User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
DangerClose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Note: I possibly have a lead on what's going on based on some code perusal for logic errors, but I could be completely off base, being kinda tired at the moment.

Running a bunch o tests with a modification to see (should be done when I get up, hopefully).


I read thru this,..and I do believe that SOMETHING changed, beginning last season,..my fast receiver from season 3, he had only 3 drops all of season three,..now,..beginning in season 4,..with the same QB throwing the same style,..he started dropping a lot of balls,..it got so bad at one point he had six drops in a game,..we basically tried all three settings, and I've maxed his catching, vision, got him to I think 25-30 on jumping,..been working on strength lately,..but still, we're getting 1-2 drops a game,..this from that same guy,..with the same QB he had in season 2,..anyway,....if you say nothing's changed,..I can't believe that,..because you have changed something,..we added the options for the three types of QB passes,..I guess that was sometime last season,..but yeah,..I've heard and read about this ever since then,..we've had endless discussions in our forums about it,..cause we're still getting 4-5 dropped balls per game,..that's across the board,..and it seems it's totally random,..so, drops are WAY up from season 3 to now,..and that's just a FACT.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I'm glad you have a lead on it Bort. I'm just afraid you'll put in a change and we'll have a repeat of games 3-5 of last season where you "un-nerfed" WR's and they were catching the ball in triple coverage.
 
aspenwolf
offline
Link
 
bort didn't have to change anything to make drops go up or down. the problem in this thread is underthrows or over throws to speedy wrs

wrs are hard to balanced, it's a very tricky scale
too fast and you drop the ball. too slow and you dont get open
if you arent agile enough, or have too low of vision, you drop the ball
catching and carrying are also used in catching
so if you pile on points in one area, it out-balances another

my speed wr went through a rash of drops in season 3 i think, because i was working on getting my speed to the next cap and couldn't focus on the other areas
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
imcompletes are up big time in my league and it's all the wr's and qb's involed not just speed wr's, somethings not right i tell ya
 
winchester
offline
Link
 


 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
I am a GM for AAA#2 and I have speaking to alot of Pro QB's and AAA Qb's and we are wondering if the "toning down of the pump fake" had an unforseen side effect. Every QB I have spoke to has a decent amount in the pump fakes and when Bort toned it down is when we started seeing the problem?

Is it possible?
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
I'm with you on that.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Note: I possibly have a lead on what's going on based on some code perusal for logic errors, but I could be completely off base, being kinda tired at the moment.

Running a bunch o tests with a modification to see (should be done when I get up, hopefully).


Thanks for responding to all of this. It means a lot to some of us who are going crazy and are about to waste a bunch of skill points trying to figure it out and never get them back and possibly have these problems all year.

I want to make one recommendation to checkout. I have 2 QB's. Last year both QB's threw for around 65-58% and we led our league in passing percentage. This year, better roster, no other teams significantly improved anything, and one QB is still throwing that high of a percentage and the other isn't. The one that isn't is more active and we have been playing with his settings. I haven't been able to ask the other QB yet what his settings are but he has been throwing in the 60-70% range where as our other QB dropped to the 40-50% range and we are now around 20th in the league.
This to me is definitely really happening and something caused it.

My guesses:
- We have a advanced QB tactic that is hurting us. Last game we had favor the long pass on and also scramble sometimes which we never used before and also turned off dump passes which we don't normally do. I think we also did that in the first two games as well.
- We brought in high speed WR's. Our fastest WR is the one struggling the most. We went from 2 speed guys to 4. But, our other QB does not seem to have nearly the issue.

