User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Players adapting to overused plays
Page:
 
neoliminal
offline
Link
 
This should be a player tactic, plan and simple. Like the "creative on pass routes".

Anticipate Play
"Never" - Play your position like your coach told you to.
"Sometimes" - Cheat a bit to where the play will go if you recognize it.
"Always" - Run for where the ball is going.

Gives bonus vision and agility on plays repeatedly run from the same formation. --- Gives a negative to vision and agility if the play is different than the expected one. Builds up over time, with the bonus being higher for over run plays, and the negative being higher when the play is different.
Last edited Jan 29, 2009 15:33:11
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
EPIC
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
I warned you about this Bort...and look what happened...
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
So you necro-bump this thread 40 minutes after posting in the epic forum thread?

Edit: @wlarson
Last edited Mar 21, 2009 19:42:18
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
So you necro-bump this thread 40 minutes after posting in the epic forum thread?

Edit: @wlarson


Mine came first...
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Bort posted in the epic thread.

Originally posted by Bort
I am testing out this idea right now, though I don't know how well it'll really work as far as stopping an overpowered play. A recognition boost still won't help you break blocks or make tackles. It will just get you to the block or missed tackle quicker.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2282847&page=last#19630048
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

I'm all for it ... as long as you give a minus to vision whenever the offense uses the same formation but a different Play. Say I run HB Slam 3x in a row and your guys would get a +1 to vision if I run it the next snap... shouldn't you guys get a -1 to vision if I use the same formation but call a different play?

If you anticipate something, and are right - great! But if you anticipate something, and you are wrong.. consider that as well.


This point is where I can see a major problem coming in. Teams will run 1 play several times in a row even if it isn't working, just so they can get the defense to key in on that play and then run a HR play. IRL if you are stopping a play fine without anticipating it you aren't going to change anything, and will continue to play "straight up." This would need to be reflected in the game.

And I think this would all end up actually working against the intended purpose. You can't have teams start to key in on certain plays after they have run it a few times successfully. Because IRL, and in the game if you added this as well, once you get a team focused on stopping a certain play you probably have them beat, because they become defenseless against similar misdirection plays. What you have to do is find a way to make it so you can't run the same play back to back very well. Even if the defense isn't focusing on it, once they have seen it, its hard to do the exact same thing again right away.

How many times in the NFL do you see the team run the same play twice in one possession? Not very often. Usually when you do it is when a team is playing power football on short yardage and just saying they don't care if everyone knows whats coming, they are going to outpower you anyway. And occasionally when teams do that for big yardage, it does open up the play action and the defense will get burned on that (I'm thinking of a few Giants games). But that doesn't happen very often at all (not because of the exact same play anyway).

I really don't think I got my point across very well at all, but basically I'm trying to say this will end up being exploited and might end up being worse than the original problem.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Hell,

Depending on the purpose to adding this to the game, you may not need the negative aspect that people are arguing for. If the game intent is to make it more attractive for teams to run a variety of plays, then just adding to the ability to recognize a play run more than a certain percentage of time should be a good thing to add to defenses.

Alternatively, you could just fix some of the other offensive play blocking and maybe people would actually run them?

PinTBC
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
It really isn't a problem recognizing the play and getting to it, it's stopping it. When power backs are routinely getting 2-3 YAC it doesn't much matter if they recognize it. To be effective, since Bort has shown absolutely no interest whatsoever in lower the effectiveness of strong I power back plays, they would probably need bonuses to tackling too.. but I don't think tackling is stopping the extra yards SA and VAs, and that's the main problem right now.

Get a 100 str, 70 speed, 70 agility back, run a rush play 3-4 times and that's the sim right about now. I know the people doing this hate to see people "QQing" about it, but do you really want an unstoppable aspect of the game right now if it doesn't benefit you? Of course not, so they need to not be hypocritical about it.

100 strength 100 tackle guys still aren't going to stop the 2-3 YAC these guys get, so it's not even about builds.. unless someone suggests that you just be 5-10 levels better than your opponent or shut up.
 
Baloney Pony
offline
Link
 
I just had a team run the strong I inside 71 times against me last game just to prove how bad the sim is... man we need to get this overuse of plays fixed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wlarson
EPIC


Yep...it is.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.