Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Needs to be explained more imo.
Well, with less vitriol than VT (
), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.
It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.
Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.
*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.
First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.
There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.
I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.
You should describe yourself as agnostic then...not atheist.
atheist = believes in no God existing
agnostic = not sure, but has no proof to support belief in God
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Needs to be explained more imo.
Well, with less vitriol than VT (
), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable. It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.
Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.
*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.
First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.
There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.
I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.
You should describe yourself as agnostic then...not atheist.
atheist = believes in no God existing
agnostic = not sure, but has no proof to support belief in God





























