User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
Originally posted by Ken1

I see the pitch play as screwed up to the point I'm reluctant to use it.

At this point I'm not seeing the off tackle play screwed up to the same extent. Again, I'm not saying that it's all the way it should be; I just feel as if the anger is disproportionate to the degree of the problem.

Anytime anything changes even a little, it's "The sky is falling!" Again, the off tackle play worked better last season, but I think Bort gets the message to let it go through the G/T hole, and I think it'll be all right pretty soon. And it's already not so awful to make me afraid to use it, personally.


I can understand your point of view but it depends on the % of that certain play you are using in your tactics. If it's a "bread and butter" play then it becomes a bigger problem. The ineffectiveness of the pitch play compounds the problem now because you are limited to mostly inside runs that haven't been nerfed. That's easy to defend against so a smart DC will stack the line against that and force a team to throw. You might say that a team should be able to pass the ball well enough to compensate for it but then you're also saying that an OC should have to change his entire approach to game planning to do so. Not every team wants to be one dimensional. A good offensive team will use both phases of the game to its advantage. There's a lot of time and effort that goes into developing an extensive AI package that would have to be corrected just for this one simple flaw.

I hope you are right that Bort gets the message because that's what this discussion is for. We want to stress the importance of making it work correctly BEFORE the season starts so that we don't have to scramble to make these changes and miss our window of opportunity again. Like I said, the frustration comes from having to deal with this exact type of thing every season and its just getting old.


Believe me, I've fought for realistic levels of offense, including rushing offense, and I'd hate to see that destroyed. I don't think a team should have to pass more than in real life (or run more than in real life). If it can work in real life, it should be able to work here.

I just am bothered by the tone of many posters. It's clear to me that Bort didn't mean to nerf outside runs, and I don't want him to be afraid to try to tweak anything because if it doesn't work perfectly right away lots of people will jump down his throat. I combine that with the fact that I don't think off tackle runs are that badly messed up, and see what I feel is too strong of a reaction.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

Originally posted by Ken1


I see the pitch play as screwed up to the point I'm reluctant to use it.

At this point I'm not seeing the off tackle play screwed up to the same extent. Again, I'm not saying that it's all the way it should be; I just feel as if the anger is disproportionate to the degree of the problem.

Anytime anything changes even a little, it's "The sky is falling!" Again, the off tackle play worked better last season, but I think Bort gets the message to let it go through the G/T hole, and I think it'll be all right pretty soon. And it's already not so awful to make me afraid to use it, personally.


I can understand your point of view but it depends on the % of that certain play you are using in your tactics. If it's a "bread and butter" play then it becomes a bigger problem. The ineffectiveness of the pitch play compounds the problem now because you are limited to mostly inside runs that haven't been nerfed. That's easy to defend against so a smart DC will stack the line against that and force a team to throw. You might say that a team should be able to pass the ball well enough to compensate for it but then you're also saying that an OC should have to change his entire approach to game planning to do so. Not every team wants to be one dimensional. A good offensive team will use both phases of the game to its advantage. There's a lot of time and effort that goes into developing an extensive AI package that would have to be corrected just for this one simple flaw.

I hope you are right that Bort gets the message because that's what this discussion is for. We want to stress the importance of making it work correctly BEFORE the season starts so that we don't have to scramble to make these changes and miss our window of opportunity again. Like I said, the frustration comes from having to deal with this exact type of thing every season and its just getting old.


Believe me, I've fought for realistic levels of offense, including rushing offense, and I'd hate to see that destroyed. I don't think a team should have to pass more than in real life (or run more than in real life). If it can work in real life, it should be able to work here.

I just am bothered by the tone of many posters. It's clear to me that Bort didn't mean to nerf outside runs, and I don't want him to be afraid to try to tweak anything because if it doesn't work perfectly right away lots of people will jump down his throat. I combine that with the fact that I don't think off tackle runs are that badly messed up, and see what I feel is too strong of a reaction.


You're certainly entitled to you opinion and I can see your side, but the frustration comes from the repetitive nature of these issues, not just this one. Most of the guys complaining now you won't find doing the same in past threads, including myself. There just comes a time when every customer reaches his tipping point of frustration from repeated let downs in a product that he has a substantial investment in.

With that said I think I've clearly stated my view on the matter so I'll leave it at that, but the frustration will remain until a clear solution is provided.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Guys, you are all too negative.

Sure - this is quite some work again, but this post Mike Rogers made got to Borts mind.

offtackle run

Originally posted by GO TEXANS
...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187295&pbp_id=714881
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187295&pbp_id=719797

The delays are a little extreme.


It's not the delay (the time the HB waits before he starts to move at all). It's the fact that the FB accelerates and heads straight while the HB doesn't even head straigth for the gap - but tries to find a path while beeing in the backfield.

