Anyone wonder if vision has anything to do with it? It seems like he's slow to react to the snap to me.
Warlock
offline
offline
Sorry, but in the real world (you know what a simulation is supposed to be trying to emulate), a DE will almost never run around an OT without being touched. Unless there is a huge disparity in athleticism. This is because football is a game of angles, which is scientifically proven. Pulling out the peak of an angle by SIX inches, can prevent a speed rushing DE from getting to QB before he can get rid of the ball.
This is why NFL teams look for long armed OTs. I don't care how fast someone is, they cannot run around me before I can at least put a hand on them and push... changing their angle and giving the QB a little extra time... currently, that's not how the sim works. DEs would have to take a much wider angle if they want to get past an OT without getting touched. Usually this is followed by the QB stepping up into the pocket and the OT cutting off the DE, as he tries to come back to get the QB.
This needs to change and change fast, otherwise people will stop trying to pass and just run. Turning this game into a rugby sim, not American football sim.
This is why NFL teams look for long armed OTs. I don't care how fast someone is, they cannot run around me before I can at least put a hand on them and push... changing their angle and giving the QB a little extra time... currently, that's not how the sim works. DEs would have to take a much wider angle if they want to get past an OT without getting touched. Usually this is followed by the QB stepping up into the pocket and the OT cutting off the DE, as he tries to come back to get the QB.
This needs to change and change fast, otherwise people will stop trying to pass and just run. Turning this game into a rugby sim, not American football sim.
Motiak
offline
offline
Well, that's not entirely true. I've seen several college games where the DE got such a great jump on the ball that he was running past the OT as the OT was still getting out of his stance.
jetsfan0327
offline
offline
Originally posted by Warlock
Sorry, but in the real world (you know what a simulation is supposed to be trying to emulate), a DE will almost never run around an OT without being touched. Unless there is a huge disparity in athleticism. This is because football is a game of angles, which is scientifically proven. Pulling out the peak of an angle by SIX inches, can prevent a speed rushing DE from getting to QB before he can get rid of the ball.
This is why NFL teams look for long armed OTs. I don't care how fast someone is, they cannot run around me before I can at least put a hand on them and push... changing their angle and giving the QB a little extra time... currently, that's not how the sim works. DEs would have to take a much wider angle if they want to get past an OT without getting touched. Usually this is followed by the QB stepping up into the pocket and the OT cutting off the DE, as he tries to come back to get the QB.
This is true, all the OT needs to do is nudge him so that the QB can step up and the DE will overrun the QB. Looking at these replays, I am imagining there is something that's not quite right with the OTs footwork, whatever goes into that equation(nice of Bort to tell us). I'm not sure how the sim is coded but I would like to see an advanced tactic option that allows you to attack a speedy DE on pass plays and push him outta the way(should be pretty easy since he's likely to be weak in strength) instead of letting him run right by you; which is the way that pass blocking seems to work right now.
But honestly, unless you keep getting owned by players of equal level, why can't you even consider that the other guy has just hit on a damn good build at DE?
Sorry, but in the real world (you know what a simulation is supposed to be trying to emulate), a DE will almost never run around an OT without being touched. Unless there is a huge disparity in athleticism. This is because football is a game of angles, which is scientifically proven. Pulling out the peak of an angle by SIX inches, can prevent a speed rushing DE from getting to QB before he can get rid of the ball.
This is why NFL teams look for long armed OTs. I don't care how fast someone is, they cannot run around me before I can at least put a hand on them and push... changing their angle and giving the QB a little extra time... currently, that's not how the sim works. DEs would have to take a much wider angle if they want to get past an OT without getting touched. Usually this is followed by the QB stepping up into the pocket and the OT cutting off the DE, as he tries to come back to get the QB.
This is true, all the OT needs to do is nudge him so that the QB can step up and the DE will overrun the QB. Looking at these replays, I am imagining there is something that's not quite right with the OTs footwork, whatever goes into that equation(nice of Bort to tell us). I'm not sure how the sim is coded but I would like to see an advanced tactic option that allows you to attack a speedy DE on pass plays and push him outta the way(should be pretty easy since he's likely to be weak in strength) instead of letting him run right by you; which is the way that pass blocking seems to work right now.
