User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by TheInfinity


Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by TheInfinity



Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Some Speed, dude. Everyone runs the 40-yard dash and has to do so in a reasonable time for their position.

Every time you and other people say "If speed mattered you'd have cornerbacks playing defensive end" i want to strangle each and every one of you. SOME SPEED. SOME SPEED. AGILITY/STRENGTH AND SOME SPEED. SOME! SOME SOME SOME SOME SOME SOME. Understand?! SOME SPEED. Christ.

Defensive Ends are some of the fastest 260+ pound people you will ever meet. Julius Peppers, Jevon Kearse, Dwight Freeney, ever see their 40-yard dash times? Not a 4.3-4.4 like a cornerback for most Defensive Ends but 4.6 or so? Thats where they are. So, hm, not 4.3 40-yard dash speed but 4.6 40-yard dash speed .. sounds like the difference between 95speed and 85speed. Shocking.

Speed not a factor at all, then why do the Defensive and Offensive Linemen run the 40-yard dash at the Combine? For fun? To get a workout? Its okay for them to be slower than cornerbacks but don't think that they can be as slow as they like to be. These are the most athletic big guys you will ever see.

AND I FRICKIN' SAID SOME SPEED. SOME! Don't go and say that I'm saying Cornerbacks should play Defensive End when I say that. Cause if you want to say that then the next time you mention Strength for a Linebacker, Safety or Running Back I'll yell at you about how Nose Tackles don't play those positions and the people at them aren't all 300+lbs monsters so obviously strength isn't important to them.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by TheInfinity


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by TheInfinity




Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Some Speed, dude. Everyone runs the 40-yard dash and has to do so in a reasonable time for their position.


And everyone does the bench press and has to do a reasonable amount for their position. But WR's and CB's don't need soft-capped Strength, nor should they.

I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms. But right now it pretty much has to be soft-capped, which is messed up.

And you called for pass rushing for DE's to be mostly Speed and Agility. DE's do need some Speed, because if they do get by the O-Line they have to get to the QB before he unloads the ball (or on a sweep to the RB before he turns the corner).
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by TheInfinity



Originally posted by Ken1




Originally posted by TheInfinity





Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Some Speed, dude. Everyone runs the 40-yard dash and has to do so in a reasonable time for their position.


And everyone does the bench press and has to do a reasonable amount for their position. But WR's and CB's don't need soft-capped Strength, nor should they.

I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms. But right now it pretty much has to be soft-capped, which is messed up.

And you called for pass rushing for DE's to be mostly Speed and Agility. DE's do need some Speed, because if they do get by the O-Line they have to get to the QB before he unloads the ball (or on a sweep to the RB before he turns the corner).


You must not be aware of the fact of just how fast Defensive Ends are, and the fact that most elite pass rushers are ridiculously fast guys.

Julius Peppers: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - 22 Bench Reps.
Jevon Kearse: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - Can't find his bench reps but he's 250, significantly lighter than Peppers.
Robert Mathis: Can't find his 40-Time but he's a small DE at 245lbs.

And 25 speed? Seriously? Watch the D-Leagues, do you see Linemen in the NFL moving like that? Here, check these out:

http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers

See how they care how fast the linemen are? And a 5-second 40-yard dash isn't 25 speed, its more like 50 speed, which is first soft cap, not too bad of a place to have to put your attribute when the people who intend to get by you have to run in the 4.6-second 40-yard dash range, meaning it has to be around 75-85 speed.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Nerfs every build. You would have to allow every player the ability to completly undo their builds to fit the new game.... Bort would have to announce that this was going to take place in X # of seasons and that all players would need to be retired or rebuilt to be able to play in the new system... I'm afraid that even though the stats and scores would stay, the whole game would break.

Thousands of customers who built this empire would cry foul and many would leave/ask for refunds or something.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
Nerfs every build. You would have to allow every player the ability to completly undo their builds to fit the new game.... Bort would have to announce that this was going to take place in X # of seasons and that all players would need to be retired or rebuilt to be able to play in the new system... I'm afraid that even though the stats and scores would stay, the whole game would break.

Thousands of customers who built this empire would cry foul and many would leave/ask for refunds or something.


