User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.



You should describe yourself as agnostic then...not atheist.

atheist = believes in no God existing
agnostic = not sure, but has no proof to support belief in God
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by X

Originally posted by Asheme


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.


It's the most logical in the same way a raindrop compares to the ocean. That is to say, you're dealing with something so huge, that the info we have is as close to useless as possible.

A firm belief in anything on that level is pretty lol.


Not at all. It is the most logical because there has never been any evidence of anything supernatural in our natural world. There has to be a point after the entirety of the history of man that somebody can point to as clear evidence of supernatural forces at work before I'll say "ok, so maybe". Until then every thing is either explained/unexplained and not natural/super natural to me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Yeremiah

If there was a god he wouldn't have let my kitten die.


I'm sure this was a joke, but this is very often why people logically reason that God doesn't exist (loss of a loved one, or serious other bad thing happen in their life).

They use their flawed human thinking as VT put it to conclude that God couldn't exist. Then they look for ways to back up their argument for the rest of their life for when one of the asshole Christians (yes there are some) says something, they can have their great logic lined up.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
I never understood why Christians can't believe that god created evolution. Win - win situation, IMO.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by X

Originally posted by Asheme


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.



You should describe yourself as agnostic then...not atheist.

atheist = believes in no God existing
agnostic = not sure, but has no proof to support belief in God


Wrong. Completely incorrect definitions of the two. Agnostics believe that a super natural being is possible but outside the scope of human understanding right now. The word "agnostic" literally means "without knowledge. Atheism is just the lack of a theistic belief literally meaning "without religion". Atheism is not the belief that no god exists.

I have been both in my life but am most certainly an atheist now.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 18:58:58
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
I am about to write completely incorrect definitions of the two.


FYP
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by X


Originally posted by Asheme



Originally posted by SteelersInsider




Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.


It's the most logical in the same way a raindrop compares to the ocean. That is to say, you're dealing with something so huge, that the info we have is as close to useless as possible.

A firm belief in anything on that level is pretty lol.


Not at all. It is the most logical because there has never been any evidence of anything supernatural in our natural world. There has to be a point after the entirety of the history of man that somebody can point to as clear evidence of supernatural forces at work before I'll say "ok, so maybe". Until then every thing is either explained/unexplained and not natural/super natural to me.


Huh? You can't prove something, only disprove it. In this case, the scope of the experiment is so large, and our knowledge so limited that we have no way to measure.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X


Not at all. It is the most logical because there has never been any evidence of anything supernatural in our natural world. There has to be a point after the entirety of the history of man that somebody can point to as clear evidence of supernatural forces at work before I'll say "ok, so maybe". Until then every thing is either explained/unexplained and not natural/super natural to me.


How about the randomness that would be involved to create a working eye-ball or kidney or pancreas? How many genetic missteps would have to occur with variations of lungs and a brain before there was finally ones that worked properly?

And if it wasn't all planned out in our DNA to evolve this way, then why aren't there people running around with variations of those organs? Slightly smaller lungs that did something a little better? Maybe some people that had a 3 eyes or 4 eyes? Why stop at only 2? How about 4 arms instead of 2?

It just seems that the perfectness of all the things that came about as we understand more and more leads me to believe it was all a master plan....and not just random.

The more and more science uncovers in cell structure and DNA info, the more sure I am that there is a God. But that's just me.

I won't think you are an idiot if you don't agree with me.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 19:03:35
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by X



Not at all. It is the most logical because there has never been any evidence of anything supernatural in our natural world. There has to be a point after the entirety of the history of man that somebody can point to as clear evidence of supernatural forces at work before I'll say "ok, so maybe". Until then every thing is either explained/unexplained and not natural/super natural to me.


How about the randomness that would be involved to create a working eye-ball or kidney or pancreas? How many genetic missteps would have to occur with variations of lungs and a brain before there was finally ones that worked properly?

And if it wasn't all planned out in our DNA to evolve this way, then why aren't there people running around with variations of those organs? Slightly smaller lungs that did something a little better? Maybe some people that had a 3 eyes or 4 eyes? Why stop at only 2? How about 4 arms instead of 2?

It just seems that the perfectness of all the things that came about as we understand more and more leads me to believe it was all a master plan....and not just random.

The more and more science uncovers in cell structure and DNA info, the more sure I am that there is a God. But that's just me.

I won't think you are an idiot if you don't agree with me.


Well of course it worked out, it doesn't matter how unlikely. If it hadn't, you and I wouldn't be here to talk about it. As for how it worked, evolution isn't really a hard theory. If it worked, it survived, if not, we don't see it again.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by X

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by X



Originally posted by Asheme




Originally posted by SteelersInsider





Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.


It's the most logical in the same way a raindrop compares to the ocean. That is to say, you're dealing with something so huge, that the info we have is as close to useless as possible.

A firm belief in anything on that level is pretty lol.


Not at all. It is the most logical because there has never been any evidence of anything supernatural in our natural world. There has to be a point after the entirety of the history of man that somebody can point to as clear evidence of supernatural forces at work before I'll say "ok, so maybe". Until then every thing is either explained/unexplained and not natural/super natural to me.


