YES YES YES YES
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
MonkeyMan
offline
offline
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by tordman
No different, just worded different. Check out the cruise control thread for something that can actually be changed.
Agree with that thread
Originally posted by tordman
No different, just worded different. Check out the cruise control thread for something that can actually be changed.
Agree with that thread
SwagOnLock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Not like this, no. If you were to take our players attributes and then turn that INTO their height/weight via some logical formula, I'd be interested to see that.
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Not like this, no. If you were to take our players attributes and then turn that INTO their height/weight via some logical formula, I'd be interested to see that.
tordman
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
We need more improvements in game play.
Work on gutting, offensive and defensive AI, realignment, and eliminate cruise control.
That's what we're looking for, not ways to have a players weight matter.
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
We need more improvements in game play.
Work on gutting, offensive and defensive AI, realignment, and eliminate cruise control.
That's what we're looking for, not ways to have a players weight matter.
MonkeyMan
offline
offline
Originally posted by tordman
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
We need more improvements in game play.
Work on gutting, offensive and defensive AI, realignment, and eliminate cruise control.
That's what we're looking for, not ways to have a players weight matter.
Totally Agree
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
We need more improvements in game play.
Work on gutting, offensive and defensive AI, realignment, and eliminate cruise control.
That's what we're looking for, not ways to have a players weight matter.
Totally Agree
Dianwei32
offline
offline
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Not like this, no. If you were to take our players attributes and then turn that INTO their height/weight via some logical formula, I'd be interested to see that.
I don't think that would work well. The big thing that jumps out at me is: What stat would correspond to height? Weight I can see (Strength, Speed, maybe Agility), but what current stat would correspont to height? Jumping? GLB would be full of midgets then.
Also, how do you account for guys like Maurice Jones-Drew, who are smaller, but extremely strong and very fast?
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Not like this, no. If you were to take our players attributes and then turn that INTO their height/weight via some logical formula, I'd be interested to see that.
I don't think that would work well. The big thing that jumps out at me is: What stat would correspond to height? Weight I can see (Strength, Speed, maybe Agility), but what current stat would correspont to height? Jumping? GLB would be full of midgets then.
Also, how do you account for guys like Maurice Jones-Drew, who are smaller, but extremely strong and very fast?
Dianwei32
offline
offline
Originally posted by tordman
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
We need more improvements in game play.
Work on gutting, offensive and defensive AI, realignment, and eliminate cruise control.
That's what we're looking for, not ways to have a players weight matter.
A lot of the GLB vets (with players 30-40+) are asking for more to do with their players because there isn't a whole lot to do once your players get that high. You level up 2-3 times a season, and training only needs to be dealt with every 3rd day (assuming you are doing intense).
Plus, customizing your players is fun, maybe someone will try making a HB who is in the OMGclass (301+ lbs) to see if he can just truck everyone (similar to how people have put DTs at kick/punt return).
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.
So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
We need more improvements in game play.
Work on gutting, offensive and defensive AI, realignment, and eliminate cruise control.
That's what we're looking for, not ways to have a players weight matter.
A lot of the GLB vets (with players 30-40+) are asking for more to do with their players because there isn't a whole lot to do once your players get that high. You level up 2-3 times a season, and training only needs to be dealt with every 3rd day (assuming you are doing intense).
Plus, customizing your players is fun, maybe someone will try making a HB who is in the OMGclass (301+ lbs) to see if he can just truck everyone (similar to how people have put DTs at kick/punt return).
TheInfinity
offline
offline
Come on guys, see the arguments you are making.
"The 80 strength and 50 carrying guy fumbles just as often as the 30 strength and 30 carrying dude. Weight will fix this"
How about fixing the value of strength and carrying.
"Speed doesn't slay all other attributes"
Speed can be considered the most important attribute in Goalline Blitz and in Real Life (40-yard dash times are HUGE at the combine). But strength needs to be more important than it is. Right now a person can get away with almost no strength at positions that should require some strength or a hefty amount of strength (Linebacker, Defensive Line).
----
This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).
"The 80 strength and 50 carrying guy fumbles just as often as the 30 strength and 30 carrying dude. Weight will fix this"
How about fixing the value of strength and carrying.
