User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Customer Support & Vet Abilities
Page:
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
My take, sorry for the length...

I have two players... just two. I don't have any aspirations of owning a team, I don't spend hours in the forums each day, and I don't have the time to learn every intricacy of the game. I don't know anything about "gaming" or "coding" -- this is the only online game I play other than fantasy sports -- and I could not tell you the first thing about how this game works. I depend almost exclusively on the game-provided FAQs to figure out how to play the game.

I believe I would be known as a casual player. I boost my two guys every season and I spend my $8 or so each season to do so. I recognize that I'm not single-handedly keeping the game afloat like some players with 20+ guys and a team ownership, but I would like to think that my $8 a month is just as important as their hundreds. I know a lot... A LOT... about real football, but not so much about GLB football.

So all that being said, I'm very disappointed in how the VA points and system was handled. Many of us have been criticized for spending our points too early... "You should've waited!" Let me tell you, as someone who has played since the end of Season 1, with almost no significant game changes as a veteran casual player - the VA system was like Christmas for a 5 year old. Don't tell me to exercise restraint when the whole reason Bort implemented the system was because it obviously had gotten way too boring for veteran players.

That being said, I'm not stupid, and I did not just assign the points blindly. I read each description, I waited until the next day until Fame points were distributed because I saw some abilities were dependent on fame. I did not just immediately assign everything. I read the FAQ that BORT PROVIDED... and that was it. As a casual player, the game should offer me what I need to know in order to have fun with the game. I should NOT have to dig through hundreds of posts in the forums searching for Bort's clarifications on topics and attempt to skip over the petty fights we all so often engage in. Nowhere in the game provided FAQ did it indicate that certain abilities would only be useful for defenders or offensive players. Several abilities indicated as much in their description. I ask... why not all? I'm not saying the game should be 100% transparent, as that wouldn't be fun, but a simple "This is for defense, this is for offense" would have done wonders. A LOT of people, myself included, were extremely confused between Sure Hands and Long Reach. As someone who knows a lot about football, both seem like they should be applicable to both defenders and receivers. You can't tell me otherwise. A LOT of people, myself included, were confused about "Special Teamer" - we assumed it would apply to anyone on the Kick Return Squad or the Kickoff Squad. As a football fan, how can you tell me that the kicker is not on the kickoff squad?

Which then led to one what I believe to be the worst handling of a customer service problem since I joined the game. Kick returners and kickers alike complained that Special Teamer should apply to their players. They used the exact same arguments. And in something I don't believe I had ever seen, Bort caved. Instead of standing pat on the resolution to keep the abilities the same, instead of saying "You should've waited until you knew what the abilities did"... he caved. He changed what the skill did... but only to half the players that were complaining. Kick returners now benefited from special abilities, but kickers did not. His explanation that "It was intended for guys who tackle and make blocks" made even less sense, as a kicker makes more tackles than a returner. He caved, and in doing so, exhibited EXTREMELY poor customer service towards a number of players. Normally, I'm against a redistribution of skill points and training points... but once Bort changes exactly what something does after it's initiated, people deserve to have a chance to fix it for their own players.

So finally... I'm not going to throw a tantrum and say "I'm taking my money and going home." I don't understand, because I don't understand how this game works, why we can't just have a redo of all the points before the season begins, because based on all the confusion, that seems like the fairest way to go. It wouldn't affect the season, and even the players that are proud of how they distributed their points would benefit, no matter what they say. Only one of my two players is really in bad shape now, and even then, my owner said to not sweat it. I love this game, so I'm going to stick with it. All I'm saying is this: The way the veteran abilities system was all handled did nothing to make me believe that the management at all cares about the casual players of this game, and that is an incredible disappointment. I can only hope that in the future, things are handled better.


i looked at long reach for my WR, then moved on to sure hands after i read it. and i used my points right away. i understood it fine
 
thakh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rot
Originally posted by PinTBC


Fair enough, which ones do you believe are poorly worded, I actually had no problems with any of them.

Apologizes for quoting myself:
Originally posted by Rot


In addition to that, the following VAs require some clarification:
Clutch: does it work for punters and kickers, who always do their jobs on 3rd or 4th down? What exactly is modified by this VA?
Long Reach: is this for WRs getting another chance to catch a pass that was deflected, or is this for CBs getting another chance to deflect a pass they failed to deflect in the first place? Or would it work for both?
Sure Hands: does this only work when trying to catch normal passes (HBs and WRs)? or could this apply to CBs trying to get: another shot at catching an interception, catching a pass which was just deflected, or both?
Slow Starter: are these the last four games of the regular season, does this cover the playoffs, or does this cover both?
Zone Specialist: does this work if your player is actively in zone coverage (that is to say, if he has picked up a man, does the bonus go away)? or would this work for anyone on the defense if the type of play selected is zone?


