http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141987&pbp_id=8984688 - Oddly enough, our LOT somehow managed to save a sack in yesterdays game with a marvellous recovery after the initial false step.
Forum > Suggestions > How to improve Pass Blocking Assignments and still allow realistic levels of Pass Rush Pressure
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by winchester
Hey Mike, are you sure it is not the tunnel vision that is doing all of this just like pump fake in the past? I have seen guys with the speed build not getting anything till they start loading up on tunnel vision. I can send you the builds if you want them. They are about the same exp one has 9+ TV.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RT step backwards too far.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RG move to the LT position to pick up a blitzing CB.
Tunnel Vision does not cause the LG C RG HB and FB to all block the NT.
The reason DEs with high Tunnel Vision are getting massive sack numbers is that their build makes the most of what is a error in the Pass porotection design.
Tunnel Vison is not over powered in and of itself, but it is contributing to exposing the real issues by magnifying the results.
Hmmm...let's say that Bort checked and all the guys with huge numbers of sacks have 8+ TV. Wouldn't that suggest that TV has to be weakened some (not "nerfed" in the sense that it should still be a worthwhile SA, and in fact one would have to take care to make sure that it remained one, but weakened some)?
No one SA should be all that powerful.
Originally posted by winchester
Hey Mike, are you sure it is not the tunnel vision that is doing all of this just like pump fake in the past? I have seen guys with the speed build not getting anything till they start loading up on tunnel vision. I can send you the builds if you want them. They are about the same exp one has 9+ TV.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RT step backwards too far.
Tunnel Vision does not make the RG move to the LT position to pick up a blitzing CB.
Tunnel Vision does not cause the LG C RG HB and FB to all block the NT.
The reason DEs with high Tunnel Vision are getting massive sack numbers is that their build makes the most of what is a error in the Pass porotection design.
Tunnel Vison is not over powered in and of itself, but it is contributing to exposing the real issues by magnifying the results.
Hmmm...let's say that Bort checked and all the guys with huge numbers of sacks have 8+ TV. Wouldn't that suggest that TV has to be weakened some (not "nerfed" in the sense that it should still be a worthwhile SA, and in fact one would have to take care to make sure that it remained one, but weakened some)?
No one SA should be all that powerful.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 00:38:29
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ilok
i'm not saying limiting or capping the number of sacks someone can get, there needs to be nerfs made to speed rush DEs and passing to compensate along with upgrades to pass protection. There needs to be no way the best built DE against similar competition to get 30+ sacks in a season. There are Des getting 100+ DEs in a season, and it's not just because of poor pass protection.
The ones getting 100+ sacks per season, I'm with you on. That shouldn't happen.
But 30-40 should occur among the best GLB pass rushers.
The reason is that if you look at the leaders in anything, whether offensively or defensively, they'll always be better than the top real life players-- because there are more players and is less parity, etc..
The idea of trying to stop the top players at anything from doing better than the top real life players would ruin the game because of those factors. We had defensive domination in Season 3 because people had complained about the top rushers rushing for over 6 yards per carry or top QB's completing 80% of passes (though the latter wasn't as high as it sounded, as they were shorter passes than real life).
So both parts of offense got nerfed way too much.
With the lack of parity (including good and bad builds as well as everything else) and the number of players, the best ones should always outperform the best real life players.
The problem with the sack totals is the margin by which the best are outperforming the best real life players. The top sack guys should get 30 or 40 per season, maybe the best few on the site 50. No one should be getting 100, though, and some are. 100 sacks for a season would be the equivalent of a QB passing for an average of 600 yards per game or something.
i'm not saying limiting or capping the number of sacks someone can get, there needs to be nerfs made to speed rush DEs and passing to compensate along with upgrades to pass protection. There needs to be no way the best built DE against similar competition to get 30+ sacks in a season. There are Des getting 100+ DEs in a season, and it's not just because of poor pass protection.
The ones getting 100+ sacks per season, I'm with you on. That shouldn't happen.
But 30-40 should occur among the best GLB pass rushers.
The reason is that if you look at the leaders in anything, whether offensively or defensively, they'll always be better than the top real life players-- because there are more players and is less parity, etc..
The idea of trying to stop the top players at anything from doing better than the top real life players would ruin the game because of those factors. We had defensive domination in Season 3 because people had complained about the top rushers rushing for over 6 yards per carry or top QB's completing 80% of passes (though the latter wasn't as high as it sounded, as they were shorter passes than real life).
So both parts of offense got nerfed way too much.
With the lack of parity (including good and bad builds as well as everything else) and the number of players, the best ones should always outperform the best real life players.
The problem with the sack totals is the margin by which the best are outperforming the best real life players. The top sack guys should get 30 or 40 per season, maybe the best few on the site 50. No one should be getting 100, though, and some are. 100 sacks for a season would be the equivalent of a QB passing for an average of 600 yards per game or something.
No it really shouldnt at all Ken.
I would fully EXPECT the DEs with high Tunnel Vision to have the most sacks.
