User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort, This Looks Like HorseCrap To Me
Page:
 
soapbox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer
Originally posted by soapbox

Originally posted by Onyxgem


Originally posted by soapbox



http://www.eliboat.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/03/0326071326.jpg

This looks like horse crap to me.

Your post looks like med/med to me.

My CB (Pacman Asomugha) led the league in INTs and PDs in S3 when I had him at med/med. When I switched him to close, he rarely gave up catches. If the CB is an INT machine, I doubt he's on close (personal experience). It looks like he's playing medium as far as the distances go, and either way, CBs do lose some battles. If you showed me his build, I could show you the reason for him getting beat (but I'd need 100% honesty in terms of the tactics).



I was 100% honestly Close/Medium I had him set like that all year long except for a game or 2 that were blowouts, and one where we wanted to try something else...other than that it was close/medium


The TD looked like close but you just missed the tackle.

All of those plays have 2 things in common and it actually just shows a build flaw. I think you need to raise two or three stats higher. However, in the interest of self-preservation, I won't tell you which. You should easily be able to figure out from those plays (it's a pretty glaring issue... just think real life).

Edit: Eh, actually why not. Vision and Agility seem to be your main problem, and tackling would help erase that one TD.


Look at the TD play again..Try to watch the CB and the QB at the same time..lol..I use puase...Cb gets a small burst of aimless running..In turn he has a bad angle on the WR when making the tackle.


Vision. And a missed tackle is a missed tackle. Ofc a better angle would help, but so would a bit better of tackling.
 
smileydeath
offline
Link
 
In the fourth link, the LE is gaining on the WR before he scores. The WR must be REALLY slow
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
This thread good example why we should just get rid of bugs forum
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
This thread good example why we should just get rid of bugs forum


 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Here's your answer. Please disregard the random reasons given above.

1) Your Agility is 20-30 points below your speed. The ability to accelerate/decelerate and cut is governed by agility, and the faster you're going the more agility you need to be truly agile and mobile. The ratio of speed:agility (along with vision) is crucial for maintaining good coverage. Your ratio isn't too good.


Unless you are on his team, I don't understand how you can say this with confidence. Unless you know his Agility score(which he is currently not showing), then it is pure conjecture on your part. In my previous post, I mentioned it as a possible issue, but since I did not know the Agility values I only gave it as a possibility.

Originally posted by fallingmercury

2) The WRs on the plays look like they're playing very well, giving you a high mark to meet.


In the space of 9 games of the regular season(+1 playoff game), how much better can they get? They were shut out, and shut down, the first time these 2 teams met back in week 8. 9 weeks later, they dismantle the same defense?

Personaly I do not understand it at all. I accept that players improve over time, that makes sense. The probem is that there is either a HUGE random factor on the game level, or huge changes between builds between level 31-35 (the margain of difference between the players currently)

Originally posted by fallingmercury

3) If the WRs have a speed:agility ratio closer to 1:1, you're going to have a difficult time covering them when they make a cut on their route. They're going to cut and your CB isn't going to be good enough to stick with him.


This I agree with, and it looks like the player CB Clyde has been beat on this in the past.... however it was not very often. To think that between games 8 and 18 all Three WR's and the Quarterback improved enough to not just overcome the dominance displayed in their first game, but to completely reverse it? And by reverse it, I mean getting 4x the passing offense than they had in their earlier meeting.

Frankly it just does not make sense. At least not if you think that a season on GLB is supposed to be similar to a NFL season. There just should not be that kind of varience.

 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer

Not necessarily. Could have been the first time the "bad luck" happened. You can read a 900 page thread about a QB that threw 9 interceptions in a playoff game last year. Everyone agreed he had a terrible build, but he never threw more than 2 picks in a game all season.


And that is a defense of the situation how? You just described another situation where performance does not match the build.

For me it comes down to this; Week 8 score; 29-0 Manitoba, (83) passing Yards
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=154117

Week 2 of Playoffs ; 35-19 Wasaga (445.5) passing yards.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=206240

In real football, this just does not happen without injuries. If the game wants to reflect realistic possibilities then this is a statistical abboration outside the expected norms.

If it is outside the expected norms it is a bug by definition.

If this level of varience is within the intended norm, then why are we playing at all? On the AA level, if one team can improve 35 points in 9 games against another team who also has 9 games to improve, then something is not right. It becomes a game of random chance, not of skill.

