Playoff record should be all that matters, regular season is a formality. Post season is the real season.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The new promotion system
tjsexkitten82
offline
offline
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by tjking82
Here's the point: YOU KNOW AHEAD OF TIME. THE SCRIMMAGES THIS YEAR MATTER. ACT ACCORDINGLY.
How is this unfair or nonsensical? Now the games mean something, and everybody knows. Use the scrimmages at the beginning of the year to test tactics.
This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.
Also, no need to get angry about it I really don't see a need for the caps.
Sorry, it was just such a dumb objection. Nobody's going to use them for tactics this year, they're going to be real games and everybody's going to treat them that way. So not a big deal at all.
Originally posted by tjking82
Here's the point: YOU KNOW AHEAD OF TIME. THE SCRIMMAGES THIS YEAR MATTER. ACT ACCORDINGLY.
How is this unfair or nonsensical? Now the games mean something, and everybody knows. Use the scrimmages at the beginning of the year to test tactics.
This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.
Also, no need to get angry about it I really don't see a need for the caps.
Sorry, it was just such a dumb objection. Nobody's going to use them for tactics this year, they're going to be real games and everybody's going to treat them that way. So not a big deal at all.
douglasiv
offline
offline
Will conferences stay the same, can western conference teams only fill vacancies in the west or can they fill eastern conference slots too?
MrMoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
Playoff record should be all that matters, regular season is a formality. Post season is the real season.
That's the mindset we're in because that is what GLB has promoted for the first four seasons. But if regular season is just a formality, again, why even have it? Why not just have four sets of playoff brackets every 40 days instead of wasting time with a formality?
And if regular season is "just a formality", why are you so excited that CWM is doing so well in the regular season
Playoff record should be all that matters, regular season is a formality. Post season is the real season.
That's the mindset we're in because that is what GLB has promoted for the first four seasons. But if regular season is just a formality, again, why even have it? Why not just have four sets of playoff brackets every 40 days instead of wasting time with a formality?
And if regular season is "just a formality", why are you so excited that CWM is doing so well in the regular season

StoutOne
offline
offline
Originally posted by MrMoose
Right, I realize that is how it currently is. Regular season NEEDS to mean something, though. Claiming regular season means nothing as a way to say that a 10-6 team last season was better than a very dominant 15-1 team is flawed. If regular season is that meaningless, why don't we just chuck out those 16 games and have constant tournament brackets on GLB instead?
Please inform me of any sport or game where the regular season is dependent on more than who plays in the post season?
Especially in GLB where teams are capable of holding off on boosts until playoffs to show their true greatness.
Right, I realize that is how it currently is. Regular season NEEDS to mean something, though. Claiming regular season means nothing as a way to say that a 10-6 team last season was better than a very dominant 15-1 team is flawed. If regular season is that meaningless, why don't we just chuck out those 16 games and have constant tournament brackets on GLB instead?
Please inform me of any sport or game where the regular season is dependent on more than who plays in the post season?
Especially in GLB where teams are capable of holding off on boosts until playoffs to show their true greatness.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:35:15
BuddyHorn
offline
offline
If the 16-0 team loses so what. they stay behind. I have had it happen to me. I could have it happen again this year. all that matters is w-l
tjsexkitten82
offline
offline
Originally posted by nfratami
This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.
Also, no need to get angry about it I really don't see a need for the caps.
Dude. You can count the number of times a 16-0 team has lost to an 8-8 team on one hand. You keep using the word "lucky." I'm sorry, but luck doesn't fix that big of a gap. If you lose to an 8-8 team, they boosted AND you got flat outschemed, and you should fire your OC and DC stat.
In summary: Not luck. Your fault.
This doesn't change the fact(unless further clarification is given), that an 8-8 team that gets lucky and wins 1 playoff game then loses their next will be above a 16-0 team that lost their first playoff game on the promotion list.
Also, no need to get angry about it I really don't see a need for the caps.
Dude. You can count the number of times a 16-0 team has lost to an 8-8 team on one hand. You keep using the word "lucky." I'm sorry, but luck doesn't fix that big of a gap. If you lose to an 8-8 team, they boosted AND you got flat outschemed, and you should fire your OC and DC stat.
In summary: Not luck. Your fault.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:36:28
BuddyHorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
Playoff record should be all that matters, regular season is a formality. Post season is the real season.
That's the mindset we're in because that is what GLB has promoted for the first four seasons. But if regular season is just a formality, again, why even have it? Why not just have four sets of playoff brackets every 40 days instead of wasting time with a formality?
And if regular season is "just a formality", why are you so excited that CWM is doing so well in the regular season
because I know its a pre curser to the post season.
Remember, on indianola legends, I went 16-0 and lost in the second round to a team inferior to ours. it happens you win, you get the goodies.
Hell, look at the Cowboys and Giants last year.
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
Playoff record should be all that matters, regular season is a formality. Post season is the real season.
That's the mindset we're in because that is what GLB has promoted for the first four seasons. But if regular season is just a formality, again, why even have it? Why not just have four sets of playoff brackets every 40 days instead of wasting time with a formality?
