User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to slow down gutting and killing teams
Page:
 
Link
 
With Pee Wee teams, it wouldn't matter as far as reins are concerned.

Its also not necessarily about 'gaining the GLB experience' as much as it is, disallowing people to exploit features of the game.

I'm not saying YOU or Raiders would, i'm saying no one should even be able to.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AuburnBlue
Originally posted by atom871


...

I say once a player signs with a team, he should stay in that league. Research your options and remain in that league. It would do wonders for recruiting, parity, gutting and collusion. It would also allow for implementation of a drafting system from the d-leagues.

Take the NFL for example, if a player chooses to leave the NFL, how many options does he have? CFL? NFL Europe (nope, scratch that one...) Not many choices are there?



-1 (that's MINUS 1, negative, disagree)

Players in the NFL (or any other league) can go anywhere they want when their contact ends. Look at Warren Moon and Doug Flutie and Hershel Walker as perfect illustrations. Flutie AND Walker started out in the USFL, under your rule that's where their careers would have ended. Flutie next goes into the NFL where he bombed. He then went to the CFL and became a superstar. He threw for something like 45,000 yards and was an MVP 6(?) times! THEN he came back to the NFL and finished with a career winning record. Walker's USFL and NFL records speak for themselves. Warren Moon was a superstar in Canada and then became the highest paid player in the NFL and went tot he Pro Bowl 9 times. He also had something like 50,000 yards passing in just his NFL career.

Short answer, blocking where a player can go when their contract expires is a stupid suggestion and has no basis in reality.


No basis in reality, eh? Well the few examples you mentioned are exceptions to the rule. Good ones, sure, but overall, they are irrelevant to the point.

GLB has Hundreds of leagues, little basis for reality there.

So, back to the point. Universal player mobility enables collusion and gutting. Limit that and you will encourage better rivalries within leagues, better parity for teams and much more reasonable recruiting. I think it also lends itself to support a drafting system. It causes owners and agents to behave much more responsibly, because there is accountability built right into the idea. Your 'rep' doesn't vanish - because you can't leave the league. Word is out. You are a good agent/owner or a bad.

I think certainly there is room to argue how much player movement can be limited. I will leave that up to future discussions. Right now, the problem of gutting and collusion could be remedied, in large part, by limiting player movement. At the same time encouraging rivalries and improving team parity.
 
Guppy, Inc
online
Link
 
why not add a rating for when you sell back a team. Rate the teams on length of ownership, cash, stadium, players, fan support at the time of sale. Sell it at the end of the season and the team has a decent stadium (for the level), cash, fan support and players, you get a top rating of 1. If you sell mid season with a bad stadium, no players, and no cash, then you get a 5. Your rating would be the number of seasons before you can buy another team. When people buy a team, they have an obligation to their players but also to GLB to run a decent team. If you cant do BOTH, then you dont deserve another team.

examples:
length of owner ship = 3 seasons ------- 1
stadium = complete -------------------------- 1
players = 3/4 roster full ------------------------1
cash = above average for league ---------- 1
fan support = increased since 1st day ----1
this owner would rate a 5/5 = 1

length of owner ship = 1 season -------- 5
stadium = nothing added ------------------- 5
players = no humans --------------------------5
cash = none -------------------------- ---------- 5
fan support = decreased since 1st day ----5
so this owner would ge a 25/5 = 5

the game will never get better if people are continually allowed to gut teams and get their FPs back mid season.

 
atom871
offline
Link
 
accountability is important. i am sure it will be the answer, whatever form it takes.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
why not add a rating for when you sell back a team. Rate the teams on length of ownership, cash, stadium, players, fan support at the time of sale. Sell it at the end of the season and the team has a decent stadium (for the level), cash, fan support and players, you get a top rating of 1. If you sell mid season with a bad stadium, no players, and no cash, then you get a 5. Your rating would be the number of seasons before you can buy another team. When people buy a team, they have an obligation to their players but also to GLB to run a decent team. If you cant do BOTH, then you dont deserve another team.

examples:
length of owner ship = 3 seasons ------- 1
stadium = complete -------------------------- 1
players = 3/4 roster full ------------------------1
cash = above average for league ---------- 1
fan support = increased since 1st day ----1
this owner would rate a 5/5 = 1

length of owner ship = 1 season -------- 5
stadium = nothing added ------------------- 5
players = no humans --------------------------5
cash = none -------------------------- ---------- 5
fan support = decreased since 1st day ----5
so this owner would ge a 25/5 = 5

the game will never get better if people are continually allowed to gut teams and get their FPs back mid season.



How are all 32 new team owners in a league supposed to achieve this?
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Sorry, but this is a newb thread.

Anyone here more than 5 minutes sees all the holes easily.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Sorry, but this is a newb thread.

Anyone here more than 5 minutes sees all the holes easily.


bad publicity is better than none, thanks for the bump!
 
Guppy, Inc
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

why not add a rating for when you sell back a team. Rate the teams on length of ownership, cash, stadium, players, fan support at the time of sale. Sell it at the end of the season and the team has a decent stadium (for the level), cash, fan support and players, you get a top rating of 1. If you sell mid season with a bad stadium, no players, and no cash, then you get a 5. Your rating would be the number of seasons before you can buy another team. When people buy a team, they have an obligation to their players but also to GLB to run a decent team. If you cant do BOTH, then you dont deserve another team.

examples:
length of owner ship = 3 seasons ------- 1
stadium = complete -------------------------- 1
players = 3/4 roster full ------------------------1
cash = above average for league ---------- 1
fan support = increased since 1st day ----1
this owner would rate a 5/5 = 1

length of owner ship = 1 season -------- 5
stadium = nothing added ------------------- 5
players = no humans --------------------------5
cash = none -------------------------- ---------- 5
fan support = decreased since 1st day ----5
so this owner would ge a 25/5 = 5

the game will never get better if people are continually allowed to gut teams and get their FPs back mid season.



