Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?
So:
1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.
2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.
3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.
So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?
I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?
I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.
Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.
Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.
So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.
The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.
You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.
I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).
Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Seems no one understands the point of this post. I thought I made it clear. Its a mechanics overhaul based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Based on the progress made through the last 7 seasons. Need I say it again?
So:
1) Its not going to require a re-spec. Its new mechanics, not an entirely new attributes system. If someone is proposing that here, make your own thread and don't hi-jack this one.
2) Its not going to take us to the stone age. Bort wouldn't do it blindly, he would use the data and knowledge from the past seasons. Saying we'd be back at Square One is saying that he will start as if he was Bort from a year ago and not Bort from today. Its like editing a paper, you can only edit it word by word or sentence by sentence for so long before you might as well just write a new one.
3) Sure, there will be disagreements as to what the mechanics should work like, but the overall consensus is not what we need. What we need is a coherent system that doesn't have to change all the time. Basically, don't have a simulation mechanic so weak that the creation of 90Speed/Agility Defensive Ends turns the entire game upside down onto its head and causes massive changes in the code. If the game's core logic is proper then you don't need to change everything as a reaction to a single type of player being made, you just wait for the other players to adapt.
So you're saying the same attributes system and all (if one starts changing the attributes, that's when re-specs and wipes start being discussed)?
I guess I'm among those who don't understand-- just what do you propose changing?
I'll illustrate with #1) Blocking.
Pass Blocking: Make it rely on Agility/Blocking/Strength with some Speed. Make getting around Pass Blocks involve Agility/Speed and Some Strength.
Run Blocking: Make it rely more on Blocking/Strength with some Agility. Make getting through Run Blocks involve Agility/Strength and Some Speed.
So when you have the 90speed/agility defensive end that's creating hell for Quarterbacks you can simply go "Aha, the speed DE, lets run against him" and shove the ball down his throat, thus taking advantage of his weakness.
The way it works now Defensive Ends that are Speed/Agility and Some Strength are useless against the Pass and the Run while Defensive Ends that are Strength/Agility and Some Speed have always been useless against the Pass and the Run. This is because a DE that was good against the Pass was also dominant against the Run, cause the mechanics of both types of blocking were the same when in real life they are not and in a practical sense for the simulation they shouldn't be, and prompted Bort's nerfing.
You see, here's a problem related to how we think things should be. I don't think Speed should be a factor for DE's in anything except getting to the QB if he gets by the blocker. If it were, we'd see a lot of CB to DE conversions in real life and both positions would weigh about the same.
I think Agility should be slightly more important to a DE than Strength in pass rushing, and strong DE's should dominate in run rushing. Speed shouldn't matter in either (except as noted above).
Same with OT's, who are 300+ pounds in real life because being slow is perfectly okay for them, and absolutely should be in GLB. To run block should be Strength/Blocking and to pass block should be Agility/Blocking but also the chance to manhandle a guy that has much less Strength than you.






