But honestly, unless you keep getting owned by players of equal level, why can't you even consider that the other guy has just hit on a damn good build at DE?
Warlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by jetsfan0327
Originally posted by Warlock
Sorry, but in the real world (you know what a simulation is supposed to be trying to emulate), a DE will almost never run around an OT without being touched. Unless there is a huge disparity in athleticism. This is because football is a game of angles, which is scientifically proven. Pulling out the peak of an angle by SIX inches, can prevent a speed rushing DE from getting to QB before he can get rid of the ball.
This is why NFL teams look for long armed OTs. I don't care how fast someone is, they cannot run around me before I can at least put a hand on them and push... changing their angle and giving the QB a little extra time... currently, that's not how the sim works. DEs would have to take a much wider angle if they want to get past an OT without getting touched. Usually this is followed by the QB stepping up into the pocket and the OT cutting off the DE, as he tries to come back to get the QB.
This is true, all the OT needs to do is nudge him so that the QB can step up and the DE will overrun the QB. Looking at these replays, I am imagining there is something that's not quite right with the OTs footwork, whatever goes into that equation(nice of Bort to tell us). I'm not sure how the sim is coded but I would like to see an advanced tactic option that allows you to attack a speedy DE on pass plays and push him outta the way(should be pretty easy since he's likely to be weak in strength) instead of letting him run right by you; which is the way that pass blocking seems to work right now.
But honestly, unless you keep getting owned by players of equal level, why can't you even consider that the other guy has just hit on a damn good build at DE?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=219881
Do some DEs utterly own some OTs? Sure it happens, but with the current pathing of blocking backs... there is nothing a team can do to try and prevent a mismatch from dictating a game. I ran a primarily max protect offense here, with a well built FB and a well built TE in the backfield to help block. The OTs aren't perfect builds or anything, but they're not bad builds (both have over 50 agi and 35 spd, with high blocking and decent SAs).
This game was dictated by pressure... a sack every 3 drop backs and pressure (either a sack or hurry) every other drop back. This was with both backs in pass protect on the majority of those pass plays... unfortunately they were basically worthless (one has soft capped vision, speed, agility, blocking and 2 in the spot blitz SA).
Unacceptable IMHO. Pathing needs to be tweaked for both DEs and blitzing players... or RBs/OL need to not be completely worthless on the majority of their blocking assignments (adjustments and hot reads). Currently there is almost zero shift/slide protection by the OL and the RBs don't hang back and wait to see where the pressure is coming from (before going to block someone).
Originally posted by Warlock
Sorry, but in the real world (you know what a simulation is supposed to be trying to emulate), a DE will almost never run around an OT without being touched. Unless there is a huge disparity in athleticism. This is because football is a game of angles, which is scientifically proven. Pulling out the peak of an angle by SIX inches, can prevent a speed rushing DE from getting to QB before he can get rid of the ball.
This is why NFL teams look for long armed OTs. I don't care how fast someone is, they cannot run around me before I can at least put a hand on them and push... changing their angle and giving the QB a little extra time... currently, that's not how the sim works. DEs would have to take a much wider angle if they want to get past an OT without getting touched. Usually this is followed by the QB stepping up into the pocket and the OT cutting off the DE, as he tries to come back to get the QB.
This is true, all the OT needs to do is nudge him so that the QB can step up and the DE will overrun the QB. Looking at these replays, I am imagining there is something that's not quite right with the OTs footwork, whatever goes into that equation(nice of Bort to tell us). I'm not sure how the sim is coded but I would like to see an advanced tactic option that allows you to attack a speedy DE on pass plays and push him outta the way(should be pretty easy since he's likely to be weak in strength) instead of letting him run right by you; which is the way that pass blocking seems to work right now.
But honestly, unless you keep getting owned by players of equal level, why can't you even consider that the other guy has just hit on a damn good build at DE?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=219881
Do some DEs utterly own some OTs? Sure it happens, but with the current pathing of blocking backs... there is nothing a team can do to try and prevent a mismatch from dictating a game. I ran a primarily max protect offense here, with a well built FB and a well built TE in the backfield to help block. The OTs aren't perfect builds or anything, but they're not bad builds (both have over 50 agi and 35 spd, with high blocking and decent SAs).