 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Something to consider. My CB on the Werewolves had a speed in the high 70s, and agility in the mid to high 50s (vision over 50, and I think 7 in super vision). He was set on close/med pretty much all season, and we would run into teams that just ate him for lunch. We theorized that sometimes he was simply too fast to cover VERY agile receivers, and switched a bunch of his equipment from speed to agility.

He covers much closer now, and doesn't "orbit" slower very agile receivers.

I wonder if they simply had one receiver remove all their speed equipment and put it into agility. That WR doesn't look all that fast in the replays, and your CB pulls away at the snap of the ball in every play you pasted.

Be interesting to know.

PinTBC
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by wombat killer


Not necessarily. Could have been the first time the "bad luck" happened. You can read a 900 page thread about a QB that threw 9 interceptions in a playoff game last year. Everyone agreed he had a terrible build, but he never threw more than 2 picks in a game all season.


And that is a defense of the situation how? You just described another situation where performance does not match the build.

For me it comes down to this; Week 8 score; 29-0 Manitoba, (83) passing Yards
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=154117

Week 2 of Playoffs ; 35-19 Wasaga (445.5) passing yards.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=206240

In real football, this just does not happen without injuries. If the game wants to reflect realistic possibilities then this is a statistical abboration outside the expected norms.

If it is outside the expected norms it is a bug by definition.

If this level of varience is within the intended norm, then why are we playing at all? On the AA level, if one team can improve 35 points in 9 games against another team who also has 9 games to improve, then something is not right. It becomes a game of random chance, not of skill.



I was replying to a specific question of why hadn't this happened before. I stand by my response.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Something to consider. My CB on the Werewolves had a speed in the high 70s, and agility in the mid to high 50s (vision over 50, and I think 7 in super vision). He was set on close/med pretty much all season, and we would run into teams that just ate him for lunch. We theorized that sometimes he was simply too fast to cover VERY agile receivers, and switched a bunch of his equipment from speed to agility.

He covers much closer now, and doesn't "orbit" slower very agile receivers.

I wonder if they simply had one receiver remove all their speed equipment and put it into agility. That WR doesn't look all that fast in the replays, and your CB pulls away at the snap of the ball in every play you pasted.

Be interesting to know.

PinTBC



This
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by wombat killer


Not necessarily. Could have been the first time the "bad luck" happened. You can read a 900 page thread about a QB that threw 9 interceptions in a playoff game last year. Everyone agreed he had a terrible build, but he never threw more than 2 picks in a game all season.


And that is a defense of the situation how? You just described another situation where performance does not match the build.

For me it comes down to this; Week 8 score; 29-0 Manitoba, (83) passing Yards
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=154117

Week 2 of Playoffs ; 35-19 Wasaga (445.5) passing yards.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=206240

In real football, this just does not happen without injuries. If the game wants to reflect realistic possibilities then this is a statistical abboration outside the expected norms.

If it is outside the expected norms it is a bug by definition.

If this level of varience is within the intended norm, then why are we playing at all? On the AA level, if one team can improve 35 points in 9 games against another team who also has 9 games to improve, then something is not right. It becomes a game of random chance, not of skill.




I only bring up the Steelers because I am most familiar with them, but here are 2 games from last year against the same Ravens:

Game 1: 38-7 Steelers - http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/boxscore?gameId=271105023
Game 2: 27-21 Ravens - http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/boxscore?gameId=271230033

That was only 8 weeks apart. 37 point swing! I hate the NFL now, because it is clearly bullshit and unrealistic. It's all random luck and no skill at all.

/sarcasm

 
Link
 
Every year this same thing happens when the teams that don't try in the regular season get serious and gameplan/distribute their points for the playoffs. lol.

You have no way of knowing if someone has spent their SP's or not - even if their level went up. So don't get too happy with your regular season wins.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Cryptotich

Originally posted by wombat killer



Not necessarily. Could have been the first time the "bad luck" happened. You can read a 900 page thread about a QB that threw 9 interceptions in a playoff game last year. Everyone agreed he had a terrible build, but he never threw more than 2 picks in a game all season.


And that is a defense of the situation how? You just described another situation where performance does not match the build.

For me it comes down to this; Week 8 score; 29-0 Manitoba, (83) passing Yards
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=154117

Week 2 of Playoffs ; 35-19 Wasaga (445.5) passing yards.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=206240

In real football, this just does not happen without injuries. If the game wants to reflect realistic possibilities then this is a statistical abboration outside the expected norms.

If it is outside the expected norms it is a bug by definition.

