User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Please stop posting that DE's are to strong
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard


Maybe the Beans should try and schedule them to a scrimmage.


I'm out of invites right now, but if they sent me one, I would surely accept
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by berzerkerusmc

I think you are playing right into the speed rushers hands, you are never going to get as high speed/agility as them, yet you try to close the gap and it takes points away from your most important attributes.


what are you talking about? the best speed rushers are hitting the 4-to-1 wall now. If your OT isn't to 50 speed yet then you are at the 1 to 1.

2 level ups this year = +10 points (say 35 to 45)
2 level ups for them = +2 points (say 68 to 70)

Next year

3 level boost for OT = +9 points (say 45 to 54)
3 level boost for DE = +3 points (from 70 to 72)

So by at the beginning of next year, you could gain 19 in speed to only 5 for them - EVEN IF YOU ALREADY BOOSTED THIS YEAR. Right?

However, I'm sure many DE's will stop at the 4 for 1 and go to vision or strength or something else anyway.

Instead of a 68 to 35 advantage in speed (which many have now), you could easily cut that down to a 68 to 54 advantage by game 1 of next year. That in itself is close enough in speed to possibly not give up any sacks.

Heaven forbid you didn't use your boost yet this season, then you could cut the advantage down to 68 to 60 and speed is no longer even an issue.

I have a DE and a OT. I know for a FACT that it is very easy to catch-up.


You're correct in that the playing field will balance and then heavily favor the OTs in a little while...

This is why the system needs to change. Right now, it's all for the DEs, soon it will be nothing. Pathing needs to be pretty standard, how the blocks are worked out needs to be adjusted. Every so often a DE that gets a huge jump off the snap, will run around an OT that gets caught flat-footed... not multiple times per game though, hell once every few games is more accurate.

SAs should make far more of a difference in this sim than they currently do. I think the system should basically be almost the complete opposite of how it currently is. Attributes should help SAs, not SAs helping attributes. Maybe even have both equally contribute. Like attributes are your base and SAs are special moves that your player has (the higher the SA, the more effective it is).
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saerin
when are people going to realize this is a game and not real life?


It's a game based on a simulation. Just because it's a game doesn't mean that the simulation has the right to be extremely poor.
 
boomer82
offline
Link
 
The biggest problem with high sack numbers is that QBs in GLB have awful decision making compared to REAL QBs. Also, DEs are a lot more able to run around slow OTs irl, but most teams realize they are overmatched on the edge and run exclusively 3-step drop passing.

As for OTs, many OTs are among the most agile players on the team.
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by berzerkerusmc


I think you are playing right into the speed rushers hands, you are never going to get as high speed/agility as them, yet you try to close the gap and it takes points away from your most important attributes.


what are you talking about? the best speed rushers are hitting the 4-to-1 wall now. If your OT isn't to 50 speed yet then you are at the 1 to 1.

2 level ups this year = +10 points (say 35 to 45)
2 level ups for them = +2 points (say 68 to 70)

Next year

3 level boost for OT = +9 points (say 45 to 54)
3 level boost for DE = +3 points (from 70 to 72)

So by at the beginning of next year, you could gain 19 in speed to only 5 for them - EVEN IF YOU ALREADY BOOSTED THIS YEAR. Right?

However, I'm sure many DE's will stop at the 4 for 1 and go to vision or strength or something else anyway.

Instead of a 68 to 35 advantage in speed (which many have now), you could easily cut that down to a 68 to 54 advantage by game 1 of next year. That in itself is close enough in speed to possibly not give up any sacks.

Heaven forbid you didn't use your boost yet this season, then you could cut the advantage down to 68 to 60 and speed is no longer even an issue.

I have a DE and a OT. I know for a FACT that it is very easy to catch-up.


You're correct in that the playing field will balance and then heavily favor the OTs in a little while...

This is why the system needs to change. Right now, it's all for the DEs, soon it will be nothing. Pathing needs to be pretty standard, how the blocks are worked out needs to be adjusted. Every so often a DE that gets a huge jump off the snap, will run around an OT that gets caught flat-footed... not multiple times per game though, hell once every few games is more accurate.

SAs should make far more of a difference in this sim than they currently do. I think the system should basically be almost the complete opposite of how it currently is. Attributes should help SAs, not SAs helping attributes. Maybe even have both equally contribute. Like attributes are your base and SAs are special moves that your player has (the higher the SA, the more effective it is).


The system doesn't need to change. The only thing that needs to change is the way you build your OT. Others have adjusted and aren't crying to high heaven. Stop whining, do something about it. The roadmap to an OTs success has been laid out very clearly for all to use.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
If you discount games against the Houston Hookers(the one gutted team in USA PRO), the current sack leader for the league has 7. In the end game, the system is about right.

Of course an NFL caliber DE playing against a HS JV O-line would get an insane number of sacks. But when the pro's play the pro's you don't see that many sacks at all.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis


The system doesn't need to change. The only thing that needs to change is the way you build your OT. Others have adjusted and aren't crying to high heaven. Stop whining, do something about it. The roadmap to an OTs success has been laid out very clearly for all to use.


