User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
Link
 
As I stated earlier, I saw the same problem like OP. It didn't cost me a game and I didn't bother to post it since OP already showed a legit case here.

I'm wondering it may relate to my defense AI being complicated.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 18:55:30
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Yes, as I stated earlier, I saw the same problem. It didn't cost me a game and I didn't bother to post it since OP already showed a legit case here.

I'm wondering it may relate to my defense AI being complicated.


(the more complex, the more chances for error)

I never saw the link to the plays where it happened to you?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Yes, as I stated earlier, I saw the same problem. It didn't cost me a game and I didn't bother to post it since OP already showed a legit case here.

I'm wondering it may relate to my defense AI being complicated.


(the more complex, the more chances for error)

I never saw the link to the plays where it happened to you?


No matter how complicated the AI is, defense AI tester should be consistent to in-game play, shouldn't it? You seem to still think the problem is on what people think their AI should do, instead of what defense AI tester reporting something different.

I'll need to go back to find out the play having problem, but I don't plan to spend time finding it since I believe OP already had a legit case here.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 19:03:12
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


I hear what you are saying, your point is, the user is saying he didn't make a mistake. Based on the fact that he didn't make a mistake, it must be a bug. Everyone else has used the same logic.

It is unfortunate that hazy thinks his gameplans are so valuable that he doesn't trust his GM to take a look when he is having an error.

There really are no secrets to AI plays in this game though. You can watch other teams and copy exactly what they are doing.


Again, you misunderstand the two different things:

(1) What OP thought his AI would do
(2) What defense AI tester reported what play should be called

The case here is (2). It's not what OP thought, it is what defense AI tester reported that was different to in-game play. Other than inputting wrong data, defense AI tester should be consistent to in-game play, shouldn't it? Again, do you see any inputs wrong that OP provided? Do you have to see a snapshot of something to agree that his defense AI tester inputs are correct?



The error is almost always in the dropdown boxes in the play that the AI tester chooses.

I don't think the OP ever shared what those fields were. Even if he did, it doesn't mean that they are correctly selected.

What if he blitzed all 8 guys? The AI would reject that and say that isn't possible and run the next play in the list.

What if he has 6 guys that could each blitz 30% of the time? What happens when 5 of those guys are chosen or all 6? This would explain why a chosen field only gives an "error" part of the time - because the OP is only choosing a scenario that is impossible part of the time.

One thing it could be is that he is blitzing someone that can't blitz in the sceme he wants to run.

Did he list the blitzing %'s? I didn't see them.

Explain why this couldn't be the user error here.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 19:03:24
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw


Yes, as I stated earlier, I saw the same problem. It didn't cost me a game and I didn't bother to post it since OP already showed a legit case here.

I'm wondering it may relate to my defense AI being complicated.


(the more complex, the more chances for error)

I never saw the link to the plays where it happened to you?


No matter how complicated the AI is, defense AI tester should be consistent to in-game play, shouldn't it? You seem to still think the problem is on what people think their AI should do, instead of what defense AI tester reporting something different.

I'll need to go back to find out the play having problem, but I don't plan to spend time finding it since I believe OP already had a legit case here.


Computers are extremely consistent. Users are not. Either Bort made and error (in which case it affects everyone) or the OP made an error (and it only affects his AI).

This thread has been bumped pretty steadily and I don't see anyone else coming in with links to their similar problem.


 
Link
 
Did you guys know that there are certain formations that you can't blitz out of?

If you try, it will negate the output and move to the next output on the list.

In that case, then the AI tester will point to the wrong play.

You have to figure out on your own what you can do and can't do though. Bort isn't going to give it to us. Just like he didn't tell us in detail what the SA's do exactly or the formula to get INT's.

Figure it out on your own. The OP sounds like he is lightyears ahead of many teams in AI, but he doesn't know everything yet.

Starting a thread like this only serves to have others copy what he has learned on his own. The goal line thing was an advantage for the people who found it first because they could avoid it. I suggest the OP does the same with this one and move on.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Again, you misunderstand the two different things:

(1) What OP thought his AI would do
(2) What defense AI tester reported what play should be called

The case here is (2). It's not what OP thought, it is what defense AI tester reported that was different to in-game play. Other than inputting wrong data, defense AI tester should be consistent to in-game play, shouldn't it? Again, do you see any inputs wrong that OP provided? Do you have to see a snapshot of something to agree that his defense AI tester inputs are correct?



The error is almost always in the dropdown boxes in the play that the AI tester chooses.

I don't think the OP ever shared what those fields were. Even if he did, it doesn't mean that they are correctly selected.

What if he blitzed all 8 guys? The AI would reject that and say that isn't possible and run the next play in the list.

What if he has 6 guys that could each blitz 30% of the time? What happens when 5 of those guys are chosen or all 6? This would explain why a chosen field only gives an "error" part of the time - because the OP is only choosing a scenario that is impossible part of the time.

One thing it could be is that he is blitzing someone that can't blitz in the sceme he wants to run.

Did he list the blitzing %'s? I didn't see them.

Explain why this couldn't be the user error here.


OP had a post regarding inputting defense AI tester, you may miss it: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1155131&page=5#9566309
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Did you guys know that there are certain formations that you can't blitz out of?

If you try, it will negate the output and move to the next output on the list.

In that case, then the AI tester will point to the wrong play.

You have to figure out on your own what you can do and can't do though. Bort isn't going to give it to us. Just like he didn't tell us in detail what the SA's do exactly or the formula to get INT's.

Figure it out on your own. The OP sounds like he is lightyears ahead of many teams in AI, but he doesn't know everything yet.

