User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Team Loans, Chemistry
Page:
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Idea on Chemistry... the whole level 5 and below thing is not a very good answer....

I think that the Chemistry thing needs some work...

If you have a team and all your starters are LVL 13 or higher then your talking about back ups that are level 10-8 or maybe 7... So picking up a new backup or releasing a back up should not affect Chemistry as much as it would to do so with a starter...

This is my idea...

- For every player that you drop or trade away that is +/- 2lvl's of your team’s average player level you lose 3 chemistry from the appropriate bars (0 if it's a CPU).

- For every player that you add to your team, that is +/- 2lvl's of your team’s average player level you lose 2 chemistry from the appropriate bars

- For every player that you add or drop that is 3 or more level’s higher then your average player level you lose 4 chemistry from the appropriate bars

- For every player that you drop or trade away that is 3 or more level’s lower then your average player level you lose 1 chemistry from the appropriate bars


The 2 and 3 for the level is just a number it could be more or less not a big deal there as our teams progress we will have level 20 players and signing a guy that is level 5 won’t even be an option you will have to sign players that are 14 and 15 just as backups.

The point is adding depth or releasing a guy that is stuck deep in the depth chart should not have the same affect as if you were adding and dropping starters


this is my idea...
 
LTizgreat56
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim
Idea on Chemistry... the whole level 5 and below thing is not a very good answer....

I think that the Chemistry thing needs some work...

If you have a team and all your starters are LVL 13 or higher then your talking about back ups that are level 10-8 or maybe 7... So picking up a new backup or releasing a back up should not affect Chemistry as much as it would to do so with a starter...

This is my idea...

- For every player that you drop or trade away that is +/- 2lvl's of your team’s average player level you lose 3 chemistry from the appropriate bars (0 if it's a CPU).

- For every player that you add to your team, that is +/- 2lvl's of your team’s average player level you lose 2 chemistry from the appropriate bars

- For every player that you add or drop that is 3 or more level’s higher then your average player level you lose 4 chemistry from the appropriate bars

- For every player that you drop or trade away that is 3 or more level’s lower then your average player level you lose 1 chemistry from the appropriate bars


The 2 and 3 for the level is just a number it could be more or less not a big deal there as our teams progress we will have level 20 players and signing a guy that is level 5 won’t even be an option you will have to sign players that are 14 and 15 just as backups.

The point is adding depth or releasing a guy that is stuck deep in the depth chart should not have the same affect as if you were adding and dropping starters


this is my idea...


i was just thinking that

 
Weykool
offline
Link
 
For everyone who is saying that Chemistry should be kept because it has little affect I have to ask....then why keep it?
Why give people a reason to complain about it?
Either it has an affect or it doesnt have an affect......either way it is a bad idea that doesnt belongs in the game.
If we want to mirror the NFL then the item at the top of the list should be a waive/draft system where teams on the bottom get the first pick and players are required to sign.
If we arent going to do that then at least let the teams on the bottom compete on a level playing field.

We are also getting hit with morale penalties.
Lose a game?....Lets make sure your guys have low morale and a better chance to lose the next one.

I think the game designers have had some good ideas but didnt think some of them through to their logical end.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Bort, can we make it so that expiring contracts cause the same chemistry hit as releasing a player? Right now, owners who would otherwise grant a player a release are holding onto the player through the end of the contract because of the chemistry issue.

 
Aoiree
offline
Link
 
What if you trade a player who has been inactive for a week or more? Penalty?

I know some people out there are willing to offer a small amount of $ for an inactive player if the level is high enough.
 
baseball52
offline
Link
 
I've said this before it should be dependent on the player not a system.
 
kastagir
offline
Link
 
Off Season - Chemistry effects should be suspended during off season. No general reset because even though it helps teams that have low chemistry, it hurts teams that have kept their chemistry high by limiting their trades during the regular season. But I think all teams should have the option to rework their rosters in the off season through player moves without the fear reducing overall team performance. If you are a player then, basically you have to commit yourself to the team for the season and then in the off season the owner will be much more willing to release you or trade you etc.

Team Average Player Level - I do like the idea mentioned on team average level and higher impacts if the player's level involved in the move is at or above the team average level. If you have some low level player that is just getting no PT at all, do you really expect him to sit basically the season out on your roster so it does not impact your chemistry. As a player, I would not be thrilled about having to do that while I could play in at least the CPU leagues. As players' level climb this "low level" range will differ greatly per team. If a individual team's average level could be used as a determining factor would be more accurate.