Basically, the HB should accelerate as much as he can and WHILE doing so just make one singe decision - depending on the ROT/LDE matchup:

- if the ROT seems to block the LDE towards the outside: hit the inside
- if the LDE seems to go towards the middle: head just outside the ROT

So no stop or "dancing" either way. Full speed and a quick decision - that might end up beeing the wrong one (but full speed = better chance to break the tackle of those still blocked LDEs).


pitch plays
Pitches are predictable - and that's their weak spot. That needs a quick fix now:

- the weak I - formation needs (at least) one inside rush and one pass play - so you can't focus on the strongside pitch entirely

- the existing strongside pitch should be played out of the all I - formations too (2 formations are just too predictable)

- the weakside pitch needs to be played out of at least 3 or 4 formations (1 is shut down easily) - especially I-formations: why don't just "mirror" the strongside pitch (o.k. - the TE is missing as blocker; but that's the nature of weakside pitches)

future:
- giving the offense AI the chance to choose strongside or weakside pitch
- pathing


Best regards to all and keep up the spirit! This game is moving on the right track (not always forwards... but... mostly)!
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 05:39:14
 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
On another note, just HOW hard would it be to have I Formations be strong right and also strong side left?
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
For those who see the game in a different light such as Ken I have no problem with.For 4 seasons I have rolled with the flow and adapted but adapting on something that has been the same since the beginning of the game is not fun or called for.I have for the most part gone with the flow but this issue was one that finally has me rethinking the reasoning behind tweaks.We see attemts at fixing old problems by taking away from something that was already solid and working reasonably well.I feel this was done to tone down the running game since the pathing problem for defensive players could not be made to work properly.Breaking one thing to try and fix another that is broken is going backwards.I am not flaming anyone but really trying to understand the reasoning behind these duct tape fixes.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 11:19:41
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Run pathing got an update this offseason (as mentioned in my announcement).

It's now a combination of the double-pass algo and new path calculation only every so many ticks instead of each tick, frequency depending on elusive/combo/power settings.

Only change I made to the off tackle play, though, is the short RB pause at the beginning to give the FB time to get moving and get to the hole.


Don't change the sim to fix stupid FB builds!
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Wouldn't it be ironic if Bort had (or soon has) fixes to these issues but was afraid to put them into the game because he knows that people will go nuts about any changes?

"My defense was stopping the off tackle play in the preseason, and now all of a sudden we can't!"

"I had a defense against the Weak I that stopped the sweep, and then with no warning the other team passes against it, which had never happened, and you didn't even warn us!"

This is a very detailed sim. It keeps track of every player on every play. It's going to take tons of work to get it just right. Bort does very, very much need to add more plays for every formation, and should set things up for people to submit them.

But I'm just saying, jump down his throat whenever things change and you could find whatever the status quo is at some point stuck there. There's never been a point where that would have been good. If it's stuck where it is now, outside runs won't work as well as they should.

And the level of outrage really could stick it where it is now for all of Season 5.

I hope Bort doesn't worry about the people who'll whine when the changes people in this thread are calling for are made (because I agree about the content of most of them, just not about the tone or the level of anger).

But if things don't change, people should think about whether it was this level of outrage over the previous changes that slowed up any fixes to the very problems they discuss.
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Run pathing got an update this offseason (as mentioned in my announcement).

It's now a combination of the double-pass algo and new path calculation only every so many ticks instead of each tick, frequency depending on elusive/combo/power settings.

Only change I made to the off tackle play, though, is the short RB pause at the beginning to give the FB time to get moving and get to the hole.


Dont understand why you would need to make the change for the FB Bort. There is no problem with the sim related to the FB. The problem lies in peoples builds of the FB in relation to the speed of the HB.

If a team employees a power fullback then they need to understand the limitation they are under for the Hb rushing. Shrug same goes for a pass recieving TE. If a team starts one then there running game will suffer.

These 2 issues wont be resolved until we can assign players to specific plays.

A player that has a blocking Fb must always be aware of what the Hb is doing with his skill points..The FB an Hb on a team need to communicate. If a FB is late hitting the hole the HB shouldnt be increasing his speed with his points he should be working on other things while the Fb brings up his speed.

This fix kinda smacks of the cookie cutter type variety. Everyones Fb no matter how badly built will be able to perform.

I'm working to fix a friends Fb now. Didnt expect it just to be handed to us.

Oh also a possible unintended side effect. Hb catch's a pass at the line of scrimmage and just sits at the spot like he is waiting for a fictional fb to move so he can run.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=186565&pbp_id=864721


Last edited Sep 20, 2008 15:00:43
 
Den
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Wouldn't it be ironic if Bort had (or soon has) fixes to these issues but was afraid to put them into the game because he knows that people will go nuts about any changes?

"My defense was stopping the off tackle play in the preseason, and now all of a sudden we can't!"

"I had a defense against the Weak I that stopped the sweep, and then with no warning the other team passes against it, which had never happened, and you didn't even warn us!"




