User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
pedro617
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
Originally posted by TxSteve

Originally posted by Intimnasc


One idea that has come up in the past and I personnaly like is allow teams that promote to boost to the median level of the league. This way they are not thrown immediately into a league where they are giving up 3-6 levels. Being more competitive will keep more people interested.



The problem there is - I sign with a team about to be promoted to a non cap league; from a cap league - just to take advantage of the extra boosts...and then i get released; or traded; or whatever so i can go to the league of my choice...can be easily exploited (even though i like the concept)


While I agree with you there is little about the game in general that someone doesn't exploit. I see what your saying and the only thing I could say is that for each 3 extra boosts a player gets they lose 1 season on their lifetime.

For instance if player boosts normal 3 boosts then boosts 4 levels to median level of league player loses 1.3 seasons on this toon but gets to remain on the team with his friends.


edit::: I say this because there has to be some reward for promoting. In many cases promoting is a death sentence for teams of friends that wanna be competitive. No one wants to go into a league where you give up 3-6 levels in talent points to half the league. Nor do we want to cut our friends and the people that got us there.


I posted this idea in another thread last night and it didn't get many + positive comments. I do think that it would be the best way for those teams to stay competitive, and I really like the idea of them losing seasons for the extra boost. It weil definitily keep things fair for all.


Originally posted by REDAZZ
Originally posted by RAPB

3 ideas:

VETO-vote / MOVE DOWN - request

A team flagged as moving up can veto to stay in their current league. The next team up the list will have the chance to move up. This prevents teams moving up too fast and loosing fun / have to make major roster moves.

A team not competetive in their current league (let's say 4-12-0 or worse) can move down a league. This prevents teams struggling for season after season.

Build-Up-League

Newly released teams are in a Build Up league for like 1 - 3 seasons. This league is a giant pyramid and serves the purposes of establishing the team and finding those new teams the proper spots in the existing leagues.

During the regular season, any team going CPU will instantly give a choice to the top team in the Build Up leage to jump in. The team doesn't have to, but can take over this spot. If it does, all remaining games of the replaced team will be counted 50-0 (so the established teams are not screwed up) and all remaining games are counted as scrimmages for the team jumping in. If the new team manages to end the scrimmages above an 0.333 average, they can choose to stay in the league. Otherwise they drop back to the Build Up league and instantly get back their top spot.

(So this is kind of "try out" for the team jumping in and provides the teams in the existing leagues a closer, competetive game than just playing a CPU team.)

At season end, the promotion out of a regular league (below AAA) works this way:

1. Winners move up
2. If additional spots need to be filled, the teams that won at least 2 playoff games are flagged (but can veto - see above)
3. If that doesn't fill all spots, the top 3 teams in Build-Up leage can "jump in"
4. If that doesn't fill all spots, ... (just like right now, but the teams can veto)

Naturally, there are quite a few spots to fill in the lowest leagues (single A or BBB, depending on region). So these leagues are filled (top to bottom) with teams out of the Build-Up - League.

This way, the teams moving into a established league are the best new teams and should be able to play competetive. On the other hand, no team owner is thrown into an established leage of average lv. 24s and has to build up from scratch.

Of course, the Build-Up league will naturally grow (more guys requesting new teams than owners selling back). So when the Build-Up league exceeds like 500 teams, Bort can expand an existing league and fill it with "The Best of Build Up" - which makes this league higly competetive and promotions no problem.


"forced" demotion

Any team doing 2-14 or worse will have to go down a league, even if another team is even worse. Any team doing 2-14 or worse in the lowest leage of their region is dropping out into the Build-Up league.

This will adress league parity, for highly incompetetive teams will move out faster - this creating spots for competetive teams to get promoted.


MAJOR +1 !!!!



I love this idea. I'm not to sure about the whole veto thing though. What would happen if there are not enough teams to fill the higher leagues because to many people vetoed it?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm


A team owner has 40 days to decide if he/she wants to renew his/her team. If you forgot then that is on you get back on the waiting list and grab another team. If it is impossible to be demoted down to the bottom tier because(your team is not competitive and) of the hassle involved. How is taking care of procrastinating owners less of a hassle.

Besides the game makes four dollars for every late renewal vice making the owner get back on the waiting list and making ten dollars.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by REDAZZ
Originally posted by RAPB

3 ideas:

VETO-vote / MOVE DOWN - request

A team flagged as moving up can veto to stay in their current league. The next team up the list will have the chance to move up. This prevents teams moving up too fast and loosing fun / have to make major roster moves.