He has adjusted. He changed his equipment around. So now his OT can stop them. However, he is still complaining. Why? Because he has actually played football at a decent level. He knows how stupid it is to force OTs to be built like they are having to be built in GLB.

Also, what happens when OTs are all having to be built with 60 strength, 75 agility and 65 speed? Here comes DE with 100 strength, 60 agility, 50 speed to man handle them.

Don't think there aren't those that already see this and are building their DEs like that.

 
smoked
offline
Link
 
You can't just change it now anyway. Too many DEs with high speed and agility. Can't go on and mess up the good players.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by oronis



The system doesn't need to change. The only thing that needs to change is the way you build your OT. Others have adjusted and aren't crying to high heaven. Stop whining, do something about it. The roadmap to an OTs success has been laid out very clearly for all to use.


He has adjusted. He changed his equipment around. So now his OT can stop them. However, he is still complaining. Why? Because he has actually played football at a decent level. He knows how stupid it is to force OTs to be built like they are having to be built in GLB.

Also, what happens when OTs are all having to be built with 60 strength, 75 agility and 65 speed? Here comes DE with 100 strength, 60 agility, 50 speed to man handle them.

Don't think there aren't those that already see this and are building their DEs like that.




That's the whole point. 100 speed, 60 agility, 50 strength DE's might work also.

1 correct build = boring.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by smoked
You can't just change it now anyway. Too many DEs with high speed and agility. Can't go on and mess up the good players.


Too late. it was already changed.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by boomer82
The biggest problem with high sack numbers is that QBs in GLB have awful decision making compared to REAL QBs. Also, DEs are a lot more able to run around slow OTs irl, but most teams realize they are overmatched on the edge and run exclusively 3-step drop passing.

As for OTs, many OTs are among the most agile players on the team.


QFT

Maybe Bort needs to add a "throw away" option for QB's if no one is open and a pass rusher is coming.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by oronis



The system doesn't need to change. The only thing that needs to change is the way you build your OT. Others have adjusted and aren't crying to high heaven. Stop whining, do something about it. The roadmap to an OTs success has been laid out very clearly for all to use.


He has adjusted. He changed his equipment around. So now his OT can stop them. However, he is still complaining. Why? Because he has actually played football at a decent level. He knows how stupid it is to force OTs to be built like they are having to be built in GLB.

Also, what happens when OTs are all having to be built with 60 strength, 75 agility and 65 speed? Here comes DE with 100 strength, 60 agility, 50 speed to man handle them.

Don't think there aren't those that already see this and are building their DEs like that.



Strength is about worthless for pass rushing in GLB... so once more OTs counter build to stop the only effective DE build (for getting sacks)... say goodbye to the pass rush. That is why I'm still complaining. It shouldn't be all or nothing, which is exactly what the current system promotes.

I've adjusted already and will keep DEs shut down for the most part (next season though, no one will get past me if this current system is in place). This is the exact reason why the system needs to change, people being short-sighted and telling me adjust, isn't more than a band-aid fix.
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 08:26:56
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
If you discount games against the Houston Hookers(the one gutted team in USA PRO), the current sack leader for the league has 7. In the end game, the system is about right.

Of course an NFL caliber DE playing against a HS JV O-line would get an insane number of sacks. But when the pro's play the pro's you don't see that many sacks at all.



How many yards would an NFL running back with an NFL O-line get against a HS JV defense? How many yards per carry do you think he would average?

Let's take a look at college records
Most rushing yards per game over a season 238.9
Most rushing yards in a season 2,628

Most passing yards in a season 5,833

Most sacks in a season 27


Now NFL
Most sacks in a season 22.5. Number of times over 20 = 4.
Most rushing yards in a season 2,105. Number of times over 2,000 = 3.
Most passing yards in a season 5,084. Number of times over 4,500 = ? (more than 3)


I don't have the time to go look up HS numbers all over the country. However, at just about any level of football, a sack = 100 rushing yards and roughly 280 passing yards.

If the best DEs are getting over 100 sacks because of matchups, then the best HBs should be getting over 10,000 rushing yards and the best QBs should be getting 28,000 passing yards.




 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock


Strength is about worthless for pass rushing in GLB... so once more OTs counter build to stop the only effective DE build (for getting sacks)... say goodbye to the pass rush.


As long as OTs are within 20 - 25 points of strength of the DE that is true. However, when OTs are about 35 or 40 points lower because they have to be built like a safety I'm not so sure that will be the case.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Warlock



Strength is about worthless for pass rushing in GLB... so once more OTs counter build to stop the only effective DE build (for getting sacks)... say goodbye to the pass rush.


As long as OTs are within 20 - 25 points of strength of the DE that is true. However, when OTs are about 35 or 40 points lower because they have to be built like a safety I'm not so sure that will be the case.


Nothing a second set of EQ can't fix IMHO.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.