Easily preempted if put in a short announcement using the new home page system a day before the fix is implemented. For me the problem isn't changes....I EXPECT stuff to be fixed/changed for the better...Just let us know so we have a day to adapt before somehting we can't prepare for costs us a game
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge
Originally posted by Bort

Run pathing got an update this offseason (as mentioned in my announcement).

It's now a combination of the double-pass algo and new path calculation only every so many ticks instead of each tick, frequency depending on elusive/combo/power settings.

Only change I made to the off tackle play, though, is the short RB pause at the beginning to give the FB time to get moving and get to the hole.


Dont understand why you would need to make the change for the FB Bort. There is no problem with the sim related to the FB. The problem lies in peoples builds of the FB in relation to the speed of the HB.

If a team employees a power fullback then they need to understand the limitation they are under for the Hb rushing. Shrug same goes for a pass recieving TE. If a team starts one then there running game will suffer.

These 2 issues wont be resolved until we can assign players to specific plays.

A player that has a blocking Fb must always be aware of what the Hb is doing with his skill points..The FB an Hb on a team need to communicate. If a FB is late hitting the hole the HB shouldnt be increasing his speed with his points he should be working on other things while the Fb brings up his speed.

This fix kinda smacks of the cookie cutter type variety. Everyones Fb no matter how badly built will be able to perform.



Problem is that the HB is set to follow the FB as a lead blocker on many plays. If the FB is super slow in comparison, he will get ahead of him almost right away and the play will break down every time. If the FB gets 2-3 ticks to get going, the HB will actually have a lead blocker at least for a moment, no matter how quick he is.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge
Oh also a possible unintended side effect. Hb catch's a pass at the line of scrimmage and just sits at the spot like he is waiting for a fictional fb to move so he can run.


That just means it was a terrible pass or catch and he fell down or had to jump for it.
 
Den
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sledge

Originally posted by Bort


Run pathing got an update this offseason (as mentioned in my announcement).

It's now a combination of the double-pass algo and new path calculation only every so many ticks instead of each tick, frequency depending on elusive/combo/power settings.

Only change I made to the off tackle play, though, is the short RB pause at the beginning to give the FB time to get moving and get to the hole.


Dont understand why you would need to make the change for the FB Bort. There is no problem with the sim related to the FB. The problem lies in peoples builds of the FB in relation to the speed of the HB.

If a team employees a power fullback then they need to understand the limitation they are under for the Hb rushing. Shrug same goes for a pass recieving TE. If a team starts one then there running game will suffer.

These 2 issues wont be resolved until we can assign players to specific plays.

A player that has a blocking Fb must always be aware of what the Hb is doing with his skill points..The FB an Hb on a team need to communicate. If a FB is late hitting the hole the HB shouldnt be increasing his speed with his points he should be working on other things while the Fb brings up his speed.

This fix kinda smacks of the cookie cutter type variety. Everyones Fb no matter how badly built will be able to perform.



Problem is that the HB is set to follow the FB as a lead blocker on many plays. If the FB is super slow in comparison, he will get ahead of him almost right away and the play will break down every time. If the FB gets 2-3 ticks to get going, the HB will actually have a lead blocker at least for a moment, no matter how quick he is.


Curious if this isn't something that could be fixed with a 'formation' choice in the AI.

First, as stated by another, isn't it min/max builds causing this generally? If your FB is slower than your OT's....then ya...you SHOULD have plays break down....imho

If Coord's could choose to run out of diff sets...they could choose to run FB lead block plays out of sets where the HB starts an extra yard or so back? (EDIT added) When playing with a backfield where the agility/speed difference between the HB/FB are bad. Teams with proper ratio's of speed/agility in the backfield could make use of sets the others couldn't.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 15:06:13
 
drazz00
offline
Link
 
Bort, definitely noticing the power back emasculation. I realize that power backs were TOO powerful last season, but its way too far the other way this season. i see elusive backs breaking more tackles, power backs not hitting the hole, and all the power backs I work with have dropped their YPC by at least half and have only about 1/4 of the broken tackles per game that they had last year.

Any chance to find a middle ground here?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drazz00
Bort, definitely noticing the power back emasculation. I realize that power backs were TOO powerful last season, but its way too far the other way this season. i see elusive backs breaking more tackles, power backs not hitting the hole, and all the power backs I work with have dropped their YPC by at least half and have only about 1/4 of the broken tackles per game that they had last year.

Any chance to find a middle ground here?


Really less broken tackles? I didn't touch that from end of last season. Maybe defenders are catching up on the tackling front?
 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
The problem is we have a HB who averaged 7.5yds/carry last season and another who averaged over 5yds/carry. NEITHER of them has the "Power" back build that everyone bitches about and now they can't seem to do jack this pre-season.

It gets real damn old having everthing "fixed" all the time if a player does well.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.