A team not competetive in their current league (let's say 4-12-0 or worse) can move down a league. This prevents teams struggling for season after season.

Build-Up-League

Newly released teams are in a Build Up league for like 1 - 3 seasons. This league is a giant pyramid and serves the purposes of establishing the team and finding those new teams the proper spots in the existing leagues.

During the regular season, any team going CPU will instantly give a choice to the top team in the Build Up leage to jump in. The team doesn't have to, but can take over this spot. If it does, all remaining games of the replaced team will be counted 50-0 (so the established teams are not screwed up) and all remaining games are counted as scrimmages for the team jumping in. If the new team manages to end the scrimmages above an 0.333 average, they can choose to stay in the league. Otherwise they drop back to the Build Up league and instantly get back their top spot.

(So this is kind of "try out" for the team jumping in and provides the teams in the existing leagues a closer, competetive game than just playing a CPU team.)

At season end, the promotion out of a regular league (below AAA) works this way:

1. Winners move up
2. If additional spots need to be filled, the teams that won at least 2 playoff games are flagged (but can veto - see above)
3. If that doesn't fill all spots, the top 3 teams in Build-Up leage can "jump in"
4. If that doesn't fill all spots, ... (just like right now, but the teams can veto)

Naturally, there are quite a few spots to fill in the lowest leagues (single A or BBB, depending on region). So these leagues are filled (top to bottom) with teams out of the Build-Up - League.

This way, the teams moving into a established league are the best new teams and should be able to play competetive. On the other hand, no team owner is thrown into an established leage of average lv. 24s and has to build up from scratch.

Of course, the Build-Up league will naturally grow (more guys requesting new teams than owners selling back). So when the Build-Up league exceeds like 500 teams, Bort can expand an existing league and fill it with "The Best of Build Up" - which makes this league higly competetive and promotions no problem.


"forced" demotion

Any team doing 2-14 or worse will have to go down a league, even if another team is even worse. Any team doing 2-14 or worse in the lowest leage of their region is dropping out into the Build-Up league.

This will adress league parity, for highly incompetetive teams will move out faster - this creating spots for competetive teams to get promoted.


MAJOR +1 !!!!


Some good ideas in the suggestion, except for allowing teams to veto a move up. That won't work. Don't allow teams any input on demotion/promotion or you are basically back to team swap time and that was proven to be a disaster.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Hey, speaking of which, what happened to that massive restructuring that was going to happen last offseason?

...we don't have uncapped teams being demoted into capped leagues, do we?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
I too have no sympathy for the I forgot, because since you can renew at any time and you have had notification, then if you miss it, your not an active enough owner in the first place.


You have no sympathy until you're the one in the situation.

Some people go on vacation for a while and don't get back in time, etc. Even with notice, several people missed it last season.

This season I did put a "your team is expiring soon" warning on the team page, which I'm sure helped, but there's always going to be that one doofus who waited one day too long because he didn't get paid or just plum forgot.
 
SharpyDave
offline
Link
 
It's too easy for guys to give up on a team rather than stay and build it back up. Any owner that has his team go CPU should not be able to buy a team for at least 3 seasons.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Raiders12

I too have no sympathy for the I forgot, because since you can renew at any time and you have had notification, then if you miss it, your not an active enough owner in the first place.


You have no sympathy until you're the one in the situation.

Some people go on vacation for a while and don't get back in time, etc. Even with notice, several people missed it last season.

This season I did put a "your team is expiring soon" warning on the team page, which I'm sure helped, but there's always going to be that one doofus who waited one day too long because he didn't get paid or just plum forgot.


40 days Is a long time. I have 4 seasons until my team expires and If I procrastinate that long before its time it is my own fault no one elses. Maybe GLB should put a final season tag on the owners homepage instead of a expiring soon. That way they really have no excuse. If they log on 1 time during the season they will know. Or a renewal deadline of day 35. Waiverable if the player contacts support prior to the deadline.
Last edited Dec 19, 2008 19:22:31
 
Dvolution
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mike2686
The only answer to solve all of these problems in a complete league shakeup. Since the offseason should be longer anyways. I'd Leave the top teams in their respective leagues.

But for the most part alot of teams need to be added and dropped for every league and rearranged. That way the league will be as competetive as they are supposed to be atleast level and talent wise. All CPU Teams GLB wide should be sent to an entire new league such as A new BBB league, reset and handed out first. Move teams up accordingly, rearrange them as stated before.

