User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Judan
offline
Link
 
I don't think CB should be making tackles on ANY HB.

CB are are built for defending the pass. They don't make tackles 1 on 1 against quality backs, whether the back is elusive or power.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall

Seriously, at least 85-90% of the carrier's strength and the same for carrying. Why? Even a 190 lb. CB can tackle a 245+ lb RB. The variable is the 10 Power Through as not all backs will have it. So, is just the defensive players tackling ability alone or does their strength+tackling both come into play. It just depends on how the attributes add together to make a well-rounded player that will not only stop the run but have the agility to play the pass .

Actual numbers:
RB - 100 str + 70 carrying + 60 speed/agility + 10 SA + 15 VA = 255 points

So I would say 85-90% of 255 = 216-229 of which should be Strength, Tackling, Agility + any SA/VA .


so your LB has 20 speed?


No, I didn't take that into the equation, as a MLB wouldn't need the 'speed'as much, if he was plugging a hole.
 
swoosh22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.


That's kinda why I'm asking this, Larry. People complain about missing tackles, but missing 3-4 tackles in a game vs one of these guys when you have 30 strength and 40 tackling and aren't running full speed with your 90 spd/agility doesn't really seem that out of line to me, even with "wrap up" settings.

I mean, you don't want power backs to be the end-all build, but you want to make their skills worthwhile as well, so a tiny weak CB doesn't take him down every time.



Bort, shouldn't it be more missed tackles? These good cover corners I.E. Prime time, should not be able to make tackles vs runningbacks like Earl campbell, or 100 strength runningbacks 1v1. I dont remember the last time i saw a corner back make a tackle in the open field 1v1 vs All-day. It should never happen. These power backs are built to dominate freaking corners.

Power backs making it into the secondary should be able to dominate cornerbacks.



What are you smoking, CBs make tackles on power backs all the time, I will agree that they do get ran over more than in GLB.

But Adrian Peterson doesn't have the build that Bort posted. The build Bort posted has 50-60 speed/agility. I would say AP has about 90 speed 85+ agility
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Firenze

Probably 80+ Str...70+ Tackling...

Depends on the formula for tackling a player...which only you know


I'm kinda asking: if you were determine how the formula worked, what would you think goes into it?

Opinions vary widely and I want to see where they are.


If you look at football players in every level of the game, you find some trends.

Some of them are easy. You just do not see a WR that Benches 600. CB Bench 600? nope.

There are very real ranges set for every position in college, and NFL football, for every position.

There are things you just do not see, other than in extraordinary players, in football.

You do not see a DE who can Pass. Why? Because his physical ability is geared to another position.

If he was that good of a passer, even his 300lb frame would not matter.... Right?

The fact is that in every position of Football there is a desired skill set. Instead of having players and coaches guess what that skill set is in GLB (even if it does not conform to RL).

I will again put forth that the skill sets in the NFL are RELATIVE, and not absolute.

13 Cap team? Yah, I am going to max my speed so I am the fastest WR out there!!!!

Guess what, you put all your points into speed, you can't catch for shit.







 
WestbrookFTW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by swoosh22
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW

Originally posted by swoosh22


If we are going to have to make players have 70+ str and tackling that is going to give the offenses a huge advantage in this game which I already think they have.

How can a CB/SS/FS have that much in str and tackle when they need speed/agility/vision 70+ as well to cover WRs and not get faked by the QB.


For a CB, you are tackling for the most part WRs. You should have around 48 tackling and 35 strength to bring them down. That isn't that hard...

Now, if WRs stopped going SPEED SPEED SPEED AGILITY, and went carrying/strength, you could have the dominate, possession WRs that are tough to bring down.


This is just going to create a bunch of players in the secondary with a lot of 60's in stats. Which will give speed WRs a dominate advantage.


I still don't understand this dominate advantage...CBs aren't going to need 60 strength and tackling. Until WRs start getting carrying/strength to at least the softcap (OR MORE), CBs are going to continue to be able to tackle WRs with their minimal 30 tackling / 20 strength.