The tool tips on some of these have been updated
Clutch---kicking and punting specifically mentioned.
Long Reach--works only on defense
Sure Hands--works only on offense
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thakh
Originally posted by Rot

Originally posted by PinTBC



Fair enough, which ones do you believe are poorly worded, I actually had no problems with any of them.

Apologizes for quoting myself:
Originally posted by Rot



In addition to that, the following VAs require some clarification:
Clutch: does it work for punters and kickers, who always do their jobs on 3rd or 4th down? What exactly is modified by this VA?
Long Reach: is this for WRs getting another chance to catch a pass that was deflected, or is this for CBs getting another chance to deflect a pass they failed to deflect in the first place? Or would it work for both?
Sure Hands: does this only work when trying to catch normal passes (HBs and WRs)? or could this apply to CBs trying to get: another shot at catching an interception, catching a pass which was just deflected, or both?
Slow Starter: are these the last four games of the regular season, does this cover the playoffs, or does this cover both?
Zone Specialist: does this work if your player is actively in zone coverage (that is to say, if he has picked up a man, does the bonus go away)? or would this work for anyone on the defense if the type of play selected is zone?


The tool tips on some of these have been updated
Clutch---kicking and punting specifically mentioned.
Long Reach--works only on defense
Sure Hands--works only on offense


... they've been updated after the fact. This is Bort basically conceding that the first wordings were potentially confusing to many of the players of this game.
 
thakh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by splitter24
I'm more annoyed with the Vet Abilities that were changed completely over the last few days. For instance, Mr. Reliable went from decreasing your fumble chance period to decreasing your fumble chance in the 3rd and 4th quarters only.

Or my personal favorite, Special Teamer. This one went from giving you a stamina increase when playing special teams, to increasing ALL of your abilities when playing on special teams. This one is a big deal for me because I have a player who only returns kicks and punts. That's all he does. We're talking up to a 15% difference in all of his ratings. So I didn't bother putting anything into this category. It would've only been helpful for my guy if I wanted to pad my stats against bad teams. Now it's the most important category for him.

I didn't misread the Vet Abilities. They were just completely changed. I'm upset and feel a little ripped off, to be honest.


Mr. Reliable was changed from "Hold onto the ball! Each level of Mr. Reliable gives a +4% bonus to avoiding fumbles and a +1% bonus to catching passes on 3rd and 4th down" to "Hold onto the ball! On 3rd and 4th down, each level of Mr. Reliable gives a +4% bonus to avoiding fumbles and a +1% bonus to catching passes ". This effect of the VA did not change, just reworded to avoid confusion. Original tool tip was misleading. It could be read that you always get bonus to avoid fumbles but bonus to catching only on 3rd-4th downs.

[Special Teamer was changed from "Special teams is 1/3 of the game. Each level of Special Teamer gives a +1% bonus to all attributes when playing on KOS or KRS" to "Special teams is 1/3 of the game. Each level of Special Teamer gives a +1% bonus to all attributes when playing on KOS, KRS, KR, or PR but not K/P." Only change is clarify who gets bonus. It was never +% stamina only.

GLBWiki has not been updated since last week and still contain original descriptions of VAs.
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Veteran_abilities
 
splitter24
Bacon
offline
Link
 
I know that now. But it doesn't change at all the fact that he clearly stated it doesn't apply to KR's and PR's, and then he changed it a couple of days later after people started asking for it. Did he not know that people who had KR/PR's that had already started spending points purposely avoided this VA because it was useless to them? Couldn't he have waited until next season to either include KR/PR as part of the VA, or create something different just for return guys? If he had left it alone, everyone would have been on the same playing field.

Now this VA is the absolute most important one to put your points in if you're a returner. And, needless to say, my two return guys have no points there.
 
Sain621
offline
Link
 
I know Bort is trying hard, and I feel bad at all the attacks on him even though he's giving us new material, but he handled this VAs the wrong way. They were released with confusing descriptions, and after the fact people started applying points, they're reworded to make things clearer. I just don't get it.
 
Vindictus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DarkVirtue
Originally posted by wooderson

Originally posted by Bort


It's not possible for the support guys to update your stats or abilities in any way. They don't have access or an interface to do it. That means they would have to forward on every single "oops I misread the thing" request to me, and I'd have to manually update it in the database.


So why not just remove the special abilities globally and then redistribute the points? That would be a great holiday present based on how many of us misinterpreted what the VAs are to be.


+1


+1
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
I also agree that the explanations could be better. I keep reading x% chance to get x% bonus to this attribute or it doesn't even list an attribute which is sometimes confusing. I think this combination of using percentages a couple times for different reasons is the main reason I am confused, and the wording in some could be much better. Who says it all has to fit in one sentence?
 
wooderson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vindictus
Originally posted by DarkVirtue

Originally posted by wooderson


Originally posted by Bort



It's not possible for the support guys to update your stats or abilities in any way. They don't have access or an interface to do it. That means they would have to forward on every single "oops I misread the thing" request to me, and I'd have to manually update it in the database.