And if regular season is "just a formality", why are you so excited that CWM is doing so well in the regular season

because I know its a pre curser to the post season.
Remember, on indianola legends, I went 16-0 and lost in the second round to a team inferior to ours. it happens you win, you get the goodies.
Hell, look at the Cowboys and Giants last year.
MrMoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by StoutOne
Please inform me of any sport or game where the regular season is dependent on more than who plays in the post season?
Especially in GLB where teams are capable of holding off on boosts until playoffs.
Please inform me of any sport or game where players can't be injured and knocked out of an entire season. Please inform me of any sport (insert other non-realistic aspect of GLB here). GLB is not a real sport, it is a simulation of one, and one that is supposed to be a game. In real sports, the concept of home field advantage is huge. For example, in the NFL, the teams with the two best records in each conference only have to play two playoff games while the other teams have to play three. Also, the idea of the 12th man is very real in the NFL, and playing in front of your own fans really is a big deal, and can help spur a team on to victory.
So actually, the regular season matters far more in most 'real sports' than it does here in GLB.
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
If the 16-0 team loses so what. they stay behind. I have had it happen to me. I could have it happen again this year. all that matters is w-l
The idea of promotions was, I thought, to get the best teams in the pro leagues, then the next best in AAA, and down the line? Is the better team the one that lucked out and won in the first round of the playoffs, or the one that dominated the regular season and happened to finally have a single bad game in the playoffs? I mean, I hate the Patriots and all, but they really were a better team last season than the Giants -- they just happened to have a bad game in the Super Bowl. That proved the Giants were better that one game, but that doesn't make them the clear cut better team.
Please inform me of any sport or game where the regular season is dependent on more than who plays in the post season?
Especially in GLB where teams are capable of holding off on boosts until playoffs.
Please inform me of any sport or game where players can't be injured and knocked out of an entire season. Please inform me of any sport (insert other non-realistic aspect of GLB here). GLB is not a real sport, it is a simulation of one, and one that is supposed to be a game. In real sports, the concept of home field advantage is huge. For example, in the NFL, the teams with the two best records in each conference only have to play two playoff games while the other teams have to play three. Also, the idea of the 12th man is very real in the NFL, and playing in front of your own fans really is a big deal, and can help spur a team on to victory.
So actually, the regular season matters far more in most 'real sports' than it does here in GLB.
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
If the 16-0 team loses so what. they stay behind. I have had it happen to me. I could have it happen again this year. all that matters is w-l
The idea of promotions was, I thought, to get the best teams in the pro leagues, then the next best in AAA, and down the line? Is the better team the one that lucked out and won in the first round of the playoffs, or the one that dominated the regular season and happened to finally have a single bad game in the playoffs? I mean, I hate the Patriots and all, but they really were a better team last season than the Giants -- they just happened to have a bad game in the Super Bowl. That proved the Giants were better that one game, but that doesn't make them the clear cut better team.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:39:24
BuddyHorn
offline
offline
regular season does matter. it sets up the seeding and the money for the post season. Injuries in GLB would be the suck. Not for me since I own like 20 players, but the guys with one would hate this game if their dude got injured.
Home field advantage is a gaping absence in this game.
Home field advantage is a gaping absence in this game.
Sarg01
offline
offline
Originally posted by MrMoose
The idea of promotions was, I thought, to get the best teams in the pro leagues, then the next best in AAA, and down the line? Is the better team the one that lucked out and won in the first round of the playoffs, or the one that dominated the regular season and happened to finally have a single bad game in the playoffs? I mean, I hate the Patriots and all, but they really were a better team last season than the Giants -- they just happened to have a bad game in the Super Bowl. That proved the Giants were better that one game, but that doesn't make them the clear cut better team.
Well then, why have the playoffs? Clearly the #1 seed is the best and should be promoted without all that messy championship stuff.
The idea of promotions was, I thought, to get the best teams in the pro leagues, then the next best in AAA, and down the line? Is the better team the one that lucked out and won in the first round of the playoffs, or the one that dominated the regular season and happened to finally have a single bad game in the playoffs? I mean, I hate the Patriots and all, but they really were a better team last season than the Giants -- they just happened to have a bad game in the Super Bowl. That proved the Giants were better that one game, but that doesn't make them the clear cut better team.
Well then, why have the playoffs? Clearly the #1 seed is the best and should be promoted without all that messy championship stuff.
MrMoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
regular season does matter. it sets up the seeding and the money for the post season. Injuries in GLB would be the suck. Not for me since I own like 20 players, but the guys with one would hate this game if their dude got injured.
Home field advantage is a gaping absence in this game.
I agree, injuries would suck. I was simply trying to make the point that arguing from a basis of real sports not rewarding teams much for regular season performance is a faulty base for argument.
regular season does matter. it sets up the seeding and the money for the post season. Injuries in GLB would be the suck. Not for me since I own like 20 players, but the guys with one would hate this game if their dude got injured.