The problem is Power backs should be DOMINATING these CBs and going through them 90% of the time 1v1 (assuming they have 30/20).
 
stephenott
offline
Link
 
50 str/50 tkl should stop him 90% of the time imo set on wrap-up.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:13:49
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TuNice
Originally posted by iMan

IRL, the most important thing you need to make a good tackle is CONFIDENCE


that is actually true lol


thank you.
you ever see those guys that always go for you feet?
and then those monsters that jsut drop their pads and nail you to the ground?
the first one is scared of being hurt and the second one is about to hurt you
 
Knicksfan20
offline
Link
 
I think the HB'S speed and agility should also be a factor in breaking tackles





IF the HB/FB has low speed or agility...they shouldnt be able to break tackles as much....being pure strength shouldnt mean shit.



the faster you are moving...with your strength...the better you should be at breaking tackles.



a player with 80 speed and 80 strength should be harder to bring down then somone with 100 strength and 60 speed.


and agility play in the fact just for the acceleration....if you got a rb like Brandon Jacobs running full speed....and his size and strength...it is nearly impossible to stop him.


but if he doesnt get much of a chance to get going...it will be much easier to stop him.



So "momentum" should play a huge role in this...SO IMO to answer your question bort



50 strength and 60 tackling should be able to stop a big power back



once you start limiting players to HAVE TO LOAD str and tackle...and neglect speed/agility (opposite of what is going on now) then speed back will start to dominate and that will be the next problem.


a player with


60 str/60agility/60speed/60tackle should be like...the ultimate build in this game.(for a linebacker....differnt variables for this for like a linemen or safety...more str for line...more speed for safety)


JMO
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:15:04
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
except if we make a lb,cb, safety with 80-100 tackling or strength we'll get burnt by the fast wrs and passing game all day long.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Power Tackling
Pros:
Effective at stopping Powerbacks in their tracks.
Causes more fumbles.

Cons:
More likely to get faked out by elusive backs
More likely to miss tackles against elusive backs

Wrap-Up
Pros:
Effective against elusive backs
High tackle rate

Cons:
More likely to get plowed over by power backs, giving them an extra yard or two
More likely to miss tackles against power backs
 
swoosh22
offline
Link
 
So again I would say if you are going to make more of an emphasis on strength and tackling, which would give power backs a bigger advantage breaking tackles, then you would have to make 50-60 speed/agility very slow to allow for gang tackles.

Because in all honesty 50-60 speed/agility is very slow.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by TuNice

Originally posted by iMan


IRL, the most important thing you need to make a good tackle is CONFIDENCE


that is actually true lol


thank you.
you ever see those guys that always go for you feet?
and then those monsters that jsut drop their pads and nail you to the ground?
the first one is scared of being hurt and the second one is about to hurt you


if ur afraid of pain dont play football
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Hmm you can't have it like 80+ or even 70+ because there are very few players who actually has that(both tackling and strength that high), it should vary per position, I'd say 70 strength 60 tackling on DL, 60 strength 65 tackling at LB and 40 strength 40 tackling at CB, I also think you should put in gang tackling. And Bort a RB should never be able to run out of a 3+ man gang pile. That should never happen, also I think that those numbers(the DL, CB and LB strength + tackling) are needed for tackling a RB on a fairly consistent basis(not everytime), I also think if you do this you need to make vision MORE important to tackling ELUSIVE RBs since they can juke a defender out with lower vision.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Power Tackling
Pros:
Effective at stopping Powerbacks in their tracks.
Causes more fumbles.

Cons:
More likely to get faked out by elusive backs
More likely to miss tackles against elusive backs

Wrap-Up
Pros:
Effective against elusive backs
High tackle rate

Cons:
More likely to get plowed over by power backs, giving them an extra yard or two
More likely to miss tackles against power backs


By wraping up you will certainly bring a powerback down. you may be run over but you will bring him down.
trust me
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Power Tackling
Pros:
Effective at stopping Powerbacks in their tracks.
Causes more fumbles.

Cons:
More likely to get faked out by elusive backs
More likely to miss tackles against elusive backs
low tackling skill they can bounce right off

Wrap-Up
Pros:
Effective against elusive backs
High tackle rate

Cons:
More likely to get plowed over by power backs, giving them an extra yard or two
More likely to miss tackles against power backs


fyp
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.