User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > My slow build strategy good?
Page:
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - L5 - Agi 12, 66% complete, 53% gain => Agi 13, 19% complete

===

OC - Block 20, 47% complete, 70% gain => Block 21, 17% complete
------ Agility 10, 69% complete, 67% gain => Agility 11, 67% complete

OG - Block 17, 53% complete, 52% gain => Block 18, 5% complete
------ Strength 18, 49% complete, 51% gain => Strength 19, 0% complete

OT - Block 12, 62% complete, 63% gain => Block 13, 25% complete
------ Strength 18, 50% complete, 50% gain => Strength 19, 0% complete


==

OC had a training break through on his blocking that about doubled his listed training percentage. It also looks like the stamina arguement is a wash. All the new guys with base 10 Stam are getting max XP, or at least as much as the 14 Stam guys were. I have a feeling that might be built into the logic of the CPU teams. So, i'm not going to track XP any more, I'll just make a note when a player gains a level.
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - L5 - Agi 13, 19% complete, 51% gain => Agi 13, 70% complete

==
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - Agi 13, 70% complete, 50% gain => Agi 14, 20% complete

===

OC - L2 - Block 22, 17% complete, 45% gain => Block 21, 62% complete
------ Agility 11.2, 36% complete, 66% gain => Agility 12.2, 2% complete

OG - L2 - Block 18.67, 5% complete, 50% gain => Block 18.67, 55% complete
------ Strength 19.67, 0% complete, 48% gain => Strength 19.67, 48% complete

OT - L2 - Block 13.4, 25% complete, 61% gain => Block 13.4, 86% complete
------ Strength 19.4, 0% complete, 47% gain => Strength 19.4, 47% complete

===

Ok so the saga continues. The percentages seem to vary by 1% (based on the OG/OT).
 
WINTYWINTY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Butternuts
when you finish training an attribute make sure you get the bar to 90%+, then soft cap it - then later you can train it again and get 2 SP worth for training it


Wait, what was that.
 
Nik Aitken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
don't play on relaxed. you get less exp than normal/hard.


 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WINTYWINTY
Originally posted by Butternuts

when you finish training an attribute make sure you get the bar to 90%+, then soft cap it - then later you can train it again and get 2 SP worth for training it


Wait, what was that.


Fill up your little green training bar while it's cheap -- as in 35% per train or more. Leave it at 90%+ when you cap. After you cap (multiple times if you want) you can go back and finish that last bit of training off, even when it's down to 5% or so per train. When you do finish the training, it gives 1 whole attribute point, which might otherwise cost you 2, 3 or more Skill Points to raise, depending on which soft cap you are at.

 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - L6 - Agi 14.25, 20% complete, 49% gain => Agi 14.25, 69% complete
-----Agi 14.25, 69% complete, 48% gain => 15.25, 17% complete

===
2 days worth
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - L7 - Agi 15.5, 17% complete, 47% gain => Agi 15.5, 64% complete
----- Agi 15.5, 64% complete, 47% gain => 16.5, 11% complete



OC - L3 - Block 23, 62% complete, 41% gain => Block 24, 3% complete
------ Agility 12.4, 2% complete, 62% gain => Agility 12.4, 64% complete

OT - L3 - Block 13.8, 86% complete, 58% gain => Block 14.8, 44% complete
------ Strength 19.8, 47% complete, 64% gain => Strength 20.8, 11% complete

==

So... decided to take my OG out of the expirement since he was only giving duplicate data. Then OC and OT earned their 1st bonus SP from training, just as they are about to hit L4. Had another breakthrough training with my OT. And, Finally, OG1 finally closed the list for normal training. Now I have a list from 10 to 24. As luck would have it his block also hit 25, so now I can expand that list in the other direction.