Starting a thread like this only serves to have others copy what he has learned on his own. The goal line thing was an advantage for the people who found it first because they could avoid it. I suggest the OP does the same with this one and move on.


This doesn't explain why most of the time everything works properly and in-game play is consistent to defense AI tester output while once in a while there is an inconsistency under same condition. Furthermore, there is only one output (3-4 Cover 0 man) in OP's case. Even it is an all out blitz, this output is legal and shouldn't be skipped.

EDIT: since you said it's not uncommon that defense AI tester shows something inconsistent to in-game play, I'd pay 25 or 50 FP to schedule a scrimmage to confirm it. Don't be vague, give the exact setting including formation, defense shell, and so on. Bort said he used the same codes at game sim in AI tester, I seriously doubt inconsistency is considered normal.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 20:19:40
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
has your team experienced this problem?

Not the same problem as the OP, but I did mention a play today where my defense did not line up in goalline for the first time ever when facing a goalline offense, and that input hadn't been changed or moved from the top all season long.
Originally posted by
That doesn't mean I haven't had things not go as I had hoped. It just turns out that every time it failed, it was ME that failed. And then I've seen a similar 99% failure rate out here in the bug forum. Ask Forbin.

Cool, so state ONCE that AI failures are often user errors and that the OP should check their settings. Harping on that over and over and over again just makes you come off as pedantic and dismissive. You are not a mod and it is not your job to police the bugs forum, nor will you be chosen to be a moderator because you badger people who think that they've had AI issues.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

has your team experienced this problem?

Not the same problem as the OP, but I did mention a play today where my defense did not line up in goalline for the first time ever when facing a goalline offense, and that input hadn't been changed or moved from the top all season long.
Originally posted by

That doesn't mean I haven't had things not go as I had hoped. It just turns out that every time it failed, it was ME that failed. And then I've seen a similar 99% failure rate out here in the bug forum. Ask Forbin.

Cool, so state ONCE that AI failures are often user errors and that the OP should check their settings. Harping on that over and over and over again just makes you come off as pedantic and dismissive. You are not a mod and it is not your job to police the bugs forum, nor will you be chosen to be a moderator because you badger people who think that they've had AI issues.



1.) I've found a few things in goalline that negate the defensive call. It is not a bug.

2.) I don't want to be a mod

3.) Every time I post or answer, it bumps this thread to the top. The OP should be happy I am here. However, it has been at the top of the bug for a couple days now and no response. Looks like Bort is busy....

 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Did you guys know that there are certain formations that you can't blitz out of?

If you try, it will negate the output and move to the next output on the list.

In that case, then the AI tester will point to the wrong play.

You have to figure out on your own what you can do and can't do though. Bort isn't going to give it to us. Just like he didn't tell us in detail what the SA's do exactly or the formula to get INT's.

Figure it out on your own. The OP sounds like he is lightyears ahead of many teams in AI, but he doesn't know everything yet.

Starting a thread like this only serves to have others copy what he has learned on his own. The goal line thing was an advantage for the people who found it first because they could avoid it. I suggest the OP does the same with this one and move on.


This doesn't explain why most of the time everything works properly and in-game play is consistent to defense AI tester output while once in a while there is an inconsistency under same condition. Furthermore, there is only one output (3-4 Cover 0 man) in OP's case. Even it is an all out blitz, this output is legal and shouldn't be skipped.

EDIT: since you said it's not uncommon that defense AI tester shows something inconsistent to in-game play, I'd pay 25 or 50 FP to schedule a scrimmage to confirm it. Don't be vague, give the exact setting including formation, defense shell, and so on. Bort said he used the same codes at game sim in AI tester, I seriously doubt inconsistency is considered normal.


why would I want to give away the info I know?

If you found a pass play that works really well, would you post it here for everyone to use?

If you did extensive tests on player builds and found something that wasn't working at all and should be avoided (say speed or agility for kickers), would you give that info to everyone or would you go on letting people waste points in areas that didn't help.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SI


Did he list the blitzing %'s? I didn't see them.

Explain why this couldn't be the user error here.


OP had a post regarding inputting defense AI tester, you may miss it: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1155131&page=5#9566309


you misunderstand. I'm not talking about tester info. I'm talking about the play the tester picks. Inside that offensive or defensive play is the mistake. Unless the OP posts everything inside that play including the numbers in each blitz% box and if there were any shifts, etc......then we don't know everything that could have caused the play to be skipped. And yes, those things can cause it.

Last edited Oct 13, 2008 21:10:36
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

why would I want to give away the info I know?


Because you can't explain why a 3-4 cover 0 can be illegal under a blitz package like you claimed. Even you can, you still can't explain why everything works fine most of the time and inconsistency only happens once in a while.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

you misunderstand. I'm not talking about tester info. I'm talking about the play the tester picks. Inside that offensive or defensive play is the mistake. Unless the OP posts everything inside that play including the numbers in each blitz% box and if there were any shifts, etc......then we don't know everything that could have caused the play to be skipped. And yes, those things can cause it.


He doesn't need to. You can simply tell everyone what kind of blitz package would make 3-4 cover 0 illegal and only be skipped once in a while.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology

thehazyone is legit, I am inclined to believe there is a problem.

You may have covered this before, but I don't recall and couldn't tell for certain in the OP...

Does this only occur against the Pro Set (to the best of your knowledge?)

Is the Pro Set defense package the very first formation in your list?
(if so, you could try switching formations up and down on the list order to see if it begins to occur with another formation...could be limited to "first on the list" formations, which might make a certain sense, depending on how the sim is coded in defensive play calling...)



No, it's happened against other defensive formations.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.