I truly think this is the only way to fix the current problem. The slowbuilds should also be moved.

It would look something like this:

USA PRO- Same concept
USA AAA- Same concept
USA AA- Same concept
USA A- Uncapped But also rearange it so that the teams are equal.
USA BBB- Level 24 Cap (Rearange all the teams to where this wont screw anyone over and put every team with players 18-21 avg in these leagues,)
USA BB- level 13 Cap (New teams, slowbuilds, and Ex CPU teams)

I think this is the only way, but its very complicated and would take a while to complete. At this point I'm not sure much else can be done. We do have some very intellegent people on here though who will probably come up with something easier and better. This is just my thought.


This is one of the best concept yet proposed, with a league level always capped at level 13, every resetted team would get a fair chance at doing well. The promotion of teams wouldn,t be as painful as it is at this time. it'd still be tough to come out of a 13th capped league to a lvl 24 capped league, but not as tough as going straight to an uncapped league.
Last edited Dec 19, 2008 19:26:33
 
Mediocre Turd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
but there's always going to be that one doofus who waited one day too long because he didn't get paid or just plum forgot.


95/5 rule applies here, do what works for 95% of the teams impacted, for the other 5% gotta handle them as one-offs.

Maybe move everyone down on day 41 and wait until day 43 to promote. That way if the team comes back (oops I forgot) they can go back up. But nothing says you won't get a doofus on Day 44 who says oops, I just got back. For them, their team has likely abondoned them (it's been 3 days) and they need to move down anyway.

 
Dvolution
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mediocre Turd
Originally posted by Bort

but there's always going to be that one doofus who waited one day too long because he didn't get paid or just plum forgot.


95/5 rule applies here, do what works for 95% of the teams impacted, for the other 5% gotta handle them as one-offs.

Maybe move everyone down on day 41 and wait until day 43 to promote. That way if the team comes back (oops I forgot) they can go back up. But nothing says you won't get a doofus on Day 44 who says oops, I just got back. For them, their team has likely abondoned them (it's been 3 days) and they need to move down anyway.



+1
 
PrizzlePulse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
would it be possible to create a game wide restructuring - utilizing the tech already in place for the waiting list for buying teams?


it would have to be fleshed out just a little (i've never seen it since i've owned a team since before it existed)

people would choose either:

- i don't want my team moved
- move me to a capped league (and wipe roster/stadium)
- move me to a different part of the world into a 'level appropriate' division with the following priorities (and force them to rank ALL zones)
* 1st choice - South America
* 2nd choice - Canada
* 3rd choice - USA
* 4th choice - Africa
etc
etc
etc

You would need to find a way to incorporate 'seniority' into it - so that a team that is already in South America gets to stay in south america before a team that's never been in south america can get moved there...(hope that makes sense) - so; if you are currently in South America; and want to stay in South America - you will - UNLESS you have chosen that you want to become a capped team and there aren't any in South America (i'm not sure)

Also - seniority would play in the restructure as well - pretend that everyone want to be moved to South America - obviously everyone can't go there - so that list of people would have to be sorted - First by team owner seniority - if you've owned a team for 6 seasons; you get moved there ahead of someone who's owned a team 5 seasons. As a secondary sort - maybe you give priority to teams who've recently won a league championship; then a conference championship; then record from this past season (or just use your current promotion script for this 2nd step)

Then you would have a massive re-shuffle - just like the old days when teams were handed out...this would include reshuffling divisions to some degree - but only in extreme cases:
- all CPU teams; or teams who are significantly outlevelled AND finished in the bottom half of the conference get moved down

There would be some black and white rules - if your team made the playoffs - you can NOT be moved down - but could be moved up. To sort out who moves up - you would probably use the system you've already got in place.