"Speed doesn't slay all other attributes"
Speed can be considered the most important attribute in Goalline Blitz and in Real Life (40-yard dash times are HUGE at the combine). But strength needs to be more important than it is. Right now a person can get away with almost no strength at positions that should require some strength or a hefty amount of strength (Linebacker, Defensive Line).
----
This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).
tperdue
offline
offline
yeah i like the idea as long as we get the option of being able to have a gain/lose weight option under training like on the normal section like going out on the town or maybe even having it as an option to intense training.
+1
+1
Originally posted by Dianwei32
Also, how do you account for guys like Maurice Jones-Drew, who are smaller, but extremely strong and very fast?
doesnt help rice is light does it
Also, how do you account for guys like Maurice Jones-Drew, who are smaller, but extremely strong and very fast?
doesnt help rice is light does it
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 20:39:20
SwagOnLock
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheInfinity
This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).
This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).
Originally posted by tordman
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
LOL, are you serious? Lv 30+ players post and send us support requests every single friggin day about giving them more to do at higher levels. A large part of the recruiting problem high level teams are having is caused by high level players getting bored and retiring to start at low levels again where they have more fun by messing with customization options. Thus, I'm brainstorming ideas on what to do with veteran skills that unlock at higher levels.
Besides, is there some reason we cant discuss MULTIPLE ideas at the same time? There are multiple suggestion threads, not just one.
Seriously? Who at this point is asking for their character to have more stuff to do?
LOL, are you serious? Lv 30+ players post and send us support requests every single friggin day about giving them more to do at higher levels. A large part of the recruiting problem high level teams are having is caused by high level players getting bored and retiring to start at low levels again where they have more fun by messing with customization options. Thus, I'm brainstorming ideas on what to do with veteran skills that unlock at higher levels.
Besides, is there some reason we cant discuss MULTIPLE ideas at the same time? There are multiple suggestion threads, not just one.
MonkeyMan
offline
offline
Ok.. if weight is implemented.. then there should be effect to stamina.
30 Stam should not be the same for a 300 pound RB as a 180 Pound RB with 30 stam
30 Stam should not be the same for a 300 pound RB as a 180 Pound RB with 30 stam
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 20:44:07
Dianwei32
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheInfinity
This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).
Ok, so you can make your WR be 160 lb and have all kinds of speed, but someone may make a CB that is a little heavier and be able to jam you at the line effectively and keep you from being a viable passing target (assuming jamming WR's at the line is implemented)
Someone else may choose to make their WR a little heavier and be able to beat the jam, get open, make the catch and truck some poor 160 lb FS en route to a TD.
Granted, these wouldn't happen every time, but it illustrates the benefit of sacrificing a small amount of speed to gain a little wieght.
This weight thing will be slanted to the lighter dudes, I'm sure of it. I know I'm not giving up speed on my WR for a marginal gain in his tackle breaking ability. And honestly, its totally not needed, its another thing for Bort to have to balance and tweak, for people to potentially exploit and pretty much gives us an option to do what we've always been able to do, sacrifice speed/agility for another attribute (not that many have ever had to really consider that trade off until the 3rd soft cap).
Ok, so you can make your WR be 160 lb and have all kinds of speed, but someone may make a CB that is a little heavier and be able to jam you at the line effectively and keep you from being a viable passing target (assuming jamming WR's at the line is implemented)
Someone else may choose to make their WR a little heavier and be able to beat the jam, get open, make the catch and truck some poor 160 lb FS en route to a TD.
Granted, these wouldn't happen every time, but it illustrates the benefit of sacrificing a small amount of speed to gain a little wieght.
Dianwei32
offline
offline
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by Dianwei32
Also, how do you account for guys like Maurice Jones-Drew, who are smaller, but extremely strong and very fast?
doesnt help rice is light does it
So true, I really want this to be implemented so I can beef up Rice into a bruiser like Earl Campbell.
Originally posted by Dianwei32
Also, how do you account for guys like Maurice Jones-Drew, who are smaller, but extremely strong and very fast?
doesnt help rice is light does it
So true, I really want this to be implemented so I can beef up Rice into a bruiser like Earl Campbell.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























