User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage is totally f'ed up right now
Page:
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Exactly.

You're right, people don't seem to understand what this was actually supposed to do.

This was supposed to help CBs stay with the WR, which is basically the opposite of what actually happened.

This gives a tremendous advantage to the WR, when in fact it was supposed to be a benefit of the CB.

I can't believe I pay money for this.
 
arrius
offline
Link
 
The idea behind the game is great and I wanna thank Bort for creating it but now he's just f*cking it up with all these stupid changes mid season.
My team just played a game and from watching the play by play i could see that CB's were giving WR's a lot more room than they were supposed and they don't react until the WR actually has caught the ball which is unacceptable and unrealistic.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by arrius
The idea behind the game is great and I wanna thank Bort for creating it but now he's just f*cking it up with all these stupid changes mid season.
My team just played a game and from watching the play by play i could see that CB's were giving WR's a lot more room than they were supposed and they don't react until the WR actually has caught the ball which is unacceptable and unrealistic.


Yeah.. But people act like we don't know what we're talking about, except that we're all seeing the EXACT same thing..
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Things have changed - but instead of getting angry (just look at the title of this "discussion"), it needs to calm down to seriously working towards a solution.

Obviously, most guys were just fine with their CB jumping the route and occasionally getting a PD or INT - even when ordered to NOT go for the interception when having no help over the top.

Granted it worked just fine for your team, one issue remains: when the description says "DON'T go for it without help" a CB going for it without help just isn't right.

So there was a bug before (hard to argue that).

Different question: do we got another bug now?

All we got so far are a bunch of awful looking examples and some guys getting angry. But naturally some guys are at the bitter end of this one. So it would just be the "listening for the whiners" to change it back without closely watching it for a while.

From what I've seen so far, I just can't confirm that there is something wrong. A CB playing man coverage always has to make tough decisions when the pass is thrown:

- try to jump the route to get the pick (low tackle chance afterwards)?
- try to jump the route to get a hand on the ball (low tackle chance afterwards)?
- stay close to the WR and try to swat it out of his hands (good tackle chance)?
- play it save and focus on the tackle (perfect tackle chance)?

That's about his choices. Obviously, playing medium coverage style should be a mixture of Nr. 3 and Nr. 4 when having no help over the top (according to the description). So whenever someone blames: "my CB just stays back" I'd like to ask: would you prefer your CB to jump the route even if chances are good he'd not make it and get burned instead?

What makes you believe your guy made the wrong decision? Maybe he would have tried and failed under the old system too?

(To point this out: I'm not saying there isn't an issue that needs to be adressed. It just doesn't seem reasonable to me to judge after such a short while. So let's keep watching.)

Anyway: tautology has made a reasonable suggestion. Implementation of the "old medium style" seems to be what quite a couple of guys are looking for. That might just be a good solution.
 
cowcards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Things have changed - but instead of getting angry (just look at the title of this "discussion"), it needs to calm down to seriously working towards a solution.

Obviously, most guys were just fine with their CB jumping the route and occasionally getting a PD or INT - even when ordered to NOT go for the interception when having no help over the top.

Granted it worked just fine for your team, one issue remains: when the description says "DON'T go for it without help" a CB going for it without help just isn't right.

So there was a bug before (hard to argue that).

Different question: do we got another bug now?

All we got so far are a bunch of awful looking examples and some guys getting angry. But naturally some guys are at the bitter end of this one. So it would just be the "listening for the whiners" to change it back without closely watching it for a while.

From what I've seen so far, I just can't confirm that there is something wrong. A CB playing man coverage always has to make tough decisions when the pass is thrown:

- try to jump the route to get the pick (low tackle chance afterwards)?
- try to jump the route to get a hand on the ball (low tackle chance afterwards)?
- stay close to the WR and try to swat it out of his hands (good tackle chance)?
- play it save and focus on the tackle (perfect tackle chance)?

That's about his choices. Obviously, playing medium coverage style should be a mixture of Nr. 3 and Nr. 4 when having no help over the top (according to the description). So whenever someone blames: "my CB just stays back" I'd like to ask: would you prefer your CB to jump the route even if chances are good he'd not make it and get burned instead?

What makes you believe your guy made the wrong decision? Maybe he would have tried and failed under the old system too?

(To point this out: I'm not saying there isn't an issue that needs to be adressed. It just doesn't seem reasonable to me to judge after such a short while. So let's keep watching.)

Anyway: tautology has made a reasonable suggestion. Implementation of the "old medium style" seems to be what quite a couple of guys are looking for. That might just be a good solution.


My view of the bug is that on some plays the CB is playing 5 yards off the WR the entire time the route is being run. This seems to me to only really be on deeper routes where the WR will end up behind the safeties.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6683202
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6685670

This is what medium aggressive should do when the WR is past the safeties
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6683667
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6685783
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cowcards
Originally posted by RAPB

Things have changed - but instead of getting angry (just look at the title of this "discussion"), it needs to calm down to seriously working towards a solution.