Can't call it a nerf until you see the re-build. You're jumping to conclusions. For all you know it could super power every build and lead to 10,000 yards passing every season with 50 sacks.
 
mrfixij
offline
Link
 
A universal nerf is precisely what the game needs. Inflated stats and ridiculous blowouts are that way because everything is too powerful. 30 points in any given statistic should be a substantial difference, not 10 or the amount you can invest from equipment at a reasonable level.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by TheInfinity


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by TheInfinity




Originally posted by Ken1





Originally posted by TheInfinity






Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Some Speed, dude. Everyone runs the 40-yard dash and has to do so in a reasonable time for their position.


And everyone does the bench press and has to do a reasonable amount for their position. But WR's and CB's don't need soft-capped Strength, nor should they.

I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms. But right now it pretty much has to be soft-capped, which is messed up.

And you called for pass rushing for DE's to be mostly Speed and Agility. DE's do need some Speed, because if they do get by the O-Line they have to get to the QB before he unloads the ball (or on a sweep to the RB before he turns the corner).


You must not be aware of the fact of just how fast Defensive Ends are, and the fact that most elite pass rushers are ridiculously fast guys.

Julius Peppers: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - 22 Bench Reps.
Jevon Kearse: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - Can't find his bench reps but he's 250, significantly lighter than Peppers.
Robert Mathis: Can't find his 40-Time but he's a small DE at 245lbs.

And 25 speed? Seriously? Watch the D-Leagues, do you see Linemen in the NFL moving like that? Here, check these out:

http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers

See how they care how fast the linemen are? And a 5-second 40-yard dash isn't 25 speed, its more like 50 speed, which is first soft cap, not too bad of a place to have to put your attribute when the people who intend to get by you have to run in the 4.6-second 40-yard dash range, meaning it has to be around 75-85 speed.


Note only two O-Linemen on that list are 5.0 or faster, plus:

Speed can be scaled however one wants to scale it. One can easily scale a 5 second 40 yard dash to be 25 Speed. Bort messed up on that one IMO, letting different Speeds be far too different in how fast the dot moves.

If you don't value Strength much more than Speed, you don't have 300 pound players playing at a position in real life.

And look at the reps some WR's and a number of CB's can do. Should they have to soft-cap Strength? Look at the vertical leap at, say, HB. Either no one has realized it or Jumping is very much undervalued in RB's.

Back to Strength, Speed, and 300 pounds: In baseball Strength (for power hitting) is more important than Speed at corner infield positions and catcher, and often teams will play slow power hitters at corner outfield positions as well, even knowing they are sacrificing defense to do so.

But you very rarely see 300 pounders playing baseball, because they might hit home runs, but they're extremely slow and can't run the bases, etc., even though again, only CF's, SS's, and 2Bmen truly have to be fast.

You never see in basketball anyone nearly as heavy for their height as in football, because basketball, like soccer, truly is a speed over strength sport (because too much contact in either results in a foul). Some basketball players weigh a lot because they're so tall, as height is a big deal there. But none look like O-linemen.

But in football, it's a sport of hitting other players, and most positions need to be strong as much as fast. WR's and DB's are exceptions, although it's surprising how strong on that same site one can see that a lot of DB's are.

One other note from the site: O-linemen in real life are even much less agile than other positions, more so than I thought. They suck (relatively speaking) at the 3-cone drill, although D-linemen definitely seem to need to be good in that area.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mrfixij
A universal nerf is precisely what the game needs. Inflated stats and ridiculous blowouts are that way because everything is too powerful. 30 points in any given statistic should be a substantial difference, not 10 or the amount you can invest from equipment at a reasonable level.


This, I agree with-- maybe to a lesser degree, but I agree with its direction. I don't think many people will, though, as I've discussed it before and been strongly disagreed with.

Want to have fewer 100+ point blowouts? Universally nerf the degree of differences and it will be so. It really means nerf no one, as it's the same for everybody. If a WR gets nerfed and so do the CB's covering him, he comes out the same.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Time Trial

Nerfs every build. You would have to allow every player the ability to completly undo their builds to fit the new game.... Bort would have to announce that this was going to take place in X # of seasons and that all players would need to be retired or rebuilt to be able to play in the new system... I'm afraid that even though the stats and scores would stay, the whole game would break.