This game was dictated by pressure... a sack every 3 drop backs and pressure (either a sack or hurry) every other drop back. This was with both backs in pass protect on the majority of those pass plays... unfortunately they were basically worthless (one has soft capped vision, speed, agility, blocking and 2 in the spot blitz SA).
Unacceptable IMHO. Pathing needs to be tweaked for both DEs and blitzing players... or RBs/OL need to not be completely worthless on the majority of their blocking assignments (adjustments and hot reads). Currently there is almost zero shift/slide protection by the OL and the RBs don't hang back and wait to see where the pressure is coming from (before going to block someone).
TurboBoxer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
if TE is not primary receiver he can be pulled to block the left side.
works like this
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=264581&pbp_id=738510
i like how there is 7 guys covering 2 WRs and they STILL get the catch.
if TE is not primary receiver he can be pulled to block the left side.
works like this
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=264581&pbp_id=738510
i like how there is 7 guys covering 2 WRs and they STILL get the catch.
jetsfan0327
offline
offline
I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet

SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by jetsfan0327
I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet
You do realize you can choose to keep the back in to block now, right? You can keep the TE, HB and FB in as long as they aren't the primary receiver. Plan accordingly.
I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet

You do realize you can choose to keep the back in to block now, right? You can keep the TE, HB and FB in as long as they aren't the primary receiver. Plan accordingly.
pnewtonjr
offline
offline
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by CoachBradley
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1148004
That play is friggin' ridiculous. There isn't a DE alive who can, without a blitz to occupy other blockers, completely go around a pass-setting OT and make a sack like that without being touched within 1 second of the ball being snapped. I gotta go with the OP on this one. 80 blocking and 50 agility...this shouldn't happen.
Finally, another person who isnt a god damn tool... That play is ridiculous, I dont care what anyone says
I've been on the DEs side of this argument for a long time, but this play is ridiculous.
Originally posted by CoachBradley
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=235260&pbp_id=1148004
That play is friggin' ridiculous. There isn't a DE alive who can, without a blitz to occupy other blockers, completely go around a pass-setting OT and make a sack like that without being touched within 1 second of the ball being snapped. I gotta go with the OP on this one. 80 blocking and 50 agility...this shouldn't happen.
Finally, another person who isnt a god damn tool... That play is ridiculous, I dont care what anyone says
I've been on the DEs side of this argument for a long time, but this play is ridiculous.
Warlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by jetsfan0327
I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet
You do realize you can choose to keep the back in to block now, right? You can keep the TE, HB and FB in as long as they aren't the primary receiver. Plan accordingly.
Thanks, captain obvious. My offensive AI had max protect (AKA 7 blockers to give the QB time to pass the ball) on 75% of every passing play. The two additional blockers were a FB (who has 6 attributes soft capped and the spot blitz SA) and a TE (who is very similar)... needless to say, they didn't help, pretty much at all. 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 pass plays (the majority of which had 7 blockers), isn't working as intended IMHO.
Besides, you could set backs to block prior to the last minute Bort adjustment. You just be more exact in how you set up your playbook and AI.
Originally posted by jetsfan0327
I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet

You do realize you can choose to keep the back in to block now, right? You can keep the TE, HB and FB in as long as they aren't the primary receiver. Plan accordingly.
Thanks, captain obvious. My offensive AI had max protect (AKA 7 blockers to give the QB time to pass the ball) on 75% of every passing play. The two additional blockers were a FB (who has 6 attributes soft capped and the spot blitz SA) and a TE (who is very similar)... needless to say, they didn't help, pretty much at all. 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 pass plays (the majority of which had 7 blockers), isn't working as intended IMHO.
Besides, you could set backs to block prior to the last minute Bort adjustment. You just be more exact in how you set up your playbook and AI.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 15:01:36
Black Peter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Warlock
Thanks, captain obvious. My offensive AI had max protect (AKA 7 blockers to give the QB time to pass the ball) on 75% of every passing play. The two additional blockers were a FB (who has 6 attributes soft capped and the spot blitz SA) and a TE (who is very similar)... needless to say, they didn't help, pretty much at all. 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 pass plays (the majority of which had 7 blockers), isn't working as intended IMHO.
