User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Why doesn't Bort address absurd sack totals?
Page:
 
Link
 
The title of this thread tells us it's not focused on DEs alone.

Last edited Oct 7, 2008 06:30:11
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
OTs have horrible builds really. Speed DE > No agility/speed pure strength OTs.


Since this guy is a LB, your point is meaningless.

Regarding DEs... the thing is, an OT build that's sufficient to stop an uber-agility/speed DE is going to have low strength and/or blocking. That means that a "good" OT can't run block worth a damn and gets clobbered by strength-based DEs.

Either way, this type of sack total is a problem. Mismatches should yield success by the defender, but not with ten sacks per game. That's just poor game design...
Last edited Oct 7, 2008 06:33:18
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Also, evasive pass rush is broken.


Is this true? Also I agree, sack totals have been crazy this season. People are right though that it is because people are building their O-Line to pancake crazy instead of adding speed/agility to block these fast De's.
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gator93
Originally posted by tjking82

Also, evasive pass rush is broken.


Is this true? Also I agree, sack totals have been crazy this season. People are right though that it is because people are building their O-Line to pancake crazy instead of adding speed/agility to block these fast De's.


It was a joke.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trubador
so the formula to win is build one speed DE (90 speed, 80 agility) and another strength DE (90 strength) and have them line up against the same OT and clobber him. An OT will have to spend his points on strength, blocking, speed, and agility and won't come close to matching their numbers.


I'll put my OT against any combination. While it's not easy to build a "Flex" OT, it can be done well enough to be successful.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
I have a LT who hasn't allowed a single hurry or sack in the last 24 reg-season games. He allowed just 2 hurries in the season-4 playoffs. He's LvL 28 but has the same overall rating as a LvL 35 OT on the same team. OT's with poor and/or unbalanced builds are the ones being taken to the woodshed.
 
Tigerbait0307
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
I have a LT who hasn't allowed a single hurry or sack in the last 24 reg-season games. He allowed just 2 hurries in the season-4 playoffs. He's LvL 28 but has the same overall rating as a LvL 35 OT on the same team. OT's with poor and/or unbalanced builds are the ones being taken to the woodshed.



Exactly, why punish the DEs because the OTs are built bad.

 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tigerbait0307
Originally posted by SAGA45

I have a LT who hasn't allowed a single hurry or sack in the last 24 reg-season games. He allowed just 2 hurries in the season-4 playoffs. He's LvL 28 but has the same overall rating as a LvL 35 OT on the same team. OT's with poor and/or unbalanced builds are the ones being taken to the woodshed.



Exactly, why punish the DEs because the OTs are built bad.



Because that's what happens on this game..... People mess up and then Bort comes along to bail them out. It's really quite comical.
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
What Bort should address is why stats for my last game show two QB sacks and yet the play-by-play only shows one. Where is the other one?
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Here's the other sack: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=173688&pbp_id=5561475

It reads as a forced fumble in the PBP but is a sack+FF.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
What Bort should address is why stats for my last game show two QB sacks and yet the play-by-play only shows one. Where is the other one?


I assume you're talking about this game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=173688&pbp_id=5561475

FF against the QB behind the LOS are registered as a sack now.

Edit: Grrr Saga...
Last edited Oct 7, 2008 08:50:56
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
What Bort should address is why stats for my last game show two QB sacks and yet the play-by-play only shows one. Where is the other one?


I'm guessing your talking about this game? http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=173688

Well here are the two sacks.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=173688&pbp_id=5560406
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=173688&pbp_id=5561475
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Actually... to fix this somehow it would help a lot if the RG and RBs got the ability to "remember" what guy caused hurries or sacks.

I recently saw how no less than 4 (!) blockers went for the NT in a 3-4 (C, both guards and FB) - while the LOT gave up a sack.

So if Bort just changes the blocking assignments to more realistic behavior ("watch the DE first, for he already managed to get a sack and/or a hurry"), quite a couple of games would turn out more realistic. I've seen my LG take on the NT in a 3-4 ALL the time. When facing speed rushers, why not allow or "order" the LG to double the RDE?

If done right, even the play-logic needs to change. A HB (and even a TE in some cases) going on a route should stay home if the LDE already managed to get 3 sacks vs. the obviously overmatched ROT - or the QB would watch out for the LDE all the time and dumb off the pass to the HB immediately. Same call for more than 2 blitzers. Right now, the plays don't consider that option.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Actually... to fix this somehow it would help a lot if the RG and RBs got the ability to "remember" what guy caused hurries or sacks.

I recently saw how no less than 4 (!) blockers went for the NT in a 3-4 (C, both guards and FB) - while the LOT gave up a sack.

So if Bort just changes the blocking assignments to more realistic behavior ("watch the DE first, for he already managed to get a sack and/or a hurry"), quite a couple of games would turn out more realistic. I've seen my LG take on the NT in a 3-4 ALL the time. When facing speed rushers, why not allow or "order" the LG to double the RDE?

If done right, even the play-logic needs to change. A HB (and even a TE in some cases) going on a route should stay home if the LDE already managed to get 3 sacks vs. the obviously overmatched ROT - or the QB would watch out for the LDE all the time and dumb off the pass to the HB immediately. Same call for more than 2 blitzers. Right now, the plays don't consider that option.


Not only do you see this all the time, there are ways to set up the defensive AI to draw in most or all of the blockers into the middle on passing downs, leaving the DEs 1v1.

This suggestion would go a long way in reducing sack totals and would make the pass blocking more realistic.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by RAPB

Actually... to fix this somehow it would help a lot if the RG and RBs got the ability to "remember" what guy caused hurries or sacks.

I recently saw how no less than 4 (!) blockers went for the NT in a 3-4 (C, both guards and FB) - while the LOT gave up a sack.

So if Bort just changes the blocking assignments to more realistic behavior ("watch the DE first, for he already managed to get a sack and/or a hurry"), quite a couple of games would turn out more realistic. I've seen my LG take on the NT in a 3-4 ALL the time. When facing speed rushers, why not allow or "order" the LG to double the RDE?

If done right, even the play-logic needs to change. A HB (and even a TE in some cases) going on a route should stay home if the LDE already managed to get 3 sacks vs. the obviously overmatched ROT - or the QB would watch out for the LDE all the time and dumb off the pass to the HB immediately. Same call for more than 2 blitzers. Right now, the plays don't consider that option.


Not only do you see this all the time, there are ways to set up the defensive AI to draw in most or all of the blockers into the middle on passing downs, leaving the DEs 1v1.

This suggestion would go a long way in reducing sack totals and would make the pass blocking more realistic.


(Ups... the Barracudas know of this too... guess now it's time to call off the 6-man-blitz up the middle...)



-------------

Seriously, the blocking assignments need to be adressed. I really like to see how many sacks are given up if the guards stay home and the RBs help out where they seriously are needed.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.