Tunnel Vision is simply the DE gaining an adrenaline rush when presented with a clear path to the QB.
That indicates the Pass protection has broken down.
That should result in a Sack/hurry.
The simple fact is the error is in the OLine not protecting the QB correctly, due to play design.
If the play design improves, and the DE is not presented with a clear path to the QB immediately, then the OTs can engage the DE.
It then becomes a contest of builds, which is exactly what it should be.
Tunnel vision is not the problem, but it leads to certain players 'Exploiting' the play design more than others.
I would fully EXPECT the DEs with high Tunnel Vision to have the most sacks.
Tunnel Vision is simply the DE gaining an adrenaline rush when presented with a clear path to the QB.
That indicates the Pass protection has broken down.
That should result in a Sack/hurry.
The simple fact is the error is in the OLine not protecting the QB correctly, due to play design.
If the play design improves, and the DE is not presented with a clear path to the QB immediately, then the OTs can engage the DE.
It then becomes a contest of builds, which is exactly what it should be.
Tunnel vision is not the problem, but it leads to certain players 'Exploiting' the play design more than others.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 00:56:41
slydersneak
offline
offline
the OT's are restricted by their build nature, a high speed OT doesn't get the same bonus as a speed DE, I'm doing an experiment at the moment to prove this but by the time he gets there it should be decided
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by slydersneak
the OT's are restricted by their build nature, a high speed OT doesn't get the same bonus as a speed DE, I'm doing an experiment at the moment to prove this but by the time he gets there it should be decided
A speed OT doesn't have anything like the number of speed based SA's to help him out, which makes the experiment a bit defunct as we kind of know that already - but carry on
I'm sure if an OT has more speed and agility he would be able to correct the mistake of the engine a little, but that doesn't change the fact that it's a mistake of the engine.
the OT's are restricted by their build nature, a high speed OT doesn't get the same bonus as a speed DE, I'm doing an experiment at the moment to prove this but by the time he gets there it should be decided
A speed OT doesn't have anything like the number of speed based SA's to help him out, which makes the experiment a bit defunct as we kind of know that already - but carry on

I'm sure if an OT has more speed and agility he would be able to correct the mistake of the engine a little, but that doesn't change the fact that it's a mistake of the engine.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
No it really shouldnt at all Ken.
I would fully EXPECT the DEs with high Tunnel Vision to have the most sacks.
Tunnel Vision is simply the DE gaining an adrenaline rush when presented with a clear path to the QB.
That indicates the Pass protection has broken down.
That should result in a Sack/hurry.
The simple fact is the error is in the OLine not protecting the QB correctly, due to play design.
If the play design improves, and the DE is not presented with a clear path to the QB immediately, then the OTs can engage the DE.
It then becomes a contest of builds, which is exactly what it should be.
Tunnel vision is not the problem, but it leads to certain players 'Exploiting' the play design more than others.
Okay, it's a point to think about, because what you're saying is to make the DE work harder for the clear path to the QB, but let TV work when the path exists.
I know specifically that my DE build was set up to get the path; I didn't want to get too TV-heavy because I'm not a fan of SA's that have to "trigger" rather than others that add a constant bonus (although I have a feeling I know where some points from my DE's next boost will be going....)
But I guess it works if DE's have to work harder for the clear path as well.
No it really shouldnt at all Ken.
I would fully EXPECT the DEs with high Tunnel Vision to have the most sacks.
Tunnel Vision is simply the DE gaining an adrenaline rush when presented with a clear path to the QB.
That indicates the Pass protection has broken down.
That should result in a Sack/hurry.
The simple fact is the error is in the OLine not protecting the QB correctly, due to play design.
If the play design improves, and the DE is not presented with a clear path to the QB immediately, then the OTs can engage the DE.
It then becomes a contest of builds, which is exactly what it should be.
Tunnel vision is not the problem, but it leads to certain players 'Exploiting' the play design more than others.
Okay, it's a point to think about, because what you're saying is to make the DE work harder for the clear path to the QB, but let TV work when the path exists.
I know specifically that my DE build was set up to get the path; I didn't want to get too TV-heavy because I'm not a fan of SA's that have to "trigger" rather than others that add a constant bonus (although I have a feeling I know where some points from my DE's next boost will be going....)
But I guess it works if DE's have to work harder for the clear path as well.
Originally posted by slydersneak
the OT's are restricted by their build nature, a high speed OT doesn't get the same bonus as a speed DE, I'm doing an experiment at the moment to prove this but by the time he gets there it should be decided
Its simple Maths.
The play is designed to have the OT step back 2 yards regardless of the DEs action.
If the DE just goes inside you have the following situation.
OT = Step back 2 yards, then step forwards 2 yards.
DE = step forwards 1 yard.
This results in the OT needing to be 4 times faster than the DE he is covering in order to be able to touch him.
And considering the DEs has all those lovely speed boosting SAs.....
the OT's are restricted by their build nature, a high speed OT doesn't get the same bonus as a speed DE, I'm doing an experiment at the moment to prove this but by the time he gets there it should be decided
Its simple Maths.