Obviously, most guys were just fine with their CB jumping the route and occasionally getting a PD or INT - even when ordered to NOT go for the interception when having no help over the top.

Granted it worked just fine for your team, one issue remains: when the description says "DON'T go for it without help" a CB going for it without help just isn't right.

So there was a bug before (hard to argue that).

Different question: do we got another bug now?

All we got so far are a bunch of awful looking examples and some guys getting angry. But naturally some guys are at the bitter end of this one. So it would just be the "listening for the whiners" to change it back without closely watching it for a while.

From what I've seen so far, I just can't confirm that there is something wrong. A CB playing man coverage always has to make tough decisions when the pass is thrown:

- try to jump the route to get the pick (low tackle chance afterwards)?
- try to jump the route to get a hand on the ball (low tackle chance afterwards)?
- stay close to the WR and try to swat it out of his hands (good tackle chance)?
- play it save and focus on the tackle (perfect tackle chance)?

That's about his choices. Obviously, playing medium coverage style should be a mixture of Nr. 3 and Nr. 4 when having no help over the top (according to the description). So whenever someone blames: "my CB just stays back" I'd like to ask: would you prefer your CB to jump the route even if chances are good he'd not make it and get burned instead?

What makes you believe your guy made the wrong decision? Maybe he would have tried and failed under the old system too?

(To point this out: I'm not saying there isn't an issue that needs to be adressed. It just doesn't seem reasonable to me to judge after such a short while. So let's keep watching.)

Anyway: tautology has made a reasonable suggestion. Implementation of the "old medium style" seems to be what quite a couple of guys are looking for. That might just be a good solution.


My view of the bug is that on some plays the CB is playing 5 yards off the WR the entire time the route is being run. This seems to me to only really be on deeper routes where the WR will end up behind the safeties.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6683202
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6685670

This is what medium aggressive should do when the WR is past the safeties
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6683667
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=271670&pbp_id=6685783


In my view, the bottom two examples are what "Play it safe" should do with no over-the-top help.

How much safer would you like them to play it? They have zero chance of contesting anything there.

Medium aggression should contest the pass, but not jump the route.
 
cowcards
offline
Link
 
medium aggression should contest the pass only if there is help over the top. in none of these plays was there coverage over the top therefore a contested pass shouldn't happen. In the first 2 despite being on close coverage they are playing off 5 yards inviting the QB to throw it there. if i wanted a CB to play 5 yards off i would play on medium coverage but that is not the case. the change bort has made has caused the cb's to play way too far off despite being on close coverage.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Agreed so far:

- CB should play close
(- CB should even jump the route if he's absolutely sure to swat down the ball)
- normally, the CB should try to swat the ball down as soon as the WR touches it (=avoid the pass interference), then immediately tackle
- stepping back to allow the catch shouldn't be a choice (unless severely overmatched)

Question: what would it look like if the CB tried to stay close to swat the ball out of WRs hands, but doesn't have the agility to break/turn in time to do so?

Maybe (just maybe) the CB didn't have enough agility before, but since he was jumping the route anyway it just looked a lot closer. Now he's not jumping the route anymore, but can't turn as fast as needed?

(Maybe confidence and vision are in the equation too, so it might not be agility based...)

Just trying to find out what's going on. This might be a bug, but just coincidence. The first play I posted a CB failed that I consider very well build. Then again, even the best CB should miss vision/confidence based checks once in a while.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Agreed so far:

- CB should play close
(- CB should even jump the route if he's absolutely sure to swat down the ball)
- normally, the CB should try to swat the ball down as soon as the WR touches it (=avoid the pass interference), then immediately tackle
- stepping back to allow the catch shouldn't be a choice (unless severely overmatched)

Question: what would it look like if the CB tried to stay close to swat the ball out of WRs hands, but doesn't have the agility to break/turn in time to do so?

Maybe (just maybe) the CB didn't have enough agility before, but since he was jumping the route anyway it just looked a lot closer. Now he's not jumping the route anymore, but can't turn as fast as needed?

(Maybe confidence and vision are in the equation too, so it might not be agility based...)

Just trying to find out what's going on. This might be a bug, but just coincidence. The first play I posted a CB failed that I consider very well build. Then again, even the best CB should miss vision/confidence based checks once in a while.


Your reasoning is sound, but if my CBs were in fact jumping the route before, and swatting the ball with incredible consistency, then that suggests that they have sufficient agility/vision/jumping/confidence, does it not?