Thousands of customers who built this empire would cry foul and many would leave/ask for refunds or something.


Can't call it a nerf until you see the re-build. You're jumping to conclusions. For all you know it could super power every build and lead to 10,000 yards passing every season with 50 sacks.


Still breaks the build. What I'm saying is that all of the new players will get to build based on the new engine, and will be better able to refine their players so that when they reach level X they (because of their new builds) will be able to school players that are stuck with builds as they were.

 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity


3) Match Ups and Situation Dept Charts on BOTH SIDES OF THE BALL

-Certain DE is in? A certain OT lines up in front of him.
-Certain RB is in? A certain set of LBs come in for him.
-Certain WR is in? A certain DB lines up on him.
-- You can set it like WR - Chad Johnson -- Matchup CB1 - Champ Bailey, Terrence Newman, Deion Sanders. Basically so if Champ is tired its Terrence's job and if he's tired it's Deion's. It'd be an override, just like the AIs and Depth Chart settings we have.



You can't have this for offense, the offense has to set first and the defense gets to react just like the sub rules in the NFL.

I'm sure the defensive side will be added once Bort codes it and codes the check and balance to it- no huddle offense. By moving quicker than the defense can substitute it takes away the D's reactive sub advantage. Of course this would tire out the offense AND defense quicker as neither side should sub during it.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by mrfixij

A universal nerf is precisely what the game needs. Inflated stats and ridiculous blowouts are that way because everything is too powerful. 30 points in any given statistic should be a substantial difference, not 10 or the amount you can invest from equipment at a reasonable level.


This, I agree with-- maybe to a lesser degree, but I agree with its direction. I don't think many people will, though, as I've discussed it before and been strongly disagreed with.

Want to have fewer 100+ point blowouts? Universally nerf the degree of differences and it will be so. It really means nerf no one, as it's the same for everybody. If a WR gets nerfed and so do the CB's covering him, he comes out the same.


If you believed that the logic was that simple, then I agree your solution is that simple. But I'm wagering that Bort's simulation doesn't have a wheel on it that can be turned and everyone is powered down equally. You are oversimplifying the solution and then getting upset that it hasn't already be done.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by mrfixij


A universal nerf is precisely what the game needs. Inflated stats and ridiculous blowouts are that way because everything is too powerful. 30 points in any given statistic should be a substantial difference, not 10 or the amount you can invest from equipment at a reasonable level.


This, I agree with-- maybe to a lesser degree, but I agree with its direction. I don't think many people will, though, as I've discussed it before and been strongly disagreed with.

Want to have fewer 100+ point blowouts? Universally nerf the degree of differences and it will be so. It really means nerf no one, as it's the same for everybody. If a WR gets nerfed and so do the CB's covering him, he comes out the same.


If you believed that the logic was that simple, then I agree your solution is that simple. But I'm wagering that Bort's simulation doesn't have a wheel on it that can be turned and everyone is powered down equally. You are oversimplifying the solution and then getting upset that it hasn't already be done.


I'm not truly upset about this factor. I'm just saying it's probably the best solution to the huge blowout proliferation that bothers the hell out of a lot of people.

There are things I get upset about in this game, but this isn't one of them. If it were, I'd push it hard, and I don't.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by TheInfinity



Originally posted by Ken1




Originally posted by TheInfinity





Originally posted by Ken1






Originally posted by TheInfinity







Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Some Speed, dude. Everyone runs the 40-yard dash and has to do so in a reasonable time for their position.


And everyone does the bench press and has to do a reasonable amount for their position. But WR's and CB's don't need soft-capped Strength, nor should they.

I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms. But right now it pretty much has to be soft-capped, which is messed up.

And you called for pass rushing for DE's to be mostly Speed and Agility. DE's do need some Speed, because if they do get by the O-Line they have to get to the QB before he unloads the ball (or on a sweep to the RB before he turns the corner).


You must not be aware of the fact of just how fast Defensive Ends are, and the fact that most elite pass rushers are ridiculously fast guys.

