents who are also expecting their Fumbles to decrease? Hey what do you know the average stays constant as both sides of the fumble situation increase to improve their likely hood of having the outcome they want. Funny how that works out huh?

Not being completely clueless how the game works ftw!

This is why the stats argument is pointless. The people who build their LB(or any other player) right so they get the stats make the other people think they must get them because they made a LB too. You could have 1000% bonus increase in FF chance and you will not get much more if you are only averaging 1 a season.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 15:47:09
 
fullxtension
offline
Link
 
Part of the problem, IMHO is that blockers under the new scheme seem to be able to hold blocks for a very long time. Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't it generally very difficult to provide protection for a QB for more than a few seconds? Isn't that why they say the QB has to have a rhythm...check down...deliver the ball in 5-7 seconds tops... yes there are mismatches and all that....yes GLB is not the NFL....yes there are NFL plays where QBs get more time than that....

But, in general, the pocket starts to collapse fairly quickly IRL.... everything requires tweaking to get it right. I think if the pocket breaks down faster, then Swat Ball impacts the ball while the QB still has it, and more fumbles...

my $0.02
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Another thing to consider that some of the Tampa-2 based defenses (Minnesota, Chicago, Tampa) have preached...

One defender will hit the ball carrier to stick him or stand him up, and while he's still trying to fight for yards, other defenders swarm to him and try to strip the ball.

It is something to consider that would greatly punish players who have severely low carrying.
 
Hells Horses
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Second Goalie
Originally posted by Hells Horses

So far he's caused at least 1 FF in every season he's played. Last season he had 2. In order to even match that I need to cause 2 fumbles in the next 10 games - but with my jump in tackling and my VA, plus tackling style change, wouldn't it make sense that I beat that number this year? Even if I only increased my fumbles by 1 and ended with 3 this season, I'd like to see some kind of increase.

Otherwise what's the point of being able to choose a tackling style or using a VA? As a side note, last season I also missed 19 tackles. This season, through six games, not one single missed tackle despite going with power instead of wrap up.


You average 1 FF a season and are complaining you haven't gotten more than that in your first 6 games?

Originally posted by Hells Horses

Reading comprehension ftw!


You do realize that as you level up everyone else does as well right? You expect your FF stats to increase against opponents who are also expecting their Fumbles to decrease? Hey what do you know the average stays constant as both sides of the fumble situation increase to improve their likely hood of having the outcome they want. Funny how that works out huh?

Not being completely clueless how the game works ftw!

This is why the stats argument is pointless. The people who build their LB(or any other player) right so they get the stats make the other people think they must get them because they made a LB too. You could have 1000% bonus increase in FF chance and you will not get much more if you are only averaging 1 a season.


I expect my FFs to increase against offensive players who neglect carrying and strength, which would account for a large portion of the offensive players who handle the ball in GLB.

And this goes back to what I was saying about reading comprehension: You don't have it. Had it been that I gained my levels and dumped my points into speed like everyone else seems to think is cool, or had I used my VA on something that increases base stats, or had I left my tackling style on wrap up as I had in all my 1 fumble seasons, then your argument would be valid.

But luckily you can't read, nor can you form a valid counter-argument.
 
Link
 
i don't see the problem with the way things are.

actually, in the NFL, the people who force alot of fumbles (5/season) are almost always very fast players. DEs or safeties that get take a shot at a player who's already engaged.

i have no idea how fumbles are forced in GLB, but i wonder how this widespread notion came about that strength "ought" to have something to do with forced fumbles.
it doesn't in real life.

forced fumbles are caused by alot of things in real life and brute strength is never it.
it's usually an unexpected hit by a defender who's moving really fast.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.