Also, it has not generally looked as though my CBs were route-jumping, they have genrally been right on top of the WRs all season, and make the play from there. They have not generally stepped in front of the WR putting themselves out of position if the swat attempt fails.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by RAPB

Agreed so far:

- CB should play close
(- CB should even jump the route if he's absolutely sure to swat down the ball)
- normally, the CB should try to swat the ball down as soon as the WR touches it (=avoid the pass interference), then immediately tackle
- stepping back to allow the catch shouldn't be a choice (unless severely overmatched)

Question: what would it look like if the CB tried to stay close to swat the ball out of WRs hands, but doesn't have the agility to break/turn in time to do so?

Maybe (just maybe) the CB didn't have enough agility before, but since he was jumping the route anyway it just looked a lot closer. Now he's not jumping the route anymore, but can't turn as fast as needed?

(Maybe confidence and vision are in the equation too, so it might not be agility based...)

Just trying to find out what's going on. This might be a bug, but just coincidence. The first play I posted a CB failed that I consider very well build. Then again, even the best CB should miss vision/confidence based checks once in a while.


Your reasoning is sound, but if my CBs were in fact jumping the route before, and swatting the ball with incredible consistency, then that suggests that they have sufficient agility/vision/jumping/confidence, does it not?

Also, it has not generally looked as though my CBs were route-jumping, they have genrally been right on top of the WRs all season, and make the play from there. They have not generally stepped in front of the WR putting themselves out of position if the swat attempt fails.


exactly.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Agreed so far:

- CB should play close
(- CB should even jump the route if he's absolutely sure to swat down the ball)
- normally, the CB should try to swat the ball down as soon as the WR touches it (=avoid the pass interference), then immediately tackle
- stepping back to allow the catch shouldn't be a choice (unless severely overmatched)

Question: what would it look like if the CB tried to stay close to swat the ball out of WRs hands, but doesn't have the agility to break/turn in time to do so?

Maybe (just maybe) the CB didn't have enough agility before, but since he was jumping the route anyway it just looked a lot closer. Now he's not jumping the route anymore, but can't turn as fast as needed?

(Maybe confidence and vision are in the equation too, so it might not be agility based...)

Just trying to find out what's going on. This might be a bug, but just coincidence. The first play I posted a CB failed that I consider very well build. Then again, even the best CB should miss vision/confidence based checks once in a while.


This, is exactly what I've been getting at all along.

The other factor is this. Before, medium coverage style implied that the CB would play aggressively IF he had help.

What happens if the CB is in a scenario where he is not? Well, according to the Bort change, he'll play less aggressively.

Solution: Don't blitz both of your safeties, actually allow your FS to play centerfield, etc etc
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224712&pbp_id=6663389

Safety playing Centerfield, look what happens.

Okay, so there was a wording issue with the original description for Medium coverage style, but maybe he should have changed the wording instead of actually changing what it did. If people wanted it to be like it is now, they could have played on Loose, and it'd be the same thing.

The point that some of you seem to be missing is that this change - which was supposed to HELP CBs - is now hurting them.

That is ridiculous.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224712&pbp_id=6663389

Safety playing Centerfield, look what happens.

Okay, so there was a wording issue with the original description for Medium coverage style, but maybe he should have changed the wording instead of actually changing what it did. If people wanted it to be like it is now, they could have played on Loose, and it'd be the same thing.

The point that some of you seem to be missing is that this change - which was supposed to HELP CBs - is now hurting them.

That is ridiculous.


If its just one play, who's to say your CB didn't get fooled?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by RAPB

Agreed so far:

- CB should play close
(- CB should even jump the route if he's absolutely sure to swat down the ball)
- normally, the CB should try to swat the ball down as soon as the WR touches it (=avoid the pass interference), then immediately tackle
- stepping back to allow the catch shouldn't be a choice (unless severely overmatched)

Question: what would it look like if the CB tried to stay close to swat the ball out of WRs hands, but doesn't have the agility to break/turn in time to do so?

Maybe (just maybe) the CB didn't have enough agility before, but since he was jumping the route anyway it just looked a lot closer. Now he's not jumping the route anymore, but can't turn as fast as needed?

(Maybe confidence and vision are in the equation too, so it might not be agility based...)

Just trying to find out what's going on. This might be a bug, but just coincidence. The first play I posted a CB failed that I consider very well build. Then again, even the best CB should miss vision/confidence based checks once in a while.


This, is exactly what I've been getting at all along.

The other factor is this. Before, medium coverage style implied that the CB would play aggressively IF he had help.

What happens if the CB is in a scenario where he is not? Well, according to the Bort change, he'll play less aggressively.

Solution: Don't blitz both of your safeties, actually allow your FS to play centerfield, etc etc


It's a solution, but not a great one if you have a built a defense around the Cover 0/Cover 1 premise.

I can go to Cover 2 and even Cover 3, but that is not what my defense is supposed to look like...we are not really built for that style.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
1. That's not my CB
2. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213631&pbp_id=6371465
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213631&pbp_id=6373060
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213631&pbp_id=6373570
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=256545&pbp_id=6478603

More?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.