our QB did horribly like a 20% competeion rate and hes a lvl 10 i believe I like to side with Bort usually as well but not this time come on 6 pages of bitching you gotta change it back to the way it was it was just fine that way man.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
UK_Giant_Steve
offline
offline
But to do this now essentially hands the leagues to teams who chose to be run heavy, whilst punishing teams who set-up to pass, so now any passing team is suddenly going to drop off in effectiveness...
rj414
offline
offline
Bort,
Even a very bad QB won't throw for less than 50% of his passes every week. 50% is considered a mediocre completion percentage at any level. If you have level 9+ QBs ALL OVER YOUR LEAGUES throwing for 30% completion, then that is a VERY BIG PROBLEM. A level 5 QB throwing for 50% would be entirely reasonable to me - and 80% is just good gameplanning in a quarterback friendly system. I really think I am not alone in saying that the longevity of your game seriously depends on you returning pass quality to where it was. This game is simply not worth playing if above average QBs cannot throw 65% completion percentages.
Your sim as you had it was excellent. The only improvements you could have made were ADDITIONS, things like play selection on down and distance, the energy improvements you made, the chemistry stuff. The actual sim was at a perfect balance before you made these changes last night.
Even a very bad QB won't throw for less than 50% of his passes every week. 50% is considered a mediocre completion percentage at any level. If you have level 9+ QBs ALL OVER YOUR LEAGUES throwing for 30% completion, then that is a VERY BIG PROBLEM. A level 5 QB throwing for 50% would be entirely reasonable to me - and 80% is just good gameplanning in a quarterback friendly system. I really think I am not alone in saying that the longevity of your game seriously depends on you returning pass quality to where it was. This game is simply not worth playing if above average QBs cannot throw 65% completion percentages.
Your sim as you had it was excellent. The only improvements you could have made were ADDITIONS, things like play selection on down and distance, the energy improvements you made, the chemistry stuff. The actual sim was at a perfect balance before you made these changes last night.
nfratami
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.
I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.
A Lvl 5 should be able to have 80% completion if he is playing against equal LVL opponents, a high school football player isn't going to throw for 25% simply because he isn't as good as Peyton Manning, a high school player has the potential to have a great game because he is playing people at the same level as his.
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.
I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.
A Lvl 5 should be able to have 80% completion if he is playing against equal LVL opponents, a high school football player isn't going to throw for 25% simply because he isn't as good as Peyton Manning, a high school player has the potential to have a great game because he is playing people at the same level as his.
sunder B
offline
offline
Originally posted by UK_Giant_Steve
But to do this now essentially hands the leagues to teams who chose to be run heavy, whilst punishing teams who set-up to pass, so now any passing team is suddenly going to drop off in effectiveness...
That was the other problem today. I am run heavy team and had it set to run 60%, but instead, we threw 60% (and for a 20% completion rate). Auto adjust was only on 10% and were were ahead or tied the whole way until we went for it on 4th down on our own 20 in OT.
But to do this now essentially hands the leagues to teams who chose to be run heavy, whilst punishing teams who set-up to pass, so now any passing team is suddenly going to drop off in effectiveness...
That was the other problem today. I am run heavy team and had it set to run 60%, but instead, we threw 60% (and for a 20% completion rate). Auto adjust was only on 10% and were were ahead or tied the whole way until we went for it on 4th down on our own 20 in OT.

Last edited May 2, 2008 15:54:55
rj414
offline
offline
Guys, please make a comment on this thread :
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=157049
so that bort sees what will probably be OVERWHELMING DEMAND to have pass quality returned to normal.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=157049
so that bort sees what will probably be OVERWHELMING DEMAND to have pass quality returned to normal.
I think you're all overestimating the change I made to pass quality. The change in the code for that was literally:
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.
Boble
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I think you're all overestimating the change I made to pass quality. The change in the code for that was literally:
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.
Then something has gone majorly wrong, sorry, but with numbers like in those games I saw today I consider the game unfair, there is no use in playin with stats like this, if now it seems like stamina becomes a factor, where a 2 deep team can't get it's players into a serious contending energy plateau, the way might be .... out of here....
I think you're all overestimating the change I made to pass quality. The change in the code for that was literally:
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.
Then something has gone majorly wrong, sorry, but with numbers like in those games I saw today I consider the game unfair, there is no use in playin with stats like this, if now it seems like stamina becomes a factor, where a 2 deep team can't get it's players into a serious contending energy plateau, the way might be .... out of here....
Rossmc
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=13268
My QB who was the leading QB in the league with about 70 % had a terrible game, not as bad as the other teams though.
My QB who was the leading QB in the league with about 70 % had a terrible game, not as bad as the other teams though.
Zeke0123
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I think you're all overestimating the change I made to pass quality. The change in the code for that was literally:
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.but that still doesnt explain why my level 15 starter with 33 stamina had less attempts than my backup with 16...I did not want My backup taking that many snaps...youve got to be kidding
..something is up with the enery patch as well...My starter had 83 energy at the end of the game...he is set to be pulled at 65 ???
I think you're all overestimating the change I made to pass quality. The change in the code for that was literally:
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.but that still doesnt explain why my level 15 starter with 33 stamina had less attempts than my backup with 16...I did not want My backup taking that many snaps...youve got to be kidding
..something is up with the enery patch as well...My starter had 83 energy at the end of the game...he is set to be pulled at 65 ???sunder B
offline
offline
I think you may be understimating the fact that some change that was made has destroyed this game today. I'm no programmer, but prhaps 10% is significant with all other things being equal
Originally posted by Zeke0123
Originally posted by Bort
I think you're all overestimating the change I made to pass quality. The change in the code for that was literally:
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.but that still doesnt explain why my level 15 starter with 33 stamina had less attempts than my backup with 16...I did not want My backup taking that many snaps...youve got to be kidding
..something is up with the enery patch as well...My starter had 83 energy at the end of the game...he is set to be pulled at 65 ???
That was an un-related issue (check announcements)
Originally posted by Bort
I think you're all overestimating the change I made to pass quality. The change in the code for that was literally:
from "if rand(100) < some number" to "if rand(110) < some number"
The fact that stamina's effect has been increased probably has more to do with it than anything.but that still doesnt explain why my level 15 starter with 33 stamina had less attempts than my backup with 16...I did not want My backup taking that many snaps...youve got to be kidding
..something is up with the enery patch as well...My starter had 83 energy at the end of the game...he is set to be pulled at 65 ???That was an un-related issue (check announcements)
Will2k
offline
offline
Well obviously it isn't working out. Mostly everyone had a terrible passing game. No one is asking for everyone to be up in the near 80% but if the norm is going to be 20-30% completion then that is a problem.
Well I have a game in an hour with a level 14 QB and 3 level 12 WR's... but I guess I'm gonna set run to 100. Not sure this is the intended effect you wanted, but I'm going to run like a madman every game if completion percentage is going to be <40 on a routine basis.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