Huh? You can't prove something, only disprove it. In this case, the scope of the experiment is so large, and our knowledge so limited that we have no way to measure.


I never said anything about proving or disproving anything.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Originally posted by X

I am about to write completely incorrect definitions of the two.


FYP


lol
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by X


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by X




Originally posted by Asheme





Originally posted by SteelersInsider






Needs to be explained more imo.

Well, with less vitriol than VT (), what I mean by that is that a knowledge claim is a knowledge claim, and both theists and atheists are claiming to know something unknowable.

It is a perfect microcosm of the most common problem people run into while trying to debate religious/spiritual matters, which is trying to take an irrational belief to a rational level.

Humans, for some reason, feel the need to validate their belief by taking it into the realm of reason/logic, which is ludicrous. If you believe in an/many unseen forces, than you have an irrational belief. There's nothing wrong with that, not in the least, but one must make peace with the fact that human logic will not allow for that, and your belief must dwell outside of its confines.


*bzzz* Wrong answer. Kinda.

First off, atheist aren't claiming to know something that in unknowable. Well, not all atheists.

There are many different kind of atheists all with varying philosophies, true, so there are those out there that believe that there is no god. That's not the textbook definition of atheism, though, and not what many atheists are. Many/most, like me, just lack a fundamental belief in a higher supernatural being. This isn't the same thing as believe that one doesn't exist. The difference is in the lack in belief not the belief in the lack. While some might think the difference subtle it is very central to many atheist's philosophies.

I do take some umbrage with your last paraphrase, though. I do, most certainly interject much reason/logic into my "belief system (hate using that phrase)" because that is my world view. I don't believe in the natural/supernatural. I believe in the explained/the yet to be explained by natural phenomenon. Many things that through the history of man were attributed to supernatural forces were later explained by natural forces. I believe in the natural world. I believe that anything that has yet to be explained by natural phenomenon isn't supernatural but is only outside our scope of knowledge right now. I reached that conclusion because it is the most logical.


It's the most logical in the same way a raindrop compares to the ocean. That is to say, you're dealing with something so huge, that the info we have is as close to useless as possible.

A firm belief in anything on that level is pretty lol.


Not at all. It is the most logical because there has never been any evidence of anything supernatural in our natural world. There has to be a point after the entirety of the history of man that somebody can point to as clear evidence of supernatural forces at work before I'll say "ok, so maybe". Until then every thing is either explained/unexplained and not natural/super natural to me.


Huh? You can't prove something, only disprove it. In this case, the scope of the experiment is so large, and our knowledge so limited that we have no way to measure.


I never said anything about proving or disproving anything.


So we don't base our beliefs on what we can prove now?
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
It just seems that the perfectness of all the things that came about as we understand more and more leads me to believe it was all a master plan....and not just random.


The complexity and delicate balance of life is hardly compelling evidence. Creationism is certainly an elegant and beautiful story, I'll give you that, but not much more than that.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

How about the randomness that would be involved to create a working eye-ball or kidney or pancreas? How many genetic missteps would have to occur with variations of lungs and a brain before there was finally ones that worked properly?

And if it wasn't all planned out in our DNA to evolve this way, then why aren't there people running around with variations of those organs? Slightly smaller lungs that did something a little better? Maybe some people that had a 3 eyes or 4 eyes? Why stop at only 2? How about 4 arms instead of 2?

It just seems that the perfectness of all the things that came about as we understand more and more leads me to believe it was all a master plan....and not just random.

The more and more science uncovers in cell structure and DNA info, the more sure I am that there is a God. But that's just me.

I won't think you are an idiot if you don't agree with me.


Are you seriously using "the human is complicated so god exists"?
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
How about the randomness that would be involved to create a working eye-ball or kidney or pancreas? How many genetic missteps would have to occur with variations of lungs and a brain before there was finally ones that worked properly?


About a billion years worth.


Originally posted by SteelersInsider
And if it wasn't all planned out in our DNA to evolve this way, then why aren't there people running around with variations of those organs? Slightly smaller lungs that did something a little better? Maybe some people that had a 3 eyes or 4 eyes? Why stop at only 2? How about 4 arms instead of 2?


There are people like that. Ever heard of an enlarged heart? How about down syndrome? Gigantism? I could go on all day.


Originally posted by SteelersInsider
It just seems that the perfectness of all the things that came about as we understand more and more leads me to believe it was all a master plan....and not just random.


You think living organisms are perfect? Sweet jesus, you have low standards.


Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The more and more science uncovers in cell structure and DNA info, the more sure I am that there is a God. But that's just me.


I find people often can't comprehend evolution because of a lack of understanding of very large numbers and probability (which is very common - they aren't exactly easy ideas to wrap your head around). When people can't comprehend something, attributing it to a "higher power" is also a typical outcome.


Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I won't think you are an idiot if you don't agree with me.


I'm not as magnanimous as you are...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.