User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Good Luck to Spicewood and any other Longhorn Fans
Page:
 
Jackhammer1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by kurieg


IMO, as a Hokie fan, this is how I see the 3-way circle jerk in the Big 12:

Texas Techs wins at home barely.
UT wins on a neutral field convincingly.
OU wins at home convincingly.


UT's win showed me the most for a bowl game, easily.

Furthermore, UT would have held up better imo vs. UF. I think UT has been doing a better job coaching their QBs, especially for pressure circumstances, and I think their D is significantly better than either Tech or OU.



This part isn't true. They won a game that could have gone either way.

UT could barely handle Ohio State and Oklahoma State. Imagine if they played Florida, a team far far far far better than Ohio State or Oklahoma State.


I woulda given Texas a better shot than Oklahoma for one reason - McCoy is a far, far better quarterback than Sam Bradford - especially when it comes to handling pressure.

The fact is, Bradford had no business winning the heisman over Tebow or McCoy. He sat behind one of the best offensive lines in college football all year, with all day to throw, RACing half of his stats because his receivers and tight end were just horrendous mismatches for most of the teams they played. To say nothing of the fact that besides Florida, the one good D-Line they played was Texas, and Big 12 officials hate calling holds - which left Phil LoadHOLD free to choke Brian Orakpo (literally if you watch the film there are plays where Loadholt has his arm around Orakpo's neck that don't get called).

If Bradford comes back next year, you will see just how bad a QB he is. He's no better than Jason White, who also racced his way to a heisman and was promptly exposed everytime he came under pressure. McCoy would have been able to score more than 14 on Florida, I'm 100% certain. The problem is if Texas's defense could have held up - and that I'm not so sure of. Our defensive line was one of the best in college football this year, and our secondary had it's moments but is extremely young (every DB was a freshman or sophomore except Palmer, who was the least physically gifted corner back there). Our linebackers also had their ups and downs but played horribly against Ohio State.

So could Texas have held florida to the score OU did? Probably not. But could they have outscored them? I think they could.

Texas has only ever won the beauty contests that make people like tom jump onto bandwagons once - in 2005. Ironically, that year Texas was blowing everybody out, USC was barely winning most of their games, but they were favored in the NC game. I doubt many teams have been as good in the second half as Texas has in the last 4 years. Oklahoma State gets up on Texas every year but always manages to lose. Oklahoma and Ohio State had halftime leads this year, as did Tech - and that one basically got erased. If McCoy had burned the entire play clock before snapping the ball on that go ahead TD, we aren't having this argument because Texas is in the title game. The fact is - Texas doesn't get near the credit it deserves when compared with some of these other teams.

Texas has the longest active streak of ten win seasons. Texas is 3-0 in BCS bowls. The last time texas lost a bowl game was 2003. The last time OU won one? 2002. How can anybody act as though Texas is this far inferior to an OU team that has lost 3 of the last 4 against them, including this year?

Tom, and all the others like him - the days of Bob Stoops having a 5 game winning streak over Texas are over. Accept it. Stop giving them credit they don't deserve. Honestly, I wonder why Tressel's Ohio State program is the BCS goat - their Bowl losses at least were in national championship games until this one. OU has been stinking up the postseason longer and with more consistency than Ohio State has.


I just referred to this quote because you complained that USC was favored over Texas in that rosebowl. Of course they were, the Big 12 was awful that year and Oklahoma and Nebraska had laid eggs in the big game in the previous years. Texas had little more street cred than Penn State and the Big Ten this year. However, Texas played the game of their life, made less mental errors than USC, and deserved the hard fought title. This is why you have to play the games. Utah, USC, and Texas all have legitimate gripes about there being no playoff. Florida is a great team, with the best schedule on paper and would not be an easy victory for any of these guys. The fact remains that we can't say who is the best out of the group. A playoff is the only way to end the argument.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jackhammer1

I just referred to this quote because you complained that USC was favored over Texas in that rosebowl. Of course they were, the Big 12 was awful that year and Oklahoma and Nebraska had laid eggs in the big game in the previous years. Texas had little more street cred than Penn State and the Big Ten this year. However, Texas played the game of their life, made less mental errors than USC, and deserved the hard fought title. This is why you have to play the games. Utah, USC, and Texas all have legitimate gripes about there being no playoff. Florida is a great team, with the best schedule on paper and would not be an easy victory for any of these guys. The fact remains that we can't say who is the best out of the group. A playoff is the only way to end the argument.


I'm not sure it would end the argument of who the best team was. Teams get lucky and unlucky a lot. It would make it less open to interpretation and subjective judgments that are nearly impossible to make due to lack of meaningful games. It would only prove who played the best over 3 games (if it was 8 teams).

Since the are 114? teams or so, I don't see any better way to do this. Put the big 6 conference champions in. Make some conditions on how this is decided. It might be that the MWC deserves a spot instead of the Big East at some point. Give 2 at larges that lean heavy towards non-BCS conferences. If you aren't good enough to win your conference, you should be out of the discussion, period. The conference championships are decided based on an 8 or 9 game series, which means anyone eliminated from that was legitimately eliminated. Utah definitely deserves a chance to prove themselves. Although they likely will get beat, they deserve that shot since its impossible to know. I don't want to see the regular season diluted to something like the NBA or NHL where over half the teams get in.

BCS standings could still be used for seedings and determining the last 2 teams.
Conditions could fill in teams in the following order:
Auto qualification for best non-BCS team (has to be top 12 in BCS standings).
Any team in the top 4.
Any other conference champs in the top 12.
Down the BCS standings.

So we would have USC, Oklahoma, Penn St., Florida, Cincinnati, and Virginia Tech in automatically. Utah gets the first "wild card" bid. Texas gets the second one.

Seeds:
1) Florida
8) Virginia Tech

4) USC
5) Penn State

3) Texas
6) Utah

2) Oklahoma
7) Cincinnati

Conferences should decide how they decide their own championship and season structure. This will encourage much more teams to schedule quality non-conference games, since they won't count against you very much, as long as you win your conference. The regular season is still meaningful, and might even be more interesting. The playoffs will have a deserving champion, and pretty much everyone gets a fair shake. You might get a team like Ball State or Boise St. that gets left out, but they just need to schedule harder. Teams will be more likely to schedule them OOC since it won't hurt them, so they won't have that excuse anymore.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.