Originally posted by HydrOshocK
Originally posted by Ken1
I see the pitch play as screwed up to the point I'm reluctant to use it.
At this point I'm not seeing the off tackle play screwed up to the same extent. Again, I'm not saying that it's all the way it should be; I just feel as if the anger is disproportionate to the degree of the problem.
Anytime anything changes even a little, it's "The sky is falling!" Again, the off tackle play worked better last season, but I think Bort gets the message to let it go through the G/T hole, and I think it'll be all right pretty soon. And it's already not so awful to make me afraid to use it, personally.
I can understand your point of view but it depends on the % of that certain play you are using in your tactics. If it's a "bread and butter" play then it becomes a bigger problem. The ineffectiveness of the pitch play compounds the problem now because you are limited to mostly inside runs that haven't been nerfed. That's easy to defend against so a smart DC will stack the line against that and force a team to throw. You might say that a team should be able to pass the ball well enough to compensate for it but then you're also saying that an OC should have to change his entire approach to game planning to do so. Not every team wants to be one dimensional. A good offensive team will use both phases of the game to its advantage. There's a lot of time and effort that goes into developing an extensive AI package that would have to be corrected just for this one simple flaw.
I hope you are right that Bort gets the message because that's what this discussion is for. We want to stress the importance of making it work correctly BEFORE the season starts so that we don't have to scramble to make these changes and miss our window of opportunity again. Like I said, the frustration comes from having to deal with this exact type of thing every season and its just getting old.
Believe me, I've fought for realistic levels of offense, including rushing offense, and I'd hate to see that destroyed. I don't think a team should have to pass more than in real life (or run more than in real life). If it can work in real life, it should be able to work here.
I just am bothered by the tone of many posters. It's clear to me that Bort didn't mean to nerf outside runs, and I don't want him to be afraid to try to tweak anything because if it doesn't work perfectly right away lots of people will jump down his throat. I combine that with the fact that I don't think off tackle runs are that badly messed up, and see what I feel is too strong of a reaction.
Originally posted by Ken1
I see the pitch play as screwed up to the point I'm reluctant to use it.
At this point I'm not seeing the off tackle play screwed up to the same extent. Again, I'm not saying that it's all the way it should be; I just feel as if the anger is disproportionate to the degree of the problem.
Anytime anything changes even a little, it's "The sky is falling!" Again, the off tackle play worked better last season, but I think Bort gets the message to let it go through the G/T hole, and I think it'll be all right pretty soon. And it's already not so awful to make me afraid to use it, personally.
I can understand your point of view but it depends on the % of that certain play you are using in your tactics. If it's a "bread and butter" play then it becomes a bigger problem. The ineffectiveness of the pitch play compounds the problem now because you are limited to mostly inside runs that haven't been nerfed. That's easy to defend against so a smart DC will stack the line against that and force a team to throw. You might say that a team should be able to pass the ball well enough to compensate for it but then you're also saying that an OC should have to change his entire approach to game planning to do so. Not every team wants to be one dimensional. A good offensive team will use both phases of the game to its advantage. There's a lot of time and effort that goes into developing an extensive AI package that would have to be corrected just for this one simple flaw.
I hope you are right that Bort gets the message because that's what this discussion is for. We want to stress the importance of making it work correctly BEFORE the season starts so that we don't have to scramble to make these changes and miss our window of opportunity again. Like I said, the frustration comes from having to deal with this exact type of thing every season and its just getting old.
Believe me, I've fought for realistic levels of offense, including rushing offense, and I'd hate to see that destroyed. I don't think a team should have to pass more than in real life (or run more than in real life). If it can work in real life, it should be able to work here.
I just am bothered by the tone of many posters. It's clear to me that Bort didn't mean to nerf outside runs, and I don't want him to be afraid to try to tweak anything because if it doesn't work perfectly right away lots of people will jump down his throat. I combine that with the fact that I don't think off tackle runs are that badly messed up, and see what I feel is too strong of a reaction.





























