User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
Noaheli
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scopur
Don't like the rerolling. If you're gonna allow this, it seems like you need to give pre-existing players a chance to reroll as well.
Either have it in a way that balances players out across the board or don't have it at all.


Pre-existing players have always had the chance to re-roll. All you had to do was "retire" your player and then remake him if you didn't like the stats. The re-roll option just negates the retirement/renaming steps which, in turn, removes a ton of retired players from the database (an unnecessary glut on system resources).
 
tejas
offline
Link
 
What i want to know is... we are having scrimmages and all will that raise the chemistry of the teams who need the +1 or +2 chemistry for next season
 
scopur
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Noaheli
Originally posted by scopur

Don't like the rerolling. If you're gonna allow this, it seems like you need to give pre-existing players a chance to reroll as well.
Either have it in a way that balances players out across the board or don't have it at all.


Pre-existing players have always had the chance to re-roll. All you had to do was "retire" your player and then remake him if you didn't like the stats. The re-roll option just negates the retirement/renaming steps which, in turn, removes a ton of retired players from the database (an unnecessary glut on system resources).


Except as new information becomes available (like the fact that player size matters and stats are randomly generated) rerolling actually matters, whereas prior to having that kind of knowledge it didn't.
Many players were created long after that information became public and added to FAQs.
Rerolling should either be an option for everyone or not an option for anyone. I'd even be fine with adding a cost to it like 50 Flex points to give an existing player unlimited rerolls until they're satisfied with the new build.

As it stands now all new players have a distinct advantage over pre-existing players which could ultimately create problems and balance issues.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scopur
As it stands now all new players have a distinct advantage over pre-existing players which could ultimately create problems and balance issues.
Good. Maybe now they'll stop bitching about "oh the old guys have such a huge advantage, however will we catch up?" now that they have some menial advantage.
 
AllDaWay
offline
Link
 
Dang, im ticked about the downtime tonight. Wat am I gonna do for a half hour. .


j/k
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tejas
What i want to know is... we are having scrimmages and all will that raise the chemistry of the teams who need the +1 or +2 chemistry for next season


chemistry gets reset at the very end of offseason, so it wouldn't matter
so it won't matter
 
AllDaWay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by tejas

What i want to know is... we are having scrimmages and all will that raise the chemistry of the teams who need the +1 or +2 chemistry for next season


chemistry gets reset at the very end of offseason, so it wouldn't matter
so it won't matter


U sure its every offseason? Im pretty sure that was only for the 1st.
 
jfbueno
offline
Link
 
Yeah, it's not going to be reset, but im hoping that the offseason chem is frozen, to make it easier to acquire talent before then.
 
mastawoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by scopur

As it stands now all new players have a distinct advantage over pre-existing players which could ultimately create problems and balance issues.
Good. Maybe now they'll stop bitching about "oh the old guys have such a huge advantage, however will we catch up?" now that they have some menial advantage.


There is absolutely no advantage to creating a player now unless you had no knowledge of the ability to retire and reroll a created player before. I'm relatively new to the game, and created 8 players, all 'pre-reroll'. I wasn't aware you could retire/reroll on the first three. I also was too ignorant to realize that height/weight would factor into your player.

The next five guys I created, I kept retiring and rerolling until I got the stats I wanted (yeah, I'm that guy, one of the reasons they were getting 4000+ retirees a day). I did go out to try out the re-roll feature now, and due to the changes in the minimum stat, it doesn't seem like I can replicate what I was getting before. It seems to me that players created pre-'canned reroll' had much better level 1 stats than those now.

In other words, if you built your guy before the reroll, I think you have the advantage. I wanted to create one more player before the end of the season, I just can't seem to get the stats to where I can pull the trigger on it though.

CURSE YOU BORT, I SHAKE MY FIRST AT THEE

p.s. Just kidding =)
Last edited May 26, 2008 17:17:35
 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
Any idea if energy will be affected (meaning it will drop ) during the scrimmage games? If so, and there is no XP gained, I have some players who would rather rest and train and have their energy at full level for season 3. Or does energy reset for everyone for the new season?
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
As far as re-rolling is concerned, why can't it just be set up where the 3 or 4 meaningless attributes per position are trimmed until they reach 8, then those points are given to the player to distribute where they wish.

For example, my HB got 7 in tackling, 10 in throwing (which is up to 12.6 now), 8 in kicking, and 10 in punting (I had no idea about manual rerolling). My stats could be shaved down to 7, 8, 8, 8 and I could be given back those points to allocate. The reason I say don't shave everything down to 7 is so that way there isn't too much of an advantage given to players who didn't know any better.

Then let all the players reroll their heights and weights until they are happy. Let them do it only once.

This way we can reroll heights and weights, get back the points we lost in meaningless attributes, and not disturb the other attributes that have been trained. And it is fair because you still enforce the 8 point minimum.

EDIT: To be completely honest with you, I'd actually just prefer it if we could all just choose which state categories we want to put points into and have the rest be at 0. I don't need 8 kicking for anything and neither does any other HB. Why not just let everyone use the points in meaningless attributes to put in their other attributes. It won't throw anything off because everyone will get to do it. It'll just mean people get to higher numbers in attributes quicker. And with only 10 seasons to max attributes before your player declines, I don't see why we shouldn't have those points.
Last edited May 26, 2008 21:10:46
 
WesWilliams
offline
Link
 
I'm curious what the day by day New Contract options will be. I love the Scrimmage update. I think that'll be awesome.
 
Link
 
BORT GOOD CONTRACT OPTION UPDATE.
 
primetime
offline
Link
 
day to day contracts just sounds like a bad idea.....makes you able to go get a "hired gun" for that special game and dump him afterwards with no penalty to chemistry.

 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I don't get what "Day-to-Day" means. >_<
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.