So why not just remove the special abilities globally and then redistribute the points? That would be a great holiday present based on how many of us misinterpreted what the VAs are to be.


+1


+1


+1 you +1'ing me being +1'd
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wooderson
Originally posted by Bort
It's not possible for the support guys to update your stats or abilities in any way. They don't have access or an interface to do it. That means they would have to forward on every single "oops I misread the thing" request to me, and I'd have to manually update it in the database.

So why not just remove the special abilities globally and then redistribute the points? That would be a great holiday present based on how many of us misinterpreted what the VAs are to be.


this is such an obvious solution... and i wish it had been the plan from the get-go (i.e. let us see the VAs in action during the preseason, give some feedback, etc).

for the record, i misapplied some VP... not because i didn't do research, but because i thought the interface would be similar to the SP interface i used a gazillion times. where's the submit button? stupid me for expecting UI/design consistency...
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sain621
+2

I didn't make any big mistakes on my VAs, cause for the most part, I waited a few days before making any decisions, but if I put $100+ into this game, into my players, and had 1 fucked up because of an unclear VA, I'd be pissed. That what all these people like PinTBC don't get.


Sorry, I do "get it"

I understand that no one is willing to take responsibility for their own actions anymore. Not a single person was forced to press the buttons and make their selections if they believed the wording was misleading. They chose to perform the action, then came crying to try to force someone else to spend time, effort, and money to make everything better for them.

Hell it has become a national crisis. I was intelligent/lucky enough to actually buy a house that I could afford, even when the banks were willing to loan me a hell of a lot more money than I borrowed. My house is now paid for, and I'm being asked to use my tax money to help someone who bought a house they couldn't afford, a house probably much bigger than mine.

Everyone is looking for someone to make their stupid decisions go away, so they can get another shot at it, whether an internet game, or GMAC.

I have no problems with people asking for things they think would improve the game or help beta test the game better. I actually believe that the Beta test would be significantly faster if there was a way to completely redo a player of any level. It is the only way to check and see how SIM changes affect very high level builds.

What I don't want to see happen is progress straightening the Sim out, slowed or stopped while Bort has to go back and either hand reset, or develop new software to reset those people who simply couldn't read, or were too lazy to find out what they were doing.

PinTBC
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC


Sorry, I do "get it"

I understand that no one is willing to take responsibility for their own actions anymore. Not a single person was forced to press the buttons and make their selections if they believed the wording was misleading. They chose to perform the action, then came crying to try to force someone else to spend time, effort, and money to make everything better for them.


Yes, it should've been obvious to everyone that when Special Teamer said "when playing on KOS or KRS" and when Bort then said that Special Teamer doesn't apply to PR/KR, what Bort really meant was "it does apply to PR/KR."
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps

Yes, it should've been obvious to everyone that when Special Teamer said "when playing on KOS or KRS" and when Bort then said that Special Teamer doesn't apply to PR/KR, what Bort really meant was "it does apply to PR/KR."


And that was a case where Bort caved in to people complaining. His original intent as he stated was that he wanted to give a boost to the blockers or the cover men in the Kick squads. He was met with a slew of people that wanted to gain an advantage for their kick returner, also. In my opinion he was crazy to change it, and if he is now letting kick returners gain the benefit of that ability, then I expect he is going to have to take a very close look at its effects in games. A good returner really didn't need much help as it stood.

So, yes, that one changed.

As did the effects of speed and agility, blocking and strength, and a variety of other modifications the game has gone through as he attempts to finish it. Picking this singular, insignificant issue out to whine about respeccs is simply silly.

PinTBC
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Insignificant because it blows up the advice of "wait for clarification if you are unsure"? I mean, you have a case where someone asks about a VA. He then gets explicit, unambiguous information from Bort that the VA doesn't do A. He logs in a day later to learn that the VA now does A.

So how are we supposed to "get clarification"? Obviously going off what Bort explicitly says will only get you a "tough shit" when that turns out to be different a day later.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 14:16:27
 
splitter24
Bacon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by methomps


Yes, it should've been obvious to everyone that when Special Teamer said "when playing on KOS or KRS" and when Bort then said that Special Teamer doesn't apply to PR/KR, what Bort really meant was "it does apply to PR/KR."


And that was a case where Bort caved in to people complaining. His original intent as he stated was that he wanted to give a boost to the blockers or the cover men in the Kick squads. He was met with a slew of people that wanted to gain an advantage for their kick returner, also. In my opinion he was crazy to change it, and if he is now letting kick returners gain the benefit of that ability, then I expect he is going to have to take a very close look at its effects in games. A good returner really didn't need much help as it stood.

So, yes, that one changed.

As did the effects of speed and agility, blocking and strength, and a variety of other modifications the game has gone through as he attempts to finish it. Picking this singular, insignificant issue out to whine about respeccs is simply silly.

PinTBC


Insignificant to someone who doesn't have any dedicated return specialists. I have two of them. I'll "whine" if I want to. As a paying customer, I've earned the right to be upset.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.