User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > World Championship Playoff vs. Champions' League
Page:
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Bump for mention from another thread.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Bump for another mention in another thread.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Bump for yet another mention in yet another thread, and:

Originally posted by dmfa41

Reasons for a top World League
- More thorough competition (play against all teams)
- No adjustment of offseason


 
cromagnon
offline
Link
 
also another vote to bring back forum search, quoted from the other tread.

Originally posted by cromagnon
I didn’t see this idea on the “never going to happen” list

The original poster had the idea for 16 teams, where do I think it would be better to have a normal 32 team league. System is already set up for that number for a league.

If you did the 32 team league format (just like all leagues) to start off you could take the top 4 from each region’s Pro Leagues and from that point you would promote each regions league champion and relegate from the World Pro league each regions lowest finisher.

I think it would also help get a better FA mix across regions because it would put a higher ranking league above each region’s pro league. FA's would see multiple paths to the true top league.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Yes! Three Round Playoff for world champion!

Not a league! Just a simple playoff during those 10+ dead days of off season.-
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Reasons against a top World League
- Promotion/relegation from Regions: worse teams will stay in a World League while better teams will make the drop if regions are to be kept.
- Removes teams from competing in their regions


 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Originally posted by dmfa41

Reasons against a top World League
- Promotion/relegation from Regions: worse teams will stay in a World League while better teams will make the drop if regions are to be kept.
- Removes teams from competing in their regions




As a tournament, this should be a no brainer. Takes practically nothing to set up and can be done immediately for Season 7 Pro League Champions.

People of GLB have been waiting a long time for their Overall Champion to be crowned and a simple 6-8 day tournament is the way to go.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Pros:
- We know who the best in the world is, and just in case a trophy isn't enough, it makes winning the regional championship even more worthwhile.
- It makes winning promotion up the pyramid from AAA to the Pro Leagues more worthwhile.
- Makes competition between regions sanctioned and official.

Cons:
- Takes away from the offseason time so world champions wouldn't begin their signings until day 46.
- Also would not work for contracts which end on Day 40, but would increase incentive to retain players.

Changes which would be needed:
- consideration for end-on-day 40 contracts for teams who make the tournament, e.g. 5-day short term or automatically extend them until championship is over
- consideration for players to be signed after day 40 during World Championship push (allow new signings to compete?)
- 1 more day of offseason (make up with 1 less day of preseason?)


 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Originally posted by dmfa41

Pros:
- We know who the best in the world is, and just in case a trophy isn't enough, it makes winning the regional championship even more worthwhile.
- It makes winning promotion up the pyramid from AAA to the Pro Leagues more worthwhile.
- Makes competition between regions sanctioned and official.

Cons:
- Takes away from the offseason time so world champions wouldn't begin their signings until day 46.
- Also would not work for contracts which end on Day 40, but would increase incentive to retain players.

Changes which would be needed:
- consideration for end-on-day 40 contracts for teams who make the tournament, e.g. 5-day short term or automatically extend them until championship is over
- consideration for players to be signed after day 40 during World Championship push (allow new signings to compete?)
- 1 more day of offseason (make up with 1 less day of preseason?)




Con #1: Elite Teams can Recruit while playing these games. Its not that hard.
Con #2: Roster Freeze. Players on the team stay on the team until the tournament is over. Its not like they can't negotiate with other teams in the meantime. Heck, even allow them to sign new contracts but don't move them until the games are over. New signings cannot be put onto the depth chart until tournament is over.
Con #3: One less day of Pre-Season is totally doable. Also, Day 46 is not that out of the ordinary these days, I could swear we got to that last off season.
Last edited Jan 13, 2009 16:44:45
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I think this past one we went to 48 or 49 to let people come back from vacations after Christmas.
 
cromagnon
offline
Link
 
I think a whole league would be better, that way you can see how your players do over a 16 game schedule and still have a playoff at the end.

Of course those 32 teams would have a recruiting advantage because i know guys that would sign on just to be 4-5th string just to say I was on that team etc.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Why wouldn't you reward teams for doing so well with that recruiting advantage?

I think the prestige ought only to go to those who won the Pro League, but when it comes to competitions formed of teams from different leagues (Eurobasket, UEFA Champions' League) they take the top several (up to 4) based on the strength of that league.

Of course, those super-leagues take place simultaneously with their normal league play.
 
GamePwner
offline
Link
 
I really like this plan.
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I'd like to bring this back to the forefront since this appears to have fallen by the wayside.

I would prefer a 3-round playoff of the champions of the Pro Leagues from each of the 8 regions to crown a world champion. This would take place on days 42-46 after the playoffs or in the preseason using the previous year's standings.

Format: Either of the following
- Geographical: 1st round: USA vs. Canada, S. America vs. Africa, W. Europe vs. E. Europe, SE Asia vs. Oceania; Semifinal: USA/Can vs. SA/Afr, WE/EE vs. SEA/Oc
- Seeding: Rank teams 1-8 based on either overall rating, point difference, combined overall rating of opponents, or average level

Pros:
- We know who the best in the world is, and just in case a trophy isn't enough, it makes winning the regional championship even more worthwhile.
- It makes winning promotion up the pyramid from AAA to the Pro Leagues more worthwhile.
- Makes competition between regions sanctioned and official.

Cons:
- Takes away from the offseason time so world champions wouldn't begin their signings until day 46.
- Also would not work for contracts which end on Day 40, but would increase incentive to retain players.

Changes which would be needed:
- consideration for end-on-day 40 contracts for teams who make the tournament, e.g. 5-day short term or automatically extend them until championship is over
- consideration for players to be signed after day 40 during World Championship push (allow new signings to compete?)
- 1 more day of offseason (make up with 1 less day of preseason?)

Reasons for a top World League
- More thorough competition (play against all teams)
- No adjustment of offseason

Reasons against a top World League
- Promotion/relegation from Regions: worse teams will stay in a World League while better teams will make the drop if regions are to be kept.
- Removes teams from competing in their regions


I like the world league better.

1st year all conference champions go.

Next year 8 that make the playoffs stay, 8 that do not go back. Team 9 gets their first choice of which league to go to and down the list, till team 16 goes to the last spot left.

Simple.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Changing regions?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.