I hope that some how helps and you can contact me with any questions. I check my PM's regularly.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aspenwolf
bort didn't have to change anything to make drops go up or down. the problem in this thread is underthrows or over throws to speedy wrs

wrs are hard to balanced, it's a very tricky scale
too fast and you drop the ball. too slow and you dont get open
if you arent agile enough, or have too low of vision, you drop the ball
catching and carrying are also used in catching
so if you pile on points in one area, it out-balances another

my speed wr went through a rash of drops in season 3 i think, because i was working on getting my speed to the next cap and couldn't focus on the other areas


Thanks for the help but if you read my previous post you will see we carry 2 QB's. One has the problem and the other doesn't. This is not in my opinion a build issue. The ball is either being thrown short every time by the QB or the WR doesn't try to catch it. It isn't that he isn't able, or misses, it is that he doesn't even try.

And yes, we all struggled with the drop issue last season. If you look at the replays given here, these aren't drops they are incompletes and this is a different issue. We would honestly be fine with drops. These balls appear to be right on the WR and he isn't even getting a hand on it.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 09:12:43
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
I am a GM for AAA#2 and I have speaking to alot of Pro QB's and AAA Qb's and we are wondering if the "toning down of the pump fake" had an unforseen side effect. Every QB I have spoke to has a decent amount in the pump fakes and when Bort toned it down is when we started seeing the problem?

Is it possible?


Reposting this....the timing to the problem and the timing of Bort toning down the pump fake are eeerily close together!

 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
Agree, Im on the same team with whodey and have also contacted every single QB on my other teams, The ones with no pump fake are not seeing anything like this but the Qb's with 5 or more on the stat are having Major Problems.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
I am a GM for AAA#2 and I have speaking to alot of Pro QB's and AAA Qb's and we are wondering if the "toning down of the pump fake" had an unforseen side effect. Every QB I have spoke to has a decent amount in the pump fakes and when Bort toned it down is when we started seeing the problem?

Is it possible?


Ding ding ding ding!

I think we have a winner here. This matches up exactly with what I've been seeing, and is really the only thing that has changed.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
My own QB's started doing terrible this season and this is after I upped his pump-fake twice. His interception rate increased too.

I'm not happy, Capped or greater on Str, Vision, Confidence, Very good throwing attribute, Agility nearly capped. The only changes from this season to last has been upping Pump Fake and Tight Spiral.

I was cool with pump fake being nerfed a little (my CB didn't like it at all) and I thought the skill was worth it even at reduced 'freeze' time on the DB's.. but if I gimped my build and gave an opening to my backup who has been chomping at the bit for my position, I'm going to be really pissed off.

Not happy with my performance and this is coming off two great seasons for 3 and 4.

I'd be happy to donate my QB Build to Bort and he could try some staged games. Maybe try something with the pump fake nerf removed and then one replaced, The drastic nature of the change is _huge_ for my player.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=107857

Season 3 - 60.9 completion Percentage, 29 TD's to 6 Ints this while sharing time with my backup about 60/40.
Season 4 - 68.3 completion percentage, 31 TD's to 6 Ints while sharing time likely closer to 55/45 with my backup.
Season 5 - dropped to 58.8%, 4TD's to 3 Ints while again sharing maybe 55/45 playing time... All I changed with my boosts were Agility, Confidence and I increased Pump Fake and Tight Spiral.

Our receivers all boosted and got better. My performance has gone down even though my build is 'better' than it was previous two seasons. My Backup is doing better than ever. His pump fake did not change season over season and was never at my same level.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=159316 for my backup.

So, whats the deal?

Another test may be to take aplayer like my own whose obvious build change from season to season was upping pump fake, maybe reduce their pump fake, manually credit them back the SP's and see if all of a sudden their build performs like it should again?

Last edited Sep 26, 2008 11:52:54
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Talking to my Backup in IM's. I decided to look at all the games we have played this season both before 9/22/08 and after (pump fake changes).

Its difficult to say but it does seem that there is a trend of a downward performance post 9/22.

Who knows for sure, but just attempting to provide more data.

 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I didn't read this whole thread, but I tried Bort's suggestion about trying a new passing style. I tried bullet passing so I wouldn't underthrow as much, and I went 12/15 for 4 TDs and 0 INTs. I didn't see the incomplete right on the WR thing one time.

Take that for what it's worth.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.