Home field advantage is a gaping absence in this game.
I agree, injuries would suck. I was simply trying to make the point that arguing from a basis of real sports not rewarding teams much for regular season performance is a faulty base for argument.
BuddyHorn
offline
offline
Moose, any time you have a tangible result to go by instead of objectivity i would rather have the winner get the goods then allow a dude with a balloon decide who is good and who is not.
MrMoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sarg01
Well then, why have the playoffs? Clearly the #1 seed is the best and should be promoted without all that messy championship stuff.
Never once said that. But when you're bringing down weaker teams and trying to get the strongest teams up in the pros, you should be bringing up the best teams, not the lucky ones.
I support the idea of promoting the team that makes it through the playoffs and promotes that way, since a lucky team is likely not going to hit the luck jackpot three times in a row. But if they hit it once, against a good team, they are not the better team overall -- they were the better team that one game.
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
Moose, any time you have a tangible result to go by instead of objectivity i would rather have the winner get the goods then allow a dude with a balloon decide who is good and who is not.
How is regular season record not a tangible result? I'd think 16 games do a better job of determining who the best team(s) that didn't win the conference are, as opposed to a single game in the playoffs. In the regular season, a single screwjob from the sim shouldn't hurt your record, where a single screwjob in the playoffs suddenly makes you worse than all the teams ahead of you.
Well then, why have the playoffs? Clearly the #1 seed is the best and should be promoted without all that messy championship stuff.
Never once said that. But when you're bringing down weaker teams and trying to get the strongest teams up in the pros, you should be bringing up the best teams, not the lucky ones.
I support the idea of promoting the team that makes it through the playoffs and promotes that way, since a lucky team is likely not going to hit the luck jackpot three times in a row. But if they hit it once, against a good team, they are not the better team overall -- they were the better team that one game.
Originally posted by BuddyHorn
Moose, any time you have a tangible result to go by instead of objectivity i would rather have the winner get the goods then allow a dude with a balloon decide who is good and who is not.
How is regular season record not a tangible result? I'd think 16 games do a better job of determining who the best team(s) that didn't win the conference are, as opposed to a single game in the playoffs. In the regular season, a single screwjob from the sim shouldn't hurt your record, where a single screwjob in the playoffs suddenly makes you worse than all the teams ahead of you.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:44:38
nfratami
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sarg01
Don't lose to the #8 seed and you don't have that problem. If you do lose to that #8 seed (who clearly is either 8-8 or worse in your scenario, because they're the worst team that made the playoffs) then why shouldn't they promote ahead of you.
Originally posted by Nixx
If the 16-0 team lost that fast maybe they don't deserve to be promoted, eh?
Originally posted by StoutOne
Regular season means nothing really, except which teams make the playofs and which get relegated.
Other than that, playoffs are the only games that have meaning.
First let me say that my team(s) aside, I'd prefer not to get promoted in this manner(I want the trophy) so I'm actually arguing for something I wouldn't want to happen to my team(s).
All of your arguments fall short and aren't really hitting the point, this system is/was said/should be designed to bring the best teams up, and make leagues the most competitive.
I am simply pointing out a loophole that with some luck, a lesser team gets promoted to a league they don't deserve to be in. We aren't talking about what team had the best game here or there, we want the best teams in Pro leagues, do we not?
Originally posted by StoutOne
Please inform me of any sport or game where the regular season is dependent on more than who plays in the post season?
Especially in GLB where teams are capable of holding off on boosts until playoffs to show their true greatness.
Please inform me of any sport where "scrimmages" mean more than the regular season, I have never said that the post season should matter less than the regular season, just that scrimmages shouldn't matter more than the regular season.
Don't lose to the #8 seed and you don't have that problem. If you do lose to that #8 seed (who clearly is either 8-8 or worse in your scenario, because they're the worst team that made the playoffs) then why shouldn't they promote ahead of you.
Originally posted by Nixx
If the 16-0 team lost that fast maybe they don't deserve to be promoted, eh?
Originally posted by StoutOne
Regular season means nothing really, except which teams make the playofs and which get relegated.
Other than that, playoffs are the only games that have meaning.
First let me say that my team(s) aside, I'd prefer not to get promoted in this manner(I want the trophy) so I'm actually arguing for something I wouldn't want to happen to my team(s).
All of your arguments fall short and aren't really hitting the point, this system is/was said/should be designed to bring the best teams up, and make leagues the most competitive.
I am simply pointing out a loophole that with some luck, a lesser team gets promoted to a league they don't deserve to be in. We aren't talking about what team had the best game here or there, we want the best teams in Pro leagues, do we not?
Originally posted by StoutOne
Please inform me of any sport or game where the regular season is dependent on more than who plays in the post season?
Especially in GLB where teams are capable of holding off on boosts until playoffs to show their true greatness.
Please inform me of any sport where "scrimmages" mean more than the regular season, I have never said that the post season should matter less than the regular season, just that scrimmages shouldn't matter more than the regular season.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