As a side note - personally I think OGs are useless in the game right now. They have identical trees to the OC (except the OC gets Line General) and their auto progression is much worse. If you look at the game film all the OGs do is match up against the DTs. Sometimes 1 on 1, sometimes in a double team with the OC. It just makes much more sense to have 2 extra OCs playing in the OG slots. Some teams do use a "pulling guard" but it's not like that's a staple play or anything. HBs can run outside just fine without doing a full fledged sweep. So, yeah, for all you players out there considering rolling an OG... Don't do it. Roll an OC with a Strength of 22 or more and you be able to spend your 15 points on Strength, then spend your L1 and L2 SPs on it and boom... you're at the 48 soft cap without ever training Strength at all. You can train "Passblock Drills" (+Agi/Block) instead.
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - **

OC - Block 24, 3% complete, 39% gain => Block 24, 42% complete
------ Agility 12.4, 64% complete, 62% gain => Agility 13.4, 36% complete

OT - L4 - Block 15.2, 44% complete, 57% gain => Block 16.2, 1% complete
------ Agility 18.2, 0% complete, 49% gain => Agility 18.2, 49% complete

==

Screwed the pooch on OG1, wrote down the Blocking numbers and hit the train button.. except I forgot to switch it to Blocking training so I did agility again. OC ended up with 998 XP after last night's XP. OT hit L4 and capped strength and switched to Pass Block Drills (+Agi/Block).

edit: also for players slow building, now is a good time to create new players. Players up to L7 will be offered contracts with CPU teams. Given the number of games remaining until XP gets turned off, players created now will be L6 or L7 by the time next season starts and will get contract offers with CPU teams. That means another season of max XP, and a chance to finish off the build without handicapping a team with a half built player. You'll head into your 3rd season, with a level in the low 20s (if you boost both seasons) completely ready to take over the GLB world.
Last edited Nov 29, 2008 10:58:32
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
OG1 - Block 25.02, 0% complete, 33% gain => Block 25.02, 33% complete

==
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio

I created 3 C's all with 19 blocking. They are all going to end up with blocking at the 3rd cap. The first will train until they can 1st cap it with available SP, and then continue to pump it to the 3rd cap while training something else. The second will train until they can 2nd cap it with available SP, and then continue to pump it to the 3rd cap while training something else. The third will just keep training it until they have enough SP to 3rd cap it. I'm really not good at explaining things, and it's a real bitch to figure this stuff out on paper with making at best, educated guesses about how much a single training session will add to an attribute when it is at ##. So I'll get back to you guys, but I just have a feeling that the third guy will have blocking at the 3rd cap the quickest.

They'll all be doing intense training on strength/blocking, and every bonus token will go toward temp boosts, and every SP that comes from that will go into blocking, too. After the first guy first caps blocking he will intense train something else so he still gets the bonus tokens and SP to put into blocking, same with the 2nd guy.


As proven above by the spread sheet break down, it is ALWAYS better to cap at the 1st soft cap to take advantage of natural level gains.

Think about it, if your cap'd at 49, and you gain 1 point per level, it would take you 2 sp to get that 1 point. It's pretty straight forward.

Don't bother creating 3 centers just to see what one ends up better, the example that was broken down and listed for you is exactly what will happen.

Bottom line, ALWAYS cap as soon as you can to take advantage of natural level gains.


Update on this, I'm using WRs instead of Cs. All started out with 13 speed. They trained speed on intense and all SP from intense training after speed is capped will go toward raising speed. The goal is to see which WR will get their speed to the 3rd cap first.

First Cap trained speed and had his speed first capped ASAP. All other SP he gets will go toward 3rd capping speed.
Current speed = 56.98
Current SP = 1
Bonus Tokens = 1
Training Pts = 4

Second Cap is still training speed and will spend his SP when he has enough to second cap it. Any SP gained after that will go toward 3rd capping speed.
Current speed = 19.98 (21% progress)
Current SP = 47
Bonus Tokens = 1
Training Pts = 4
Speed if I dumped all his SP into speed right now = 57.98

Third cap is still training speed and will basically be the same as Second Cap until Second Cap second caps speed.
Current speed = 19.98 (38% progress)
Current SP = 47
Bonus Tokens = 1
Training Pts = 4
Speed if I dumped all his SP into speed right now = 57.98