The play is designed to have the OT step back 2 yards regardless of the DEs action.
If the DE just goes inside you have the following situation.
OT = Step back 2 yards, then step forwards 2 yards.
DE = step forwards 1 yard.
This results in the OT needing to be 4 times faster than the DE he is covering in order to be able to touch him.
And considering the DEs has all those lovely speed boosting SAs.....
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 01:11:52
slydersneak
offline
offline
I'm trying an experiment to prove this or whether the sim has it wrong
sorry missed the last post
sorry missed the last post
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 01:11:51
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ilok
i'm not saying limiting or capping the number of sacks someone can get, there needs to be nerfs made to speed rush DEs and passing to compensate along with upgrades to pass protection. There needs to be no way the best built DE against similar competition to get 30+ sacks in a season. There are Des getting 100+ DEs in a season, and it's not just because of poor pass protection.
This sort of thing will always be the case...there will be unrealistic numbers at the extreme ends. It is an inevitable part of this sort of game...real parity exists for only a few teams in each league, and the gap of disparity between even the best teams and worst teams in a league will generally be very large.
I don't think you will ever get away from it entirely...you can only hope to limit it somewhat.
Things can be better than they are now.
You would (or should) make the same argument about QBs with 7000 yards passing and HBs with 3500 yards rushing, presumably. The same answer applies...you just wont get that level of parity in a game like this.
i'm not saying limiting or capping the number of sacks someone can get, there needs to be nerfs made to speed rush DEs and passing to compensate along with upgrades to pass protection. There needs to be no way the best built DE against similar competition to get 30+ sacks in a season. There are Des getting 100+ DEs in a season, and it's not just because of poor pass protection.
This sort of thing will always be the case...there will be unrealistic numbers at the extreme ends. It is an inevitable part of this sort of game...real parity exists for only a few teams in each league, and the gap of disparity between even the best teams and worst teams in a league will generally be very large.
I don't think you will ever get away from it entirely...you can only hope to limit it somewhat.
Things can be better than they are now.
You would (or should) make the same argument about QBs with 7000 yards passing and HBs with 3500 yards rushing, presumably. The same answer applies...you just wont get that level of parity in a game like this.
hemprobot
offline
offline
I rarely say this but MikeRogers is pretty much bang on here. There doesn't need to be a nerf of DE's at all, the high speed/ag pass rush build is perfectly valid, but the O-Line and backfield blocking needs to be redesigned to cope with it. At the moment it's all wrong in that it creates unrealistic gaps and allows Tunnel Vision to activate early and too frequently.
happylittletrees
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Ilok
i'm not saying limiting or capping the number of sacks someone can get, there needs to be nerfs made to speed rush DEs and passing to compensate along with upgrades to pass protection. There needs to be no way the best built DE against similar competition to get 30+ sacks in a season. There are Des getting 100+ DEs in a season, and it's not just because of poor pass protection.
The ones getting 100+ sacks per season, I'm with you on. That shouldn't happen.
But 30-40 should occur among the best GLB pass rushers.
I don't agree with 30-40 sacks being sucessful, 20-30 should be an acceptable amount for the best of the best since only twice has someone gotten more than 20 sacks in a season in the nfl, jared allen led the league last year with 15 1/2 sacks, so thirty is double that, think about it
Originally posted by Ilok
i'm not saying limiting or capping the number of sacks someone can get, there needs to be nerfs made to speed rush DEs and passing to compensate along with upgrades to pass protection. There needs to be no way the best built DE against similar competition to get 30+ sacks in a season. There are Des getting 100+ DEs in a season, and it's not just because of poor pass protection.
The ones getting 100+ sacks per season, I'm with you on. That shouldn't happen.
But 30-40 should occur among the best GLB pass rushers.
I don't agree with 30-40 sacks being sucessful, 20-30 should be an acceptable amount for the best of the best since only twice has someone gotten more than 20 sacks in a season in the nfl, jared allen led the league last year with 15 1/2 sacks, so thirty is double that, think about it
Koncorde
offline
offline
This game isn't the NFL. What's the record for sacks in the High School and College systems?
happylittletrees
offline
offline
high school I don't know(theres way to many in the country to count), but terrell suggs holds the record in college with 26 which is still less than 30 and 14 less than 40, and before suggs broke that record it was only like 22, which stayed for almost 30 years
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 06:27:01
Originally posted by Koncorde
This game isn't the NFL. What's the record for sacks in the High School and College systems?
Even that is not a fair comparison, to tell the truth.
What would the record be in a 16 team Conference where 6 teams are from the NFL, 6 are NCAA Div I , and 2 are from High School?
Thats what 90% of the leagues are like here in GLB.
This game isn't the NFL. What's the record for sacks in the High School and College systems?
Even that is not a fair comparison, to tell the truth.
What would the record be in a 16 team Conference where 6 teams are from the NFL, 6 are NCAA Div I , and 2 are from High School?
Thats what 90% of the leagues are like here in GLB.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