Julius Peppers: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - 22 Bench Reps.
Jevon Kearse: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - Can't find his bench reps but he's 250, significantly lighter than Peppers.
Robert Mathis: Can't find his 40-Time but he's a small DE at 245lbs.

And 25 speed? Seriously? Watch the D-Leagues, do you see Linemen in the NFL moving like that? Here, check these out:

http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers

See how they care how fast the linemen are? And a 5-second 40-yard dash isn't 25 speed, its more like 50 speed, which is first soft cap, not too bad of a place to have to put your attribute when the people who intend to get by you have to run in the 4.6-second 40-yard dash range, meaning it has to be around 75-85 speed.


Note only two O-Linemen on that list are 5.0 or faster, plus:

Speed can be scaled however one wants to scale it. One can easily scale a 5 second 40 yard dash to be 25 Speed. Bort messed up on that one IMO, letting different Speeds be far too different in how fast the dot moves.

If you don't value Strength much more than Speed, you don't have 300 pound players playing at a position in real life.

And look at the reps some WR's and a number of CB's can do. Should they have to soft-cap Strength? Look at the vertical leap at, say, HB. Either no one has realized it or Jumping is very much undervalued in RB's.

Back to Strength, Speed, and 300 pounds: In baseball Strength (for power hitting) is more important than Speed at corner infield positions and catcher, and often teams will play slow power hitters at corner outfield positions as well, even knowing they are sacrificing defense to do so.

But you very rarely see 300 pounders playing baseball, because they might hit home runs, but they're extremely slow and can't run the bases, etc., even though again, only CF's, SS's, and 2Bmen truly have to be fast.

You never see in basketball anyone nearly as heavy for their height as in football, because basketball, like soccer, truly is a speed over strength sport (because too much contact in either results in a foul). Some basketball players weigh a lot because they're so tall, as height is a big deal there. But none look like O-linemen.

But in football, it's a sport of hitting other players, and most positions need to be strong as much as fast. WR's and DB's are exceptions, although it's surprising how strong on that same site one can see that a lot of DB's are.

One other note from the site: O-linemen in real life are even much less agile than other positions, more so than I thought. They suck (relatively speaking) at the 3-cone drill, although D-linemen definitely seem to need to be good in that area.


They're definitely the slow pokes of the league and the least athletic (due to their size). But I guess we're yelling about scaling here. To me 25 speed is way to slow and taking it to the first cap 48 is reasonable, only because you can do that with training alone over time. I also don't want the difference between 25 speed and 35 speed to be greater than the difference between 80 speed and 90 speed. To me 10 is 10 in a stat.

And yes, they do value strength heavily at those positions, hence the large sizes of people. But its definitely not the only attribute, its a primary, and I'd say that's why you need it for Pass Blocking and especially need it for Run Blocking while Speed is a minor attribute for Pass Blocking and not much of an attribute in Run Blocking. Strength > Speed at Offensive Line, I agree there.

For Defensive Line, we see people sacrificing Strength for Speed, hence the big difference in size between Offensive Tackles and Defensive Ends and even Defensive Ends and Defensive Tackles. They're still valuing strength but speed has definitely come into the equation for them, especially for the Pass Rushers who tend to be the fastest of the linemen.

As for Vertical Jumps and Broad Jumps, those are products of Leg Strength in the combine and is what they actually measure. Except for Defensive Backs, Wide Receivers and some Linebackers, the number that comes out of the jumping measurement isn't so much for the height of the jump but for a measure of explosiveness. This is why I wouldn't link the Jumping Attribute to much for Running Backs even though in real life the Vertical and Broad Jumps are indicative of explosive running ability.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 16:23:39
 
TheWorstGuy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by TheInfinity


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by TheInfinity




Originally posted by Ken1





Originally posted by TheInfinity






Originally posted by Ken1







Originally posted by TheInfinity








Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?

So:

1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.

2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.

3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.


So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?

I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?


I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.

Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.

Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.

So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.

The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.


You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.

I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).

Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.


Some Speed, dude. Everyone runs the 40-yard dash and has to do so in a reasonable time for their position.


And everyone does the bench press and has to do a reasonable amount for their position. But WR's and CB's don't need soft-capped Strength, nor should they.

I'd call a "reasonable speed" for an O-lineman about 25 Speed in GLB terms. But right now it pretty much has to be soft-capped, which is messed up.

