User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I see what you are saying, and I do understand the math you've pointed out a few times now. I get what you think the problem is. I guess my worry is this, and maybe you can point out that I'm way off base, and if I am, accept my apologies:

- Bort changes the penalty system from a flat penalty to a progressive penalty structure, thus eliminating the chance of these gross outlier games, correct?

- As the SIM moves forward, Bort adds in more options to improve realism (throwing the ball away, eating the ball for sacks to avoid INT's, the ability to pull a low morale QB, CB's needing more catching to actually make as many INT's, penalties which negate some INT's during the season, etc.)

- My worry is that the combination of all of this will lead to a SIM where multiple INT's, even games of 3-6, become a complete rarity and mabye 5 or 6 becomes the complete outlier, compared to fact that more INT's have happened in real life, both individually and as a team.

I'm not proposing that 9 or 10 INT's in a game happen often, but the chance of those numbers SHOULD be possible, just not at all probable. ThoughtS?
 
Majpain
offline
Link
 
Camon just give props to Perfections defense. Played lights out.
 
vrock627
offline
Link
 
maybe the QB just had a bad day?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
I see what you are saying, and I do understand the math you've pointed out a few times now. I get what you think the problem is. I guess my worry is this, and maybe you can point out that I'm way off base, and if I am, accept my apologies:

- Bort changes the penalty system from a flat penalty to a progressive penalty structure, thus eliminating the chance of these gross outlier games, correct?

- As the SIM moves forward, Bort adds in more options to improve realism (throwing the ball away, eating the ball for sacks to avoid INT's, the ability to pull a low morale QB, CB's needing more catching to actually make as many INT's, penalties which negate some INT's during the season, etc.)

- My worry is that the combination of all of this will lead to a SIM where multiple INT's, even games of 3-6, become a complete rarity and mabye 5 or 6 becomes the complete outlier, compared to fact that more INT's have happened in real life, both individually and as a team.

I'm not proposing that 9 or 10 INT's in a game happen often, but the chance of those numbers SHOULD be possible, just not at all probable. ThoughtS?


I think they should be less probable, but really only because offense should be improved. If one were to accept Season 3 offensive levels as okay, then this is just an example of that being combined with crappy confidence.

I most definitely think that if, say, a level 25 QB entered a game with a Confidence of 15, that once he threw two interceptions the team should be pretty much guaranteed to lose unless it gets him out of there (for which a mechanism should exist).

I also think that a Confidence of 29 at Level 25 should mean a QB will have truly disastrous games. You sacrifice Confidence to gain in other stats, there have to be major consequences, or you may as well not have the stat.

Now, with a more realistic O/D balance, a disastrous game would be 5-6 picks rather than 10 total, but if you want a player to be consistent, put a lot into confidence. If you'd rather he be fantastic sometimes but also downright awful on occasion, then ignore the stat.

Game. Tradeoff.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 22:41:54
 
Zeke0123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Majpain
Camon just give props to Perfections defense. Played lights out.




LOL Maj..I have to agree with the consensus 10 was a bit much Brother.
 
Majpain
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke0123
Originally posted by Majpain

Camon just give props to Perfections defense. Played lights out.




LOL Maj..I have to agree with the consensus 10 was a bit much Brother.


I know I was hoping for 10 by myself
 
jamyp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Majpain
Originally posted by Zeke0123

Originally posted by Majpain


Camon just give props to Perfections defense. Played lights out.




LOL Maj..I have to agree with the consensus 10 was a bit much Brother.


I know I was hoping for 10 by myself


Miami played an outstanding game on D, no doubt about it.

 
jetjore
offline
Link
 
hey Roadgrater... where's the sportsmanship??? ok, so u got creamed!
give congrats to the other team and prepare for next season so you
can knock them out next year! and you know this is a BETA game that
is being CONSTANTLY worked on! its not perfect, but its getting better
every day! and besides, nobody FORCED you to play or pay for boosting!

i'm not gonna try to explaing WHY the game simmed the way it did... but
ur response is completely out of line! give Bort some credit! he's
working his tail off and u go and complain that u lost a game...

"Any given Sunday"
 
Majpain
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jetjore
hey Roadgrater... where's the sportsmanship??? ok, so u got creamed!
give congrats to the other team and prepare for next season so you
can knock them out next year! and you know this is a BETA game that
is being CONSTANTLY worked on! its not perfect, but its getting better
every day! and besides, nobody FORCED you to play or pay for boosting!

i'm not gonna try to explaing WHY the game simmed the way it did... but
ur response is completely out of line! give Bort some credit! he's
working his tail off and u go and complain that u lost a game...

"Any given Sunday"


Who said were sticking around we want it all!!!
 
Mr Yakov
offline
Link
 
OMG !!!!! I can't believe it! this is total bullcrap !

My 8th seed D league team just shutout ,0-17, the #1 seed in our first playoff game!

What kinda friggin bull is that ! If I'm gonna play a game where my 8 seed can do that to a number 1...well I'm just gonna have to ask for my money back cuz how could that ever possibly happen in real life.....wow
 
goat123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
poor confindence??


a.k.a. Bort says it's the most underrated attribute


i agree my QB was throwing a ton of picks this season 18 toatol

but the ints went down alot when i got his confindence up to 40
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 23:55:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr Yakov
OMG !!!!! I can't believe it! this is total bullcrap !

My 8th seed D league team just shutout ,0-17, the #1 seed in our first playoff game!

What kinda friggin bull is that ! If I'm gonna play a game where my 8 seed can do that to a number 1...well I'm just gonna have to ask for my money back cuz how could that ever possibly happen in real life.....wow


Guy, a bit late. We are pretty much past that part..........I hope.........I missed about 30 pages since my last post it seems.
 
cooljesture20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mr Yakov
OMG !!!!! I can't believe it! this is total bullcrap !

My 8th seed D league team just shutout ,0-17, the #1 seed in our first playoff game!

What kinda friggin bull is that ! If I'm gonna play a game where my 8 seed can do that to a number 1...well I'm just gonna have to ask for my money back cuz how could that ever possibly happen in real life.....wow


The Warriors beat the Mavs. The Giants beat the Patriots.

Upsets can happen.
 
Link
 
Not to mention, it's in a d league. Who cares It's there for developing players not winning championships.
 
ashtonbt1
offline
Link
 
Yeah, the teams change so quickly in D-League that seeds really mean nothing, I would think.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.