It's already obvious that just first capping an attribute for the sake of capping it will not get it to its final destination as soon as leaving it low and training it before putting SP in it will. This was obvious to most of us all along but for some reason people thought that the extra "value" of 0.33 sp on level-up beyond the first cap would outweigh and entire level's worth of training a sub-20 attribute. This is just to put that to rest. This is already outlined on the GLB wiki about slow building http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Slowbuilding

People who argue that "total SP in build" will be lower, yes, there's probably some truth to that since you're spending much more time training your main attribute. But the attribute will end up higher, sooner.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 12:56:49
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
It's already obvious that just first capping an attribute for the sake of capping it will not get it to its final destination as soon as leaving it low and training it before putting SP in it will. This was obvious to most of us all along but for some reason people thought that the extra "value" of 0.33 sp on level-up beyond the first cap would outweigh and entire level's worth of training a sub-20 attribute. This is just to put that to rest. This is already outlined on the GLB wiki about slow building http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Slowbuilding

People who argue that "total SP in build" will be lower, yes, there's probably some truth to that since you're spending much more time training your main attribute. But the attribute will end up higher, sooner.


Bizarre rant. Your test is flawed, and things are not so 'obvious' as you proclaim.

1) You have to train speed on the first WR at all times also for it to be a fair comparison!
2) Why not wait until the 68 cap before drawing your conclusions? Things might be different
3) How about for a C, not a WR, like was originally discussed? Again, the conclusions would be totally different.
Edit: 4) Your receivers started out with 13 speed. That is very low and will give a bias to the ones who train. I suspect your conclusions would again be different if you started them with a more realistic number of points in Speed.

Oh, and you need to re-think what "total SP in build" means!
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 13:11:40
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Jack Del Rio's results are interesting. I think his point is that skills with low natural gains reduce the efficiency of softcapping vs super slow building.

I have a question about your test Jack Del Rio. When did you hit your first cap. I was helping a friend plan a build for a new WR. I noticed while searching open builds for WRs that a new WR created yesterday boosted 3 times to level 4. For some reason this WRs speed rounded up leaving a whole number. While the older WRs who were level 4 had a X.99 for speed.

I wonder if you were able to do this same test but softcap speed at level 4 with 49 with 90% to 99% trained. Then train it one last time to make 50 in speed at level 4. Maybe then the natural gains would be enough to make softcapping more efficient with a skill that has a .33 natural gain.

edited to complete the sentence.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 13:28:50
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
1) That's not part of the test. Why would it be? The point is that you'd train it until you can first cap it, and then move on to train other things, which is what the soft-cap building is all about. You don't train attributes at 48 unless you're just trying to finish out the bar with one training session, lol. Doesn't take a test to tell you that if you did spend time training an attribute up from 0% that you'd be wasting your time.
2) I'm not stopping by any means, I'm just saying it appears that Second Cap and Third Cap have already surpassed First Cap in potential speed if all three players will be stopping at the third cap.
3) Agreed that they'd be different, that's why I chose to do a WR test. I HAVE seen a test like this done by a C, and with an attribute that goes up 1 on each level, it's hard to make a case for slow building via the training route. But if you actually wanted to 4th or 5th cap strength as soon as possible, a case could be made for the training method, though it's probably one of the worst build choices to make because you postpone training your minors by so much. But for the pure sake of getting the main attribute high ASAP, ignoring all other attributes, the training method takes the cake.
4) The conclusions might be different in terms of the magnitudes of values, but I see no reason for the "order in which the players achieved the third cap" would change. I'll check back in at the end of the season to see if by some miracle Second and Third Cap are falling behind First Cap.

I know what "total SP in build" means. I've acknowledged numerous times that this is a method of building an unbalanced player for the sake of ending up with a higher main attribute. Maybe I should have said "total points in build".
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 13:38:04
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Fair enough, I am interested in how this pans out, keep us updated

As for training attributes at 48 - I think it is criminally underrated even for a low-level player. Just my personal preference though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.