And you called for pass rushing for DE's to be mostly Speed and Agility. DE's do need some Speed, because if they do get by the O-Line they have to get to the QB before he unloads the ball (or on a sweep to the RB before he turns the corner).


You must not be aware of the fact of just how fast Defensive Ends are, and the fact that most elite pass rushers are ridiculously fast guys.

Julius Peppers: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - 22 Bench Reps.
Jevon Kearse: 40 Yard Dash Time: 4.6 - Can't find his bench reps but he's 250, significantly lighter than Peppers.
Robert Mathis: Can't find his 40-Time but he's a small DE at 245lbs.

And 25 speed? Seriously? Watch the D-Leagues, do you see Linemen in the NFL moving like that? Here, check these out:

http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers

See how they care how fast the linemen are? And a 5-second 40-yard dash isn't 25 speed, its more like 50 speed, which is first soft cap, not too bad of a place to have to put your attribute when the people who intend to get by you have to run in the 4.6-second 40-yard dash range, meaning it has to be around 75-85 speed.


Note only two O-Linemen on that list are 5.0 or faster, plus:

Speed can be scaled however one wants to scale it. One can easily scale a 5 second 40 yard dash to be 25 Speed. Bort messed up on that one IMO, letting different Speeds be far too different in how fast the dot moves.

If you don't value Strength much more than Speed, you don't have 300 pound players playing at a position in real life.

And look at the reps some WR's and a number of CB's can do. Should they have to soft-cap Strength? Look at the vertical leap at, say, HB. Either no one has realized it or Jumping is very much undervalued in RB's.

Back to Strength, Speed, and 300 pounds: In baseball Strength (for power hitting) is more important than Speed at corner infield positions and catcher, and often teams will play slow power hitters at corner outfield positions as well, even knowing they are sacrificing defense to do so.

But you very rarely see 300 pounders playing baseball, because they might hit home runs, but they're extremely slow and can't run the bases, etc., even though again, only CF's, SS's, and 2Bmen truly have to be fast.

You never see in basketball anyone nearly as heavy for their height as in football, because basketball, like soccer, truly is a speed over strength sport (because too much contact in either results in a foul). Some basketball players weigh a lot because they're so tall, as height is a big deal there. But none look like O-linemen.

But in football, it's a sport of hitting other players, and most positions need to be strong as much as fast. WR's and DB's are exceptions, although it's surprising how strong on that same site one can see that a lot of DB's are.

One other note from the site: O-linemen in real life are even much less agile than other positions, more so than I thought. They suck (relatively speaking) at the 3-cone drill, although D-linemen definitely seem to need to be good in that area.


They're definitely the slow pokes of the league and the least athletic (due to their size). But I guess we're yelling about scaling here. To me 25 speed is way to slow and taking it to the first cap 48 is reasonable, only because you can do that with training alone over time. I also don't want the difference between 25 speed and 50 speed to be greater than the difference between 80 speed and 90 speed. To me 10 is 10 in a stat.

And yes, they do value strength heavily at those positions, hence the large sizes of people. But its definitely not the only attribute, its a primary, and I'd say that's why you need it for Pass Blocking and especially need it for Run Blocking while Speed is a minor attribute for Pass Blocking and not much of an attribute in Run Blocking. Strength > Speed at Offensive Line, I agree there.

For Defensive Line, we see people sacrificing Strength for Speed, hence the big difference in size between Offensive Tackles and Defensive Ends and even Defensive Ends and Defensive Tackles. They're still valuing strength but speed has definitely come into the equation for them, especially for the Pass Rushers who tend to be the fastest of the linemen.

As for Vertical Jumps and Broad Jumps, those are products of Leg Strength in the combine and is what they actually measure. Except for Defensive Backs, Wide Receivers and some Linebackers, the number that comes out of the jumping measurement isn't so much for the height of the jump but for a measure of explosiveness. This is why I wouldn't link the Jumping Attribute to much for Running Backs even though in real life the Vertical and Broad Jumps are indicative of explosive running ability.


To those that just scrolled through this post without reading, I hope you took shrooms in order to appreciate what you just scrolled past
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.