How are all 32 new team owners in a league supposed to achieve this?

Achieve what? This only applies to teams being sold back. The 32 owners would all be compared to each other. If you are selling back and had a terrible team, you really shouldnt be getting another team the next season to destroy. Every time i see a thread from a new owner that doesnt understand basic GLB financing, I cringe. And any owner that cant commit to the initial 2 yr deal also dont deserve to be given new teams. the point is that these owners already HAD a team and now they want another one. odds are that they arent going to be much better if they couldnt get thru the 1st 2.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 18:16:41
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
why not add a rating for when you sell back a team. Rate the teams on length of ownership, cash, stadium, players, fan support at the time of sale. Sell it at the end of the season and the team has a decent stadium (for the level), cash, fan support and players, you get a top rating of 1. If you sell mid season with a bad stadium, no players, and no cash, then you get a 5. Your rating would be the number of seasons before you can buy another team. When people buy a team, they have an obligation to their players but also to GLB to run a decent team. If you cant do BOTH, then you dont deserve another team.

examples:
length of owner ship = 3 seasons ------- 1
stadium = complete -------------------------- 1
players = 3/4 roster full ------------------------1
cash = above average for league ---------- 1
fan support = increased since 1st day ----1
this owner would rate a 5/5 = 1

length of owner ship = 1 season -------- 5
stadium = nothing added ------------------- 5
players = no humans --------------------------5
cash = none -------------------------- ---------- 5
fan support = decreased since 1st day ----5
so this owner would ge a 25/5 = 5

the game will never get better if people are continually allowed to gut teams and get their FPs back mid season.



This isn't quite the solution that i was looking at, but it certainly would be a step in the right direction. This plan institutes at least some form of accountability for owners.

Still think the players need some accountability too.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
Originally posted by Viscount

Originally posted by Guppy, Inc


why not add a rating for when you sell back a team. Rate the teams on length of ownership, cash, stadium, players, fan support at the time of sale. Sell it at the end of the season and the team has a decent stadium (for the level), cash, fan support and players, you get a top rating of 1. If you sell mid season with a bad stadium, no players, and no cash, then you get a 5. Your rating would be the number of seasons before you can buy another team. When people buy a team, they have an obligation to their players but also to GLB to run a decent team. If you cant do BOTH, then you dont deserve another team.

examples:
length of owner ship = 3 seasons ------- 1
stadium = complete -------------------------- 1
players = 3/4 roster full ------------------------1
cash = above average for league ---------- 1
fan support = increased since 1st day ----1
this owner would rate a 5/5 = 1

length of owner ship = 1 season -------- 5
stadium = nothing added ------------------- 5
players = no humans --------------------------5
cash = none -------------------------- ---------- 5
fan support = decreased since 1st day ----5
so this owner would ge a 25/5 = 5

the game will never get better if people are continually allowed to gut teams and get their FPs back mid season.



How are all 32 new team owners in a league supposed to achieve this?

Achieve what? This only applies to teams being sold back. The 32 owners would all be compared to each other. If you are selling back and had a terrible team, you really shouldnt be getting another team the next season to destroy. Every time i see a thread from a new owner that doesnt understand basic GLB financing, I cringe.


I meant for example, how is every single team in a league supposed to keep up their fan support and build a great stadium.

You started with an expansion team, do you know how difficult it is for new owners in an uncapped league starting with a basic stadium and $1.5 mil to recruit high level players to compete, pay equipment and yet stay financially viable?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Sorry, but this is a newb thread.

Anyone here more than 5 minutes sees all the holes easily.


What part of this don't you like? The part that limits you from having all your players on the same teams and exploiting the system? or the part that catches your tail on fire when you gut your team over and over?

Lets face it, the only comments you've made on this thread are troll posts. Add something intelligent or go to FFA and waste your pointless keyboard pounding time there.. K, thanks, bai.

Even if you don't agree with it, give some actual opinion to it.
Last edited Jan 12, 2009 19:52:15
 
hyunsuk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SikoraP13
i like it, although i would say two seasons...but that's just me...

Only problem I can foresee is what happens if an owner has to give up his team due to family issues(not having enough time) or a crunch on $, and they were good owners?


agreed, but then there should be an emergency person, like one of your trusted GMs could take over until you're back

Originally posted by Viscount
Originally posted by bigpimpin123

Isn't there a waiting list? My suggestion would be that new potential team owners can be placed in front of previous owners.


This already happens.


I disagree with the main suggestion in this thread. There are many other reasons why owners sell their teams during the season, such as real life time constraints and then a month later find that they do have time to run a team.

The admins won't have the time to evaluate why each owner sold his or her team, so this suggestion would be punishing everyone who sells a team not just the people who deserve it.

Also, losing an entire season isn't exactly a fun GLB experience. Although an owner may be abandoning a team, they're also giving the players the opportunity to go to a better team.

Coaches who lose lot's of games in NFL get fired and eventually move to another team, why can't owners do that here?

Also, for the record, my team got promoted and and now we're losing most of our games but I won't be selling my team.


coach and owner are completely different, there are also owners in the nfl
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Sorry, but this is a newb thread.

Anyone here more than 5 minutes sees all the holes easily.


Find another thread to troll on please...

Constructive stuff going on in here!
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
I have some ideas I am working on to prevent gutting...they will be posted later.

I figured I would go for the easy effective suggestion first.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
There is no "cure" for gutting.

You are wasting your time.

The only positive thing that could come from a thread like this is ways that GLB can make it more appealing to owners to keep a team.

I'm telling you that there is no stick thats going to help gutting.

Try some carrots.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.