If this level of varience is within the intended norm, then why are we playing at all? On the AA level, if one team can improve 35 points in 9 games against another team who also has 9 games to improve, then something is not right. It becomes a game of random chance, not of skill.




I only bring up the Steelers because I am most familiar with them, but here are 2 games from last year against the same Ravens:

Game 1: 38-7 Steelers - http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/boxscore?gameId=271105023
Game 2: 27-21 Ravens - http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/boxscore?gameId=271230033

That was only 8 weeks apart. 37 point swing! I hate the NFL now, because it is clearly bullshit and unrealistic. It's all random luck and no skill at all.

/sarcasm



You would have a really great arguement there if it were not for the fact that BOTH teams had DIFFERENT starting QB's in the games you posted. First game was Ben Roethlisburger for Pittsburg, and Steve McNair for Baltimore, the second game started Charlie Batch for Pittsburg and Troy Smith for Baltimore.

In the GLB games in question both QBs were the same. In fact all the key players were the same. So the question is..... is it possible with the exp from 8 games to take your team of WRs and your QB from DuD to Stud while the opposing defense gets the same amout of points to improve?

In 8 games even if Wasaga did everything right, and Manitoba did everything wrong, build wise should the game be so lopsided? We are talking about 34th lvl players here. At that level there should not be that kind of variance in just 8 games.
Last edited Oct 28, 2008 00:57:42
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by wombat killer


Not necessarily. Could have been the first time the "bad luck" happened. You can read a 900 page thread about a QB that threw 9 interceptions in a playoff game last year. Everyone agreed he had a terrible build, but he never threw more than 2 picks in a game all season.


And that is a defense of the situation how? You just described another situation where performance does not match the build.

For me it comes down to this; Week 8 score; 29-0 Manitoba, (83) passing Yards
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=154117

Week 2 of Playoffs ; 35-19 Wasaga (445.5) passing yards.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=206240

In real football, this just does not happen without injuries. If the game wants to reflect realistic possibilities then this is a statistical abboration outside the expected norms.

If it is outside the expected norms it is a bug by definition.

If this level of varience is within the intended norm, then why are we playing at all? On the AA level, if one team can improve 35 points in 9 games against another team who also has 9 games to improve, then something is not right. It becomes a game of random chance, not of skill.



Pffft, this is easy.
You didn't plan for them to gamble in the passing game, and probably spent oodles of time concentrating on their running game. They gambled in the passing game. They outsmarted you, hence the win with less roster talent. I swear, every time a team gets upset, it must be a bug! Chalk it up as a lesson learned and move on.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by Cryptotich

Originally posted by wombat killer



Not necessarily. Could have been the first time the "bad luck" happened. You can read a 900 page thread about a QB that threw 9 interceptions in a playoff game last year. Everyone agreed he had a terrible build, but he never threw more than 2 picks in a game all season.


And that is a defense of the situation how? You just described another situation where performance does not match the build.

For me it comes down to this; Week 8 score; 29-0 Manitoba, (83) passing Yards
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=154117

Week 2 of Playoffs ; 35-19 Wasaga (445.5) passing yards.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=206240

In real football, this just does not happen without injuries. If the game wants to reflect realistic possibilities then this is a statistical abboration outside the expected norms.

If it is outside the expected norms it is a bug by definition.

If this level of varience is within the intended norm, then why are we playing at all? On the AA level, if one team can improve 35 points in 9 games against another team who also has 9 games to improve, then something is not right. It becomes a game of random chance, not of skill.



Pffft, this is easy.
You didn't plan for them to gamble in the passing game, and probably spent oodles of time concentrating on their running game. They gambled in the passing game. They outsmarted you, hence the win with less roster talent. I swear, every time a team gets upset, it must be a bug! Chalk it up as a lesson learned and move on.


Yep I mean how could a team that was beaten by a team in the regular season ever improve enough to beat them in the playoffs? It just doesn't seem fair.

 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UnsaidPlayer
Originally posted by Serenity

Possible he just got faked out by the WR or QB...

High interception numbers during the season isn't an accurate way to judge if your CB is good or not. It just means that the opposing team was throwing at him a lot.



You dont know....You have no clue how this game works..You are not even close to being half the DC I am..

Your post is just dumb and I ask that you go get Bort for me.

Unsaid-


Really? Is that so? Well, I do know how the game works and she's not far off. It does look like the CB was faked and INT's are not an accurate way to judge a CB's effectiveness... So... Apparently, your post is the dumb one and YOU have no clue how things work... Irony.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.