New Owners of Existing Teams - Maybe help brand new owners of existing teams out by giving them a reset on chemistry but not all the way back to 70. How about reset to half way between team's current level and 70? This reset happens at the moment you buy the team only during the regular season if you go with suspending chemistry in the off season. For all the team owners that would abuse this option, they of course would be out of at least 500 FP or like the player release penalty, put in that a team owner that sells a team can not buy back that team for something like 15 days, whatever.
But I guess would you reduce chemistry if the levels are above 70 when they buy? Changing team owners has impact on "Team Chemistry" like a player move I would assume if you are buying into this concept. Also might suspend chemistry on a team that has number of active players on the roster below a specific amount. I am talking like 24 (11 Offense, 11 Defense, Punter, Kicker) or 30 players or something. So once again new owners of existing team where the previous owner just simply released every1 can rebuild the team at least to a point without hurting their chemistry to field a playable team. Now for the soon to be X-Team-Owners that packs a team with every scrub they can get their hands on and boost the roster to 100+ players, I guess we would have to have a high number as well. So if you cut players off the roster while the roster has above let say 100 players, team chemistry is suspended. Ok for the X-Team-Owners that pack scrubs players rate in the middle of these two values, I have no idea. Nothing is perfect and you end up with lets say 70 level 1 noobs. At least you will know it going in before you buy. How about an option to release every player from the roster at the moment you buy a team, all or none release option (player release penalty can not resign 7 days whatever in full effect)?
 
Dmac2008
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kastagir
Off Season - Chemistry effects should be suspended during off season. No general reset because even though it helps teams that have low chemistry, it hurts teams that have kept their chemistry high by limiting their trades during the regular season. But I think all teams should have the option to rework their rosters in the off season through player moves without the fear reducing overall team performance. If you are a player then, basically you have to commit yourself to the team for the season and then in the off season the owner will be much more willing to release you or trade you etc.

Team Average Player Level - I do like the idea mentioned on team average level and higher impacts if the player's level involved in the move is at or above the team average level. If you have some low level player that is just getting no PT at all, do you really expect him to sit basically the season out on your roster so it does not impact your chemistry. As a player, I would not be thrilled about having to do that while I could play in at least the CPU leagues. As players' level climb this "low level" range will differ greatly per team. If a individual team's average level could be used as a determining factor would be more accurate.

New Owners of Existing Teams - Maybe help brand new owners of existing teams out by giving them a reset on chemistry but not all the way back to 70. How about reset to half way between team's current level and 70? This reset happens at the moment you buy the team only during the regular season if you go with suspending chemistry in the off season. For all the team owners that would abuse this option, they of course would be out of at least 500 FP or like the player release penalty, put in that a team owner that sells a team can not buy back that team for something like 15 days, whatever.
But I guess would you reduce chemistry if the levels are above 70 when they buy? Changing team owners has impact on "Team Chemistry" like a player move I would assume if you are buying into this concept. Also might suspend chemistry on a team that has number of active players on the roster below a specific amount. I am talking like 24 (11 Offense, 11 Defense, Punter, Kicker) or 30 players or something. So once again new owners of existing team where the previous owner just simply released every1 can rebuild the team at least to a point without hurting their chemistry to field a playable team. Now for the soon to be X-Team-Owners that packs a team with every scrub they can get their hands on and boost the roster to 100+ players, I guess we would have to have a high number as well. So if you cut players off the roster while the roster has above let say 100 players, team chemistry is suspended. Ok for the X-Team-Owners that pack scrubs players rate in the middle of these two values, I have no idea. Nothing is perfect and you end up with lets say 70 level 1 noobs. At least you will know it going in before you buy. How about an option to release every player from the roster at the moment you buy a team, all or none release option (player release penalty can not resign 7 days whatever in full effect)?


I LOVE this idea!
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Nah off season should have "half the effect" of the regular season. It still counts because you are still "turning over" your roster which will effect the essence of chemistry.
 
kastagir
offline
Link
 
"half the effect" is acceptable alternative. Something needs to be done because in 8 seasons we could be starting to retire what could be 10% of the total players on the game that point on with the 10 seaon - start reducing stats effect kicking in. And given a player can not retire while on a team it could start to get to the point you just lose chemistry for every season on at that point. Players drop off the roster and you have to replace them as they retire from the game with new players. How can any team get ahead taking 2-3 point hits per player drop and you add to replace and can only gain 40 points a season?
 
kastagir
offline
Link
 
Or have a limited number of "moves" in the off season before chemistry take hits.

In 8 seasons this number can be increased to compensate for retirements.
Last edited May 16, 2008 18:31:28
 
Bears Rule
offline
Link
 
My only gripe with chemistry is that it should get back up quicker...at this rate if chemistry affects us as much as I think it is...some of the most talented teams will not be a solid team in their league for at least 2 seasons...which at that point teams will start disbanding due to that fact...great talent, great energy, great gameplan, bad chemistry = not great. Something has to be fixed on that issue...
 
gotitans1010
offline
Link
 
This guy is not playing me and he is saying he is going to bentch me for the rest of the games.......he has lower players ahead of me.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gotitans1010
This guy is not playing me and he is saying he is going to bentch me for the rest of the games.......he has lower players ahead of me.



Yea, I told you this after you told me you were going to retire your player and not boost your skills after you were moved to #2 on the chart for one game
 
spotty
offline
Link
 
chemistry is just a hit on the teams trying to build a winner..which we have moral and everything else to hurt us...also with no draft they have yet to come up with an alternative for us to be able to compete...we cant sign higher players and we cant draft better players...everything is set up for the good teams to stay on top...and the low teams to keep taking hits...they dont even give compensation to teams that make the playoffs that have road games...just top 4 that gets ticket sales and concessions...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.