Don't worry, they'll all just respond that you need 60+ speed on all lineman and probably 70-80+ on FBs and TEs or it's your builds fault. ;P
Thanks, captain obvious. My offensive AI had max protect (AKA 7 blockers to give the QB time to pass the ball) on 75% of every passing play. The two additional blockers were a FB (who has 6 attributes soft capped and the spot blitz SA) and a TE (who is very similar)... needless to say, they didn't help, pretty much at all. 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 pass plays (the majority of which had 7 blockers), isn't working as intended IMHO.
Don't worry, they'll all just respond that you need 60+ speed on all lineman and probably 70-80+ on FBs and TEs or it's your builds fault. ;P
Warlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Toriq
Originally posted by Warlock
Thanks, captain obvious. My offensive AI had max protect (AKA 7 blockers to give the QB time to pass the ball) on 75% of every passing play. The two additional blockers were a FB (who has 6 attributes soft capped and the spot blitz SA) and a TE (who is very similar)... needless to say, they didn't help, pretty much at all. 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 pass plays (the majority of which had 7 blockers), isn't working as intended IMHO.
Don't worry, they'll all just respond that you need 60+ speed on all lineman and probably 70-80+ on FBs and TEs or it's your builds fault. ;P
I think the better route would be to save myself money and aggravation, by having 100+ in "I'm getting tired of this nonsense" build.
Originally posted by Warlock
Thanks, captain obvious. My offensive AI had max protect (AKA 7 blockers to give the QB time to pass the ball) on 75% of every passing play. The two additional blockers were a FB (who has 6 attributes soft capped and the spot blitz SA) and a TE (who is very similar)... needless to say, they didn't help, pretty much at all. 12 sacks and 6 hurries on 38 pass plays (the majority of which had 7 blockers), isn't working as intended IMHO.
Don't worry, they'll all just respond that you need 60+ speed on all lineman and probably 70-80+ on FBs and TEs or it's your builds fault. ;P
I think the better route would be to save myself money and aggravation, by having 100+ in "I'm getting tired of this nonsense" build.
anthon9283
offline
offline
This also happened in our last game. But it was the RT getting owned giving up 7 sacks to the same guy. Guess it could be a great DE build but it such a drastic change from last year where we didn't give up much sacks. Seems kind of like the whole RB fumbling issue last season.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=265513&pbp_id=1120271
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=265513&pbp_id=1120271
Porch
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by jetsfan0327
I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet
You do realize you can choose to keep the back in to block now, right? You can keep the TE, HB and FB in as long as they aren't the primary receiver. Plan accordingly.
You do realize that we only had 3 guys out on the pass play and they rushed 4. We had 7 blockers vs 4 rushers and no one touched him including the HB who does have great speed and agility. Yet no one even seems touch him.
So the solution to stop a 4 man rush takes 8 blockers and they can triple team both WR's?
Originally posted by jetsfan0327
I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet

You do realize you can choose to keep the back in to block now, right? You can keep the TE, HB and FB in as long as they aren't the primary receiver. Plan accordingly.
You do realize that we only had 3 guys out on the pass play and they rushed 4. We had 7 blockers vs 4 rushers and no one touched him including the HB who does have great speed and agility. Yet no one even seems touch him.
So the solution to stop a 4 man rush takes 8 blockers and they can triple team both WR's?
TCR
offline
offline
Originally posted by Madcow8me
I gave up all of one sack last year. and 2 hurries
If this bullshit isnt some sort of damn nerf.......
My tackle has almost 80 blocking, and softcapped agility.. and he isnt even getting a hand on the DE
With soft capped agility and speed your guy will get nowhere near my DE.Strength, speed and agility are at the 60 plus cap.
I gave up all of one sack last year. and 2 hurries
If this bullshit isnt some sort of damn nerf.......
My tackle has almost 80 blocking, and softcapped agility.. and he isnt even getting a hand on the DE
With soft capped agility and speed your guy will get nowhere near my DE.Strength, speed and agility are at the 60 plus cap.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























