User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
I don't get it, wasn't this subforum created so that we could create multiple threads on different facets of game changes?

Keep in mind the OP is from when this was in the GLB Main forum.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
it was - Tuba was just a bit confused by my OP in the other post which was for when the thread was initially in GLB Main and we needed to keep it to one thread. I'll make sure he knows not to do it again.
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
My bad, yo.
 
Worker 3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tuba_samurai
My bad, yo.


such a heinous offense can never be forgiven
 
Link
 
Somebody should mention, that as it stands now, the speed archetype for DT is unusable. It cannot result in a successful, full time player.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darren McFadden
Somebody should mention, that as it stands now, the speed archetype for DT is unusable. It cannot result in a successful, full time player.


I've mentioned this a few times and nobody responds to it, the imbalance gets lost because they are grouped with the DE and the DE ones are all viable. Every DT build should have strength as a major. I don't know why more people aren't pointing this out, they're busy whining about watered down WRs which isn't even a balance issue.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Eh, I think you can have a successful DT with strength as a minor, especially since guards will be getting less strength than they do now. The Strength DT may be too good for balance, though. Maybe it needs to lose tackling.
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Eh, I think you can have a successful DT with strength as a minor, especially since guards will be getting less strength than they do now. The Strength DT may be too good for balance, though. Maybe it needs to lose tackling.


Or agility, having those two in the same build is too hard to turn down.

But I agree, my point was more about strength being too good, not the others being too weak.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Do not create spin off threads about archetypes. If you want to discuss them, do so in this thread.

If you have a legitimate concern about an archetype and how you think it might break the game by being unbalanced, then please pm me and I will look at it. If you have a suggestion or want to add/change something, do not pm me about it as I will delete it without even looking at it. You're more than welcome to discuss it here, but any changes/revisions that are made will be made internally after testing.


Should maybe edit this post TBH.
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
So you want your TE to have tackling? Or do you want your LB to have blocking?


not at all but in the things that require checks I'd like equality.

Break Tackle Vs Make Tackle.
Speed/Agility = = Speed/Agility.
Make Catch Vs Deflect Pass
Hold Block vs Break Block

All of these qualities should be equal (For particular pairs of archetypes..)

Receiving TE should be just as likely to do these as a Coverage LB.
Combo TE == Combo LB
Blocking TE == Run Stopping LB (If that is an archetype)
etc etc etc.

If one of these is badly flawed and leans one way, the game /sim becomes "broken" . I could talk about statistical distributions of rolls assuming each has a fixed standard deviation.. and talk about how much better the TE would have to be in order to beat the LB'er a particular percentage of the time.
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
it was - Tuba was just a bit confused by my OP in the other post which was for when the thread was initially in GLB Main and we needed to keep it to one thread. I'll make sure he knows not to do it again.


I apologize for creating the TE thread, I wasn't really paying too much attention to the rules, you can lock that thread if you want. but I still think it needs to be investigated..
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Here's a newish topic:

The problem I see with it is that it will be really hard to create a defense, especially a CB corp, that can stop, or at least slow down, any offense that comes their way. Having so many options on offense is going to cause a lot of teams to go to one extreme or the other, meaning that a single defense can't stop both of those offenses.

Just a quick example, here are three different WR builds I've ran through. None were particularly well-built, but they will give you a general idea.

Possession WR (Lv. 72 WR)
Ht/Wt: 6'6", 215lbs

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 49
Speed: 95.02 (+22)
Agility: 90.17 (+15)
Jumping: 78.13
Stamina: 50.02
Vision: 60.18
Confidence: 53.02

Football Skills
Blocking: 10
Catching: 94.13 (+6) (97.65 with Soft Hands)
Tackling: 8
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 67.19
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8

Special Abilities
Possession Receiver Abilities
Route Running: 11
Sticky Hands: 12
Jumping Catch: 10
Diving Catch: 1
One Handed Catch: 1

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 0
Quick Cut: 0
Head Fake: 0
Spin: 0
Juke: 0

Veteran Abilities:
Possession Receiver: 15
Slot Machine: 15
Mr. Reliable: 15
Soft Hands: 8
Prime Time Player: 2
Overtime Killer: 1

Catch Ball Chance + 21%

Speed WR (Lv. 72 WR)--I'm sure that one can be made that's much faster.
Ht/Wt: 5'8", 175lbs

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 31
Speed: 135.13 (+42)
Agility: 81.13
Jumping: 53.02
Stamina: 51.02
Vision: 61.18
Confidence: 51.19

Football Skills
Blocking: 10
Catching: 78.18
Tackling: 8
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 68.02
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8

Special Abilities
Possession Receiver Abilities
Route Running: 0
Sticky Hands: 0
Jumping Catch: 0
Diving Catch: 0
One Handed Catch: 0

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 23
Quick Cut: 7
Head Fake: 0
Spin: 0
Juke: 0

Veteran Abilities:
Track Star: 15
Ball Hawk: 15
Comeback Kid: 15
Clock Manager: 10
Overtime Killer: 1


Catch Ball Chance +19%
Power WR (Lv. 72 WR)
Ht/Wt: 6'0", 235lbs
400 Days Old

Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 84.13
Speed: 95.02 (+21)
Agility: 90.18 (+18)
Jumping: 17
Stamina: 49.02
Vision: 56.18
Confidence: 49.02

Football Skills
Blocking: 49
Catching: 85.13 (+5)
Tackling: 8
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 79.13
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8

Special Abilities
Possession Receiver Abilities
Route Running: 10
Sticky Hands: 1
Jumping Catch: 1
Diving Catch: 1
One Handed Catch: 1

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 0
Quick Cut: 0
Head Fake: 0
Spin: 0
Juke: 0

Power Through: 8

Break Tackle Chance: +21%
Catch Ball Chance: +19%

Veteran Abilities:
Possession Receiver: 15
Outsider Blocker: 15
YAC Attack: 15
Down Field Blocker: 10
Overtime Killer: 1

Now imagine we have four teams. Team A goes all Possession WRs, Team B goes all Speed WRs, Team C goes all Power WRs, and Team D goes one power, two speed, and two possession WRs. Now try and figure out a CB corp that won't get exploited by at least one of those team. The only CB I was able to make that would probably be able to do that was a hard-hitter zone CB, but now it appears that Zone Spec is going to be an archetype-specific SA instead of a VA, so that route is gone.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
not at all but in the things that require checks I'd like equality.

Break Tackle Vs Make Tackle.
Speed/Agility = = Speed/Agility.
Make Catch Vs Deflect Pass
Hold Block vs Break Block

All of these qualities should be equal (For particular pairs of archetypes..)

Receiving TE should be just as likely to do these as a Coverage LB.
Combo TE == Combo LB
Blocking TE == Run Stopping LB (If that is an archetype)
etc etc etc.

If one of these is badly flawed and leans one way, the game /sim becomes "broken" . I could talk about statistical distributions of rolls assuming each has a fixed standard deviation.. and talk about how much better the TE would have to be in order to beat the LB'er a particular percentage of the time.


I don't think it's that simple. A combo LB is a balance between Blitz/Coverage LB and Hard Hitting LB. He's not specifically designed to be equal to a Combo TE, who's job is to be a balanced Blocker and Receiver.
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Has it been considered to give the Combo Players SA penalty and bonuses as well?

For Instance for the Combo DE:

+'s: Strong Base, First Step
-'s: Tunnel Vision/ Wall.

?
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
So they get a penalty and a bonus to pass rushing, and a penalty and a bonus to containment?

That seems like a more complicated way of trying to give them no net bonus to either side, but even then not all SAs are created equal.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.