Originally posted by AuburnBlue
Originally posted by atom871
...
I say once a player signs with a team, he should stay in that league. Research your options and remain in that league. It would do wonders for recruiting, parity, gutting and collusion. It would also allow for implementation of a drafting system from the d-leagues.
Take the NFL for example, if a player chooses to leave the NFL, how many options does he have? CFL? NFL Europe (nope, scratch that one...) Not many choices are there?
-1 (that's MINUS 1, negative, disagree)
Players in the NFL (or any other league) can go anywhere they want when their contact ends. Look at Warren Moon and Doug Flutie and Hershel Walker as perfect illustrations. Flutie AND Walker started out in the USFL, under your rule that's where their careers would have ended. Flutie next goes into the NFL where he bombed. He then went to the CFL and became a superstar. He threw for something like 45,000 yards and was an MVP 6(?) times! THEN he came back to the NFL and finished with a career winning record. Walker's USFL and NFL records speak for themselves. Warren Moon was a superstar in Canada and then became the highest paid player in the NFL and went tot he Pro Bowl 9 times. He also had something like 50,000 yards passing in just his NFL career.
Short answer, blocking where a player can go when their contract expires is a stupid suggestion and has no basis in reality.
No basis in reality, eh? Well the few examples you mentioned are exceptions to the rule. Good ones, sure, but overall, they are irrelevant to the point.
GLB has Hundreds of leagues, little basis for reality there.
So, back to the point. Universal player mobility enables collusion and gutting. Limit that and you will encourage better rivalries within leagues, better parity for teams and much more reasonable recruiting. I think it also lends itself to support a drafting system. It causes owners and agents to behave much more responsibly, because there is accountability built right into the idea. Your 'rep' doesn't vanish - because you can't leave the league. Word is out. You are a good agent/owner or a bad.
I think certainly there is room to argue how much player movement can be limited. I will leave that up to future discussions. Right now, the problem of gutting and collusion could be remedied, in large part, by limiting player movement. At the same time encouraging rivalries and improving team parity.