Beyond the fact that this might be impossible to program - or might take too long to program; so couldn't be a solution for this offseason - what are the problems with it?

edit: added what happens to high demand areas


Really like this idea, +1
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PrizzLeTaSTiC
Originally posted by TxSteve

would it be possible to create a game wide restructuring - utilizing the tech already in place for the waiting list for buying teams?


it would have to be fleshed out just a little (i've never seen it since i've owned a team since before it existed)

people would choose either:

- i don't want my team moved
- move me to a capped league (and wipe roster/stadium)
- move me to a different part of the world into a 'level appropriate' division with the following priorities (and force them to rank ALL zones)
* 1st choice - South America
* 2nd choice - Canada
* 3rd choice - USA
* 4th choice - Africa
etc
etc
etc

You would need to find a way to incorporate 'seniority' into it - so that a team that is already in South America gets to stay in south america before a team that's never been in south america can get moved there...(hope that makes sense) - so; if you are currently in South America; and want to stay in South America - you will - UNLESS you have chosen that you want to become a capped team and there aren't any in South America (i'm not sure)

Also - seniority would play in the restructure as well - pretend that everyone want to be moved to South America - obviously everyone can't go there - so that list of people would have to be sorted - First by team owner seniority - if you've owned a team for 6 seasons; you get moved there ahead of someone who's owned a team 5 seasons. As a secondary sort - maybe you give priority to teams who've recently won a league championship; then a conference championship; then record from this past season (or just use your current promotion script for this 2nd step)

Then you would have a massive re-shuffle - just like the old days when teams were handed out...this would include reshuffling divisions to some degree - but only in extreme cases:
- all CPU teams; or teams who are significantly outlevelled AND finished in the bottom half of the conference get moved down

There would be some black and white rules - if your team made the playoffs - you can NOT be moved down - but could be moved up. To sort out who moves up - you would probably use the system you've already got in place.


Beyond the fact that this might be impossible to program - or might take too long to program; so couldn't be a solution for this offseason - what are the problems with it?

edit: added what happens to high demand areas


Really like this idea, +1


Same. I do like how the areas are split off and have their own reputation and personality but I would rather have competitive leagues. My team is in the WE region and we'll be a cap 21 team next season. All I care about is 31 other teams being cap 21 in my league and competitive. Anything else I can live with.
 
sickie8305
offline
Link
 
I like the Idea Of moving up but when you move up your about to make the team moving up have to reorganize there roster to compete with the Higher LV teams, just part of the game, there is a way to fix things to make it much more competitive for all teams, just like in real life football having a salary cap there could be a LV cap imposed for each league, explaining - adding up all your players LV's totaling up to X amount like when you have 45 LV 38 players = 1710 Or 1800 LV cap once you get to that amount you cant get anymore players or if you above this you take a Chemistry hit. It could make every division equal and no unfair advantages...I also think the only teams that move up are both the East And West Champions, I hate the player swaping and teams begging to move down to win in a lesser league, there will always be scum like that trying to get the unfair advantage....Thanks Bort
Last edited Dec 20, 2008 01:36:44
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Here is my question -- Is the actual root of the problem the fact that there are too few level 32+ Players? It would be interesting to see information regarding the number of Active Players who are level 32+ for each Position, relative to the number of uncapped teams there are.

Of course the number of higher level Players is increasing, but there is no way it is increasing as fast as the number of Roster slots opening up. Each time that a Player goes inactive, that'll open up a slot. Each time that a Player retires - that opens a slot. Each time an Agent decides to quit boosting their Player, that will effectively open a slot in the uncapped leagues at some point.

I ask this because the reason behind the relegation/delegation in the first place, is to create more competition in the game. If the number of Players, which are sufficiently leveled to create competitive teams, is lacking - then it will be very difficult to ever get real competitive leagues because there won't be enough competitive Players to fill the roster slots.

If the above is true - Then there is really only 1 answer that is even slightly palatable: increase the number of competitive Players. Best way to do this is give access to hiring useful CPU Players to teams. I'm not talking about CPUs so good that a team with 50% CPUs will march to first Place. I'm talking CPUs which perform atleast on par with bad players at equal levels. And make it where teams can bring in CPUs (and pay their wages) easily and for the right positions.

Having active, well-built Human Players should absolutely be 100% the best option.. but Owners shouldn't be stomped on just because their Roster had 3-4 holes in it which were filled by random crappy out of position CPUs that couldn't compete in a D-League. Fix this issue and the question in the OP goes away because then it isn't nearly as imperative for teams to do a mad rush for recruiting the limited number of Human Players available.
 
Crunked
offline
Link
 
Divisions within the conferences would help all of this long term. 4 divisions North, South, East, West (ala the NFL) would fine tune the whole parity process and give GLB more administrative wiggle room for moving people up and down. Freezes or not. I am in a league right now where the top 8 teams are averaging level 40+ while the rest are CPU's, newly or recently gutted. Not a very competetive set up honestly. It still wouldn't be 100% the way I suggest but it would be about 85% correct which goes a long way to making it right for all.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.